High Court Karnataka High Court

Smt O K Devaki vs M/S Standard Chartered Bank on 19 June, 2008

Karnataka High Court
Smt O K Devaki vs M/S Standard Chartered Bank on 19 June, 2008
Author: Deepak Verma Gowda

k;3_L,jff?:%§§

E;’§ *§*§§§ Eéifiifi gggggrs’ Q?’ 3? gg%.;5§€j:{;§.§.;§§§

mgygfi *§*§2%§g ‘§’§r§§ mfg fifié’ 9%’ g§§3;s::f%:.é§i,5%E$-i ~
?%§%§§?

‘§:-§§ :%%?§’§;£ gggga £§:§§’:?:;s2:-§§$$§v,§;§é?§~§$§g%%E;%g”‘*
$§§ V .’ . _ _
;a:a§*§;§« EEK, ;a;§§§g*;.f:§§:*§%.$f:§§=§:§&
wag? ?§?§?:%f§%§– :§§%}%:g;§7’¥9:’§g.a5g§ g§3’§§«€%E§§
ggmggyg: T ‘b ”

1%? 5* er; i::z_fi€%__E%S1.;;r~§_..§~Z’.,ii5:#;.5; :§3§;::;~.2,_,,
.»’-‘*:j;»;{‘,s;i§; ;é’-§%:zs:,’:–.% ?§=_ ” ”

er gi

3
. 2:7: igsiié =;*::é;:’i,§’i 1 , §§”§§;5§;2:%_g.”: 92.1,’
_2’§gi:i?:féf.° :3;.%h:a:::s.’:_E:’ “;.<'V. ” __

Ev
W-€

E

:- O

3*;:1:{y:.:»:’ 2%: g’ 0 9:,
, {.7:m::é.$§ ‘?”‘§’*’ §:§ié;s<?%<.

. z§:3§*éa§.§1’a.g,a__:3 ,

— =- 56$ fififin .. ?§”?§’i”‘E€§§§E§§.

V ‘ :33;i.VE5i«:€-3%1a;:§;z;; s«;§:::’::i:’s.:” ::’ra:;’::.::§<-::E *»5.:*;%'§Ef:
' . :'.;E'»,,a,f.i..E.}}'§'§/§2:}f;a K1: gaiazfi. figcian}

,g3*§§-.—-

_ , _ :2;:’;=’:s;,:%:?;:?a3*;2i:;’a§2::: €:.:.;%–;§;:§2:-“:”::;~’2§3:::; §am2″;«;,

~ §_}.713s§§’=:f}m:::’ é;ff2:::’t? .§_:3€’§’.;§,§{4§1′”EII}}i?i’1’ig
€231} E§a:’;3s<:. £f.'.'.z-mé éffisszmiifizg
£335 ::,:z'':<i "@551 §?'i<§<3:',
Rahsga §"{}£§§?é', f%s'£ag:'a£,.':3 §E
fifififfifiifififi «–~ fififi fififi.

Reg}, E3}; fig: ?ax€:=§2′;.§§.g€2″. Tb

,5w\v.\
v…….-

19

am? §..}£4§§’ 1.22:? }:’:.:*§;{%i:>%.éz’::;’: of Eiiig? §”§§§§}’,E {T.’.<3%.2;:%. :0

'-#2::'E.:f:"i.2:é,:': 54:: g;'2::%E:%"zi::";2:i3 a:§::'§«:~%:" jkazf,

?'2.«*E;":§'{=*§' 22211 '%,}.:.:i: §"}&%'E:é%'é{:::'}.=:;%z' 37:22:? ?%}§€?§:if:?{§. 3.}? .? "?E.;':"i':i: V

– . _£

i….7{;’=§.§{:i{?i::§i’ Emaf. :’;s::;= __§’§:§”i:%;{.§§CE..§{’23”} :5: ;%;::–;:3::ea’2_{§ fizz’

§3§ii_§,}:f3§§§§ :22′ £31.: if; }}€*.;’1:f§:é§:.g éhat

2′;.a:%’.:§i<~;e2§é:;;,': aiiai-ta-:2:"§ ;¥§:::1:f=; 1% §::as:§.' 5;. .

