High Court Karnataka High Court

Smt Kasturibai W/O Shanker Rao vs Spl Land Acquisition Officer on 24 March, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Smt Kasturibai W/O Shanker Rao vs Spl Land Acquisition Officer on 24 March, 2009
Author: A.N.Venugopala Gowda


….x

:3; ‘§’§~§§%’; gam-~§ :’:<::as £4252' s:.§§-' 2«;;a§e:m'rga:;:;a_""_» :
::::§~2<::; $2' §?-5fEi§€{;§’%:’~’~:: ”

Tiéii. %£€Tf:*:’.’~1?’§.Z?:LE=3 _%’v§.§%i .g1,::%:;*§*:’éf:–%i “~s.m. %s;: :~;:;:3;{__;-§f*s§’:;;*x~:;«:;%w§3A’VV ‘

E’:/E.§~’?,2’¥’a. ?~%f:.’},.. Vi3’z.::%i;az ;2i>:>§ ‘* . _. 7

§=g§3′:*w:%:§a;&s: 1′ V
2″ gig? :z:;a;s:”+*<i'§.2':~2V:ms22%;3~<_::=iL':a1€-:'a':§2%;s::~:%éz_ fig-sgjé 1'

A('§E%§: :;@;%:"§f:g§;% <::j;:, i,gfi.:=§:§ ;=*:gi.e:>:§’;_Si*:’:_:~€ ‘:;:-:i§{;mz: Ni}. 3 1
‘:~§v§n»:–3%;é§ 1z::3:gAr§’;g~–:§:;§::HA

” §3;a ?=».{}§. ;

§%3§€;$i>'{}E’~§§.}E:Z?*§’f

“2s.a:i%f;: E–=’iLE’;§;§ gigs; :”§<'é{§} as: Ejé zac? A<3;m:::;T *2";-«£3

;;:V;;iL::§.<:%2~:§'2::%4'§' mm 9;s:m.;{::: £m":*;':::; ;.9;::f£a:~.§SE%”;E1.:t 3% mar:
* §*§{}._;§£}§§.i% §a::; AT’

EEEJA 5% £4} , §”§%§€”‘f’E.£%’ 2%..’ LQW 1 ES {E ‘TH E E%§§§7″§%2I*13’§E=’Z- $3 {‘3 I3? PE?Z”§’ i’§’§ {I} 5% ET} R

44 _.§ii-?~I§”‘§E%E’é§fi§”*§§} {T{f}§fi§33EZ.§€E§fi{§§i}%\§ ffiéii} f*§E€;E%i§<~I§§'§{} '§¥'E§§¥"E'§-'§§}§3?

§"":7: 3%' §'"%}°§§\é {X41 3% E5 {E E' {ii} 5% §'7'E*Z ?*é' §:§'?§'E'E {} $2 9

Em?

rib’?-§§f%§ ;’iE7’§'”*’E§.,«=1″*.a.§’..{ {.§{}i’%rE§§’==§’€f§ €}§’€ E7′{._}E4? E§’§§3?i§.€§?€{,§ ‘”_§7-EEES E35-RY,
f§”§”£Ei {‘Tf{,§i..»’Z%€’§” §.’}§}§ ;§E??*Z§€§*Z§’f} ‘§’§~ii?3 §:%'{Z}E,L{i’}\?§E?*~§{i§; 7

x.§¥}’§G§§}EfiT

;Egg:’%:'<v:=:{'§ Esjsi '§§:§~:: {T§_{i;?'£§"§§'{i§I'3. gf. <:;:*;::1§;:_+:§z1r;;;%«:i:i;f;:% §¥’_éit{‘€i€?§§ ¥:3;g ‘

$;§§§:’s £3E::§s§{t§’1c:: iiimzfi in §:Z:i€:'(}’i1.1′ af :*:§.:€fé§}3§V3ei§an§’ at §£s;:;?f§V;§1.§}Gf ~

_{§{‘:i”‘ ac:§'<:% azzéi «::},:,~}£§;3.é:"3g E32, 72' ,€iQ',=*§2;G{}f ~ "par a::2'9t:}_, A€l?:is:….g1p:§;)€aE. has

1:3:-352:: }'3§'{?§f3}f§'€{i ?a}-* $3135': <:'§aém:;m'£,.

