High Court Karnataka High Court

Smt N Padmavathi vs The State Of Karnataka on 29 January, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Smt N Padmavathi vs The State Of Karnataka on 29 January, 2009
Author: B.Sreenivase Gowda

ywa

:5: THE: H1{.’ii~5 :::;:%zW:;;%’r<31r«* E<:é%i€§'~E_?a'.FA%=:A, : "

{:m*§::3 *2'-mg; '{'E~iE gamé EEAY.(3?-«.,}'éN§;E';°§_f§'f.'V::;%f;"§€f;§'.L 'V

B$§$EE "

‘§’H’E: 3-e;€3::.~m:,;a: I%.a’1i§~3x LE{.#.§Eg!i1§€:jEE?’\:..E?¥~-“::?L§.’§;:3fiE:§§EIu%j:1g%.%€§:§h:V’V£T§;éf§’g¥{.i}2é,

W531?’ P£«::;*:*3′:{;>rg :~«.m:s’::-*;::r:~%’:;*1<*f;éL;'a-'L.=2<:a':*(:;§*~;:§"V%
Batween: p

E%§x;t,N,Ei*adma1:fat.E1i '

Wfe ir{:'is:.}?:.:':a,_ jz

zigeqi ab:311i: y§:~;';:~:'3Afs _ ' _ V

3%? g' at 3%. £361 1; «,?s§£i:-g€.;3i1wg:Ifa";~ .§ga;:<:"-:.:t,.. '
iféfii C:'r3€-;$ E';xffs3z'':§:i0:'1 ' 7
§'§i3§iLF §{:.::1a:;;a,t'+,-r:1iréifiA: "

§’~Eg;f:j;31v;ag:;d1§:’ .”V % — .

1afi:,vsm-‘e”‘ ATaié:_1k :a,na”*=;*:is:1..ié;:€;: 1′

» = . K1 ~ E7’«*:é¥:§;E:_i@1″1&:’
{B}; M X S. S1¥3fli1a§._<:a:~:;a$~~–;%%ssQ€:i§;:'::,sf:s,
Esiazlzaitishts/"a:' P'Q(:g§a:r}=*, Adm}

ti

on

* E_:'r;'é"'*;:~;:aé'::={:§ §'{a:"::ai;:ai«:a

' B3; _§i:;- §5Er:'§<:1*:_%i::;1?;

12c:i?e;:::’:1<3 E3$§::arf£:11§::1";:

%_’*sz§,S.. ‘ffiizikfiixxg, Baiigaiarf: 1

“_*§’T’:16 .E_’,§€:’§3z.3::.§; €:§:3::1:::i:~’«;$i0::€r
” E’vE};’:i-;Q1′:~: i:*’§§§?_”§’i{1i§ I35}-*$:>:’:3

~ ” .zx;s ”

i:”s’>€:;’§;%_€”,-1′ Géitaiagéai. {E=’£E”i3;_§
iE}::p;artm€:T1i £123? Mim:$ :”§.:1:.i {}m;:E<}gj;:

§’\;3;’2 ‘4 {T%.ag6a_:’1aa{§
E{jL;%£em;3:,’;;’:aga:”a §!§}g”S{}E7*Ei :23

4;.

3:e:=.s;:’.i=€s:?’:’. €21!” pzsfitta .£a~1nd if: im: §£bSf§I}f.’.-fit 0:” C{}}jE’§tf;ii’E-i«}°_4€Z’2.1V’,’?i”f;’§1(“sfi€Z£’

iSS3..Z£€id by {$16 .E3epi_:t§2 iZ”1§3:’::::1é::’;:*».:it:2:[;::”:::* E,1I’3.if§.i;’fi” ‘E122? .

“aha KLE2: fact, E26 Caz). mtsi. (3%;-3″_:5§::§V:::j hes’ =:+:pT§:;é§;§éE;ai”i§i:§:” fififi K ”

;«:{tii€>s:1 sari}: ha iz:;,§<{€::f: if $226: "§'$~:q.:%i:aZ§.1<:£ §i13?.:1i.:7g
33:16'. I ' K A H

Thtzr §3€I':§i.i§;_:1z:ir a;gva3{zi§.:if£€§g§..V £3s_E"lZ1€fXi,.3ZE'€:': E}
daieii *;:§v:§3§ié:;:ugf&§.§:_4' 2 fiéifigiiif ffiffiffjiifillg

