High Court Karnataka High Court

Smt Kamala @ Usha W/O Govind … vs The Asst Commissioner on 16 March, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Smt Kamala @ Usha W/O Govind … vs The Asst Commissioner on 16 March, 2009
Author: Ajit J Gunjal


‘\

E S1′: Gepai,

Sf 0 EZZ’zai:1’:2fi:ra}’a B633″;

éigeé abmri ‘?€} “§f{:’.E’}.i’S3
R] 0 Cmvaiii G313,
Near §}:;;:’gada4 B831},
H’t1b§.i, Di:-st: Dhaxwaci.

. Sm: Padma,

Wj (:2 Mcrhan Qatar) Ktifiiaifii?

Agazi about: 66:: yearg,

1:; Br. M.DuK.”t.1Ika1″1’1.i,
§g~1xmi:1.a1″a§?a:: Nagar,

Near Mi<::m'::i3:1§ Cz<:)kz;_i E130ae:i,V_…_V "'._ '

Ehsbiis

5 Smi. Shaina, V' ~ _.

W/Q Rm1ga1x’ag:;» E3es}3;:g5’a3:g<ié:; "

Ageé. afzroufz j§#*aa.r::s_, __

R] Q ?vE1;r1i<§,haif 'B_aug}3.} _
Gpp. E€'i5"'R 'E'–E_;s?:éfii:'J:s::,. If _ V.
2%'i€$..§R€*'é::i;"'E."i:€:ie=:;a.§'i':=:.ei'.'.' «-
§§:§;;'"1:"&:S£§ off,E)}_1a"i;%?x;i.,«':21d.. ,

gig g§L$¢s,%.::;;m5~g3., "

{Egg}: §<Z:ité:'L1f *Z§h'§:1t1.n–a2:1~::;23. Pay};
_§3:31gL:m1n Raaég

– .L__iT}3i1;;g.;~fa/3:1 x

{Rf} éjaaiistaz dispezzsfié}

‘Ev’? I’§{>. E l”39i§8 {>5 i2i3{‘3?’

mE?;E3SE3{T}E’§'{}§3??%§TS

L’ _S:};7§:.:’§f3;§*:3#§?3i{1?.C§§”Ei i5′:”a$a{i 5:, %i1°;Z$%:11a $s£}§}iS§.’§.§i5 z”§{§V$. Ftzar
_ :2;::;v;*a:;vv-s;:–é,;s’::’-.§-§’ehha:. my, ism R4; Sn”. Amsmdha
§”}e:~:%1§;a:§§§.§;.§§dv., Em” 153:3; Sri S,S.Pa:éi, Adv? E303: 3&3}

‘E’hi3 péttiticn is fiisd 1i11fi€ti’:%I”§iC}€S 122% amé ‘E2? 0f {E16

fi:1r.:;€§«:ure«§, anti (SEC.

Canstitaziien of Enéia }1’I”&}’iEig to qziash the €’}I'{i€I.’ dataé
:4w1’3.28§§, in exacuiien case f\i.§:}9i”£Q8f.2, 0:1 irhs {fie 9%” me
ii ficifiiiiémai {Zivfl Juége {$:: 131$}, at i)h.a;m:a.1i72§’4% of ‘EGG?

This pstiiiezz sawing 0:: far p1″€iimiJ:;ary E1aa;”i£:g. ‘i:1y
Group this day, 1:116 Court made the followixxgz ‘ ‘ ‘ ‘ ..

ORDE§”»¢i”

The petitiensm’ is q_uc:sij0:_1i11g Vfht:”*:>rdz:;j.~;’3asvS3ii E75§;F’ §’k1€.?”
exacuiing Cami on 31: api§£.i_é’2::fi0n “ma3ti:”:5 the 3rd

I’€S pQ11€}€I1? uizéier Q:€§§:€:j«. 1 agf th::; C5de of Civi}

P1’0cedm”e to came: an rggdré.

2. :’}if;’3,tT'{1VtT:~%.”i’1vv'<'£'2O;3;:I'.:I;'LV;§('3}i appeazing for tha
p€'£itis;mc;<r Court was n.c:;t justifieti
iii. gigmiitig ifiasmuch as :10 third party cars.
be pfizfiiiigeti in an t:xe€:';3.ti1*<::(:£:&d§ngs.