2. WES: the €{}§’E3*§}fi{‘éfif:E€fa{i{ié&Z§; ‘€?€§12fiS€Z§” 017;. bofiia skies,
gizzce {$3.6 znaiisa? {:{§v{az”:-‘,é{i.: “mg “:5Q’§3§ivisis:sgf1 §3fi1’i(.’E’E jmigmeni cf

$1273 <:'s:;{uz'§§ i}::is'v:2:p;§€»a£ ié«::?::_<:€T:: 13;: far £1123} ziispesai.

3. « ‘”‘E’h=;:’ zVa§}}fé£,:V§§z3l::.?§.”E::’éémii %x:a3:”ing ;€§:§v:?€::;if§’2″?/ :2 ssiifuated

aii. Aiazgd viiiééggtv fat};-‘i1i<.; Gmibarga E.}is€.I"iz::%, measuziizg 2 EC?'-{'f;":3

'3

» _;32"§3'iifi'i3S vs.-ggs pragéijiéééai :2'; ha ar;:*a;}1ire:§ bf; fiéii ;{'{':$§3()§.'i{§€:"E}'£ e.i§1<is.:r

_ §3r%:;§ii :3%,:;2l2x53f§;,_::é:.:ifi<:ze:t§::s:; zisriszii E125 2.2. i9§'?E §E;s:' S225: pa,::"pc:§;<3 if

iéniaifia _§?§'{2_§::«:i%;= :53: fimai §§€}§3if:.£§i?i{}Ei§ was 'i.%:5:1'€;–2_fi:=.:* iasmeii.

{7=:§:1i:é§':§;_ Eiw :%.frsaz;i.%{i éamé _:-‘2E{‘;.§’:g 1%-“iii: {}§”§}ffE” §3ra:;v1;2£::”§;§::&

“§’V§T:é:%$é;11§N”‘Ea%;”, an z-§a;2:::'{§ afisasz ggéélafifgiéfi “E33? ifmt 3.,-§%{‘} e:>-:2. 2 E.f§,.E<§§:"':1

'i§§'.;"'€»3i'§_'£'ig iézistt 3:2'-.§§.€§ ii; {'§§E{",E*é§.§{}2'.'§ E:-ES ::'i:'7,s' .§z.»§.mi ami zw:a:*{;§iI'2g 3

<:t{:E32§g:i3;'::~;a{é:3£: 5;?' Rs. E?,i;§{}{§;' ~ f_.}{i§' :9§{T3"'€f. E§}é:;3a€isfijs: aha §£%{"§, 2%. £"%"3f{'fE'i'E'}(.'f€'i %::-3J.si§':g 1}éi:=:.:.1 gazighi $10 the

iiivéi {Ti-231:3? eimi. the 113:,-2E*:.s:" Eaavézzg §.:z:{=:.;"2 re.f'€3:'r<:*{i .U§:i3_{'."fivil

{_';<3zz:"{, W513 3::/gés;E@:"€':{§ 15:: E.–§§{f' 3%}; 2{1?{}3 cm' 1:I":cf" (,'sT;7-_i:§;3.§:

§%:am':.:3<§ Sivéé Qiuiigzfj §,}§1.§ faizmiia »

4%, That €:§m'm:.»mii Efazaa Qsgzfiiééifijj. £253 " §5"%3J~43*..'-;;::{3A[. Eazzs'

§;}§"€}{§?:}.€':é*1}L {Em ::£§,sc'u:§::ar.<i as .§;i§:=::£':sP~='§:

':6 R28. '§"'£1€% awa2"::§ maiézi $3}: E;?:{EL'L»i,$%'C} %,v;a§;~§né;'§<€d Vwifiia Cn$€.§1’%

