:’f::*sw:’srs :3′ ?¥§’Ai~§£?$Hé, Amr,;:
g,asé§%’:
1
I
i
1?? “E'”5r”f§ i-éE{:I駔§ QGQRT G? K§%R§’éfiaTfi4§~i’fia $1″? $25′:§’1é§:3§§,3£}V”§ ~.._
amga T2-{ES THE 2″” am’ 0:’: MARCH 22339″ ‘ .
2 gzaaxamga, 32:3′ ;£*~ff%*E ::*?;;a%§*~§§;:;:;2;~a M
AQEE2 amass? 33 *s’;sA.§'<iS
wwwuvwv.
hé
R.s%?s§G$?€A%§%fz’~—@ ?<;;w§?;g: I
S;if:§S;5g?\§._}EE}:;i:'3sE,51§-i'. " "
fi:§EE»;§éBi:.;..ij'%* 2*§§»£a~ _ L '
QM
..fi:_GEEi _;fi.'B€i"%i.3E' 33 ""2+".,E,E§*–'–". '
4 awzk, %:aA;a%.§=*;:L$a§;:a:éé%?
M59 «.a_«m3: E? _£S._’:’E..€’-§TS
Egg 5: 1;'”3€LLfi:G£
% . mrgsgégisgrstja “?A§..Li§<:
‘ ~ . A %s:*:%§ajR§ “§:$’r2::m*”
‘ = %.§%&”‘3*”1’*§”:«g’::r~s§a$
‘ ._STATE
3:’ BAE3AE¥§xVALiJ PGLECE
REPaEsE:~;?Ea 5′: s,9,s=,;
i-3Z%’3§~§ C{}¥_.!RT £3?’ §=j;
§L~<1;/'
'§
,3.
£RiMFLE’§’ISE*§?zi ?E’§’§T§§3¥f%§t’§ Efi FELEQ 333,39? 52, 32131 {ZR.,P,C
5′?’ ‘§”‘§-E .£’§§}\..3Q€ATE FQR THE ;9E’§”ifi€.§§\§ER PRA’r”E%~é$ “%’§*§;=§T
mzs ass-was cam? _?v”:A’:” 5: masga ‘%”Q 35? gagszzga,
ma 3i}EG?é§;§’\iT St 93353 as-” cazevzmm ??&35$_§’$ “§”;f
9&5. Fr:-;:; 3*-i”t:”Sfif-‘EE :5: §RL,A,N§’2;:§5f€%f,. §:=4;:;:§;$;§§
CiZ§§*§FIR.?v’§}I?~é53 THE C?Z3?*»!’».!I£;”fEf..’§§\§ éi’}R§ER ?,$15SE’-‘.;7;’%_E’.i”‘[Tf§’E*~wE:
A{}§L,CI’v’£L QEQEL {3fR,§:”é,} §¥’*’§?~’C,, ?\§,fi;§’5–E:’~i_’?§–.%:§iE§:’j’~v.V E
ff:.£,?\§.§,143§.’.5;’§§ 0.5% 3.1.§.€.3.§3;, ‘
‘fééés patiiicn mmirag 4::-Tr’; fr:-tr” aQfm§ $75§Q_a–.;tfz§$ .%;E:’a’1;f;, €§*’§&:3z:C:£§§””i
mafia the f@§3r:.rwEr:r; ‘
Ccrrzwictad a’::f;ii_«?§~E§i§ 3;? agaairzgi the
jafigmargi Er: :’iff§”,vé35;iz:::Cs:3 Qifg the ma 5:?’
