""""""* "**"V'_'_*":"f*"-'*-h' 'WIS Imv"«I'ml'cw"anII"mA\-WI» alushlafl mwwma Va ummmiwmfimflflfl 3"1'9'.'!wu'J%"l Vu:»'\JiJN.I Mfr RFQKIVIQEHKFK I'"lIVJI'"'§ QQWKI K)?" KMWSWKEAM E'?
IN THE!-IE6!-I com? or mnrwxmm nausanoas
nmn THIS mm 6" my on mam 2009 H
BEWK
-nmaownnx m.ausrxcz %%
w.P.uo.3_.1795z'ma
BETWEEN :
1'
2.
3.
4.
5.
Smt.Muirathnamm:,
mad about 39 years,
8mt.Chikkadasamߤ;a
Aged want 3'? yea;;*s,- '-
sri Muniraju, ;"""::V x , .«
ngad sham; 35 yuaxag "V -'u
smt.#ankat§fiaa;*§aR*
mt, 3g}.¢m,
ifiri _ Mfisisjiyagfisa, ' « - _ « I
A§§d_abauef29'y§ags;
s=1k%m:;a:-aju.. "
1. aggd a"nu;:ui:~ '2': yam,
'sxi fianjunfifihég
uVAg&d»§hs§t 25 yaars,
. -_;Sm{§G¢#r§$a,
'_' Agad afloat 21 yanrs,
55¢ patitionars sc.1 ta 8 are
Children at latc Badigappa 8
'xV "aMunib3digappa and all are
" ~'Rlat: Byrathi village,
Dadaqubbi Post,
Bidarahalii Hobli,
Eangalort East Taluk. m9etitionera
(By sri C.Ravikuma:, Anvo¢ate J
i
'5»
lnawnunruwnwnnr-nuuc-vs ammuwn-wcw um-mm»-om» «av»
li\'$.?.'H"h \m'JWWW£fl 'WW '-'\'"'fl\|EW.N"'I'l.lf"$W&H"K\ K(!|E'9m"'%'?£ VMMWQWWWKM Qnffi
IE
1. The 8tat¢ or xarnataka,
Rnpresantad by its secretary,
Rcvenue Dopartmsnt,
M.s.Building,
vidhana scudha,
Ban§a1ore~1.
2. Tha spacial naputy ahapissigfier, a A
Bangalore Urban bistri't, V
Xbmpegowda Road, 4
aanga1ero--56O Q99.
3. sri s.Lawronco.";A*
sfo savari Huthu,"_
Aged «bunt 40 yiérag
Rlat: tattqrviilaiy?
Tha1aku1aa Ecst;_ _ _;.g
Kanynkuwaxi'nist:a t,
Tamil aadu, _ v"*A
m.Respondent3
(By six: 31. n’.$a£hy::nV§ra§ia§ .3inqh,!-ICGP for n.1 as 2,
sri H;Vt33mch2ndx§ gaady, Advocate for R.3:
ii-é
_2A ,; fh£$ Wp§tition is filed under .Article5 226
»§n¢ 23? #1 the Constitution of India pmaying to
cjupih iwugnod ardcr datad 2.2.1398 an the
filéz 6: R.2 {3pl.Dcputy’ Cammissianer, Bangalore
«w =j’n1§tric£ at 3anga1ora)vida annaxur ‘A’.
“This patitian caning an for praliminary
HM- H_§aaring in *3′ group this day, tha Court made the
fcllaing;
i
‘T.-
rlwaa Mwlwwn ‘M9’! mmmmxvmmawmaww I.$a~:~\’w»Ww wwwlwrwm Wm fl’Wl’II’sIcWm”‘nIrvIkmr*m via
Therafone, accordim to the petitioners, the
grant made is in acmrdanca with law and tlVxa.é,:.:'”mama
has also been afrirnnd in an earlier
before the Assistant c¢missi¢ne_;f,_ :”.th§”~ izsme
cannot be contended otherwfigst “bar izher
at this stage .
