“BURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURTOE KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HEGH COURT
3:}? ‘i’I€£ RISE-I ESQERT €33? KAF.1~IATAK§1.,
BETEE EH15 ram 33″ may GE H9vExBs§~[2fi¢§J7.
BEFORE
THE E§N’BLE ER. avarzgs:_é¢s;3fi§Afi§a{Ofl_?
Q31? EEEITEQE Ne. iggss 53O2aov,{aak§9fi}”
E§’Z’?§’Efi<?
no-ununrnwnnnca&
1 am? mayavza _
WEE Efi§£§H&RI,__r. .,
fi£EE g2a§?_3a $Eags_>§._ «
Rfigfflgzwrfigagaaaézngxvizzaaa
E§§RNEfi$R”HQE$£,*EEEIE&PRTfiA
Exgaix nzszazar ‘.’V’ “” g
. ——– ». =. “ns.” “;u¢”EETETIGNER
§5y §zi:$:§$3K§Eé£O$g$;::§fi
33$. g?QAR%l§HfA3EQCIATE§j
*§m.A£a§? 48 Ezgas
an Ef$~fiIT?§EHEEE§SEL§ vzzzaaa
. ;On&§§§$§a Hfifiblg yaaxrayawxa
*T.EEEfiEE
fl
E’€TT.E5.5§€’AHa£Z}I.%..E£
~”5f$ §&KVa?HA£fi%RI
Efifififi EERE E3 Lfifi
ia} SE1? Eifififfififi
E930 LATE E’E}…5’T@.$%EFaxfi@L{1E§fi.RI,
L
-r
n
ESE? .§s.Ef;’F’2.3’I’ $5 ,
§3f..s”§ HIZWEEEAGIEE VELLRGE?
§”‘ERI§é%?P:.T3′:IPa TREEK
.»-W,
$3’
mm:
ggr HAMAKEHQEMA »w–
wfa 5HI?ERRfiH£EI
fifififl ABQUT as $3233
35$ $3933 $:LLAsa,_t
?EEZ?APATR§ TALUx–_f,
ésigfif pggaanvnwgr ,
wgw fiaawnaasgxaaj 1.
afian %BGflT 35’£gaa5}g= _.
33% BELE§AEI VILLAGE ,'”
KfiNEH§E.HfiEL$, V*. _-;a_ :
&EEALfi¥3§¢?3§g:Ov Oa'”*–
3 sfizigszfigsfigtsfiéxff’
§m@3emm32§;as*
fi§fi’EATE.ERLLEfiEfi£EARE
Efi£¢§.R5%gHE?§EfiEBEAGEL¥
“”‘+.r..””$§.s’.E;..*~’4’E%Z;54’r’;’E’a,, “‘§EE.’If.’.’3:’13»’#5,E3§’I.i.’?’;*«*1}’s i’E%.L§i€;
“5.§3$§E£ 53.,”
Q}
~e..:.-
OV,’€§;C*$E:f3é3m
_. sfa_aa?$ Mazagsaaaaaaz
‘ fifigfififflifif §ETEEEEEEaGILU
4.’$:L;&$C ?ERE¥A?AT§fi ?ALUK,
~%3%$K$ %E§TREC?,
:1
“T’§&%.gR: AEHQKA
ZOURT OF KARNATAKA i’flGH COURi{ KARNATAKA H¥Gl-i COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA H¥GH COUR1
‘ 55% 223 fifi$LE3E§€flfiRI
fififijfi KEQE HITfiEfiEEBAGEL§
vxaiagg PEREY£?fi?fiR yansx,
mygmax gzsrazcz.
é :3E<'i;T£ :3E"§Z?ZK%§?¥é{IE§P1R§
233;' Cs ??;?*§"".§'§.S§:'é'.?*3..-'€z"%;€I-'§§'=sfi
T£=§A£%C%§. §.;'ii.'§E' §§'E¥EEEfi%IL§3 VILEAGE
in
s
E-""*.;'*f~i';§I'=;'fI".5i;E3i~E'I'%~1'A TALEEK
EZETREST .
.3 :5; kagaanaaz
. %§€%S§AEA$HRRE .w,C»ua_
§¢R 35%? §EEEEEEG1L3″¥I£L$G£”¢C
Z%fi?hT§A Tahfifi I i’–‘ ‘=’
KYSQRE axswazc?