…. £..
izsége, i”–“”asi:Tv:-“–a_:’f»+-f-.? f;§i:;:*f;w ?v2j.y’§r:::re;,”‘{;«:m%%rrn§i:g the j;,:{3:;2ma:r;_
m x’.;£,:43’fi;’§§ §aié2.€§ “‘~:.:’;»1i};;a’;:$rg”3: 9:: tffia fiie :2? ms: jiviéage
éfiufiiar Ei§VR;§3z 3§*T5:;__ ?’é;’:~::§§a.éé§:g:§, cisnxgiciirzg yzeiitégnezrs L
a:r’z§”¢*§;i:. :fg=_§* €532 éfEa;v.’;-93% ceavmmg the 3*’ §e€:§tEsner fer Em
V z::ffa’m:e=§f:fié§V–V’:?;é&::§@n 325$
‘A $5}
;T:”:.,aA.maiie:r E3 iisiefi fgr aémigséen aftar msiiae,
§¥ijg§-1e%§fT=L’~«..AA’§’i:e géiiiiarz is aémiiiaé arsfi taken 1:9 far flag:
‘£3§$§(?S’3§ by cargaentg
aw
E
E55
«ii
‘:,§§”:tf§ef Segtécrrzs; 323, 32:: arrfi 385, iii; fisgzugaaf céarzieé
the gizayzga grad mi :2; fiefargse sf riieféiéi simgiéciiazr”, :”f”§z»:s*y
a%s§ aiéegaé iraiiizécai enmity wag Eiia cause §§~r..’;f:ei_$’é.§’;%_ ‘
impéézating mm: “ms rzacfeiséiaztgfifiriéf Ljéurugg
.9′
Sffifiéiiiiiéfi sxamirgeci £3 wiirzésfigs afr:é~ féiemfi ;-=.’,§.. éa:s_={r;:;:–;r’;f~se*:*s;t.s
am piacaé 2′”&§§§iI”¥C.£§ an 2__maier§a_§_V’§§j§.::s.
35, The Seamed ::*iai””jé:駒e,__ }:é3;ns”E£i.fgr§ ir’:i3_V:§1e aszidairgca
arzfi fiafefzsa, ffiijfiii Vifié :;’§”2é’:rg§-;-1 ;sr€:.§e§ §§«§{i%§§i the acéaseé
azrnj ::§s’: ‘xzé::ie_§é–w§:»:§t%%§E§§isa;*5_’i._A,’ 3¥T?§??v ffiif “E333 affences iif$§§Ei!’
Seatiera 32,35, ‘EV,.;P’;ei.i’;.;;j§j;V,fr3g’§g§”:i_e§é::\;i§::i§§éafitéwser ms fer tiié
§f’fa:r’:<.:e7:_:':*:§.&;+' VSe;'–;=::-'£:§s:§;r:% ixgarie-rgefi by éi, they
were if': a§§I'E§§*§§f'§ €?i:'}ii_;;i»«:T§V8;jT:'.;":,, mg: Eng aipgaéiaia 2:332: 5552::
§@iJ§3§._§€§§ irififiiivihéziééfefifié aflfi reéeciafi 1:532 apgeai,
V .fi§g';z§;"{5: :%:§sg§:;§§mefii:s; i312?' 3212 if! ravisimii
" .__«La§«%%:v§é'~::§.Li§ssa: fa? iém Qatiiésrzers wcmié miziarzé
V . Ersai €533 éauzrt arm; first aweiiate tatgsi £23335: seriaaisiv
5-é{:r':A%§.;:é__4irgégmrireg §5£'3C§§"§$iS'§_&f2§ Siéifiméfiifi mafia by 93?:
in the matter ra§at§::§ is actfuai aggazzit 3215 the
: ":;-g:g;%=sb&r $2' aergarss whiz wgsseé the éncifieni, He éraw
M':
my aiiérziimé is tiée éyiéefige Qf Wu’: wherein ha states
that there was rm {me at the time {sf the ingééani, but PW;
gt? §§..©g_jZ>,(,”\»’\.5.”>
says there were a*§$«;2t:M*~i:iEt%2 fegairfi is use 9:” ma: riai
‘–,/y’\ 4.. M ‘
abjects, aw: says 1″ petitioner used stenes and ciagb.
“iiié afésecutien has saizaé aniy ma cizéb _a-ii锧:§’;:§;-…._ .
