Smt Hemavati W/O Jayakumar … vs Shri Nana Nagu Kamble on 4 March, 2009

-1-

1N THE HIGH coum” 0F KARNATA§{‘}’i«’ % _

CIRCUIT BENCH AT [),§+i;§R\éJ;agg_~–,. Zi”:; V

DATED THIS ‘ME 4*” 5Av.QF&A§c:H% é%ooi9A%%kLjLff i _

aEFc::g:E: %
HGMQLE MR.JUST:E;E..MC§}§’éx§3’1S§~é§é’N.éTAi§iAA§SOU5AR

WRIT :=g_;=§js*.::’.r:tm%1~4o.z>:§692zo§i7 {SC/ST)

ggtwssen :

§1u?fiaVéfii _ V _ .’
$2′! 0 Jayakumar Km-:ma}:ap;f¢;’ __

Aged afE:20’1;1i_3{“}A y€z~11_’s ‘– _
Rig Saandaétg “€’i};E.::’1gt% ‘ ~
T3111}-;:.~1-Raibag * V ‘

§’i}ist.2ii:.§’i Bfifigaum’; _____ 3. Petitiagafir

~ { E_3§%j g§;:§*.:a: k”é::,_mar 53. E333}: $3:Cam1$€:}. fer
V :’73a§2=i.raj éfi §~Ia”Eii§ Advacatej

I

.A Nan§a.V?§agu Kambie

.. ;?&g§:<i aéaem. 5'2 years
* iiiiifés Smm<.§.ati:i vzifiagé
"§'&h;ka §"€:;ii%ag,
§:5§S{§'.§.('fi Baigaum,

A :2, The 'E'ah3:i_k§ar,

fiaihag Taiuic:

Raibag,

District Beigaum.

3. ‘§’he Assist:-mt Commissiemsr,
Chikodi,
Qist: Belgaum.

4w The Deputy (Zommissioner,
Beigaum, — _
Dist: Belgaum. .. E§¢_$_§:3Gn飖§nt$

( By Sri T.N.Ragh.13.gathy for Sri €.’;.’:.H.Ja:1h:;~2v, -I’ — ‘–
Advocate for R»: and Sri R.K.H’atti,1f” ~ ‘
HCGP for R»? ti) 4}
This Writ Petition is filed 1_;;1ii~s:_r ‘A_1*tic1<2s" 2225 5;: 22? of 'the
fenstitution of India p1'§€zyi;1g to SEE fifiiéfi' the iB§};3i1g11ed order
passeé by the fourth fespoiztirfiiig 4"-Ljfiigptltgf Commissioner,
Bclgaum, dateé i2,€.3I.3.:3GG']r"-I vi.'ije' ;'–"S:1:1¢§<;::;*::wi;3 confirming the
Qrcier passed by the "2§i'SSt:}'{:(}Z};1I1fl?i.t}S§E(}¥fi3'I:, Chikodi, éaiteci

22.?.:z::2e;)5 –

Thisgsfii Pé–‘:ti€;i:;::” ‘hgivmg barn heard and i’€S€§’V€{1 fer
s:§rci£r,<:.* an i27.2,;2{}G9 aizti yronounced ihfi orders an this day

33% March 28'€J–'_§..__ """

ORBER

. ‘ .__”§’1::{é« ]§z;<%:;'£i;9§i:id§2e1" E2213 purchaseci the gfimparty beafnig

.q Szifiéy 495/ 1, measuring 2?; guntas, simated 3%.

K x V' §'3{;%;1;:;d9;V¥t;{i Efifiage Of Raifiag Taiuk, 'ihraugh regisiersé. Sake

* };"'§'.:$:d5 §"n the yaar 199? $516 is in pessessiera 0f '€116 jZ)§"°G?;)€E"?£}'

" virtue 0f the Sam S336 fieed, Tha antrias am mutated

4:

\,,,» 1

– 3 –

in hegrfavour. According to $221: ,$h€ has improved the land

by spenciirzg considerable amount of Irxoney.

2. The “Fai1si1da:*, Raibag Tah1k,’7 fi’ %,m¢

Sl1§Z3i1’ii'{.t’t3€u A_ “:0 .; AV

Commissions? aiiegng that the ‘ }”a1};:iV v.;.vaS i%_;:i 3Sf€n}:*:r,;éd ‘i;:”zL

favour <33" the petitioner if} 'viffiatioii TfE1e.'1vK3;mataka

ficheduied Ctasies 'S_cf:€d'{;.I€§:§. '(V?r<5hibitio§1 Of

".i"'I*ansf<:r 0:" <§1€r't£u";3 Lamci) referred to

as tZr::%:"'§5"f'€.3'LA..§#?:<_:t' Eééed on the said report, the
fissis%3.{3£: issued nmiice {.0 the petitiazzsr.