3&3 5§REfiHAfiHARX ‘_”.
$53 ?§??.swAmAcHAR:*.C _ ha’ y
EAJQR R§§§ §ET§EBBR$ELfl ?ILLAGEn »
§ER2?A?A?fi Eaafixj ‘ “»
£33333 §I5TRICTg”
£3′:
OCO5¢§;vfiESPONflENTS
: gag a2:a;;=ag3;,;a;;¢ {mag R4, R5 and as
&E% aaEva%;.i ‘ *’ “O *
E2 ah;’andL§§};ar%_uawSéxvéd “”” 3
axzg §£”§:LE3*§fifiE§”§3?I:Lgs 225 Afifl 22? GE
$33 zmfigézésrzau Q? zxnza ?RA¥INE Ta QKASH THE
*-,_$a§§aO§:, 2§L8V23$? §A$EEE ax THE E£PLICATIDN
»:%_fifi;X$?F:fi Q.S.RE.2§9f2fi$2 3? TEE I£££NEfi
_ _% ;é7eE £32.35} EEREYAPEENEE A5 ?ER
a§§Eg§3Ef;’3 Afifl TEREEE Ta BLLGW THE
?§.§§Eg%3;:.,§TZ%:}f§ EELEEE 51′ ‘SHE E’E’Z’I’I’ID}’*3°EE.fEiEE’E}IB23;N’}T’
C;x§m;§ $5233 @3333 xv: gyms § as sass 93 cxvxm
*§§a§§§fi2£ ETS.
ZOURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURIEJ-‘E: KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA IVIIGI-I COURT OF KARNATAKA I-HG?! COUR1
‘§«E.ZE-“H, IS flfififlfifi 8% FER PRELE*IIHAR’£
E”$?«£i.Ei*Ei?v $.25?’ ‘E’ T315 Eifisif; ‘I”§”£E§ EQEET HFEBE ‘Tfirfi
J»
ZOURT OF KARNATAKA i-IIGH COiJR’/¥_.’£}i'”_; KARNATAKA H16!-I COURT OF KARNATAKA I-RGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF l(ARNA’¥Ai(A HIGH COURT
0 Elifiig ii
The patitianer is tag 5″” defén§afitf1ifi_
:’:s,$. 25::-:~O.29§ :::f 2332. gzzhe .a’=.:.:in.ii[j¢§.*:5
institutefi far gartitienf-fanfi’»°sé§arate
yafififififiififi 95 the aui§’5chefiu2aV§§¢pé:ty,§ In_’
thfi aaifi suit, tbe §%§O&§f§nd&fitO flag? set-up
W’
itia ta aha aai§%§:mfi$£$% fig cgatending that
tha aw fiefagdgnt is §%éH§%fi§f§§£§rY undsr the
“iii fia§fi§l$é}§3%%§%gg;§3f ié in that regaxd,
ah Va”? §§%é$§g%§O:%fi’O@§g§irad ta prave tug
£iiExObaf%$$fj%h5OO§¢m:fi ts aucaead in tha
dafeamé’+pu§4§§i%kfi:%$§zein. It ‘was furthex
¢afi§$fifi§§.nO:§at V tfie said, fiili ha haan
»fi%§;fi§t§£O»y tha 6% defendant with the
*$§r@g&§:ifiaOEank§ Periyagatna Eranch ts secure
Egan an the aaié Qragarty. Since the aaid
‘z’£fiaaw#n: is alas sag af the dacumant dapcaitad
Oxifih tfie flank fie: tfie puxgese mi defisait Of
Rtitig figafis hg is n$t $3 a yasitian ta yrafiuca
tha game; as such a dixection has beau afiaght
*§’§iE:fig an applicatien finder firéar EVE Rule
i
o
n
$ ffifi §£&*§etia& at the said fiocumant fly tha
fiagagar af tha Eaxpfization Ban§:~[gg $he
apyiiaatian was a§§¢séfl by 3&9 plaififiiff}._Thé,4°
tziaé. flour? by ita midst §.§at§€:.r§.