,%:t:£3?¥’§§§”:§ m we i;3i!’§$€C’t§ii§!’: seiéufé cf? §:’i;2:}–$’_;:1″:a’:1§:f;z :3 $3′:
3:3 prafiaétém; by ma:f;?s%.si4:%::§s,;j:§:a2;:a§a::;~s,;’@«:;:.,:: W53 Er: ‘:’ei$
evifiestce siaieg tfrg’: it 53 :.ys:v§*a_é }1a*”§’~v§i’€é§”1 fixe ariicies ta
tag §$§§c:a* i-£e%__”§:;i:i:j::%n-E5 £%f:§$7 i’i%é¥5éffQEfég”§é§’§§S the siaiemahi
sf the §§’:=:*:;:é:-_;ir::s;_é**:;: am: y5i’:%fiL_£fi “:vi*~:*ai”aal’:%”1; Q?’ thaw baa? aged
giam if; ca:§§§T;§..;–2j’;,;’%§e5;.. “»§;§$i§3.2 fig sabmiis we if it 5
$-
{fin
3:-In
heéé i%”:a£:”::%3a” E23}?e..::.§§s;.LjV5::f§~§;fé:%””§*g Wail am’ Fizm airé gauge,
$3′.
is? i:i1é:– aacuséfiffi gm éffeége Wéfiié rm: faié urzafar figgiién
fieaéfer, 9;: iiia aiéaer hané, ha:
‘ gzgiéggrief’ Smmigszgfi §%4o§é§¥fi:I:§$§x¥fi’$t
“§’§2»«:§i:§%*: iirzés is 5:; Zfévifiififi Lzrséefs’ Safiiiéfi 3§?, s:::?:C,,
i;fz,:%.;*»?r;-é” afiééfiaifiméfii a$ ifi wfieiher iffiéffi is 3:23: §§§e§a§§:y
uihe fiffléééfiifiéfi befgra tiéa iris; zszsrt Q? wheifiar
W
‘§;:i_?3; f.%1駒id§%;f§r §*1a$V”‘f§€ii§§ea§ thé §t§§3§’3?%!’§if’2§ injuries:
.;:.r_j: __E§?z;.,;?«=’3g the czfaettaer ‘nag imiiéaé thg faiiawiag iniarieg:
‘2’
1%. 5a fair erg Eiiéjéi avert 36:5 Q? the a:_s..ii’>3 arm? 94 are ihjury
car”t§t:*’=’:€@:”:«’::-es; §:se§*é:a§’r:’§r:§ {£3 ?>%:’v’: arzé pwz resgeétéveéyp in
V fi’J::«2%fa’:g:§§zr.i .§=’r2aa$::;”§n§ 2 cm, :4: :95 cm. (mar Ems iefi
‘ icewéiés. ,~f:7bde»:*r2«.’-if: fiéfi?’ arziteriarr $;2§:&ris3:* fipimié,
.. re”:::§é;i’;§.fr3 in mieur;
.::§.A7*§ras§c=n maafiaréng 14 cm, 2:: 1.5 gm. -*l2’\?§’:.?* Esfit
::;fr%.:er§§r afxiiiafir Eifleg féfifiiiih if? miaagrg
A’ *£3;j:2 Yendefnefig r::n;er- fewer aéédamemwaeferréé ta:
maéer Ewggiiai
1} fiegéeiraiésig waunfi meamring Q5 am, if :3 :1:-‘ta:
we: tha iszawer part ca? right ieg, béeeding gvresent; *
/}i7*V
233
gage Féféfféé ié §<,R,i~ios§§iaE '
s:3,.Er2éc:2: Cemmuiaé frasture icrwar 3"' :3? tibia
{§'E§§*?i S§§&§
3:, "§"§*':i.:$, it is agar iiééi iiié ifijiifiefi gufiereé by 5'-"-'%és'_i.i":;.
