IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE
[)A'i'ED THIS THE 09th DAY OF DECEMBER 20,09
BEFORE
THE HONBLE MRJUSTICE ANAND
WRIT PETITION No.298*36 /'2OOs'3{Gv1\?I:}:(i.1?_CV:j5?
BEIIWEEN:
Smt H Sumathi Udupa
W/O H.\/CK. Udupa
aged about 70 Yearsg .
R/A 94-138 & 137. I ; I
Tenkapet Ward Udupi 'I'oyv"nf"V "fj..._{_'..PETITIONER
(By Shri: A Ad:\}"o:é*athe)
1 S1i:II,_S.avro_'ja"SVI'K Major
_ . I R/A'9fié"'}I,E31. ,'Tef1kapet Ward
Udupi 'l"'owI1 _
Bhat Major
R 934- 150A. Tenkapet Ward
v_Ud1Ipi Town
" $har1tha Karanth
Major. D/O Lt. K.S.KaI'anth
R/ A 94-150.
'l'eI'1kap€t. Ward
Udupi Town
@
Narayana
Major, S/O Lt K.S.Ka1'anth
R/A 9--4-- 150.
Tcznkapet Ward
Udupi Town
Narasimha
Major, S/O Lt K.S.Karant1_r1
R/A 9-4-150,
Tenkapet Ward
Udupi Town
J aiaj akshi
Major. S / O
R/A 9--4--150, _ .
Tenkapefr._Ward_... _ '
Uéupiif-awn I
M '' V
Major, O:_L_f K;S';«Karanth
R/A49-4--150',.. "
-- -. Tenkapet 'Ward
o'3'C'UPi Towno o
- 2 a'*¢§%ndra
Ma-jjor,'o1'S/O Lt K.S.Karanth
,R;A4..9-4m15o
" .. Tenkapet Ward
Udupi Town
Lakshmi
Major, D/O Lt K.S.Karanth
E
10
11
12
14 VA
R/A 9--4-150.
Tenkapet Ward
Udupi T own
Ramachandra Govlndaraya Pa}
Major,
R/A 9~4~143 ,
Tenkapet Ward
Udupi Town
K.Narayana Nayak
S / O K. Ramaohandra 4I"€ay'ak
Major, R/A Amb.egi11u',"" --
Puttur Panohyatf ~ "
Uciupi T'
Yasho-da:t__ih;_a.,. "Major _. '
V V
7--ShiVa1i \r'iI1-~:;ge,.v ~ ' '
M;;_1r1i_pa1 ' »
2 :Sul_{aI1yAa"«-. .....
. V *=1\2;a;*o;:_ R/A Anantha N agar
_ 'V vShi_va1'i Village,
" 'Mani "
Rafnakara
Major R/A Anantha Nagar
Shivali Village,
Mani pal
K
15
17
18
V-.R]'A"Anantha Nagar
~~ V Shivali Village,
"Manipal
Gururaja
Major R/A Anantha Nagar
Shivali Village,
Manipal
Madhava
Major R/A Anantha Nagar
Shivali Village,
Manipal I
Narah ari -- _
Major R/A Anantha Nagar _
Shlvali Village, . "
Manipal ' .
Narai/anal V
Maj Q1'?_R/ iA~'A.11antl1a Nagar" "
A
V » v.B.Ajv:: Klima-r '
' _l_\/lajoi"R]';A....D_,1'~J'0.9«4m133.
V A ""lf'er1"l<apei. Ward ,
" ~ . _ " Tovm.
Vijjayaeiakshmi, major, respondents 12 to 18 & 20
are legal representatives
of deceased B.Krishnaiah
.. RESPONDENTS
UN
This Writ Petition is filed under Articles 226 and
227 of the constitution of India with a prayer to quash
the order passed by the learned Principal Civi.1’~.._Judge
(Jr.Dn.) At Udupi Passed In O.S.No.l2/92 O1ic,.I.A.:\lo.29
Dated 18.8.09. produced at Anr1exure-H. ”
This Writ Petition coming onp.for’f.Pr–e1imin_ar’ypll»
hearing ‘B’ group this dayftlie i’;o1_.i.rt’-vinade’ the T
following:– V
O»RIT_)__if3R if
The present petition the civil
suit, who has filed appointment of a
Commissioners vpeveliln-beforel’*evidence on his
behalf. The the application on
the grounditlia,-t.fit’wtrhefiipvrovision cannot be invoked to
gather llincumbent on the plaintiff to
t:eI1der evide1’1l”ce_.l: in the first place and thereafter, to see}:
.A local inV«estig*ation if any. This. on principle, is the
c«orreCt.V’1?i’eWr:=ll There is no ground made out for
j interference. However. the petitioner shall not be shut~
oult’=..frorn seeking a similar relief, at a later point of time
andlf it is for the trial Court to consider such an
ii
