IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANG.A_I_.ORE
I)A'l'i'C1,) T}-IIS T1112 20w 1)m' or NO\=*'I-*2I\/{BI-~Zl"{._2QGE} ~
: PRi.~1SI£NT:
TI-IE HONBLE MR.JUs1j;cE N..§i'.':~=AEtf:L"'*».: - _ 1'
AND I
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTiCE B.SREENIVASE vspwfzm
M.F.A.No. 20 1% MV)
B i£'TV\/I:':3EN :
v"E3i.i'l'1!'€?~'5:5'O O}. O
S1T111.A1'1:m'1. V
W/0.G_T..S3'Ta.pk:.11'. _
,
R/asi' 107. s:m_c+gatwaiz-:11i"_ "
Mz~1i:'1'V..f{t3s1:§_. Me' n_;--a.,z HE} i }--1 héigzl
...A;')p(*112u11
{i'3_V Sr!' 'E311 i' i1 )z1d x',\_=' a" $1" :<.:'__. V}-'\E1.1\*<:("';':110)
AMI; .. F
11 C] i'. KL.1E2-1.l<e.1mi.
"SV/'{).'§3'E1§'}L'.1'Lliflllgal R210 E{uika':u~11i.
V' * ..;2';,5~2/5. 20m §\/lain Roe-Lci.
1*?' --C;'0.€%:=3. M21:"e:121 I----ialii.
\»-.'i_;'~:'1_y§-A 1 1 aga 1". £.3211'1g_gz'1i<)1'e~ 40.
' P2L:'1dL.::'2.1n,g;;1.
S'/0.Vi1.hal Rm) Ktllkami.
R/21.52/5.2O"=Me:1i1 Ru-c1d.
1*" Cmsssa. Mz11'cm1i Iii.
Vi_;'21},~'2'1:1ag2'ar21. B' .f'.11c')1'e~4().
L3: Ncxv lnciiu ;\s5.<;u1';'i11<'(:* Co. Ltd.
;\§().i2-B. Uni1_\,* I311il(iI:'ag3j.
Misssion R()aCi. E3&1I'1_L{E'i1()l'('--27
By its E\/'Iama;_{e1'.
R('s;)<.)1'1gh*:_1t.:s
(S1'i.(].Nz-11':-lye-mat Ra-10.[\d\.-'0('a.ur;.- for R45
R1 and R2 dis})L'11:-mci with \-'/O ('i1(:{.13.6.2006)
'§'hi.";'i20.05 ;)a"1,$&..iL.='a.1'1l(:f,§§3;'£7_. "CT,0«;~;_:'1'~.(.)£_S:41.i.aT1}'1
Causes. 21nd MCmb(.~r MAUI', i-3e'1i«I,';';_'z.1'~§_(_')1"c= (SCCE 1.-VEO}:_f3«:.u*1.ly
zziiowing the C12-lim pe£.il'i<')n ;f;_;E1z1y. N.K.
PATIL J. dclix-'('*a'r:?("l the 1~%.:>&_ll(>\x5'i11g;':A
T---'*{.'.4'..0D-- 73 ' :0 ~
V"1"_1'1i's ;'1;)_1')'e{i10..V(:1_iré-:.:j'tc-fd a_;;'air1st the <:omm learned XIV Adciiti11a1 dz.1c.ige:-.
£'0(:>'L'1r'("~._tV>f'x_SI11a1l Cz~mse$; arid 1\/IACT. B2'-1}1gg:1l()rc'
(1'1ci9eir1;1f€.c-S:_'fef"1'1 till the czizztc oi' c1e1.'30.r;:1I and cgioci1mc?ntz11*y L-rvic'1c~.a'1"c'r.¢'.<«.._'i=1;-155
2-liioxvcéd tihc s21i('I <fIain'1 pcliiinm in par! '(1l1u'('i:"2-l\\{i-1i'fi('C:}.""5'1
sun} Rs.1(9},600/-- as (TompeanSz.1.t,i&(m'_ 1.11V'14"(.i'T(--.'V:,I"' (.EV'iiT_cfi;1'e'2i1t
h('£1dS with i:'1t'm'o,:=s1 at 6% p.z=1.. 'E"1f()13:1 filo ti':»1_E'L:--. Q11.;.)'<fi'i.1._'i't3:1_
tiil the date 0!" (i€p()sii.. E:l§;§g1'i€i';»f,€'?€i: f:ij§.{WiiI"aL'§ s2;1ici"'
jL1cig111C1'1t: anti a\x.'2'11'C1:-'._ti'1C ga;)'}.;é1mfiit... }1as 1)'n:~.:sC1"1iL'(1 lhis
2-1IJPE?2'1I . scc-rI.c'4' :'1«_5'c:1t'i11.
4. _,.i':V;§V(>"=.1"1cé;tf&-E_\f*1'1_é:A,Ié;--10rnC(1 (*()1.1nsc'! z'11.);.)(*;"11'i1'1g
for 2-1:;fjf;){§2II'2»1¢:1:{'. e:1:"'i{'_1VV'§c§€1'1jfi('(! {_'.0V["lVE'1S£'.l 2-1ppc'z'1:'EI'1g fox' i1'1i1*(.i
resp()1'1c1em .