H33<f:.%.rk3,€1* siifigfiiis "{3::.:,a§ iha p::'ii"»:ia£1er was gsermittezi 'ts mama

. 'z:;s'§.j: 1*§:f;¢§~=.:"zE<';aI§:Va isgaise, m1{3;€1" 8.13253}, iii §fIw§?'.g%aN<}.§3i2f 1§9Qy

SqSx?a.i:i}3 iearmzd {#9111183} agspearing fez' fix:

pm§}«:3S:5:€E *sfis§:;::s::s§€ms gubmits that the véiffi, 0:: whieéiz

H , ::°€§§.a3::c€ is §i8i3fi€3; 'fly the *g:e€"£i'§i0;1<3r, 53 Eabficatsé, fivfifi

a3'£§"§{if'W':ES€:, tiafi sslasém 9%' {ha tssiaém" in the property is mzziy $33

1113 sxteizi 0? E2431 sham. Eis fufiher Submiifi ihai ix; figs

/

/X

'=59? N0) 3: i'}fr§3 <3?' 23$?

~33»

a§S€i}{,”fi 9:” 3 gzazfitiozig Eihs %.<:$"£atQ:: §:.£su'ié "*d€:': "'–}r£2s,f;ve

btzquaaéthed 11:3 zgxidifssideé Shara in favaur .’¥!1%”.”‘,»..V”‘-,

4;. ‘§’h€ “fact germané fer {§i:.;}:x3$a§ ggef “%’s?§é.t,

£32113 bf? &1;.;3,mar.i.sa:C3; as fQ§10w;«s:

‘E’%1e3: iaaé. in igtzasfiggz }.’?;fT?:._:31::V.°r§:a%z1:*i:3g .316:
;’?1{.’f.”€i’:§§ 12 gzmtas was #{§i;.’i;”V§§.;’:h€’;%’€£i4’VE_.i§};§.fi§’ S€Ci”iO.%’iS #5:
zansi 6 9f ‘ihcf_ ‘Lan:”i the pzazpose sf
ssiabiifikxiggg 37.3 .._«3;V’£f:aQ”.:.””i::£; ‘{fiV£spu’€:§f ihai ‘tha iand
::>ré.gi:;a_fi§qg Rmdabai maiiafi mi
zxiapiicaiéijiz __§;8{1) {hf the 3,2316}. Eicquiaiii-aim Ski’:
.:~3%:€E:i:’:§ 2%?§'<?if%3fiCa:?::' .:T§);{;§"-ufi§%'{?{P;":1' wag Z'fi§f31"'I'€{§ 323$; it wag

zstfigisiaafeai 2&3" 1€;"§?} 1984* Tht Saki §'t°.'ff?;§f6E"i{',fj amaiiataiizm

"'2¥f'E§'£-; §3;'?§{f§i}§"§Z€:;'.€§ 2233:? {:35 {'f:}fi§}}{"E.'§1Sa§iQ§;'§. was az:i:an.a:’::i

.’ . ¢§€a<.:« gmii gm: §{5E:.§§€:$ai was %:2:'m1ght 9:: zcceréfi '§'h&

fiieaé. M.§?;:%.?%s:},9i%'2f E'??? sticking m';%:a}::s::€m€::"{ £32"

: €3§3C£§.§}{"":EESa'{§{}?;}; '§'.'§.:a=, z;;;:3§;«€3z2§ fiiaii Esfg figs 30:: ivag ;3i§9wc:<'% <32':

i.2i"_%.{}Eie,2§{}}. 321$} fizz: :*;:im:§_3€::$z:'£i§::;I;. *%'%?E?éS itigizzzzxgfszi ii;

/.

%

‘$3? §”3{3. 1 $948 Gf 29%?

: :3 f
Rs,&.t$?€}€}f~ gar ii is 530% ii} €i§$g3u$$ that {iurigxjg the
p¢t:dea3.<:~j§ 9?.' that said M.F.A., 55-on flied and :h,::V~._fg52§é;e:.mf1'£

petiizirgner has coma: an rtcoré as legai heir 01:_.iT:§ é'
W13 said to have exécuted by §{..$:;'}§sai
aiimweci me zapgzsficatiazz ané §_:a£%r1::b;§§.i§:ziT'..€§:;
{tame 3:3. rehetoifi. Th€ §u::igm€::;:__ta u
Refarétnce Csurt as wall flxis sags put in
£3X€fi{',Ei'§;i0E1 in EZ.P.N. f 1%-?;? 9.i.4.A§Vi::«”«:-32_3j.{i }:¥ 3;.’G;$t3tfC§§..?:1gS, it
agjgzeazg the €xeA<;'u£i0:: sf ¢99/ 28022 is filed, The