fiismifisefi thé aaigT,a§§liéatian,;”whiah’Ewa5°;
xggiatgxad fifi E.R. 12. HT$§3Vdafafi@§ntflNc.6 is
kafmxa thia $uurfik f
2; fin hfigfiing %§§:$§$§n$§}$%un5el for the
getitiQm£&€pf”%g§éQ§§x§%§§ the Qrdez impugned
im.’$i£”§§%g%§$n.V E§éAfiréér is & aammcn arder
in réfiyfifitv5f§{$§%;U%§§iiaatian$. The caaa 3f
the §a%§$£@h§§ §aia§§a anly ta E.A. 12. in 39
“v, fgfkgg ZR 3%; ya trial smurf has acnsidereé
‘§fi% $a%% %§&% §&za 1% fif the Qzder. The mniy
xafififim b§ %hich the aaifi &§pliaatian has basn
q»£§§e$t€fi ky tba triai csuxt ia by ahaervimg
‘ “:§§: if tha flafandamt Ea.€ was ralying an tha
E332 ané if it i§ kmmwn ta the 5% dsfendant
ZOURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURTAAGE KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA RIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COUR1
that tfig fiaid will is a$ai;abla with the Bank,
§§thiag had §revented him frmm raaeivimg tha
3:
aamé %aei fire the bank amfi greduaimgiit in
:2-
9931:”
33 in my view, tha saié raaaflniag is hat, ”
auatainable far the rgamafi that}thé waxy ¢a$$
gut-mz~:h by $319 at” d.=.a§er:.c1,ss4k~:,;+:”~.::s ,:i:;§;t 2mf; kias’.
aémurafi tha lean firm fifié fiaépfifififigp Bank,
Faziyayatna EE&m%%2’a%§$h%m¥%fd§ d§§§sit cf
ézzitlea dead the €$;,;_3;_:..h§§_s: ‘»~i’..’:;:§7:gmsitad with
the Eankiflfififigg_i9fi$yi% §fi§Lh%Igefi; it wmuld
he wi:§,_fifi§;V§an§sf§gfif %$ such, the aaid
fis¢a§%n§ fi§a;%w§¢% §§.:%%uzned t0 the gaxty.
EinaQ ‘§$$ ‘bfi§$a$” §é$vi1y resta an tha 6″
éaismiani $@ §hava the Wiii; it is neefileaa ta
‘”m$fi%£§g’ffi§: tkg aaid daaument wsulfi have is
A”jb$ ‘%afia$a§g>§r$§ the Bank, befare aha Cmuzfi
3i&ca;”in’ any avant the saifi dsaument is
. >J’3駧i%$d 3 tha Bank tili tha discharge cf the
‘ifiag Eaaae it w¢ui§ kg apyrsyriate ta diregt
‘»~fih& fianaggr af the fiaxgaratian fiank himself ta
ZOURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURI. KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA H16!-i COUR1
§X¢§§$$ tha aamfi bsfaxe the Court and if th$y
fitiii ggad aha gaid daaamaxt, it wguid he gpan
is
far iha fiaurt ta xatain a ca§y at the $afi§F£cr
thfi fisgzt zecaréa aftax cempazissn ayfiwmafikfifig
anfiO return thg ariginai ta m,fiha7[fEank}.
fhereiwzag in tfie ¢iz¢um5tan¢§éO*a£5gthi$
m&tu:$f ths trig; magi: wa£,fiat fiastifiefi in°;
Eéjéfitifig the apglicatiéfig’
=32 Heme, stag:”:j.a;2:s§O%TVg%%e::%.O::=s.233′? in 3::
fax aa fiismis$£ngO3 IQEQ, ‘fl¢§l2, is mat
su2tainafi1é;VV*[_V?h%Ow_$am$ ,’ia accardingly;
q$asi§§;.Caa£%§aafit£y, {kg aaid apgliaatian is
a2l’wsfi;4’ThéOh:i&i¢£¢urt is fiirected ta iasue
an a§@z¢§zxate_éi:&£ti®n as pzayad ffii in tha
“=, a$i$._§p§Eic§t:fi3; kagping in.’wi9w’ the ahava
;%$$fiv&§i§sfi;Oa
‘AQitfi.’Oft§e abava abaarvatians anfi
%VO_&i3&mtia23g thia petitian atanfis dispaaed of.
“_fi$’arfiar aa :3 casta.
ZOURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURTA KARNATAKA I-!¥Gl-i COURT OF KARNATAKA Hit-‘vl-i COURT OF KARNATAKA H36!-I COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COUR1
Sd/*9
Judge
Ea”.-}fi”‘