High Court Karnataka High Court

Smt N Saraswathi S/O Late M … vs Karnataka State Financial … on 17 August, 2011

Karnataka High Court
Smt N Saraswathi S/O Late M … vs Karnataka State Financial … on 17 August, 2011
Author: A.N.Venugopala Gowda


X2′:

mg “mg H152»: Cfiééfi”? SF E»<;i%R§\%£¥§Z&i<A £1" EAWSALGRE
§ATEB Wig we 1??" my 9? §'a§..§Gi_.§S"§} 2:31:

§EFC5RE

THE E~i©P\é”B:.E MR. :1U§”§:C§ AN:v§:\s23§:;’:?{{3$V:><&::_:'

§E"¥"\:"'v' EE §'»i :

Smi, N5 Saraswathé,

Wfafi Late M, $E”*:éva:*a;’m:,. _
Age «$2 yaarg, Qfiiii §””§0_L3S8*’§’§€§§jd’ \’Af{3r%.j_E<;,1 A'
$49.45,, 22" E'~='EaéE':; 22"? Erega;-1§e3r*sa'§Efia§"f:~§<&:f'E*}i'siage;

8an§a§<3re-?05      

  5:  . «    "" " ,MAP9§:m§»s":"
{Ey gm gm! Si§F':g_,:<"§", fi;d'\;<_.:§   K

fi\E\ED:

E, Kamai:éE»<,a State F§.£*:z:%_n7L:§;aj§T"-{iQ;.;";3oraiéan,
Havigzg its8anga'E–<}E"é.Ei:sfaE firanfih Qffice at
The Church""%:feei;;V-. Sa-.:f:gf5{%0:*@;

By §;i:_;}s ?’A.§s%’ Sénerai $1-‘%a:*:age::

§’v’:;.’g; “§”é”<;§i:a*:.:;Ai;%ia§ Qeefers,

QM

_ hE':;:,_–»i:1'§.,"'2?_'27"?'fMairjzg Banagéiafikari {Z fitaga
'fia':2_<gaE{s:<é-<.?S;:;'*'

, Sr?f"§,€3..;: iv:-;;€"a;ag;,
S;'{:», 35%. ':;":%san§rap§§,

V. é3§.".:§,}. 5'v'§3'hab<:@'§ ""§"aEE<ées,

– {5’1§;’ Sr§. $3: aanaggf mag. an

“‘–‘_§w%.:._:r’é§g;z.:§:é§,
“£:%§;”‘a_;:’2:;:*a fiiairzcéx
i RF §.E§§€}N3EE’=??S

;:;e@.1″5§f§C;%i&, azéareafi $9 ‘$8 égguegf. E

wag fzgriher mrstenfieé {baa ag ger iiée agreeme:”:i:___::Ea€ed

1,1’§2, between 5% aggeféarzfg 30?; fiiazzéégi: am _.’§’;§*”§§{“A.,;a»:j:é h§3%€§é”:§f§;e ‘§j»r3’:§.:£G-fig ‘

ég zgsétmabfe.

43 Far ‘she €or;3o:*aV’::§'{‘:s-%;’*§.i:£”> was
axaniineé as Wu’-E ar:fi~..V§xs,’.éi>’i’ ie;§ f”3§°’~s:’§ereA}%é’ar;§%Vefi. The
agmiiarzt get herseif e>;éVrr-:’:”;f’sé§i:§’ F%?;E}f’%§.§”‘–v:71′..fi}”, §Tf0§:g£derir:g the
évifierzce cm Eévaé cafitentianaf
the §ears3ed’ {$33 Corgoratien has

g;*o::eé “i:§§éz”;’ ;:§§_5:<':;:é:%*é{%.;lé':%t3 getitéim are ééabfe to

my R$FV£:"fS'3'.§?V§3KVV6':-4%'S'L'i:C'§V@-:'E'€v'~%S"<§'F.} 1G,é.98 and the Carporatéozz

£3 antitieé f:"€.:~ bfe .és;:::.:e e§ i%;2?t¥: a remvery cariéficaw far {M

""~._am=f%§}fit;»_~c:%aé»r{2e§ §"§"2§"§_;E"é'é geiétéerx The gefitéan was aééawefi

a;~=%éT ;é:f;ning we gaéfi arms” 333* the %:§§”?S€@:§§z”‘%?§§§ §”€C€}’v’E?3f

E5 Sri Fifi. E§§E’}§%’§, mameé afivacaia agzmaring figs”
ti??? ggpeiiani mn%:em:ie§ that, the Cam’: 5E’§G%/’xi §*3§$ F303:

apgreiéazéé the receré af ‘Che cage $5; the ,§:::§.:i;:’92;:».;’:

pe;”s9ectéve and the (}!”€f&¥’ gagged agaéast thefa’;;.§_gE_§:$’;:_::_’-_

entééfiifég we Carpcxratéozz ta remver the s_a;~a*n.-._j}:;i{¥€:E§g a:*::;§

$evera§Ey ég wézeéiy erroneouié-.,:5::%i~.rj» E*:e :*’*:C.§,’ Er’:
we matter fig caiied for} 2 h’ V

