High Court Karnataka High Court

Smt Lakshmamma vs Smt Lakshmidevamma on 30 August, 2010

Karnataka High Court
Smt Lakshmamma vs Smt Lakshmidevamma on 30 August, 2010
Author: H.Billappa


EN? “E’E*%T§iI E’*9§§{.’I}E'”-4% {fff%Z}U§€’? %;’;}E.3′ .§i2″%£~=5N;- ‘§T5¥E.E.{;’% :’*'{‘§’ E;–izfié i’§-é§,§.}§Z

.§i.}§§’}’.E%§£} E’? ‘E.’§'”§”§§E Eil’%:’%fr” ii}? 3«Ei§{%U

fiayfikg Mm
233 §£$%§§EE.;E« :¥:a.§::$%r§%:;§: :r§g:.§§7v§§;::,$;§§:?*§;”‘
Rfisfiafik:§Kxxfi>A?Pg3L§Q&a95g2$wgWf

EE’§””§§EEE;

pm

. Sam,La§{sE:.:3.2:§3;’2m23;,

2%? 1′! G.”v;€iEi§i8;€fif:§§’éi,E, _

:”%g§:~.3:_:i a’%ts<::T2%1 5:3 }»'<:;;s§"$, '
i"§:':"2 'ii. 'iI's::§:_§«{s§:;2;::":'i:}3z:g V_
E} ,1 <3. '\f§::':i~;aE;;s<~':s;h:z};,,.

§%.gs5<;§ 5: §;}{1*E.V.§ j,"i%é;%3;;s.._

3%;

{Ii}:i:’¢<3§':§%.:<-fig-:1,' .

$j<3.%'e;:i1i<§{Té:$%::1 ' V
?ag;§@:.§%_; ._§;§:am.7_ ” V

_.g’T%.§A§ éiifi at :%fEe’l?Ef,§__,}i7.;§§3pE§_’iEE£II.Eé£ “£§§EE§§§,i’3,
” – 7§4€{3£?;<::f%;S'<s1:§':2%3: E-5-£Q_§:eE§ ,

1%';-._§'3z. E,-;3'§; %;%z$3i;'g:3;'_g}e'€; f'.'§':a31:sE{,
§<:.§§a_,:,M’?:’$

V “;;fi=f%:; $§”‘i;:1″%~3. §*srf,§:,’Ef3.E’€.%13:}’., %§.{/figs £233 Sm’ L»-i i;’e::<2:'*aTppz3$ azivjg

}; ;._ E§'ii'§§7;£;éi%l{S§."EE}}§(§f3E£é3.E}{}Elia,
E ;";§'<;.E€a::1ag.;s§}a, 11'}.8;j{}Z'

-, ” ;s'<':gé%:{i a?;;<:::_,i*:. 25%.} 3/ééars.

V.

“Y
r

{§3§;” ;%:§1′:1{Efihf:§:’*ik’3;:’:%:é:g.§<}12<ia f<31'£%E»–L {:33 5%, g <3}
§§:"i.'Eia§:2;33iaE:, Eizipx fa}? §§~8,_, £i3~=2§ E}, E3 33%.}

fi¢°'€:'§€'§n§":¥r

'E'_E':i_:§ §=?;€:g1:i23,:' i-:'§E:<,t:'H"'::i z%§3;:::eaE ffiéid u:}.s;§;<-:3." ':;§t§{:;..,E{}i.} <.%:%_;w:}:.%'«–

'E

éégéfiiiétéi; §'.%1t:32;3. E?–£%j§é}{§i} {>11 me: Eféééi (if v'{E”:€: C:§..:€§i’«,,§:,z:§g€2 _-§§§E’;§;?:”:.}:. E'{.,{:,};1’%f%i,
aéifiziiéfiaizxg iE’3»:~: Ei§fi3§f.3€’;EE} amii V ‘-“;.’..§i”:§.”§.§..§;”§E.iE.§1%’ ‘£1′; ; 15.}’§:;{i;»g1′:’:£iii’1’t. 2§§;’§’:{§

§}<v=:s:::*g«2€: {times} .E__€'.3f 3,'2é§<}é} ;_.}a;$$§:_:ji§;'; i;ra,_S.N%§',iEé{j}V;:;'8?§ <32: %.§:«:-::- 53315:

afrhaiwfififié.£fivfix}ufige§&r.§k;}§;é§?;

‘E’.%.2§:s };%A:§z–:;§ §€%€’E{}}§’§f}:’ ~§i”:W:§:::<3'LE_ <..%<'}i;T3;.fl%;§':%'_»"$ am §%:_:2r z§:':"§.2.::§:;ssi.:’;
_ ‘E :_ _ _ %:>

iizig 23:55, iéatit {_i’:€.}:s1’§ {‘£§iE§.§::: f§*~–.’iv§’.,1’a”ir:,4? §’§é§§€fi>§”§”i’é’§§:

.» g”y§fi§§§fi§? %%%%
Iriézirsfgé $25: §5:–3;:?::’:~f::j§ v::{§’L3i;.:’2:.;3,r?:. in £>.§:§uE\§{::.i§€);3 $3} aigzci. _§?~i?a

E :2′ E 9, £{}£;}€f?{ AT

” A _i:%. “l::§§:’ i§’::{é $13′: §}?,i§2§3§E€{i :.§ua:Egm<:fz3.z 2-,12:<E _§[}{Ei{'fE'{i€E-5%,; °i§E€T': ':.:':7_:~:2i

" .{'§<:a:V.i:':"i.–As§:"7a<§ :::Es"s<} i'§'E{': é§'§3p<:Ei:i£iE{'i é;.§a';v;.,:_z'*§:, ,%"';.;;:%;:sr:2 <§Ta::{'t:"€-:=;<-::'§ :~§:,:_§E. :3?

;:}.ai1:%T.§i§.%:, anci §§j'éi§i'E?;.f:':(i§ ;;'}<-:§*:':}z§;::s–:::i. "$3.3; E..§.:{.§.<1":EE_s;'3£':..

V.

éf%§3§2€X}éfQfi§§e& ma,

5%. ;%gg;=;i*§c::$s:{i $33.? %;I:::»3£i, {Em é3:§}’§3€flE3}’1?;Sr~{§.{:iEf’§:i{E-§}§’}ff:E.4 33355:’:

éékzai §’§”:%:~; E§€*:{‘”:€)§1£T§ 3.;;:§}€23.§.

5. “§”?1€ §€’;£;3§’Z'”§€i€i§ {f?{}§_ii}i%it:§..SV:$.3_,z;E;3:;_:::%,z.<iai%. -~

'a.%1a'§: i"E":{:: £?%§)"§}€.E&1.§ iE'}Ei}*' .3}:-: c:§%:»;j}:’: sz’§}’;{‘é:{}” ;j_;:f;:’e%;1::<.i. , V
S:__1':}mé§§;ti£i E31333: EEK: a§3p{3Ei:1z';i§.§_V"§.:;%1%;::: §§'§::§::§:*– 3;}. 9-,2§?;sg;§.;_<:z2.§.:_i:§.2 i%_::a::'
a::§;<:§§.%é{;1T1:«3§ tE§'*J§{..§€'f§;Es°ZZ€i'. *a;1':_siEf§2i' .C}i7{§€f{* 37:» 2?' :33' i1P.{;3 §3:_'Ef:{§ {Em

éip§§}{*:}3:§i'E(;"i {;?<}m:i::'* §&'§.%.§'1a;{§'§;;' « :":\"'f'g:,'x3;"E"5:i-3}?{i1'"§;§}§§.. $'.§"E{*: §%}3§'}§§Cé2fE.i{}i"I §'1:~'3;:;~3

paaagiizi %;%":s;::. i::':i':J;

:.:§;£’1’§i<.i5' zjzgcigésii-3_'::;¢'};i. zsliiifi §}r::é:£*€e aiaii §E'::;~::§'::§E:;:*<1:,
§:,"§3;{: f:::':§}.'i–,.:§;§':_§'éé:§~.V{E'§'{§§;:::};»é:';§;_ '.z§;§'1é:§…E}_€%»ai:r€:f: {:&1'm:3':; 'ix: és2.:3§;§f:::.t:d. in

Eaw. }7£r:: ":}iaéé5:§':f"~r;'::' ms: ::ii:@s::is;%<;::'1$ cf 'ihéz §':%I’:1′?.:§{i

:§up:~e;:::: ::é;gg:: :9€:g.;<}:*?;§éa%«::_§i2 am 2&8 Se gage zggo ané 3:3

. 2fiE€?;-:8§'«:.$;Cff€i? _§;ag§é""?§§_§i"%.

E55; z”;3.{~ta§ <:<}11;m;:-":E 50:' {E13 trs:S;'}13:£e;:E:=séA’:-A 4% 2-;.::<§

Q/.

