IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,
CIRCUIT BENCH AT GHLBARGA.
Ef.3A'1'.'£"E"'E§iS'_E"'HZE 2;2> {:»,;x::' 0;? §?Z«:E§§'E'~€'{L~'a¥€_?:";"'iéimj 5 u
BEFORE
Tm: HON'E3L£§ MR. JUSTICE; Agfiff1;}; '{j}.{ENJ}i;E;if--..__
REGULAR smcorm APPEAL N €)~,.}2EV’1 33 {s§:3:;2:ogf7}
BETWEEN:
E{e1ma1aw\wa1 W/0 Vit4h21’i-_Er§:;.g;1r ” ‘
Aged E1b{‘}L1i’. 49 T
OCC: House W0r”}<:v .
R/0 Hz1nge1r{;gj __ ..
‘.E'<:;, .E321:s;a1°Va1j1.–.E3.agé%§%;i21d~i.Z' _
915%.: Bijaptizr, H .
... .?;ppeE121111:T
{By Sri.
Sri... Jafgaciish E'atE1,~Advocate &
S;-ii Vishwgnatis. S;'v_Pai*ii1, Advucate}
V z ..... .. W
__E; J’ S;i'<Ea.4′”Qif:’z::3 1′”: a ppa. J (>12: :1,
~. 2″?%–g§§td”:”§3*}f’_v»};<%g:§fS; Ow: §Ei5:§§§"i€;?E%S§
Afipp, {Em-*§1.,'TS<:h:}<3§ E°'*${}.E§$ Sinah;:pc":E;.
231?} V21§:s'z::'«';*"'3§£%§§ 2 GE .
V’ ;v’§g:.§§i}:a::§:.2r: €::E’i€iI’é1″§&3.§}§£§.«§{)=}.§:1{§§
‘ ‘?§;;_§€%,a::*$§ Gczéz Sgfrvicefi
<.4=;fl £¢%& M&%R{¢Wb ; ‘ 1.
’73
Upp, €}’9. Shahapeig
Bij21pu:=»5§8E31QL
3″ So :”:*1e1.ss}1<:%1s:}':21r Chziumiippa J<3i.:~1(§,
Aged 5&8 yeaxfi {}<é::.: Pr:-?:1$;i{)::1e1',
R/0 Sh21hapei::., Bij21p:.11"–5861O 1.
Respz’:Ei{%:2i:_’:s- _
{By Sri. Praveen Kumar Raikote, Advocate_-&~ » V ” V.
Sria Sanjeev Kumar Patil. Advgiééte-« f§ar_ R~_:1 ;:1′:§:7_.’. R3;
R~3 served)
This Rsguiar Second ATp;;§_ea.E .iés.V_f;i.ix:.c’E 1.3.;:i€h;;::i__gS<a*£*1
180 of CPC aigairzst the: ‘}’i,l;(‘,:1V’gE;§VIV:.Tf'”‘i€E’I1f 2ii2gi””a:i.–é<:1".é5:s'; Vdateci
1§.zii.%2€)O'? passed in 0:1'. fi'i e af {he
Pr}, Civii Judge {S11£333,' TE3»§jé:pi§§f], Ehe apyeai
and cr1.fir1ni11g;;V. ‘{.1″1(;% A”‘j*2££iggfi1€::£t: léiszcreti dexteci
zaxazoeagxgséggngjggfikigiéféaegkngrhaiaezfithg
1AadLxv§§gagé§fi§§ggfEfi§§gn%
V .i;_(}Ti’VV%E.{§I”§”ii§§E§§{}E”§ *::his:; day’, iihff
Cam”? d’eiiv@::*€:{i– *C.h€§’f{5§E{‘3i§%’i.E},§§:
” ~g§é@MENT
EE{3?;f_Ef3 _V”::E:$; {im.::’é:$ Eyekéw §1gws:: s::<};1<%urr:.::”:§§
L'”E:h215§._ iffzéé :§:§V;é_i§::x:’é;.é:§*§’° is :;’1<:»i:. <::m.ii;Ee<:e::§ fiéi' t:he:+ rake?' sezmggghi. far
_ §§:i:Ea:2d§::f;g;f {ji*3"":§€';';*. :2? §I'Ejé4'2§1{":EI.§{}§'?;.
V .. « «E
2}: zfifitziui ;3:3:*'s<;:": Eiilii <:§§§'::z2.§§':e{§ §;.%*n;=, §Es:*:«:7%.:'*::*:<~'-: E3; f:"a:.:{§,
2, TE1e s:s2,1bjec.:t: :1'12:§ia:%1' is; 2:1 1'1m,:$e3.. '§'E2e a':a$:3 :3? ilhff
piaimiiff is 812121.. (i€ff{ifI":€1E1E1i',§E% E. ii) 3 had f'ii::?d .21 :a'{:_'ii:,» .i:1
O.S,?*€(3,23£};' .E.E}§}€-3 aaggzzixzesé. the moi:}1eér atzxf i'§:1<:% p]g.1'i'::tfi;§§_'__:39pd
:p&:r’i.y;”
it appears the :1:c>i’,I’1er1* :f I?:}i<;_ 1ia;'i':i£:.:'§'":§;;2a<:._¢3f1:a:%:'1i§.
It is»: as:§.<:rte=:d $111121? {the p1ai'nt.if:f"'-:Ts_ gfiizlg-?_'§I.a1L1:gg'ht.€1' to
her m0t,h.é3:1" anti she go? ssuii; property.