55:»; if: :.7:§§.:–:.%é€E F31 E {_5i’§S£?x:§E.;i2§§”f3§i’€)

§”}e?ii’if§E’§i’}Ei§.{i§”

saga 2%; §s%.;.;%;2%$§§*;:~:g”T”‘$;é§§%2{§’:*._;$§ §;;§§’:;:’Zéa§: ggafaig 23%
g _

§§@am&~’§”E.?: ffééafiz-x

“E2’3i::>é3;’:;:a-:%fi:::2f>;._ 22:3′? Ei§E§’}EfZi}§%’i§T3§€?. ‘z fig ézrzii

” ;,:é::é.€,.é;?:§:;>;’: Ea’; :’t:zf.i§;{% E7233. :3:’:i%&2″ {éa::z2£«:’§ $3:-*.

§f}’:’:’.f:”.}.§.”§.’ ‘z”,§’%{‘i é’.7′<}21:2:&é$f:%%L:;f::'2<ir:' of §2'm;}:2:,se:;*-«
33:2,: §~~§é§"2"E§:%fy ?'=§:m:§§'2': iEjis:Z"%§s='{","i,32 :2: ;:3:::5.i.'§é{2:1 in

4,3,3: {.j'.§;*a'::"3 !"a.§},:-':i§§';s."-§.i';-37:3: 2f»::;;%.a:§ fix": E-fig}:

-:1’§_i§{f’2″§’é€%..i’§}£’€3 %”§t:_:sz.% §3€%f.é%é::%3;2. Eff ‘z}’:€t ?§}?.§;§3.
.’:s’:2;’;:”2″ §.”s::»2z’§ i:”:{:eii i?’EiE§fi3″{§§iiiffi{§ 32173 §}E’I,iI”iOE3,
;fEi:”z:§§2;; ?’£;%m;i;’: a’*=::mE§§ 233%-‘€ ::}§;nJs:%’:€.% $2″:
£j:{::;’z’;mé:§§;;i€:3.’;a::%:’ 3’2, ;;’:;*.1:.é5;–;:§m’:j §’}i??(..”.f~RESi?’ gs: ‘:.§1″z§%%
€_’§e’%:§.{:f egm. at-‘E3’é::tE’r: 2,’-§’:::* p:%’E..é§.:k:>:} :a’::::«:. 13f§i’}’ir’s’f?{§ E3125′:

§:z?;:és;i;2e”:7% §}§”{f’f§(.”E”i§f%:T{§; E3}-” ‘f:§€i£.’%§i€>§3 :,7%:3=~2″§ :3?’ {E16 z’-‘ii

W

‘3%:%…%’z::;2″i§’}; 3:; 52:; gm. $1 3_§}€?{7i,’§EEi§.

2.

“Ezra-2a.’:-“s’m;§: 21; 3’wés=;z”{;.:.z. §§_§§§i3:Zi_’é%’§§.{3§.’E zifaéiiii V_E1::%§;€.._V

§.}fi”é’f..E’§ :’:2s;’_:2.:*:’;”.§. far §’%_ET§. <:zr::§é.*.:' £'{i3vZ'§'§".{"fi§i§ $;§?3,€é 4t::f:ff:53'7;

$2?” §§.::,E-: §E”§{“<'}I(§3:":'-§é§?{' '{."};:;§E<'€:' '::3':§%€%r i7%rf%{"*?;'§:':»::a,,:a-n..,A

ms!»

3:22.: .

mg?” 27;’.:a::,sar<=:-*.::§, E'},';{'i jg':-§ég:§"2 €f.T:<:'é.é.':"t' ':fi;?}::3:,2}éj1V Ba

"' .

;’§:$;::;€:::::.§. ;%;s”i §§§.::~:1?:3§i%$é§},g;§;

‘§f’3€??§§§’é:”}§.’i} *9;-“éiiiéjs ‘=@;’:;»2;:’~’; ‘=;=:_r:€;i:%;2s.i:2.:?:jé; ‘1¥..-‘2;s.§;”‘

}’§§ié~£_E”€.’§ {.233 Ehzi:

‘”§’%’3.:’* ?:’:~§.a?.%;:i§.’_’s_ iWf4{i’?§”{I’§:’:~if:Z’– Eézési 3§<'2%fi::*§" :17;
3% 3…}: :.":rs.::' _;?:::§§;:}":ii:3:-E.

533:3 “aim? 233:?’
£%;;;2s:3§.22.€§:~. %:<s,%::i$i;%:§':E

§Ef3.{?G§11{:%w%.é§';}Z *{."E'§€{'e:* :3;1za}'

§2'a::az3:.: :3i3€:= :"€§rfi:"{§.

