High Court Karnataka High Court

Smt H Vasanthi W/O. H Ananda vs Dakshina Kannada District on 25 June, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Smt H Vasanthi W/O. H Ananda vs Dakshina Kannada District on 25 June, 2009
Author: N.K.Patil


TEE EEESEZ (‘L’%f3§Z3′{~’.T ‘Q? E’§§’€£§?3A7§.¢s§é:§ AT ?~$L<3'13.§- '=35 f:?+'-$861} .

W}

has 235 gm: cssm? 3? Kgfim 33252;: A 2* g§§e@Az.§s*§l§_

:”,>;;”§%::>”:’§§:$3 ‘*;:~+:£«: 23% BAX’ e:1*§’J¥.E%”%’E:1,

gsmssa pk V
rag §’§$%v”8£,§ 3&3. 33335395 ;~s.;:E§”V. «. ”

am’: z–«é “:ms:«:€?:~:: W33. :»«: Aasamsa ” –

Maw ggeu? 35; zfggxaa -A L *
$99; saggy; HQi..§:’i$E sxsgfig §=i;:%§% féaaégzf cs:
ggazms, Efi\??;ELS,&}:, QEJEKE * = . ‘ ‘ ” . ‘ ~
gsmssaagaag 535 3.24 -.

33$ 9: €=-§.»’-%§§”‘°\:’;»<§i'.é's"~{

-1 5 ‘

was;-::xs§:’a ;z§%’:xR:*r;%g:;¢\%”‘;”, ‘@j1;*?:’;§::;_=¢;’a§’%=.: ‘
$%flTE.L s:,a;:;2%:::;;sg2:a’re<;;'a@»::i:; H 2

?3'§"§'§"f"%53%=£E?{$

.23 "é§$§wi?¢"£RJE7§H'$F ZT"E'{§ }=?«5.}'~@§§Q»*z"§'E§

a;3;i-<i;:»:;««i'§:x.2,'a i<;sx2=z:-;%§§A ::3:s;*;a:Cs"

C;O§'»é$%.£«?':'3§'§€ $§»;'S'£-"{.¥"§EE§ SEEQREEE?-S §..

" _ Tr:s.§:1:L;%r¥%2%2m_.~e!'a:;;&};.@g;_r §«ZEP§¥2£$§;f2%'{E§
__ .a2m%7:*:33§:%:g;s'z*;::;i«¢aQ

32% ~;{<"}4i,§'i§'§~%§.§Q; :=:::.;=::"s~4;g*¢g C;-éagam.

' 3;<::: ;<u%s,'mT;:§~gz;¢ %s:'%:-'a….£Q§

E5 3..3§'3e':;. S§'{§»¥'§{fi§"a§;'3'-«.§§'§ QPF".%{§£§
?~"{;*3:"'s{§R §~s?€}i.,§SE2 MQRGLE §<_§.§L$%%§<é*'?gQ ?C3S3'

' ggéazxmgeag ax.

.. w ,

$32? MELQRES £3 Sgeuza

‘£33 3%: ‘a3’e*’.*’r'{B. D $€’;3%..§3§%

:”=»1’%s%,J@§§{

R.3z’%°§° B{}%’=é ‘»£§§_Lfi;€3E§ PA$A%’§§”~iéX%~§GfiQ’:’
§v3.&§*«§{3§,$_CRE 3155 83%

233 Tiiii EEEGIE {f€._}{§£«?:’f§” ¥;§a§§}é§{EZé%E{.’rk 533%’ §Ié2Xl”€{3gi.E,{2=§7i,{i 384$~§€} 253$?

2353 “SEE ZIKEEE i.’-€I-{JET <2? §.<.§aR.':€:~'{§'?3'aK2% 3'? {§§'a}&€3:'§§,<§R.E. '$5. 3$48==§£} asf 2€}%i}':P

.1.

4 ‘J 3%? $§$§L’«£;-‘3i
34$ LRTE J.Ev B’€:3iL’£fi.. ?&;’§z§u.§Q§:i
RAT f\.%G.$$C3i r’1″RE€%’:§ER Q.»’3§’E3G3T.§}§i
;hfiER{3:’5§§f3a HELL. RQAQ? §E§’sEDL}R
§’s:’%:’3*s§’¥3$a£,.€”,,’}§i£ Es?fs $32

73 SYEZLEJE A $S%LEr’§ §”s’§$ V 3% 8 $%L’~£§%

zgzégaa gram” NO. am: mgmgarz D&?FlQ.£3§L ;
mgacaaa Hiii RGAS, gamma 1 * ._ ~
mAma:.Qr*::E 5275 G32 T =

was?-2 G?’ 343:3: . .

