Loading...
Responsive image

Smt Nagamma vs Sarojamma on 20 February, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Smt Nagamma vs Sarojamma on 20 February, 2009
Author: A.N.Venugopala Gowda


, g&§_ V

IN ‘mg HIGH Cam? 3? K§R§’飒a’§’A%<§ 53,3' [3,§§§e::f".;g&;§*:?§2A9«%E T

MTE3 W35 WE 20:2»: my €3F;:A'FE$ f§?§i;;$;'f'Rj3§§-I'gaéig.

§EFQ§§E.L .,
THE %-§O?\§'Bi_E MR. aajgmg ,a..az§"%?:%%fi.ss;a?%;zxéJsi;;®a:%;';:A"

REGULAR _SEC{.3;?§h__§;§ 
aawgamz T         

gm. f%£AGAMFv§A  

AGE 42 YEéRS,.    ~  _

we E…é.§<$%é¥'%'i§;fx,
we BANQAKU?séf$”E’~-§éE_§,LAGE’-M s?z;3?
§§3as%;aaé.e&§:E’%4;Qf’%3:_:

SERA “”:°Ai§JK %

?i;§»@é<L:;2 a:§T§.:CT.; " _

fiE3?E%«iA?'é"?

gs? SR}; ..?§?Ei”§._:’KfiR’E6§*¥€§;5sg Aw}

_;s;.§*¥:’ 3::.,1¥s:;;?as

g Wffi KL’§'{;_ %*§Ai_A?PA
‘=R£G__’T’H-f.”;8ARAGUf\E?E-5?2 :3’:

Hmwgg? 95 ?v’iEi_§.,E Kama
A .A _ %<..as:AaA aaaa1,$§2.m*A:m<

"7§iiF&KUR QIS'§R;ECT.

~ M 3m. Bz§sL.fi$r’??~fiA

E??? 13 f%’%fik%”i§sé.iE'<§Gfi.??!3%

AGE 5? YEARS

R,/0 §#;§'&GAKU§'\ETE \fI§.Lé'§6E~3?2 13?
G9W§AGE§E HQBLZ

Sififix T.5§£,i}§<

?i..§§'%KU§ QISTRICT.

{BY SR1. M K BHAS§(A§A§A§*§, ;§QV. FSR R1.)

REs%0%4€3gé’§jf$._V

‘rags REA ES FILES ws. me (BF <29: fisfiiiifiiféf.':?'§*'{«E "':«'
guaagmem & 3553255 DATES: 24.6a20G6.V__F_'.?4SSE_E3 4£N*
R.A.N0.186,f28€}5 ow THE FILE 05 THECWIL J%_}BGE»(f22R;SN;.), '

SIRA, ESISMISSING THE APPEAL ?IL§:B.. "AG,5&-F\$5T_ ,Tf'i'E

EUDGEMENT AND DEGREE BATE3: 1'I?,0i»';'2€)T03."»._
35.1%). 458/1993 ON THE FILE Q? THE '.__CI'e!IL 3UD;3E'{}R.E'i$£;}.j '

Si IMFC, SIRA.

THIS APPEAL comma as»: uF0.?f§;’»fix_Drv§IV§’?.S-I'(}?iV’:”??§:fES ESAY,
THE COURT DELIVERED THJE.FQLL§)WI3’ivG:”–».,_

iU§GMfi§E;”5TQV
Chafienge E;; .é:if)§S a§:¥;§é.s*a 3′; gasseé ii?
RA I86/2SG§.–V::§’駧é{»::2.f$gfiff–._%#)?.’V§§@:’§’éV%rned cm: Ridge
{Sr.£}n.) thereby LEfi%?$§§§£’£§
the detiiiejee-. ‘§V%” V.$’;;{%£éf§€~» :::*erf§rmance am aefmasaai

Efijunctéené§;3§;sz?-fiV’i’:*:_a{13§.é§:%I_E§é,;<'§§93 fiateé 3?m.2a§::; ms

_._i:he ieaiffiefi C§=«£E"'.§":2§;gV 'a fin.) Sira.