[;ii’€£’};” é4i,EE.}’ :::i:~’;%i::’§«:.£:=: ;::s;2;’2;32e:-323$,

55;. ;;;’§f:’:::1i<_'- {"};€%"i{%6:" :%:§.§:E'2

\

-ii ::}§

gm

E”.§f:.f=§a’§é.?i..%?z.i§f*:’:.f?f3, ii. EE; §_EIE}.§_3Ei’E”Ei?§”5EE “:_,§fg2§>;’2 E’:;.§;:2 3:3
Elia £7§’E£§I,§’}{%§”i’§._’§’ iz; a 33;::»,:§::a:2e:°*r
‘s:”::~.s%2::= £3 EEK? ::”‘.;”-éfifi v:}’;i?2’3 §::;:1j”€}-*
3I3’2€.:::’2’s::%:”<'i:%&%

':9 »":.é..2*z £2331;-'~§{;}v:% _ .'

21

:.:1£,>;.’::%%’;’:;;s;.§€.%; cf *¥;§.:.:’:t §§é%’%.’;:«.PE.’§{;§’§. 9:’ €;§:§2_;;>r
p’§§»:::13:s,§ {%é;”;”
j2:zi:%a;’é:§,§ ‘i;é::*? 02″ 31%:-‘2:e2a:;§.;’:::::%. ‘§’}”:§: 1*g:::’s:;1’%i*:;=2f_’___i{s§ _.__ A’
E:a::u: _§’i’iE§§iii’fi% :92 213% 2% §§{}'{..{fE’i’§ s;§:'”:.1g§ Z ”
%e:’_}E.E
2,,;u;’ ‘:2 an 2 £32, if

f}{}’:’;’?{T?§’ E2223, z:§3;.»=:§ §E%.§’§_’éii-L. §§;~e’:.:%:’: 1f}:f:,€*. .g}%:t{}§”3E%::’.3 ”

§;i=°mim::E §2;”:: %.E11:”* a::;::§.. 2223:}. é=:ij: 9;’*.;3.jI;*. E?§iC§.§ 92″

1é{;:,:§7::i§;:=2%€ aim: ;3:,2z§;”_:%_:'”‘». in-2§5%s’i« .55; ;;2;{%i°:;E 2:}

E.’.:’:2::3;T»2.;’3 rig}? E. :5: ._

§E:.::= 3L..ég§::€ {sf aim §1::ég:€:a;§%*é;.,” ii. wsées <?@:{:.§az"::3i:%a'é fizai.

:*~:sz’%;:: if :A::.§.”%,s;=%;a'”2:z«:?_§.:Z %1f’:*:%:r;’%s%.;i%3*:,V€:;<:é;'ss':en:L 272: 2%;-"::32;zl{} 33:}: €Z.'}"€é?iE€

Ei§z"::s$ :;*7::§f*:;”1§:a12{.ia{% E3}; {Em E:?:ar:”:§%s:§. &;€:’:i:;::r 66112333? fix”

%;}}’§%. }j.?f$f§§’E_’§{.3vT:’;£Zé”?;§§’?§’2£%’§I £’w:é<i<"*§§: 2125 :3'. s:;E{;s{';{% 'C:l(}fi},f~:§§ii'.'L'E7§§{}E} {z'r?"0:€:_%;"-

,%’%:a%é:::3_€%::;zf;’ r:€_’,: A5′: E’:§}ZI”E?5, ‘§7:i2s.: p2′:’)vé5.s.§<';.:: 'ta aE%€:;:{.:a.:év€
2'::;.::;£%?s:%§; E:-§a:%:. '1§'é}.£?:;'3 <T§.»s;*i&€.::fi. '§"'1'2€z'<;';E7::z2'E% if §gi¥"€i ixnifg

‘ . :”:’2§’z€’:i:’m;:–;,«ii;:;’%.7:’>§{‘g ‘zzm ii ha-sz:s.’; 3:: E23? «:§a:*i:i%a%{§ (3.33 ::::%;’:%€,.3 aigg, {E$:?%:? §§_§§

= .%.§;§:?4E_g§§M§gg§{I;§’;§”:?§1%§§E §§£§fi’§” Sfigfifi $22 — Chaaéza $92 fihsrma