éimié be causes: by figtéracg ainé. §§'!"'Z§$§flE'!S Céijiii ?::x&~ts;:;g:e,é_r
by 32$ :53 3%' &§"'£=::::t iiiée éiab, as has mar: t§2é.,$ ic'a.iéfiée::i '
52? Wis: am The dactér E333 *sé:::;rafgé :gv;=;éjTgr::g§:s
iswetf ahéémers arsé has §e2;§é;:*;-*é~:;f_ a.""%:§a;fm'_Vh§$:2:tai fear
?a§§§§'§"y" examinaiigsgz, fefi afiiéfiéf
axiiiay-Ty iirze f§.i3–§"'v§;u5:é_::;3r*: :f;;%§?;<'s;_t§%:&fs:ai:=_érr2a§ii 9:22' ?'v'v': ef
jééini aitatii; gr:
:12, s’%é’.:*eg$;*:;~§ss_?§:§;’:;’T»t§i[:?’A”§’:2r:”: that site had szsiffareé
fracture of §s%;3.:a_;* 6? t7::t}£’a-.§§ confirmed thraugfs radisiagy
_.–vr.g_mrt_”__n:%:g §cc£:i:i>:.___§:,ézs Qeriéfiad it as Qfievcas éhjury,
i§;a:j§:’a3..eg–é§vé’:2:€2′::'”*s;.:§2p@ri3 fiar varsity; aim, The act 3%
V Cassigigvgr%e:§§;§$A’TI=%v§§3izry is attributed in 3″‘ gseaitfoaer am
‘the §§E”I’4’4!ui§3§’ aV:€::’?; ‘Wiifléiéi tha 1252 sf afirjeci is attriéuteéi to
isissgrs V:, 2 am-2% 4, Tiiresaczztion has iaié charge £33533?
35>: :’v’%,§$, and the iearned triai jixgfiaez has apyxiiéd
“‘e;s:’%é’énce and fmzrsd it astabiigiwag ii: beyané E”é&$£i>i”:a§§&
fiflijbi. in the §§’v?e”r2 get :33’ girsumstarygas, agprreciatiérs :3?
(it?
evééanca fay thé triai mus’: is just and prsper, It rseecig rm
izrziefifeiremta, The awafiate ceurtg 0%’: :*&-a:::9raEs,§a5§:._ ::§
evifierzm, hag a¥s{: fmsiéwé rm reasm: is interfere ;_«§’ii?:f.A’s~L§:}§’€
Cfififiiiéfiififh
i
:3, in thig revigim, E fin-gfi as éacéféiavhié
§§S§%JiE”§3 the ceficurrent findéfig ra:;cr:ies:i§’—-::§%’w%:29ih [;:i*.:,:i%ij§:’s,” .
:4. fiemirm is iirfza qgzesiiéan iczfV:$§§’:}’;éfi€;§%”¥:é,é::f§i:§0§%&*rS 1, 2
323$ 4 haw beg;;i._._5eé§:*:e:’:s:,é:i i:}.::_’V§a*g.Vr:VnVi§r uf§’r:jTe’§ e-:3? :’€,$:§£:::3,;”- fist
as E
the Qifféiféiié :;:1:.%i.Va’:¥.£§:gz:ti’:::’:*:<–.3;,*L..'7§«–%_:*::§ Em-:?,. whign is a
iéfierai $e5vntencé"i'é.gn;é§ A2 regarw 3"' petitésner,
45"!'
Gfifiiéafiifig'5:_§"3'%E.?:é€i1fé3 V:;f arufi abject E35325', he hag
'gear: :f§;s;;:*gc:i_Q:,:i¥i\;r» §Ef'f'r:a bffehée Lmiier $a::i§e:;rr: 32$, ERQE
";_¥€%'=2ei?§Vér ;'s:}i::r§'e«A_._:a;:ia? ha ccsnséfiereé ag a éarsgarfirzsg
szséeapV$'§'2f%;3§§::f;;'%':1é:%2.§"is: the quasiian, 'i'ir":e:re are éévergergi
E
Gi§':if%i€3";"'zS GE? '::<:;§'$ aspect aizé it vxisazéij be Safe is carzciuafe
";'=%ga$ i:-. fie aargsiéereé as we iiiréfier Seafiszrz 324, "i" this
'}aix::'%:é§:t éifiy, the fifiéifié ir"2eéfi$ ta bee meéifiefir
(%@%%%