High Court Karnataka High Court

Smt Noorjahan W/O Kashimsab … vs Sri Kashmsab on 27 January, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Smt Noorjahan W/O Kashimsab … vs Sri Kashmsab on 27 January, 2009
Author: V.Jagannathan


i?-E” ‘E.’E§E§ E»§§{§~E-E CSRERT Q?’ E{§§RNA”§’i{%§{A

{‘i.§%i3{,§.E’? BEEQCH, EEARAWAB

}f)a*i.eci the ‘2’?”tfi flay 9%” Jazmarfii T *’

:8 E F O R_E}…:,__
‘E’§~iE: H.{)?~f’8LE Es;1R.J{f8’E’§{T:;E?’§”:.:’ ‘v’§f§§25%;£}4’fi;’1§x?’§’%§*.f’§ii’§-§;e;’§:Efa*7~f

CRIMENAL ggv:”s1;~: E*é;:€*E::<3é€"N§; %39:%Vs'gu2-.a:s<:::§

EB-'§'WEZEZN :

SQ}: Eiesfiahafl, ” V
Wis §’§:&Shi131S€1h’§’17§}Sa13Lf3;,’VV’ – , . .V s
Aged abaut 4? CECCJ;§”ié3i:i1S’§3§ii{}§$i,’£?§0fl<,
R] 0 {ifs} L23:§I§1.§§£§§(?§~Ei;,~.§9i«i_2.$'J$i'=g*E1ii3f1_?:5€£1iZ§§£'5;§.;

Eiggspagiaiés-.'zi, {T§:E:2,:§;'§'a:&:;s'–:€§';~.j?':– .. _ "-

; k . §3e§iii<:2'z:§_ $3.3;

“E’3§ui:%: $5911.? Gaaiag fiisirirzti.

{‘f}<rc%':A Govémgrygéui Servfisrs,
Riva §'§if:§i'3;g;t{3.£§€: £3332, gen,

2 . , §%€s§3€:;m.i€:1€

Sri E¥§.¥'KEam&sT§} .3913 «E5 §§ .§€k§:1:'ga ?}"aE§3§;, AdTv{}+:'3":§3s ~

3% 36:11:' }

Crémiziai §€€'vi$in I:’§~:§%.§J£e:>§1 fiifié Eifiééfi’ S:*.c*::i.03″3 3%? {XE
ms {Ti3:P.C. pyag»-“é:z2g as $6.: aaide éhe Qrdar ggaggad ‘my that
.%”-‘iii-;’:’~;’,s§., .§}’iza:’a§E:a::i, 33:”: {fr1,R§~”‘.?é'{>’ 18ég”7.2Q{}«*% {iEi'{€€§

2

};’?a$,2{}{35 312$} Confixm ihs srésr gasssé by EEK: Pr15{.?,s._}.
{dr.é}32.} 5:; \§?v’£F'{7f-, Bharazvad, 3:11 {Z§’i.?¥§isC,?%§2. jE’?€:’s,f2G{}3 {iatsd
E4~.12;2C!C*4,

T 2:113; pefistiei: {taming Q11 far hsarégzg {his déi:f~r7«_ :§’g:<*§'<;;?'§:t{,§;*§.

made that feflowing :

@RSE§”m ‘

*?he getiiisner ciaimsd :213.§;i’§:%:3ééa:”:a{: T!;,f§::r§}:’é;’ “i..§&’;:”i’§€,**§1″V

123 £35 thf: C129. iii. agaimgi £56..,é*t:s;g3<3§'}éiiéugégazaazi zmaé
the; triaé cmzrt gE’&§}”§£€’§*f_}r;’i§”i?§:€1i’:i§}1§.:E}*;é§§§§f{.{‘i}f}&EE{§{i af ?€S£é{§{L’;’ «

per giant}; V “§i’§1§_HV§*:i>%s§;<if;:"§§i§€:'*:?;.¢E'§%:§;E:§m?;<§ .§.'%§_s::i

agpiiéaiizyzz V{§;–'::i';;;Y'~;?1:§;2}'«v%.;§;::a§i<?1'.' $€C'5I:.§{}£1S 4 235% 5 G? 'fiza:

Mtzsiim §§Gi'fi€f§ {.%*?;§*<;.3§"4:%i:i?A3Z?::s%:1 if rights 0;": €§§'§{1%§'{fi€:'f§ fxzti,

34'~}.,8:'%-fie '::az':§'.&t1";é&i:';g magi. 3. éévarceii fish/zsiém w113az’2 E3 zméi

. €;:3.%..i$,i%;;:§.wi:(:44€i§}ai:z: §}.’33iE}’§Z$I”1aE’iC€ ‘i}I’:{§€I”‘ Sscizisn 3233 :3? tfaa