'2i2r:i'. _;:s€'i':?t§<}:§ .?'§§v';';i"§z5§3§ §,+',£§éfi-K.' ':3z%§§ie'":£re: V'j.i::1i:–:. Cmsri Tim said
wriij §3£§€i§i{}fixi';g{??'1{iTs.§f: "=':€;'- '§i"fsé€"::§'i%:*;;'3:*,<s€<;§ 2:}? .f:§:12z*é: P,

“;Acf:Ei%:ia;:1té:* szzbmiimd h«::t3:’ :’@;:=3j; an

‘ ” z”i:EiiiE8,2:’3€ji€§ as $6? ;5§I”3§’§€_§.s’_§_1£’€ E magi 1*@::;::$s%:@{‘i {he 3:563

:*@$§3:::p;3§é€:ati<)1': in '€116: Eigléi. :31?' the

j:.:£ig:2::e?:::}§s sf £216 Higgjz £f@:..1:'*:. azzej '$16 §31:p:'<3:H:t:+ {T;<:::u:'i'.

Séfiiu

K!'

and i$:~:.1_;€: piérmii fez' €§'§S'€fi8.'E.fihii'§g £E1i"£'1{3E"~ i':é{_;

321165 331:3 .:»3f;:;:»:3.g w'§'§;i§1 §'§%"f't1E' f§'€=:;3E;§:-* SE25 1:535 f:i,§kia:;:;§'t:;I'"i'a:t1€::;§';r;?aj§

e:<3§3iw:*:5: £2? 56111153j'§.1{'3.§3':€iZ1§S7 –

Z?” ‘;f””i”:f:: 8% :*{as»;§:<:1':{§;e:j;i. E:1'1:":'<%:x:::2€«'E-'i'
<:§aI:::–::;1 Edfiiii'-f»};,;:E€,}€f}£:; i::f::t:§:'V:,::;<£j:i:§" siasiing that
an efifiate, a..,§1A1:1i{}:'
Bliiagiiifiezy J Vviifiagfi Ac:a:<'_7z2::':?a:2§;

§;:”§:%;%é1;:£:€: amgi fassziéi i:§:2a.’z= héii”

3;-::”:{‘§5 §:».;a,’i;*£’a S§I1§§ is ;;:::’@€:§;€:::1: ie €53 §€’f:f§1

§’2″a:3’.a; ‘g:”:f;:s_m€i 3;fi§’§?f.’_’;§ aaritii 1’33?’ Szaiieihéfl fez)? 3′:’2Tfi’:i::g 3:36;’: 1:51′

V”:J7.:}Li:;§j;§i(:_a?’Ei:A:”;1’j:’ 3’3 i’€T?_§{‘:i’f§Z€€E.

-.8′; . T. V’ ” ??fi¥e&1i*.3’fi:;§;a:1€§” a fitmd $3?’ Ehfit €iT§{i{}i”S€*,1§If§’£”1§=
._ V 1 V _ .

A1§:i.:§x:_::?exS..–izhailifirz fi{.’§ $335 $3338 by fiém :5: iméiséaiz
.. .. -. 3 –

K “*3:v::?:iti§; ‘;m:i§£::’*

A’ E%?f””s;:3,%i.55a3 sf’ iihit §{315*§’1§’€a}:é’: ?2:E.§_§”:{3:’ §¢§iE”3;€:’£’£”::’:§S i:ii;§i”1f_?i’;i$§§{}§1

1′ _g;?:§W1ié%S, T.”§<}<§ fizéyeizéafiér :"t:f€:r':'§:'§ if} as E{.§3¥E&;§,{T§, §?;:3i::%},

'_'f'§""::i=: £431 :'v5:$§::~

«::x:’::§e:* :’a:2:’1€:xu3:c»V :ia’tfl::% f}2a€};’;.f2i.”}i3′? i_§i?3§i1~%.:3z~:»a+:§E _f%;;:39:*”

:*é:*;?%.$i::.s§: pr:”i”:}=’ iii, .A::?:3_a:::-mré: :§%:.ai:.§:fsgV–MiT§”:g:ii .z:’:1a;}-’65:
zsastztci is p;”<:":$€:::i; §:::§:i”w–¥;a;:i.’: t:ia:i::.21ge thf:

}T;!E°fi?i’§i:’}Z_.?;S §§:n;:”Eé§_ ii; {}’.£z’fI2 arfjgzg 8.113;