Stamsnent §bje¢ti§;"1S ';etr€ filsd by {he petitioner E0 the

"'sai{%— Ii€§€iC€', Tfiéreaftaz', {he imp'a:gI1<":d erder vizis

gzassad can 22.7.2006 by the ,:§SSiStaI'1'§

€Z30Ara*:an1i$5i{::§":g':23Ai* c:iir€C"tiI1g rim petitianez' ta regicre the Eanci

"izja favoifi' sf 3:*es§0::{i€::2€ No.1 hfiffiifi B5166? Sesiiom 5 0f

A AC5, The 33% €}i"€§.€I' is c0{;§'%.1"1§:;ed by me Daputy

..€if:z:3:*:;::;§ss§:3z2€:r§ Esigaufig, 2:32:18 é.m:1exure~'B' dated

7':

. V; .>-

Kg”?

,4-

‘2’§%.3.20{}’?. 80%;. E1115: orders are (gueSti(:§1e<i§§;':jt

pefitiifim.

3. The records 1’naint;ain€d;”:.§;§;i. fi%:é . ?

are znaxfie avaijiable by t}1_&Vi’s_gi;1=§:ed C3z>§*€r;1:1:ef:.i”‘Advocate’

for perusal 0f the Catzzjt. S. Patil,
Eeafiied cotmsei petitioner’, Sari
‘f’.E.’~3′ 011 behalf of
raspsnderztg” 1′? learned Govemment
fieadéif,-9;pp;§Aé§.%;fi:;§§§i.i %Sf;a1:e and perused the

ma:6ria}~_{::1′:; .re&:;of<:1«,." " V –

ii is 33}? Sri Jayakumax S. Pam, Iearneci

V. Semi}: Ct05::::i§,$cE ap§eari:1g on behaif' af petitioner {hat the

{§:*:i1éé$ ;'§'a1£'~:f_*:§.¢::i ,b7j.;»' the authorities beiaw are :39': jus'£:ified,

— ifiasfizxicfg 215, may are pagzateti in viaiaiiom Qf principies sf

” Elatifitgi jiistice. E-£6 aim arguad an merits 0:” the Iiiattér.

Per {tantra Sr; ‘i’.N.§€3;g!1°:;:pathy, Efiarzzaéi mzmscfl

” a§3;3%:3.ri§:g 91:. behaif {if i’€$§3{}§1{§€i3f1i N9. 1 arguiid in Supper:

GE 5 ,,
{}f the erziers Of the au£:}10rities beiew. He contenfiad aha’:
t§1€§*c: is HQ dispuie that the Ls.-mzgis, are $*ant<i:c1 Eaads and

that the gamteea area Harijazm. He further 8I'g£1€Ci'f}"§;§lff',i§'}€

presurngaiion arising '1§E1C1€3I' S€{Tit'i(Z}f1 5 (3) af ':"i."-;;€§'* -isy

net ffibiittfjd by the petitiorier; jthr'*;:sé:2 ' 1.

submissicms, he argued far <i§s;§1i5sSai_Gf t}1€'%.§?fit,Vpctfi1'<§zi;».

Sr: R.K.H§ati:3:, ifiaffifid €';§i£s'.e:x§::1[::§i:e1it.'-Plééaéiéffgappcarmg
<31": 'atzhaif at' $515: State af1§g1§-:exd" 13:1» iéiupgaort of tha erders

passed*'£33?'ih§j:a1,1{f;érii'ié:$'- E3«2§£$f;ik';" '

5. As Vafo1’eI:i’£ijifi:i<.53';1.e5d, {ha zkssistané Comrnissiefier

E1§;$_§§;-j3 é1:g.=r..é E"1€}:€T%{?§V3 "£() {ha §3at.i€ie§:er aftar geéitirig 'the yapari

§:a%i'.3,i:€§8f, The repart of the "I"ah:.=;i1da:* is ciattid

Qfiiiiiflfiflf harem has flied siatazzient sf

-V i}§)jf§€i€iGi§1:S.€3§”‘i E5.’E’:28Q6, ‘Z’1’i<"::'€af-6.61', :30 sari Qf énquiry is

L»f£3i?€:ii§-b_3}N '£16 Assistanét; iiamznigsianér. Wifiwui furihsr

' §"%;+;}i§§é am? Wiiiamié: Eieasiérmg izém p€t.i§ic}::€i; 'size flfiifif is

;:é:a$s:s:<§ as 335:? .g%m'1eX1:i'<w:-7A' gésgzad 2i2.?,2Q0§ by 'E116

ziagisiazzt Cammissiaizar agaiflgt the petifiamer. 'F116 Qréiar

§-3

mi
'F

s
Q

-5-

sf ‘éhfi fissistant. C0mn1’:ssi:{1er is in vioiaticzrx ;<3;f";):'i;:?%ji:iTi;1:}.es

of naftura} justice, inasmuch as, nf .’F’z”‘::1i1}*’3f§-Sr }jema:;,§
Lands) R3163, E9759, appafiiinifiz of being
heard sheuié 13¢ giv¢:1V_ ?,;’;«_VV it is not if;