23:3 €:x:’:.§7~:’~§. G31 €i§$$€:’;:{S};2;ifi:’:*£I«’AVi,3§”A ‘{3..f”c”%§ aizéi V€i{;:::1’3;::;£:*z3;i:a;’§7

fiV’i€§f:§1{“.»{j;”f_’:~€E_A§3:E:§€1§:€§fE{};’§’?€§”€:f:5′{3§’f. ‘{fi::’i€1’z12§1;1?:=5’g:§€::r’i:§;_ ” _g:;;%” E%s.i§f3,9’T~3{}/M gas? €~.i(‘.§'{‘i }:.iL., E2};

if-::ai3é§;tiT’é22§iE”3:=..§:;:§3.a:i i§:._:::gta§ti45x;%i.%;V;>§; 23.3 :55: {if}-‘ Eamgfi.

E3. ..3.é% £2}. «:§i§a§}13’Z.5: §:E;..3.t, ééiqazzg ‘ea-*iii*1 ‘§;E1:?< iafiii in

'{§'§.l'T:y'-§3§4§:$:3'§§', _ ::'§:¥ii{:1" 232:? wiry $5-,'ifi1.§i §}:'3§imi:*1a2*j;~* ::<;E.§§i€ai.i0£1 ii:5″1a3a’§;i:;, w1*3i(:h

“ea-2&3. 592$: ixfigaifid §z2n:::.{.=i, ifiiiiég :«;:gg§”§.€:v<':*:£ hf; '$33.5: :%2v::s,:'ifi§ mafia E3}; {hit

V. _,§%§_fi:i§%~:awr"::2{:::t {ii::;'::3'§. :3: Efiii flay E.i3{§} €3'?§ ziatttzi E."§./»'%;;3;{){}i'<3 had .§7ik:s;§

1's'§I~?'2'% §'€c:::( Sééikééf :2iI}{§i"_§ in 'ibis c<;:m"*£. ""E'§f1."§_s ezirmiii éaiszing 3.112%}
=3

€?f}E'iSi{§€:'..§"€:2§i{}§.'§ §'?ix'§"P~E Z, 22 <?€fiifit:r<i {rag}; 231" éharé J5§§i~V1§Ei':'{i§Zf€iC§ iii:

re5§}£:<:i <3? fixes: gait: gf m:ig}.;?:mu1'i;3g ia:1{?:'..'_"§)e2z.ri2"1'g'" T»s:_'i_:.;iéc:§;

N<3.4i}3f 1 3§i:;z.:~:i:%§i ii': fix? Saifif': vfiitxge»,-.pi:-'_x¥}r.éCf1' ~.:'j1:11€fh.:';a"t:i;E:a.§1€:§: V

hazani '::2::<~:n. piacezizi, W§}E}L'€i{I} om: ass}:-§ [{E.:a.c-

had $3663: saici fez}; 21 cc;z1si:ié::’:Vfi%i€;.g’; sf A§?€s;;_’§. argczfizyyax
2.5%. 1%}, ziliowfici ihé: gippsai ‘v.£i€i9:;vmz;_.i2é€,§- Ezzarkci. Vfihlfi
{sf £316 aatquiréd prd§§e?;i}?_A it » par :7«1r::z*€ ‘W13:

<:::m8eq1it:niia} :'.=i1%.:}§is:%tt{§ *:I:.1c:*€iu éhai,

'ii1<:su.gh i}1€'V'.1#?:§i',i£f§i:. was j ':haV"'€§1z§:3§e..:’I’.§.g§L:’.g’-§.:’f»:§.’ },§§}’k€§§, by’: {he {:::m§§{é:’:safi{)x: W213

<§&£=.:*1':::i:::&z§, §':?;':i:£§f§i"§"Vé£;?§ZEV i§:;::"'s3_}€ _{§{:{:i:'% Ei:<:%.. E1 3. Ti, :sz%;.éc?.%1 g:§ti:"%.3i:':«::«:,% is

2.5: ééijg' §.az'::'§, "

,

an ‘::.€:s:£ a:{;ez:§’;:3s::§ §{}E’ figs :»3p§:«:::’§Ea:’3§. <:<.m¥,&:.r::§.:é:"§ Slat.