6. 8;; 8&2 ?a:z:t§’EtA’,_.’é’eér.:§’§§<;'3 agfigearéng far
the férst :espQn:i e}2.t_f gentendeé 'shat,
the record {ff "E.'f:€a§4'§f'§::"'~',;:£','§f'V§_""#'.{.u#,V:T'ZE';/ apmeciated by
the the Eiabéiéty at' the
borrowié-:_A"hav§;:g been proved, the:

Qrfier was V’p«-a_VS.s@§’a_n:i._ éegifivery Certéféaate wag Qrfiered ta

–._be _é”ea:%*f”:e.’2€fi.__..i;a::uma gasbmétieé that the recafd Q?

iéiaé”:ajs:4:V4’%:%23V5%, %=;%en carrestéy aggrefiéated and the féndéngg

re7′{::3§’:§édé§’§’§ef’rée£:%:er ;3€¥”2f€{S€ mar fiiegai fa” bang

%§’:ierfE:’é”:§.,wV%:%’: in we aggeaée

A in View Q? the ma; qsnientéang and the recard

‘ w ‘:§é€E: E have §e:*i,::’-zed, {he {mini far €Z$?ESi§€E”§€§G?E ég:

” Ekffiaifiér {fie Effipugfléfi arfléiéfi wrzserge 0:’ iiéegai?

/.9»

8, Aggeéiant mg flied £A.2f$? under 0 4?;

C?£Z is gerrnii the graéuciéen sf an age*eem§::t:i ‘_»§i:$%§§.{§~V.

193%: between N. §\¥&ndE$%2 am SM. §’éaga§’a§ gig-..%’%é'{a:

rm game as adfiiiicmai exzéfie.r’:<:e; Aifirgg7:;ar§iE2-._fih–g._s;ai§

apgéisatéefi, 5 2:23:31; 0% 'the agreiemerzt-.AE:§étvvee;é,."_§'4%; fa. V;'§fi'§%A '

Kumar @ N. Nandish SEO §a{i€§u:;S%':§§:araf:':1V_
Exéagarag', SE0 SEQ §vEinaj§§'g§_, hj;éV:s"":;87VeT€2{.r_;V '§re:';;:iucééf "éfvéhe said
agreement Shaw; than__§§f§'éA.__gzfiégi§§s.«~«:g§fe5}-'sf§.'f'»»__ §3aré:ners 32' a
regéstereé par%;':ééf:;3§"a'§V§:.%?§gmL .;,;;z':éz,",=fi§?s*'%§',-/:'.'%_-.s,V.. fffé:§2ne<::"a': Reeéerg
wézish V10?" géik feeiing at
%:§3& 15" garty £'+'E:", A
Ami is miire fmm gartreerghig

ané itm 2"" Féégaraj agreed ':9 recangtitute the

.°?%rft'ri%"éVh§–."/ad§*:2§:'§éz"%g&Eéééiéabéééty is gay Rg.§%,C3€;3S;"'- if} Mr, A.

;<3.%é%.§?-"@V"?~§§§nd§si% vméch was &§;**eed7 E0 §E paié 35:3

§€§"'u£__(If§¥?{;;!' mterast asvseagzzt far havérzg @a§é is 'aha

'%::II3??f',EiT€Q¥'8§:C.§:"Z?%'"Ex

§»'%,~='$; "§§:%m9:rat Raaéezs hgé 'cwe garinam $3,,

.,,:%5.f?=«*:; F*«§aga2*a3' am sag, bianéésb, gisvzg §"=éa§ar§j§ gs %:%":@ am 9?

_. _ §§$m.é§–§eé".*

E0' fine iauri beiaw, by miécéng {fie 8'~¢'§fiE%¥3€T_E <2?

mfiia, EXEPE; Ea Pé am that of RW~1 » appe:z'a}:–:'f"%;'aT:%:as Aéa’::§__§r’é:::§Vf§j»::§V”~–f;§’§;re!;:~ ;a§’:eé the
materiaé evidmce /’ z’@’e Eg neither
any Gmissian Eve;_:§iG__rj;Séd:§E”:a'{%§¢ “.§::xx}:;’dence mm” any
wrsng r€ad§€r2’g ‘=”;:»_f ts haid that %:he
f§ndés%gsVV.ra::<;':;A'{;§ af :::'1f¥ji.:?:%":&-j'§'§:<{b:;"g'r"s–ed.Efirder are perverga am
Eéiegaa V 4' ' Z '

in %.§'éé.._4;f%e:3u§§;._i§?:§:2"afigeai is éevaéé G? maréi am 53

_Ba3.:5:eaf'a.sf;"'v:§'2e gzwartéeg are diraateé :6 bear iheér

;*&::;§;:éai~t§%,s3e'{:%;:j3tV§.é:;VV

V "-3§C*