REe~'”3’R’iE$E€\é’?E% 3′; as SESRETREN’ ire
LAW AS’-«K3 9A§~%L§A?s«’%EN’§1>%R’f ,:?§i.:;;§v:s
3a.:Am”::e&:x;”r. aaw a:>a._s~::j =

{am :a:.$\ ‘v’ES£~?@¥5¥§~3RTH ma 5%’; 32:4; ;_ $2:’::-;?gj:;”:%;’ 1′ ..
em aavasagssxm gmaswav, ‘;a;”>a: 9<::.:§..:52-3 ..«a.r~:.;} as

sm 3" SHA;-me:;:~»:s’.r*;”:*:.:”1:”g::::’=-4. T-33$ :~:~=»:;:%A3’~.,flRA*{;s4:3″‘ rs: Quase “‘;’:«~z§ E§’~£”{§RE
sfimcaazaaseas gm E;?<§%".:{3'L£, am PER: N Na. 292233-:1 3S:'"2%3{.§8 as-es 3 ..223
?é'E§'~£§lW3~.§?.1E;3?{3E?_E mg: =§:;.:s.s zmaga i3ECT!€3!'3 2:? mt T2-%§
£s3::$:::4:a;2 P?~2C3?E£:"§';:i3%x€. ,é;Q'%°"«%..»*'«::":iE 5-'a€x%3<»:%. Q a 3 RE"f$P'E€L1"§"§'JEi;'{.
smxzaxg 9Qs;«z%:$: S53-$Ef;T£:}»§'~§ 23:: $E{1T&€.'}§'~2 2? Fr: mg C£3§aéSé_§§'é§§
P§€i3'§'EC?§£3i'~: MET"?._AS~%$%4G{;}%u'$T§?"QT§G?a§. ; ma 'ma: gs'; 5.3:; FAR sass
W§?§?.%£2§'~3?.ZR$ 5:35.: C'C}§*»§CE§¥»3E§1

" CTETE-;'"3{E~–'s:g {FE 'C3§'~§ FSR Q§S£"RS "E"H§$ $é's":C ?%éE fiifiafifi?

, mag "%'":~ag.;x;i::.:.:;?t:§*4::~;:.;:

.. :§§?§ER:

“§””§<§€: :.:§'%1 {base mafigfg éfé pogiéa' Edgy {sf sréerg,

ihé' mrxgemt 3:' iearfiaé mungei safiasréng far' iméh

5g:éfi§e$_ 'the maifara am if an 23$ far fine? d§$;::a$=,$%, as":

'V "§.¥3a gmufid %?*;e: the gab}

matter érzvsséveé in ihew

3%' "H12 Eflifiii {'7=i'3L?._T if?' AT 23' '="~Ez'(§ 'é€.'13'.Z'~Er3:-3. J9 3-a«f«'I3 <3? 3????

1':-E'EI§§;'§*§i*f}'££=i3<1:='€;"£~':'§' «arr A?' EEAE-§<?AL%.'3R£, as 2:339
(1..

aégefs am dérxtéy fisvezrefi by the arfiey pawzgé bi;;”‘–%i3%$

Cauri if’: sémiifar mafia’,

2′ “E123 peiitianers in these gzetiéicna h;axsé:’_E3§£;§=_3f§:*3E4_fcs”‘ ‘

qugshéng Q? the éfiiire pmgeeéérzégg i;§.T§E-jjx§é:;§;aéé§;§%?:”fieaiéfécsgéf

mas. zgzzaaa, games 3:36’3§§2$§A.V_§efid§mQ ‘ iéae x

first raggmnfient fiied iifiéfii’ $&é’£i;§}:*:.u2? éfléféé C§3¥?$£.§¥’§’E3¥’
Pjreteatéan A22? vsiée § l ._(‘;,, iggpesééveiy.
fgiéffiiéfg pa*§i%§a:_*;e:_$ %::a’%;&-:§.4;nvL;g,:;§’;i_ flit .;é’E:**’é%'<e; dawn 39%;»-

gacfian 3 :.fef'ése_;c"§§i%.3§3 .§'§…§%:§:*'.-;':va3n$:_§'é%sar Prstecééara Act

':§8§ 2&3 L::"é§*;:::;§?';3€§f££§§§§:'24:}é§«Vérsd %1::$E a' in $5 far 31$ petéfieners
32% z::@nt:e§zfie§.' "

3. _E E1é’x:”e “%ie3é’é’3 %e-awed $a:.m$e§ apgseeréfig ‘far

5

§si%%_§5’Ei:i2r§éé3§s_ ‘~..g:2a ieameé c::5:sr:$e§ agsaafészg §$;’

:*%§$§::¢§”:”éé’?;t$;, ‘ ‘ ‘

fi;’ %.V…é’é.%:%;e§ murzgeé Q§Q%§3§’§?¥”%§ ‘far §:}af%°: the gggiiéesg

.f=.a7i:”i§%§ §§,;%$&%, $2.§i’32=’§:§fi&§ 313%, iiia $§.§§_,%§:::% m3’i”£$:r ézzxsaiazeé

” ?§:*’:; fifiééfi ewes ES éimzziiy Qaxzémfi by ‘éiim ryrfias’ §}$$$%é hay”

éhig fisagrt érs, the gage g? g Sééafitifinixaian i-iazzsirgg

T’: $2 EEESZE =Tl’*{fE3_,= 1?’ 53?’ }}E’x?€<§ '§§<§"'»7;'€G7' 3&3"-$345? {Ff 235}?