'A'~'T5fl§'.'2ée:"'-.;;a§pe%§a§':t was the sécerzd fiefeséésst,

suéz:s3;1E§*§;M' :7?5e§§j;'»a.r;'§;'fii=.é%;§% was the first fiafendarsi arzfi férst

§'$S$fiu§4'4'§C;3:Ef'2V'§T: fiérein wag tine giaimtiff E:"; the _sa.5%i.: Fm' am

' :;$;§%{e§*-.4§fVémévenémse, the gartées wiii ?'§&¥'$§f%3fi@§' be

–.j’:-‘e§c§%§*é5 witfi rafefemte 2% their rank in the %:”%a% saga.

1
\

/.

3. Sasha a? the case in 3 na.s’t$he%§ are :

fimt. Baéamma, tfie firai defefidafit a:z:iV__§;iv:é :f.V%1?é§.$§;a;:’;s:*%’ >

me Mafiaéingappa, S,/<3. E$ai.VQ3.ii9:§3–«:r*§.n fa}§é1a%§’éf

fiiaéntiff, agreeing ta sefi the ;3r5i’&:*w§e§?€i/_das:~:<'§§'?.=s~:§-3§;*°§.':{%°§Vsuit
scheduie fer a consiéeréiiqn a:%§é ééecaézseé
me arztire agreed saEaV:'. }§.;%§§:3i&:':t. §§§E€&

0.S.?&o.56′?/8§;~%r;”:«f§%f:é céurzéx :*e%§g:;;és§%:§.. &§.T’2?z92F£ at Sire gm

respect sf téié si;{€t_>.éti%;+«<.?–1 ta E:<.?~i8. Yéze gamma ée§e'.¥<2.:',%.:3;'_1z"§.%__'_z_§¥€;'%:EI"

heraeif examined as §'%;'*».+'—1. C§fi$§§e£'%§"§§ fie fggfizé a?§}§ :é9§a'

mat ccnterstisns, the %r"éa§ cam': aa§és*.-%i»é'fe:i"'§;ssIues;_.:

and 8 in the affirmative az1:i_ans§§&'s–:§§4éfi éssgs-;.'A'f°zfé0l?V

heédésag tinat fiefefidant a:3é"v _%i'feT:'.; ? éV§§s§.:H§ir$a':zd
Mahaiirzgappa are compteiiefit V §: %::~.. exa:':i,éViié V5tJEV'4se saie
fieed and decreed the 'AA:§'_e'ff_&3rma:1ce and
gerrrianentirsjiggsctfirfi-. A 'L V'

. E'. §.=;::§':1é defendant féieé
RA 18fS§'2§fiSA 5»§'_;s '§§§é§VEate mart, %n%:e§~»ai%a
ccnterzdifig !€?:aE§, sf eviéeace by the %:"§a%

court is .vaer2,%Tés*':-=;é a.ré.é Ai'E*§eVgl"'a§.§ 3:25 the consfiaratéen cf ma

fiisatteairj cf' '¥':Vf€é"'é:é.é§t £3 bad and 'mat five degree has

'bgégé,érTr§j§:»ef6*v;is§3;'gaasaefi and €Of3$&§Lée$'§f§'§ decyee is éiaéée

ta 'b'£%4 3atVea'$§{;f§e . Canséderiség the rasazé am the riaxai

'»-'4.___t:<m'£et*:t%c.;f;_§.é, the first agpeééata wart $333 saéséé 'fiéé

V' §é§§G§§:€:f";"§ fissases far c<';§1s§dé;"3tie?:: \

i. Wfwiher agpeifanf graves ma: fewer <:c;:..:.r.1?", _§;=a:3'V..f .
cammitéed arm: wbfiie apprec§a£":':3g $_4ra§_a';r';:f
documezzéary avidesms ,aia<:*e{2f'_ égfare ',5'? .é&§:§'~..'vv..L
aisa wfzife answering fssues? 1 ' A'