r€s:§f}¥;}fl§§:ei:3%. z1′:>ss_.3*tc: :33 make 311 appficatian finder {fizzier I

” Rtfia? 3’§f§€ Ccyde :3?’ {iivfi §_3″};”‘§)€’fi€(i1iI’ft :0 came. 0:: recarfi G11

fE}1’a: givaitgé they saw fificfissaiy am} prepay patties; figs};

haxéa Efigifiiiifiafe iniarest iii thii subject. mafis:-3:’ 63? $16

preitfitzgfizgs ifiasmticiz as may are the Eegai Eieirs W113 are

‘at:%§§?;E€€% far £_’,fim.}f}€E1S&Ei8fi. The exectziing Court. aéiawédi the

__ }:::a§é agéiisaiiegz.

. /.

/

‘E3?’ §’é<::. E:73'?%«z"i§;'Té :'3:?12f3{.'%7

W}

;–§.§3.p§i::ra%é.<3z1 was Q_'§;_§j3:3s::{§ E2}? §f}1E"f giiiifi £31"
Céantempiateti mixsim" {7}r<i{i::' 212 f€%…:.§t: 5 if CPQE
:0 be zéaiiissstl ihai: Ehf: ciaim af $31.3'}3§E§.§;'§§Q";;1{%%%§;§"'V '
the w';iE exézeruiezi '{2}? }i:,§”§AV”:§::i$VvVaficwttéV L’
the é:i§”.}}3§i{T3’§1iE1}”i1} C1065 3.}.gr;f: 1}€§j6$*%.£é};’§}j§?’ 7iE::”~1f; Sagid Wifi has
33:23:’: aaéitspiaé ‘$3: 1:116 {§<;i%?;'Li thereof has bfififi
pmved h€f0:*u€ g%ii::§ is Iequired
'Sm pmve .f;3s< u iiifificr Eaw, msreso, in
Eviezience Act. Indeed,
this 1:3 8;. to 13$ Considered by the Civil
{hurt §*s*3:3.§§1":: :31 Vi;.1.%::.i*.é n2<§§:;i§réi1e13sive suit is pending in which

ifmé? in q:it:As»';__'§ir:»¥11. rs also a mibject matter.

_ M Efisjgtéfzar as the present pmceafiixigs am concemafi,

'fixeiieeii, ':1*:'i._:v:1i execuiion pr0£€eéiz2.g3§ E am 0? the: View thai 13.0

}3€3:2:~3cm«;_ca.n be }:1€1"'B}_i{'€£:d $0 came an receré who was not 3;

in '£1123 ozégiaai procesiiimgs. Thét raspondsnts have ffizsté

a zzzere cgmgrshszisivfi Sufi, zvhich is ;}€31§£%::g. '§'h§.$ {f::3u.§'i in

ma €336 0%' ii}? 2964 EAR 5313 has sfliszfl? that it. is eizgsiiai far

at: i§f1§Z£E"€i${€§L f}€?EE'S{)E1 in $56k Ezig ?;'€IE€i{"§}' €1${~:w."':z€:r€ €313}: €313

/

J

'$5 53 N0. E.;f31'5.?@-é:'% C»? léiifi'?

:9:

It is apstri far the :”6$;_:u:>11z:i€::1t::: ti) maks gm ap§:«}:{:afi«:;~:’:
in the psnéitxg suit f01″ba:a3;*i;1g {SE16 §3€iiEione:” ‘–.frG1:n

wii%1Ci:”3.wi:1g the aflaouz/H iii e:x:€<ct1ti011 §3I'OC€€3dAiE1g::S.}§§Uf};(iVi1"§g

:%§$;(;{3$a} (}'f the azuit Ef ssu<:t.':1 air: appiication is 'fi.1c(i; "£é,1é éafiie

$11211} be crmisidfzreci having ragani to '£133 {3?JS=§:rV§:§i¢g;g~.;/;1a{§.e
by this {:1<:=':11""£ in ':h;i$ axdttr. T.

1uDcsE