M4
.:~

-1

. . .. : – r ‘* ‘.’. ,…. ‘ *5′
1?-.3£’§§1i’§§{i’.€.’:5J;2$’§’éi3EE iaaiifésxl 2;? ;«,:,<Ts:2§? '*3: j*«$«%3»§C= 9% 35:9

9!
…,3-

?§i§fi§$5§§G¥3 fig, firig. {§ai§.§ ‘EA. figvaiéh é::§vr§}§§<f;ié:$

Era w»§.§§sM9§;2§§a arm? cagméeieé szaa::ers;§;s;J;:;x:~:[;s;i'a§ _

$21 '$33 Jana 2fi§%' '?°'seréfa:'e; fimy %§:_%";a%§-

§§§§s*a:v"§:2g fééa ééié arfiezx i:%'2e E::§$§;z*:§E,%=:s§é'A_g:é%*¥::i§g.%é§«.f%%$<t§7=§§i'.

gargiéiéanerg may age be éigpasecé $3'-S,'

5. The submimian $1.353 §.é2.r:§é’&é””-,§s:*;:i§§*’:$a§ V

agapgasirgg far {math the p2r:§es.§.._é1s.$i:3;€eé :g?{::;#2.%¢%_Ae,Av.§9§.«:. Qéaced
an ragemi _ V 2 _ ‘V V
g. 5?”? the iéghi §§ ‘§§'”§;.’§_:”S§.§§3f;’%.§§§b¥’2 §”ff&’3§$ by %e2r’r:e§

§§i,§%”§§€”§.§§ a;2peés’4i:1§ ?a;*”~.ié<"§§:%':* fiée pzariiies aa gigigd $:_:?§2*3,

the ér:$i:g:i':,_$¢gr";*%: §:é'a§§%§§::.é"'§%§;aé by getéiégners gm é§$§{3&'~:»&§

e€.v.~%§:§j%;c?2sa§::g %;*:i'a :¢;f§e;:' g:-sages by this Sam Ea Eirze case

'?*£iSs.. $§§aA§i:E%:§§§§§::&ta2§ fisfising §@§§§:daE§§r: Rig.' Sfig.

%{%9;§:a:.;%;;%§¢: fégvagaza am megs 2;; asss».m\:@,?§§;2@§a

anai'a:§}*:;:%é€z%&e% mattéra éspesafi $3": 1%?" ,%:.ma 2§§§

'= g.::_§""'*§a$§ éféée feagafig gfaéaé ifiargéag *=»:=s§%§': $5 §8§§$§%¥%§'"%§

di-¥'&€:'3fi£:*¥'§SZ' E

//«~..~.-.é..m.»~.~,.9._.¢……

E33 iii EEEGEE {,T{§§,?§3I§.’ €33? §<Z.§a§€,;";4f§"?:§i.z'§ §.1é§.Z'€€§ _.v%=§si}§–3§Z "'%?J.'§'.T'«L"»:»'z§( «:2:

2.’-:2 “ma :;1:3:;s::::z;{:1* azf ;§g§:’_:=:’;=’::’;=..i§=;,.-“=«. A:-.;’;* ::a::s:_:::,:3::*§:A Z’s8£8«.f’={a :35
Wt}:

Séfifififi 2′? ef the As: éra méréig, in {Ewe iéghij

aha 3′ gemaiisna mafia 5&3; ihég Caurt in ‘:%.=-.;s;.».§”:2:fd;;é:%:V “‘

agtea 1%?” June 233% in W.§?;Na’.~?§_G§§§§f.§’SV.:V:~
€”;$¥’§T$””§8fi’§€=;:fi rrzatiérs. J AA I
iéii} ?°hé ;’::$i§ti:”3:’2&f:’$”V””::%V:5::né”:*eé:’:
appear fiefcfe Qruzfi H ::srVix < E
Aaigzist 25:39, fer gay

E7285 2'? §i§i3§1€?i'fEZ.5R"§' if}? AT E}=E%_'é."£G A 2.€f}§3£; "'f.P}~E 3=:'§~§$-:3€'f- <35 2%?