2. Wfzreifzer a;::,3e§ian€ furtf2=«:%:%””~~:3r”3ve?s.__ zhgiv-._E§;:é””‘
judgment and decree passéfi 22;: feameéa?’ Cévéf
izzcige {}r.B:”:.) 3.»-nid :’§:7:f._=3 .55″-.€2..§
f%ic:.,458;’1993 cai!’s–._ {er -‘_§nte%r?’?er_e;f;::sA of Eéis
couré’? ” s

3. What 0ra’e_§*.:%§f ‘ V
T59 fir52E”«a§’§;§é:E:§»%-:é*f:1_e:: the ma? cam”:
haé corr€x:§:§3«..’V§¢%§§féIar”as.jtzifiié A’:”e*€s.>..%fé:V sf the 322%’: area: has
grcgeriyv:’a–1_p:;:fec%Vé%fé~é?§’~~.:i§:%3év’ ‘e§;{§:§§:’;€a an raaaré am has ms?

csmmétiefi éiéy arm: §A:’§_ §:<==.,,:€:'eei:*:g the suit, §1a%:'é€'s§ feufifi

-“kite V_g’§is§u;%_$}:ésVv%_ u%§§é=r3…___be€’m’e E? is be éewéé sf meréif

7§§$%fi’:§’;3s¢c!.__thgéggeaé, Cirzaiiaszgifig %§’%§ gaid {aw éecreegf

th?s?.sézicr:§ é锧..”;’2§;?.”.-éi has teen fééefi.

AA iwaaza heard Sfi 9a§&% Karegawéag Eeaaraafi

_<:5s;:.aV,é1:"s»s".~*@;§' far the agzgaeéiaséi. warned %Z:$i3?"§S&§ mrsierséafi

=t.§'.'¥_E%t,: ta EXP—3. the §§§'§e?"f'§8E'§'{ 'is: 39%: éaieé 23.§8.:§§i§

"'§:%3e aggeiéaaiféefafiéaht §"<§fi.2 E3 :25': a $3??? 322$ hafice 35

{mt biaflifig fifé her; %:hat tfifig En ?e$§e£': af a faméiy grsgarty

is'; which 52% fiag §f§fi?&§%?':§%§"2'{ ghara 35$ iniiaay fif iéza

ifi

18. fiigpaiiant is mat a gafiy ta E:<.?«=§.

rww :39 fiéagisia iéaat, Exfi-$3,. was axaszsigfi by ”

9? the a$pa%%a§*:%. $3! %’i=X%Ci.%?§§”‘£§ E><§'-4'§;,'–a§:°'s'§er:f§é%%*iV ééii

the gait s::%:eéu§e m-sgertig, the p3§aVnfiéA_T§§? §T%€£A &~§§&§%é%2%T 'i

have received the ersiéfe agreéa*=.$7af%g €Q%iS§;éér§§f%'Q§"§ –§%Y%'%(,§i§€'§*{.
9f Rs.iS,G§8i-. '?'hes'e :3e&V.§'E'3p §ste}""-?E%':at, *:’;~~t%*:é date

EXP»: was axetuted, keen ffieé

against the faifigef.:§f«..§§”iE:;§§§é§é&?$§”%’z?$ %3a;3; §e:’;d%z’2§. E? is

after exec::%%§a?: ‘_$f§¥E§g_§?”£.%__’§%”np%$aéed t%2e$”a§:% as we

Sega: représ.e;§ii<at%ire;=s'A._ fieceasaé fig'? fiefersfiantu

.~.§§€a%za_§*E'§':ga§';:a" a:é§"–wi:§f;_;er€safie:; we wit was éecreézé Er:

V:em€s._mi"~€:i*:$""v:::_ar*:%§:"cr21:se between the fiaitées an

3:.'t:%.%~1'9§A3.M'%'%%%;'?¥:%:§'é, %: is flea? that ma sag: $:"<2§e§'€'y'

' '§3a§<3n§¥e:~j 'izsf hgafiafiéfigawa arté §§"% View as? %'s%§ fieaih, ihé

"sL_§':a5:ré".3ff Eiéahaiéagagpa cams $3 $9. a%§s€te€§ ta we &§$$}§§3E"§?