3.. The learned at the
outset would suffers
from delay and requires
to ba di’su;:§§ésad maid grcund.
Raliancé-‘ the order dated
tt*;”FK;ii;V:.51/2007 to contend
that”’-_ tte’ _.'<:.:.'der dated 2.2.1998 was
qua:-xtiucwixzgfiiv. " earlier: writ petition
§zd:,i.O £fiS/2V¥DG*6.,v_§)yé.ans at 1:119 parties ta the said
'A ;*.:*A:”A«.%:%:’a:;’:xaJ__.y’ sri s..L.awa1:sn¢:a. ‘rho writ petitian
_ ta; on the around of delay and lattes
ind =.i::he ‘fgsazae has bun affirmed by the division
.. tenor: “in the said ardar.
Even an merita, the lam:-ted Gmrernment
H hdvacate contends that the petitioners are net
untitled ta tha xaliaf sought tar since as per
the Govaxnmant records, the land in quasticn is 3
J2
“‘-3
ilfivfiifl “‘Imn’hI1″‘¢W9€’b.5 ‘fa C$’1|ufl°”‘%I”Q,\I.’#d&”‘%(0m””}.’ntt’h!!i””V4. ‘me<"Mn'£ Vkmwailvfizfwww
pracuedings and theruartcr the reasons pu'c–:Eor'ch
by him in net emailing than said order
reasenabla time was that he was 9su.f.fia;.*i't1é§f':'__"__£rc}h:.é
illnass and in that regard, the c¢:;1:§n;i:5j:~ i:t'-1
fcrth was disbeliweu.
5. I-iowwar, in t partias ta the said orsar,
delarf ~c.f§nae§i against them.
II:t d:dM’.’ ta rind nut as to whether tbs
‘1._’_:;’.sz.-e§__t:3;:L_’t:.£rA:;r§2L§’.:’_,s have right at all to: consider the
fjc=3,_a3.’m,Vg a sacrusal of the papers would indicate
‘*-.._1:1é;.==..iV:m&s per the preceedinga in case Ho.mC.”S’I’–»
‘r.. ‘r6’?u;’39~99 which is at anzxaxura ‘W tn the
patitian, the grandfather of the petitioners sri
J
.-
‘3
approached this Court belatsdly since they have
ngsprcachad this caurt on gaining knowledge.
8. since I have 0% to the cor:c1u:§j.:z:n’4′ *
the petition”: should havn _!;m.nx_1 ‘ :i;:1 “‘t§_:’ag
pracaadings, it is ta . ;:dr.s;.ic§§r””i.§:z-5;
rsatuxa at the land as cdntgndéifi-._5y VtIa§ ‘ ‘.3V.a§a_,;-fufid VA
Gowmrnnaent: Azhrocate since ;:a;V:;¢c:: _i:s 1;o be
ccnsidarad by tha in
a trash proceeding a£f;§§:f~A’.’,#”,g§:3rtunitY ta
thli patitiangiri-§L:V1.In .n”‘ §r».-‘£$c:s.\_.i_n_;§Vl§:’.ry1g;, it wauld
be opan rfiz; V. =’¢.9:¢ntand that the
1.3116 tank: and it
maid also ‘Vb; ” fiat, hpatitioners to
indicat:e 0therwiL8e_V%Aba:3 e€¥_ <a.n" tiéh documents.
H¢'nz§e '=i'Ear" ..§J.1 said reasans. the
. onhr"V':1a:t§:ti'TA is heals! as not binding on
patit§<A:na:s' : thfl pracaacdings in can
..rié§ggR3':€;R~221i!9u9I?-98 is restated an the £11» at
Acifihxaisaioner only ten the iextent: <21'
the case at the petitioners by
the petitioners herein as respondents
'V ' ' % that emits pracaadi rags .
[WW3 ‘Pn:aI%fi’5hJ3’\l WWI flW.Jr’%kr&a%ttw”%a&*”g¢n..x’~¢ Jake mar
J
‘1