Af1V.€"i'~.,,' pe1'3_,1sz11 of the n1a1(rriaI 2-tvzlilable on
» :1'w?_o1'd.=imjit--:.cii:1g the _}uc:La;mer1t arld 21wz11*<:i pa.=.3sL:(:i by
'1he.'I'rii;»{f1';.1zi'§:;.VVit is not in (Ii:-;1'3Ln'c than, in the z1cr0;.,w.'g~11-(41:11 1T1z1;~s f~5L.l."-3'{.£:1i}'1C(I f:'2»1('1L.1:'C 01"b<)1I1 bozlcs of hm'
V'.'§"ig:_§I'1t leg z:11'1(I 1'1"';-1c?i'.:11*<:r of bc)1'1'1 p:1i'3i('.' and Fihti'. 11:51."; taken
I:rea:1tmer'11 as inpaiicrlt zmci 121r':cicnvcm. stlrggtsly and on
4,-
1nonth just and 1-cs-1s<)na1.3!<: 21nd we z-1<*.cep1. t'.11ejsa.n1.
Thc appellant" i$ 2-xgerci a1:)01.:1 32 yc==2::1*s aund 21;_9}'1;17§.5';:)i'i--g1t.<?
iVh.11'('ip1i(==1' 2'-Ipplicablc is '16'. If tI'1e i1'.'.~'4'L'E.':(")1'"Il.éH":.i5'i:~ : t.'E'1C*.
é1]3])('.'.ll£1I"lt. is taken at Rs.2.5GC»/5 phi"V ':'I'1V0;'11711»__fwi':.h
disability at 22% and §\/I1.Il1.i})li(»:"'I"V (:)!. ' iT6'T'i:<_ a.p1[:-.1i(.é:f;~. {i'1Lf
total loss of fLl'('LEF€ e211'1'1i1'1g'S~..%comics '1'<)_ RsVj"--.1 .uO§.'60O/4'
(2.500 x :2 x 22/i1"0é}A=;im._1 2-.c~}¥m-Acimggly. n
21war<i ed.
7. He1v.in'gg_V1'fega1i?d L0.:f?:}'1G.f£71vCjE}SV aitijd <%ir('t1.:n1s1a11ce:1< of
the CE:1S(' 521$ ;1F)--zfj'-9,5.' i!'l'i~j)'1E\§__§Il&T{1 _jL1Cil§_{II'l("..I1I and
aw-2;1:jr:i f§é;1ss(€fc1 lay:ihgé".T1'ibufiéfé'1V is liable to be 1n<)('iiE'iec'!.
"Fine total r._"0m--pé':~{se1i'.1('afi"pzzyabie ('.()1'11CS to Rs.2.97.200/-
and {he i'r_):<.£}'e1iIir)\x?s:
1.
»,.’_f()uwa1-(ls [3ai_1:1 21n(i: s11ffe1’i1’1gs 70.000/~
2;-.L..’I”()w:-.’:1rcv1;sj n’1eci’i'(i’2{1 expenses 74,000/~
. ‘l”‘owa .11′-153’ “€I()1’l\-‘C_V£lI”l(“,(:’. and
” V , i”1(.)m.e dllrirlg 1116.’
A »pe1’i()d 1’1’r:21tme11i’ 9,6300%
5. ‘”F0w;1rds loss of amenitms 30.000/-
6. ‘i'<5v.i_2_1:1'c.1::s loss off1mu'c can'1i11gs Rs. 1.05,600g~
'I'<.:)t.z'.1i Rs' 2.97.200/A
8. z~\(:*(é()r(1i1’1g_g”1y. the E11)}i)t;’2ll is 211l()wecl in pant” zmd
the in’1p1I;-_§11cu:l _;1:(:lg1nc.:’1t” zmcl 2l\xs’a1′(.l 1)a:ss;1.’i’ » V
The 1’1’1i1′(1 1’esp(_)11ci<:*1'1E»l1"1Sa1:1';–ui('*e C:.)rnp;.:.1'1'j.,:_"N.Vviii
directed to deposit the (3(3,T'§l}3CI1SE1li€)1"lV. .2_1I'{l'£)LlVIllI withll
i1'11'<?re$t'. within four__ \vc*elE.xi’c(écip1′ of
the (:;:’$p_v”0E7 figE1é{1T:<.;i"1t z:11clW:1\x-'211'c1.
Out = of ':_"1'~l1 C' –. '{".4fi"11'<1l'l]C('d c.-0n1pe1'1sa11ir1 io1″1e1te
‘i1li’-£*Vi*e*slt s’h.al1 l)e§””i’i’wcsE.e(l in the Fixed I.)eposi{. in any
N_z.1ii(:rja.l_iz<jcll._'gr S('hCdL1l€'(1 Bank, in the 1'1dm(? oi"
ap.;__)c*,1l_2:.a~:'~1t._.l'jlsior a pcriocl of five yc.e1r.<; a11"1('1 1'cI'acéwzIll:)!c for
x£1VI1()1'l1'f3.l'" five yea1's. T116 22.ppe11z211'11". shall be enti1.1cl to
‘ –. \’v»i1E’icl1″dx.v t’.he? i11t’.c-.*.1″es;t’ 2’u’*(‘r1’1:c*(l on it. (’11l&i1’I’t.’.i’l_’\j’.
The 1’cI”l1a1i11i1’1g.§ amlolmi. of EQ.$o554600/W with
pI'()}’)()1″1i()nEi1{‘ interest jhall be 1’e1eas1.n’ of the
/
z1ppc>llz.1111. i1m1″1c(lia1c1y. 011 c1c*1.)0;~;i1 by the {11s;_.11’z«1n(.*c
C om pa 2 1y .
{Draw the award. z1(*c<_)1'c1iug.{1y.
IUDGE %
I
tsn*