___' §22s€ §§t§°2é semad ra§§ez'2§e:'3% as his %'}€§§"S; '%'%§e awaifiarzi E336

'" {z':c "'i:2de§enfie$2§' right ii: {he firagerty am we éate Ex.P–:

was éxemstaé am thé régfii aagzgérad $3: fie?' §§'?s iesms af iha

&

12

over’ 3? pcasassim by me said ‘sfE§”:dG?$ ta §§’:E

T?30%.i§§”é, ms 1 has fiepssed that time 55%: s*.:?’:eé:;.s.fi:é ”

is £53 £39: gessasséssz am a§3jeyment ,<'§?s'a.
any datument in supper: thérg sf.

pcssessian and enjaymerzt 3% *:b%:a’;;s:§s,;»%t é’s”:a§z
agrécasétazrai iané, it wsiji-fi..V%%aveV-*§§§;:n e’a s:§! fi§?’§”:–e%”.-éa Ezaase
produced the RYC reiatéeég %’:a2r§%*:e:*m$s’a,
the 3}? §afa:2éa::t;;§=s:..%je :’:.;’% ‘§x,9.f:.5, Ems fiat
contested Em’ éntie the %3¥§Z?§€:S§
fiox ‘Ea c$ntra’§A:%~§§ vvre’€ é:ea::§S fiaiéaérzg tése saéa?
evidencévgréfi ?&’x.?.3, iéze T:*§a% Saar: has

§”§§%3t§y ansaééeréai. t§V§’e_§:$i:3V%.éé«::$’?;?a.3 ta 5 in we affirmative.

12. f§’§*:@_f%rst a§3§p*?駒§aie’ Saar: has aém racagfiaai a §??”§§§fi§

I-‘ _ %§°’:3% §f§§:a dafé’éé§ant/apsefiéant Es baramé $31 the sae

a’g.é9e§§%§e%§§”-$,f§<é5§f:a¢§:e§ by dateagaé Mahaéifigappa arm the i"

Z _ §eférs«;ia?:§;'é';':. ¥5$é'sasr :3? the fiiainiéff, as she $3 we Eegaé mi?

_t%§;e é:ec$ased_ it hag aésfi hraié tag: fine 'E°'zéa§ Sear: hag

_é*§.;.§%%'§§3:.i'3p§rec§ataé the Mai and éawmezztary e::§§e:'2ce am

° »a.s°f:.§we:'efi the éasages. There is CGfECL§§'?"&$"'i'§ fiafiing sf facis

14

am act ammmténg is sasbaiaméai questis:”*ss__:’e%jV’TEVa%%g,’% EEEQ =

second appeai Es rm: maiatainabéiré.

$93″ the fereg-oéreg rea$o”;€:s;’;V-%*;%:e §e*a;3;V§*s’§Té_:p:$’1e’:§§V ‘§ss§%ab§é

:9 be mjectad far :.@:.~=:.;3t s;$””4;;i;§%:§$té’§2.*;_Ea% a§3les3’;§’§a fif Eaw

arésin fer c<::r:sEderatEo:rV":.T ' {fie-é3:'$'eQ_=.;§é'fi'%,§?sjéhe 3 yea: fa§%£
V . ?'

am starzds é§.$r%§:§ssed éfsgiéy.

sax-

A % Iudge

¥,p!* , ..

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

* Copy This Password *

* Type Or Paste Password Here *

Cookies help us deliver our services. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies. More Information