‘ff £10 3} :;1%;;:f.:»<33 i%;i.}'§, €,§§E?%§3%jEfL€: ififiif i%~3u::'s: iéazgat, §ji"§.€"i ;;:g';r;.3i:<t2;:%":<:s;: '38:'

'*.é§<;i:’1a% €–:’@<4§<333€<: Ems E33533: .§':%§§:~<:§ 2mg} :3. E2323 ;.';<.s:. E}§a’:s§é{§i«33*§:.iiE i}%,§;i; S’%.2%}::’1§t’,:; ‘§§££§3;3Z %’..%:{:é £i§3=§;§f§8E. :.:1aay bi? €i3§§§}i}Sf’;{§ 0?;

f”f:<3:'§: é:.:'3:=:§Z Er-42:-2 aéssz} :=,1T:E);':;:§%.i€d €3.23? n€;1':.-<.:'.i;s2:_:%i<,%6::T'aEi<}:T: (sf .Ed.£%.v

L/4

(I I

fa?! €'i{'§{§§'éi'i€3E":§i§ ii'£i{'§{3§'}C€i 3516.3 2':%;, 2::§’%”<1:%;:ET:':<;i Efiizié %E1E{":E'€E"§Ei 17:?' fizz:

ap§;<i§§:«;:::'£,ss 33; 1:13 §E'}<6:':::E'r;%3'1€::, $1: is-; E1{}*£. :2:-:<::3::<;$§1'§'ja_:' ii}

I} Ii £3i'.?{5§' .

Z7. “‘i'”§i3,:z }~§€3z'”:§§;>§i’2z'”iéi'<ii ,%,:':.;%§§§ AS!:§;.:%¥….;i*i}€}E§ = L

page '?3'_£%;E has 1';:::§{§j wlrzegz a:1_:=:g3§3ii::2:§i::s:'1 8;;,:§:iit.i?0:":a,E

§:§:§z:i§:r:<:£: is i:E}::{.E, it is {he :i2::i.§- 'i%'é,.E:é;€;:_ La2'*'I;.»i}s;;=,'C<;:t§::&§'§<§s::i:*:' 3:.

8, §~§i:z':§Es3":€j; 'i'z<'f§ _E.<§aE«§;_2;":zz::__ ¥§i§§3g%T:"'é}§;– .§g;{é{E1e1' 'ES S§Ei'§f,€;'i :31'

«i%z,,'%'<}i~%;:%:§*»:-if» _V§'€'3}1'V-%I;'{E"ii*f:it4{1'T':i'«..A':i.i'I¥. Azéé ;£f;}{}é§ 52:: {Jags} 2<.3€~::3
E-%<:,::';"T*3§€: :$u§:';:i:–:::'2e {3s::%:;:§':._:'féféziaa. %*«::ii;§i'E§:a:i %:;:1«-:2 z1:2;1'i:E<32" £2.22? '§':":i:$§3
{t(::'2$§:_::;{£ ¥;7i1<*: ap§3§%ca:.§z::'2 EEZEE" 2§.:_ia.§_é_iA%:_;2:T_::aiE§

£i:\':;j,%L{ié;?1:*;<:€;=." Ezgag 7.%i":<::~§€"' E3661': C{3§3$i:<i.

'ii. ,%E1 '%T;37–':js:T_: f;_3:*:is@2'1E: ::as;’: .f::¥::’3.aE <iV%::'§{=::'1::£: ui::<£::::* €;}:*<§ci:* 5%}; §~€'::2<;:2 2'? <2?

; :%::':–£t:E it Ems; Tzéat. %;'=ii€i"3 ::<}§':5s'i{iit*::€§:<%. "'£'hs';:'r::..§.'s3z"{-:, i.%;3.<f;'.

{h ;g,,q.,va. 19/2004 4/

.f§':2%1_'§§':::g:'3;::<E &z_:z§g§:;<é§";?, anzzé ET}<:c:"::€A::”:;’1 3:5″:

;/..

1 T . €mm”s~#4 V
zi’:e%(:{2:”i§;;’::g§_j:;, %;}.’:{*: a§}§’><*::;:i 3%; :§.§§.<):a'3s;:<:§ .;i'::":e:E §§ii';tAz.E%..;f.€Eg;§;';§i'§E§,

$2315.? .§_'_}{'i€Ifi.E"'{,':€f: ;"3;3.§2::3;é3:§ §}§»-' i§'E.€3 2% §'f}§I'3€f §E:«1§:s:: {'.'E<::1_:.:'?: :32 E~<i;'-X %'j«-fi;'—-;

_

£5; .iE{':i"€;E?{}:%; ;~z:si:'§€ 33:31: 'Lina-3 :;;;::3._':.%;{::' :25; 1"§:;:1§€.%1€:::E.'%I{}' ,2i§;2.fg':sé;':~.%:§2;g3\'_z::" "

€;f§s:}z1:"%:. aaziééa a (i;?_:'é:{:?,§?::;§ E0 3'€:c<}::'::§%:::.i<E:' ¥i"£::€:': :j:<i:a'a;_.::':<–: 1:} §i:§}:_s:'3

21;j2pE'i<::3.Ei<'3§"E §"<';::* :»s.z§<_§f:'i.Té_<33.;§;;§ :'~':*;%<'%€:;§\:€{:}"—._'E"§";{: A£§ji'}§;':fi3E£§i.€i *£§'§'t,+’§