“Av?-£’ E;}g@:.V&1;§é;i{§. fifiiiiisaiéarz was aiéfizasiégfiaié bf?’ Eéziz izéaé

zéozégm Efiiia the rassiaiamai {Z{3E}f’§. giiawegi {he :r@;§:s2§<;r':

flétéai' fiéfi :'*€S§~

‘ 1

3
erzisr er}? thfi rewifiienafi {:a::§”E., the gaiiiiezxer is befsays: Ems;

<::__:r1: LEIEGSE’ S€{:§§.@;’*: 39′?’ sf ‘the E31,’-‘§)6{~’:a

‘§’3″2€ submissian of tha iaamsfii {:;::%..1z’1§<:§,1'L:'—- .

g,§aga.d§.sh ?a'{.iE far gm: p€%.é{§0§°:€=r__i$. thaé _-?é.h;¥::" K "

'2::;;s0n which {ha revisignaé ceéisi 3353'§{§£I;éL§_ 3:5:

flied be'; {he re$§2ofifie::t»hi;:r5i"3a:2d £3;-*.*»f1s .%h%:V. %:a5.§a;a;';…:§a§.i:,%e:~.'

'§1)¥Ji§}}iSh€C1 in the ;3§:Wspg§;e3": 'v1:;y'_t:h€ 'E211$%;:;z.=:;%1£E aiieci,
Eimrafgrfi, the reszisiaiéag'c<§:_;z§t }%":éi«:§§%_ {3;{1{':f: taiaq '1 is
figtabiéshsfi §;},s. i:.i1;§: V_pa:%ti%:§.£fm under Sacéiggrx
E325 «:iiv@1"<:§:{i Véfiffi is 31:)?

maini:$i.na%3ié.– _ ,.–»:o the decésieng af {Egg fiapax

Caart, thea” ‘Ee 3:*::1c:€d {‘:.@{1″%a.se;% arguaé fiiaii ‘me sziiaw taiéiizi

:33;VL–536-,”LreVégiGnaiV”C{:$u:£”€: is efguiifi CG1″§§§”a}S’jé is £336: 3394; E52352

i%.e:.~_~%.2″1T1 hfzigpax Gear: arm, :%’1€z*e£’s:;r€:, flfifififi ta} ‘§3{-: ;:;a'{

asifie .:a-mi” :1’§.A§€i ixzriai’ 0%?’ {E16 {rig} cm,*§ graafiizig E§’i§£’i§.’§§Z”;

:§.3.i:§tas:::”§a§”1Ce X?E?’§§ haw {.3 E23 §§~:$i{;2″s{§,

Eéazfirzg E12311} as 5-ibfiiféi ami 3.3 213312;: é5g’3″§3$8;§’€{§ £92″

‘£16 :’€S§3@§:dé:Iz{»~%:z.1§;ban{% a?};’S,{§ i1E;’::3;+?’€ bsiégzg ms}

§”€’:3f€S%3§’i’€a§”i§§”3, fimra: 3g {:9 €;E:Ei:€ar gar} than is §3:”@<::s:<-3:1 is

gzags €335: <;r<:Ei.&§: The 311:3? gaxuzsd 2.:-par: &v§":%€%": '€'.}":{":

. . –. E-'fJI£:;~§i'i:1§3;'L'. Wamai} A

§'€¥iSi8§"§3} sear: <.ii:3m_i$$ed {his 325% g;%:ti$.i<;:1 b3; the %§?ifE"3 is;

mat the §',2E}.S§8}'1{§ haii pagbiigheei Elia 15333:; nstics E-2"; the:

f{ifiWSp&§_3€3};' ami, ihfiffiffiffi, ihfi 1'€:€€iZE}"S€ ':0 be

$13 wife is "amaisr {he §;)i'G"€§S§OE'"§S sf {he M:1';§}._i::;'E§'::2i:€if

{Frte<:iiz32"; {sf rights an divsrcajr" 21{{:;'::,4. }§3_8€s_; 4 311:3-E7:

way at" 3. peiiiiazz unfier S€:c€ifi?n__ Sf

Therefore, this: questien is "'wff;5:ther '–3' '@::=§1%:i':i&:;f1V 'é.1a'3;ds;:' V

Section 125 sf thee {Z1§xE1';.C.

4. The éapex Court: tifié agggesiian in a

I1z3,;1*;h;v&:’5%§:”césgsif’V fianéai Laiafi V3. Union
fifkldifié. }~f,«}f}C§I’§f?%;Ci§5′ E{amat.aka 5289, the ;%p<:x

*C{}11.A§'"f,._ €:0fi'$§d_:'s:*eti A'€;hé'"C0:1stii.uti<)I1al vaiidity 9f 'the

gfieiection. sf rights an divorce} Act,

1s:;377e= Setziian :25 9f the C§'.P.C. ami sfliiie

u§;1f;_éid;§;}§ '§h$ vaiidiéy cf 198% Ac: mferfeé £0 aheva, figs

'¥$iL1}ex.'C*»;,§':1rt alga heid thai the pmvisisrzs Gf €316 Egfifi A3?