,'E3fTz'€., _§'Ezf§§3:;?':€;-5.1%'?"éaifiiéii €:§f¥%Z.?'£§E'i'§ :i:22§.z:<§ 128" 7§H2{}{}8 pfifififfé :3": ?a»'iF1€% P~E<3.

8§§€§§§£-

;–:f;%:§;i’:5§§@3 as éézgz ézzsgizzzfzé ;:}{::”:j;

. V ézzff, SS. §,{}’%3,{}{}$f M pm” Eiitiix

33 §<i:2:r§::::az:;, liézzfnsiié E:3':ai:-:-: irmzzgsrii S:;%:2z::!i'%,i,,-‘§.’z:zz’§%:e:§, €326: £:amz:,£ *»§4′,§..E;§{.”§.f£ éwzs

E,.E”;fi §;z.§§3j:?:,?€: ma%.£.s:?§ 5:23’ ifaiisaidé-:z:~:%;é<;§:: :3': §z'£§¥';°§ Eézy. 8'9f§<'§ ;' 2{}{}:""§ ¥'%3'«E3:E§

R

UV

3:: ?z§':'3Zgz2:§:z::§4 Eazki :~:.:::2{i §.':€':§'§{".€: Ehzii jui§.g1':2a:'::';'?; :"sz3d:'.3*€:<,%. <31':
LL28. E;;2€}*»l}8 figs. ;'%:E§¥'§%. §\?<;.. S€}€%–5§f ;»Ef€;}€};?§ <*2'~::m«;"3§. be .?;§§'}§}}'i${C§ 2'57; gs;-1:433; 2111

EfiE'§E:§.§l{.'€{§ é=,i."é§"«:"':'i£'£§.,:

8. E’§:5:v1§::’:g E %2a;:’:.’§ {hi-; k::§;*2′:<::'i <:{}s.:ig':§:{~';§:–»::\s:;§"%i;::;~§'ii;; £;:éa';?is:?V§s'4z-"12":§fEV'~–

zafim' §§r;:%:"z:$§_§'::g; '£1325: §*{:<%§’:’,§, $.71: :32}? iaggérzigzag, fiiis éa;.§§}ei%:»;iV. ?;{;*–.

‘£25: :a3§:32s:e(.’z in 1.{%;*::’:::; 0%’ 31%;: {.§€,’7=ii’f3’£B.§.’£’}§’£?fif’$}:3§’: Cs? 3′:;2>2L;*§~r’%it z*2:§’*;:€ Vé:;:z:-33::
in ?%’E§~=’:’-R :”§& 8’¥§i’>€§;’2{}i}:7§ {i:é§fi%{:€§ T§.,iZ{}§}8″.*._ ‘§u’ET::<§;*§t is 2.39 dis§3":.1?:§:
'iézaé, fiéét izmii €':'i€'.'{'}_§,§.§§'§3{§; fiizefi §.¥3:ii-'§§';L'i.i::'£.'§ffé;??'$f3 31$ wtzéi as éém },«f:'§I.'E{

'§§'§Z§{'§i2 2%:z;»zs: §.§'.1{"1 1-;:,m5§§:<:'§. 2;:a.:;s,€t%é%':1:*V €11 §%§?€}4;' 2{}{}Z"3 ax:

$é"§:;.a'éz;::_:’.;s:’E i*2;?€:’:*c aztggamizi z.:1’2{§€::’ {E153 s~::>1m€

-1

§;}:*:3}Lé1z:;1s§::3;”}7″ ;:m5’i§§}{‘a§§m:’:'”-.{i,:%’§.:E%E :12. 321 E€%9’i iibr Amaiffia §5:’t>j€ic€:.

