High Court Karnataka High Court

Smt.Hanumanthi W/O Durgappa vs Ashok S/O Jambayya on 3 March, 2010

Karnataka High Court
Smt.Hanumanthi W/O Durgappa vs Ashok S/O Jambayya on 3 March, 2010
Author: Huluvadi G.Ramesh
I
IN TH 13: 1~11<;';11 r;::Um' ()1? K.A_R..NA'I'}'»\I(A
c::11:2c':1;1'1" I31I:«:Nc:1---1 AT (_}[,JI,F3AI2("n'-\
I)A'l'I£-1.): 'l"HIE3"1'HE zsm DAY 01? MARc;:1~1:;201o
BEFOI{I£ 

THE 1»«£oN*;3LE MR.JUS'I'ICE 1»~1ULuVAI)1 
M.F.A. NO. 30290 OF 2010 [MW   '

BETWEEJN 
Smf . H a 1'; u n'1a.m: hi .

W/0. E')1[1rgappa.. Agcrc_i: 37 years,
Om: Agric1.1lt.1.1rc. & Ccmlie. " 
R/0. Nancii1miViliagc=,  »  = --- 
T211t.1i~:: 1naui1vi._ T)iSE.ri(71..__R£;1i(ff1':.1.1?,_'  : A'pp,cjii;=g:3Ta1'

[By Sri. Prakei-1.511 Yeii,"Pxf;1\;'()f';;;1:}:}

1.

Aslldk,’ ._ V _
S / 0. Jar11ba1yy-21. “Agéit : ajor.

Oc_(1: D I’iW3 r”-:>.’.£’ V KSR.’_1’C~~* ‘b L1 5
N:;j.KA-37/RQ159, Kappa} lI)<-spot,

V " ….. ..

7_1’11e’Vi)_jiri.é§’i:)fi’2;}l C01′”111fol}er.

_ KSRT CT_”_v._I_§(_~1p’f)a1 De-‘}p()t.,
A K(:)pp2J.1. L’i~-hI'(T)1.1g;i1 i’fi)ivis;i(>11ai
C”‘o1′”11″.~-roi’i’61’. Re2u’c1’m1″. : Resp<)11c:1e1'1'£.

*..{¥3y'S 1*i. §3L1dhir Singh R. Vija.p111'. A('Iv0(',211c for R-2
_ ' " .._E\IQ't.icc i0R–1 is <1ispc11s(:d with}

3

THIS IVIFA FILEE.) L?/S 173[§) ()1? MV A(‘.’.’1′. A(“}AINS”I”
‘E’1″iE JUE..)(i}EE\/iI’§;\I’]’ ANI…) AVVARI) E..);’\’]”I?LI’7) 24-.()8.2()()9
PASSEI) IN i\/E\s’C NO.684/20()8 ON “I”I”IE FILE C)!’ “E’I~i{C
PR’fJS1I)ING CDFFICIER, i’*”f\S’I’ TR./r\(3K (‘,'(‘)’UR’I’–E 63%: MAC’?
RAICHUR, PARTLY ALLOVVING CLAIM PE’E’E’.1″l1C)N I*'()R
COMPENSATION AND SEEKING EINE”‘1AN(ZIE-MEJNT. OF
COMPENSATION.

This l\/[FA (‘:()111i1’1g; 011 for (:)r(:1ers. this :1’;-i’y, A*.A1j’1V(?'(7iV_i,1T1’i’» 4_

(1 e.i_1’vt1*1″ed th 0 E’ol.i.owi1’1g;:

J{}1)GME:N$ [3 C

‘l’11oug1″} the mam-sr is1~:;’C_}’_i–_$*,_t’_c.c.1 F01″ ¢’>Vrc’1(§V1’s%~{f{‘(«>.(1§1}F, wiTi:–.’:.’1″

cmlsem of the 1<=:e1r11ed_ (.:0uI1s_(:l i'u:.1_ 'both Si'e:%.es. the same is

heard séti”‘G~i”V’by this Judgment. For
the pL1i*’p()S.c Of. (5cfiwez1.i.(€13,Cg{‘¢_. the pa1’ties wonid be refe1*1’cc1

to. a.s_t1’1.cy “z31~.1-ctit.1’o11.

22:7 “E3c.i1’1g H1301” .~;21tisf’ic(1 wi11″1 UM’ (£1.12–1m’.L.1111 of

A’—réonl;:)t’:nCSa1.1″1(>11.V;-%~\.va.1’c1c_2c’1 by the “i”1’ib1.111e.1_i_ [or {he (.ie211′.11 of 1 I

gc)a”is/ 1.110 ciaim2=,mt: has preferred E’.1’1iS appeal.

_”s;.e§2C1<_i'11g'–* .e1T1I'121.1'1(:erner1t of c0111pcnsation. 'l'h@ claim. xms

'(:_’1″1t’t9s1:ec:I by T,h(3 i11surar1<':e (".(')11113'c'11Iy.

xx

338:2"?

‘\

-1
V3

3. I—is–1*»-‘E11;2_; 1″<'.jq;2-11*(1 £0 1111c 1(_)t:11i£y oI'£l'1c 111015 2-u'1(E
("'.i1"("T1.1IT1STE111(.}&'f:3 of the (221539 and the vz=21lu(-.* of 1"1":c-é

g(_)21_15/s1'1c.t3,p's as on the ('1E;11(? of £?:.(3('*.i(Iic;?1"1E.. I zm1___of the

E

(3()11SiC1<:'.]"Cd Vicw t.h21't" the (,'.O1'I'1p(?l'1S£11'i()1'1 21\x-'211'(k}V(T1–w.§3y'.fi.}T1(?

'I"r1'b1m211 s1ig;11t:1y' on lower siclcx I1'11.(?n&:StV.(;VI'

" £1": .3 {.3 EEG.' ;

would be met if 2-111ot.1’1e1″ s31,.:1n of R+j:3′;”71’5.,()()–‘() / »_ “eiA\’;r;4z1’V(V’i¢%.’«::i«. (;’}’\,sit the

(:o_m_1′)c_:’1sz1tion w:’thi;T1 I.I’11’cc n101’1f}”1s l”1’0m t:()(:1z;-1y.
av”

Sri. S1..1(i}’1irs:;i11g R. \Fi_j21p1.z:’. A(iv(,)(‘.a.te is (.’11’1’c(‘t’u-::r<i 'in
file his memo of2.1.ppea1'ar1cc: for the 2"" rcs}'3o1a(.1cnt'_ 'w.i111i;'1

:ib1,1r xw-2:31.155.

A 1§£;?§ékA