" -.fi;ap;f9ivifig the divarceé Masiim waman of $uch a right ':9

…_r§1air:£:,e:3ance fmm her hazsbaaé and providing ha? fer

znaintenanca ta be paid by aha fomwr husband rzmiy for

the gerioci ef icifia: and ih€:reaftar_ $0 mafia hfii" mm {mm

b

'1

péfiar E10 gsasii in saarsh of a rcziaéivas one aftérr the sathszi'
anfi uitizxzatmgf 1{1"1{"3C§{ a: thé {E0033 :3? 'E316 'Jifakf §':30ar<E_,
dares not appear ta be reasQ3.'::a%)£e and fair 3ubS,§'i.§§€T€_V_@f

t,}:1_r;: gyrmaisisns ef Sactien 125 of me ("3r.E?*.{f:. _. '

23. in another ciacisierz. ix”; the,ea:s=_c:i of Iq’Z*}’;r2E’jV§é;£r’:§c§>A»V’.f;i::

State «sf UR, reperfzétd in we 2i”f}{}??’.’_S’€§i

iiazurz, deaéing with the provissgiaaxgis c§;2..%;a§3},$:’%_ TL1*1_ ‘,i’~3-SEE A{:%;.’- ‘

and :Z~§€::7:i:.§.0:1 1’23; GE” fiza (T3-*5-._.ha.s ‘i;s<~:;1.;<%..,»'§I:§':at. {ha

pmceadings umdar Sattinrx gjf (3. am aitivéi in

fi§."&¥.'–i.1:i"V{<":V'V§€::::.Eg!{-3-fii-:E:':,%.,i? €3:1n3 '-{:011:9Ei'":t:{)%:i::<-:23 iélai them wag 21
€§ivs:2:r<:éd *-.2w3fIzar:'§'§fi f:§v1:s{*2;":a$–<*~: :1}; {§§"i€:S'¥;iQ."§1, ii; was {}§}€§': fie

thé v_<:Vm11*i" fEf€13»"§i7_ ifiiizezs 3; 1:3<3ié;E;%:”; iiflfifif $16 ;§€:%:

‘ V’ , c(>:’z:§i{§:§2§i_:2g figs: %}T$;;’.<é§§a:iai nzsflixire sf tbs: Eagsiatimz.

¥i:a;:*:;gi3_;a:tT, in 31:33:61' {§€CiSi€}3".i in the (sass: sf

J¢;s@:1V'<}:;zas;:unam; reparted i:1EL§¥<Z 339% E{a:':";a':'ai«:a

334$; hem that irrespestive of arm persaxiafi iaw <31"

,ii":%t_'..?;}ar€;ies, the §mvisi0n_s sf 8e{:fin E25 of the {ir.P.{‘:.

.. a{tract.eé 311$ in {his csarmeciiczrz, this {:<}%.11*t giant; '?.{){}i{

meta of €316 gxsovisiens ef 1986 Act,

%

'E'. AS far as th::~: talaq is <:ar1ce.§:1€{i, the §z:a:tf::;'_:is; $f%;fiE

perzciing at the Stags of receréirzg of 6vi€fi§:.§i{:é§" .

main petifian bu: 9:113' the ir1€.ar=i::; Qrdaf' 'i"si" p%i:$$'é:£V"a::_€i_, " "

therefsre, the qtzesfion of the ;';:~.e€;£ti€;:1

Ixiaintaizlafiia undfi}: S&ct.i0r':« 7:fI».3.'5 0;? A "E116 119%' '

azfiise. Mareaver, mg. t,2.vz1a;q___L:i'§g<;:V~»t_i<:«:;LA m¥fis"' 5313131.'; E3}; the
advassate fer the

8. in the {E16 §§f}€§{ éimzri
in the 5285 1:33: ihifi gtaugt in
{Eases ‘Q36 Viflfif ihai the v§;<:w
iaiiem camrzat be ;~:;:_:s"{Aa.2?;f':ed ii': £325:

323:}, g:s*._s:z.<::}1,p. fthé' (2z*§::§<=:r pas$e€1 by E: is fiabie {<3 be Sat

"a«$iV%:ia:% '*rr;=:§:Qring that sf the trig; Smart.

9;. "E13 ":;§V"é$ ?:€8z1§E, the }f§€i'Zi?."iG};"}. £3 £iE_§;::)W€:d arzé the

émpugxiégi flfflfii' af 1316 rafisémlenai gear: is set asifie 323.5%

f"f 3:138 triak Cami Starsiis restareéi.

Sd/-‘v
Judge

skcf»