:3.E5n;:a» ‘Zii.£€:i a:.1′<::a. 31%: Fiafiiéa
E"§'§€i}C' 1 «V.'::::5§f"*'.._§"'f§_;3f"{§:€%%' ifigamagf: i.'{'1<:*: ;:ippE,%.:*.<i
§;z:'€& . A ' 1

9' '.?_'i';'u=:é_ i:"3€:':'=i'§;*i§:é;@' :f" :1 'rléziarfiii 33$: "ilhifi §::r1:¥.<3:*$::m<:::i.
.3 ~ " '

;§g1';3";E}§: 37:»; 31:3 s:§i$;:::.:1je fjhaii {ha Eazziig ii; rfispr:::€:: :35

__ T*s,*g*§2.i<:%':1"A the §;:<:=:i:i"£:i€;:ne:2" has; a;;;}p§i€::'§; 5:31' p$:'::r:fi3sé(:s:i1 ':9

~ 'i2'%E:fi;:§:::v€ $z3::':<i 3222:? ;::s3;i;"£a §a;§';z:i:§ §~;if:i:.1:,a;§1&§_§ in EEK—}si§}«"S€j.!§"ff

fifthiaifi 53:32' 'i3%,?§1§Ch 12¢} mizléfig Efiase €31' §'§§:€3::<2:::6: figs :'&:;:z§:*€€§ 23$

'§;:r¢::' §4'5fi_.:1€: Z:32{ E} {:5 E{E*s;§?\,:j§{;§ §?€2:i=i%$ .E§§€E=§~. E-§f[§:z§as_§. WQS s¢:;:,:gZr"1'{

i3%

%:}}; the pt:i'§t,i:3'::£::f; is Ciffifé a EeEi:1f_:2*aE .£}i$§:z2:.%fi*~; '§'rE:':§1;%.€

§M7§}?} 3% £:::::1f1't.€:::§;2:§a.'if::€% 1,.:}::{i::i' Esfliifité R':;j{7'

$311363 13:: :'("::::a<3'e;e $336 ::$€:'§ _éE.*::c be i?f;§§iié§€t:§?,:;i°'é1é*}ié1j

Eagiiis ::iu2'i:":g flacié $i%:a.:§;::§§' _§;§%:€ 5~:i3i.1M1ai€.s:i
3:ijaCe:'2.t $0 }'{a§3":§a' :« 3:": iiissgtzzzifi:

‘§.;’§1a%’. tlhfi {}€:’:ii.§'{i§i3i”§€i:’ in ma §a::<:iS
'Er:

Ti}: is §Th£:”i§Z ii} ‘iziew 0??’
{:(:£1z:-%§:%’£:_j<*:'::":A igfiéxtis {3.'Li:'§j":g figeié gfiafign £11

.iw:a§%ii:$a;._:*§:e:fit? ?§:§'hiZ5"V.€3f31§3Z,§m1"':Liii iii: =;:'::.:3i.i¥:~3.éf€: {E16 éaiiiis

a:=;},di §r<}*es: §:«.2%.~;:1¥»ii§z Ci'€.}§_3' 'j§";%3v:: :§:_1f%;§3:"éi:ie$ 'is2é.1:I%:::.'si,,:é; &§}§3if;"§1"i§

' . $1313" ;1'fi:§:§..$ 33 %i::: figs: p1:1"§:xr}sf::< 551:2" wi'.1§{:§": 131:: §}€i§i.§i{§i1i':.i' ig-

-;%§:ii;€°’;§{.i.§T£”§’%g.§J€§’iff§iSE§§€i}i7§. ii} r£:m:::-‘ma $a”:’1{3_ f:*a::r;:: iéfii” iamég afié

%7°’;z:’:<%.,:' §§i§${?€}I§€€?§'.§{}1'i %:i'::a3: SE12: is séexiiig mi::§;r':g §*'3E1S€

' {é§;::’§

$5: ‘i”‘f:’.§¥iz’Zf’§i”§V1g 33:21′ éE*;§3§;>§iC3i§€}fi an (3113 maszgrza 2:1″ 3:15: £}i:.’::€:r,

322.: A3 §;:=£::’ §3§”f.’}’§;’iS€) is} Rigsié 32 §::€:”$e::::£3ss. *a.f«,?h{:» §E”ii’i in

g3e33$€:3$§i3:2 2:2? §3§_?i”§7’i§_§ latiuig E51 {‘:X~§’v§§f%§f}?€ §.%:a’::.<:: §%:§*§éfm:'j§'