‘E”?t:<;:,:§;§: {E352 Eeszzéi' '£~;*'§§.§.{?,§?£. "ée§:::3 §;'I7a:':=. Siihiéfiifi mazfim' ::}f <E<33;zsi:,%§:r2i§:f:::»§;2

_ ii; ":%§%i': é;;:';%?;z%:s~;§ai§§_ z§;;:§§%fée:.§ 'i.¥£:;:=;§; 33': iX'}?§.§2:ii€{§ iaizti, ihess: CUEEIE §;}§EE(_'f§E"i§

§*€:Vi§3i:::%§"{%a:_ §}_’;x’;.,§13«a§ E3 :’x:;%3.:i<:§'3. §.::~:;:fE2:.i:*; '£0 3 {ix}; Eaizsi, $21935;

:5:'%;%.'*;:§i'&<:{§_ f:§?.::€-_:7%"3§3§;;§::3.$:-§€é{2:'z. iii'; 52% E335: ;:":;ai{*: :2? Eifs. E.,§}{},{}€§{}j » psi'

E§(T§'§_"f. ~ §E;§;;'i,.§}«EE 83:: ax»-'§';:éz::_%: 1't:§i£i§'i§.T%fi w:+§$ §3}a:,':€:€i $3: $315 e3i;';}}"fi'$€:§j;§

f~i'§_3§;§?.E":%%§, tag Ex: gmcie a§.spEé:;7a'b§s: $0 '$336 égzgiain. §.1?§E<,%:a;§;%ai;z;:, a.z2.{i E1325: vsirfg *s::'§,::1:': g3é:3;2*';_3<;§;:=:~

s'-'£:§':a:§}:v: §"3E"{}j{if€..'?:, fiésfz f,«1§?§§}€*§§iiEf§§; £5; aaitgé} €§E'i§;i§§€fi 3:3 138 zm;'::::1§§::[§ 32:;

{as

€.E';.€% §:1::1"=:.§ %.,:.é_a*§=:<§ §}1"{}§}€i'€}"_, {£33 {.i{3E}3

{“§{IEj »« ;;.2&:%2* :::::–::’3€i§:{ <3? §.%§1;€:':¢'§;§Z:$;:{*§:$§:r:é:§_ "Saki

zézrtcié E.}'3::'=::'ixP-E 3., mi a-*::?3.§<:%2 E"€f:%§.§:1Eil{?t3 '§&'E§i§~ {;.§Té':.{r:é€f§.V «Em EEi'ii'~'?;*-

'§'~éz:}R8§%€"%:–"%f ';2i){§i'E, .2m.<§ <:r:}.§;::;s:-:;:::*::;:é§1é::i’='{i’Vs;: :s’3?;2i.i’§{fi”{

¥{-£335′ C)? flag: ;:}2″z:3;§:::’§:§; §5€€4s<;;;:'§;,Vf433.€f§i}f », é'.:: A 's.1'}':{'fW"; :5?" E326
:;§{i:i%:i':::}.%§222§i£}z:: iiiééiiiff 322:; fiE.§§§ <?C%{2.;"é:' ix: '$255'-:.%2§€}rés:»zi{a§ zagpfiai, that
zgézvzazfi; :;:2§"§;%35–: §'3€EfE'.§'f:1'i{.'€' IQ/£7§:_%.i§'§i"§'iffi,§:fiL§7z"€?.S,:§_§~. :am{,§ifi::»z.§ asiii §?:f."..?£'1{f{?_,

E §;}:~:ss$a Ehzzi €%2§§<;2%?:l§3g;;

_ ‘?l§§:::~ Vz:a§;§’::é;ai’ 3,3 ‘V::2.§§s;.»2a?{%;£,
§_i%§’ ‘?§’:<§ V;::za:r}:.:§§f_;:; in ;a<,?-:::rcs:*z§::a§";:;?z3 ai;'§?.§:: ésmi',

?;%*§ . ""§ff;'::=. 5:2") ":§:;§a_z':%' is ziaiaia fiififiiéfiig ':5; "K5;%}<};'%:é:}:'2.:;s%..5: i?%i}$§$,

'gag }§%§:g§;$§:"}; is i§§§'ff{f§".{i{§ iii'? {§3E"EE%§;*' §m;:s;§§§i€{'% :«3:2e:ar:§,

Sd/-

JUDGE