‘§’I:’:2;2s a<:e. .hexj.*{3*1’§ éiémregr pamafid
in (3.S.§,’~Ec)f_.3′;?;{%_,f’ 0:: heat The
¢:*7i;<-:f'e:1d;»,"~;.tf::..t:s,-3_é:1££:;:i3g§ deferzéajiir, N95; fi.Ee:d
a <::zs§:11t;i:1g :ir*§f£i’3£j€é::=. “:;:.?:j.2*:;%{:’r:’:ez1″é. siiaéiixigg i;:1″:ai; he was
c§af€:2{%:.~1:fiV:” K };Q§5 and 2-‘i’E:é:r the cieaztih
A_ sf :}’:€:s{.Ej:§}.:’ 5}?’ !E.§’1%i%’*’;:sv?,a;’_«z1v’£’,iff: he hééfi §;>r<}L2;3;E':.E, thzi fact: is iihfif
:':.9%f'§a::% é§'<5:;:'1:::e3é, 3:: E5 aiisfi s::aE:21{.€‘C,E§€f :3m;.§e:;:<': of i'.h.£-2 iZi:3z.2:*§T Ea;-m:*<;t cigéiibéirzaifiifg §;r<:<?€~::;%s_%_£*{i
2. ma ‘\.>3
If}é3fe:’1ci211’1i$ I gmxfl :2: fiissd xx-*:’§1:t.z;%:1 ss£,a.t.e~r:1é;é:1i: zmd
qiefermant; N33 ad<)p'{'<;éd 1:11:27 5521:3227. A:::’e:Ei’r3;g %.0i}’1i;31:2
E.§’11:* Ema’ nétather =::§z1i:m’-éci ‘E.i’i’l€ {.0 ‘{%.1§:a**-;:1:_f;’:;:_=s;a¥;F:’::.,%’
at 21.11}; p(:i.m’ {éf i:irI1<;é_ It is i;hwnership 9?:;:::I1€;;…R§1gi32i3é1″é.h=Ti?£2}sar f
who S3€33.C}. the szzme in fa-1x.=i::u_;j if A:§’éZf=52n.€1:::§§’t.j_:
}}HQ?.i963 for 21 <:; ‘£’h£:y Wouid
gzhiggj; {:():1If,(3{?;gj?;. ::§§é1E§1§.iE§~ had Ifilflfi E1
Sufi, in and the said Silif
‘$921.3 :32′: E938. E995, Th:,1s ighe
p§a.%r§€’,iff E22;-:é_; ‘:3.:1p’;::ré’:5s'<:.;§'_;~'s;§'1e maE::%r§21_i §'21£:i;&s and is not
<&r:'::§;i:}§§3§Ev Lf<:i'r r: -sV:vb€21’i.:::’£::i_ by d€:£%;%nd2i:§f..s I :9 3 is; ?}§§1{§,’§I§f.§ en mar
is ism: ;z§,g22i:’2s;’:. ziiisad g:am”:~s»<;:2¢ KW;
59'
iv;
igiaésiéé :T:<:%'.'2*
§3_z'<3e:§2.:a:;:é%:fi <?2i'3i.:»; §'L"é+?'{} {i§<}{':'e,2:11€:':§:ss iii". juaiggizzétziii. 2,-mgi; <ia*:c:ma::~
3. Le.2i«:1’m”%d ‘}”‘1’i21§ Jufige: on e’~.,zi£ie:1<?€: ham f<:»uf:1:i Eiiqziiz
this p'121inE.f£:{f Ema: f£ii:l€:',{f ix} p:'<3ve. t:b.<:: t'jT.S;?LEI~i»€; iH21S}f'i1Lé{?,hI}{}
ds:2<:mz'1<=:r':t.s; art? f1ni1′:g; to se:§’::{:sW :1i}i:w.i.t}héétaéiifiiig 3
th.:-3: r{:{: in {h{;’ earlier’ Szzit, sshe Ems: 21.123gsfiégygltxligmitc: {};”–
any ng;hf..
4,. §_.£:?Ei}”I”1€3€§ App€1i21t.a>g}::d_,g€:
5. I §’1’d3e_..>(;’; perL1sed ;1v%1d.’:Vf§de{:ree3
pews-satd by bath iihe 21é;ssi§i21r:c<3 {ref
leazrned ¢:)(}L3.if{:E:3€f3§~:f(§E' the3:{%s;f:o:*:§£e::1§,$;;. 'E=;'§?§£'é%é3c.'£ it; 13 {G be
ngticed 'é:hat4_.§iiai::; ,' E :S'§T_:jy.ing _t;9j:1'€§*;3Vié"":}1%: judgggmenii anfi
deems <_;:f_: %j':iz§:%"'*g:§:;§L::';;1'*Vi;}:::s.'€ is} p'c'%E3S:§f;'E€i agaizlssfi; déztad
pé3:rS§i7_i1′:2:.:1s.:n”é;1′{:E’;=.as A§”‘i’%§}§’V.”E’§*9,_{}’§i;”?’i«i”3}” avzm; ma: aiiva whs3::1 ihéf
d§€f€3E”€’3%€3 w9;:;;_ p:r:ss;&’:d§’; E»–*2: %;i;: this be :10t;%<:t3d Ehé-FE. 2;:%$11'm§ng
§:Ef::«3§;.«.{:i'£: is: &;£},.§i{V2-..«:11:; fazirzsci ?.:E'2.<:: g31ai§";i.E{f E'3z1§; ne*£: EEIEEQE
~;2*§V:-:iE;{§:.,E€.'«a_:':.:g7":?:;:€:{3'rd is &§i1w ihéii, she is in p<}sss€*::ae5;si§j%,:3:9i;}:: E)a:.ring;’ ‘she £3{}LEi”S€? 53:? {l}j’i2fi SE15: $33.3
I’
/W,,»*”’
M,/”
f”‘1
. 4