High Court Karnataka High Court

Smt P Ragini vs Bank Of India on 10 June, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Smt P Ragini vs Bank Of India on 10 June, 2009
Author: N.K.Patil


EN ‘3″‘}ZiZ. EEECBE C.SUl~’.T GE? §<;Al3_E'é£C§'A}{A ; T '=.ié.k GA LEZERE ':}vF'.P.}§GV1 E133» G? 25388
E
E

are THE H36?-*3 seam' GP ;<&a:~zA'rAKA A'? BARGALGRE
DATED 111:3 Tim 1373*' DAY cs' JUKE, 280?,
355935

ms i-iQi'~£'Si..E am' gusma ?€,K.PA_".!"{{'~ I f _

samrr ?E'}Z'§'I'§GK am. 1 1 13591" 2603*": .:iG;3§;;~§Rf£' aé % ~ x

BETE' EEN:

aw’ P R;-as: _

3.; :0 SR} PA§3a:;x.:~eAa2–;aN ~

3-saga ABQUE’ 4? YEARS *

ragga? :40 3.319, §$”§’ sagas

MGSEL c<3a.r:sm¢ '~:fas;»;.aa.*¢zara_'i:"%~{:?:3§+2V
EA%~§GAi..QRE-22 V I * ' . ._

gay 3:5; 9 S gagéma %<U:s.:,A.§'<;"»*e:*,n;%§;:f::;a*:g»;_ ' K

Bfifiéii G'%7–"%.i"¢§7..'§§.s.-"-"xi a

4|
E
“=z<;::AL'{::=Hf:a1. " _
E3§x€\§%< 3:: :z:.%§;':g»%.\V'e:_;:s;:r:;r~sa=
.*»»:'(.1s*§*:; *i~<§_$é~"{GA£17 = .

_ Bi’-.§’\z'{.’-‘;:\1X%..Q§’.EE§:7?2 mi LCTMEF %’e%A%~§AGEE§
3% M as A§i’#g?~éT%é=%%v§i.3R'{‘n*'{

2.21% “me-r: ‘»?EER,»°%

_ A-sW!m2~–%N AGE

– _ f::;~:,.;3? r4 amcx
“=%§?.JRé§§&.%.<3AR

3:%?§$»%%;QRE»1Q

A RESPCENQEE' '$53
(£83! 5'33: iéééék' ':<i}?v1s%i, 'V' #33:' s…z'%['§'E FER R1;

" V. x §€:;i':?§','rr3Rz'§2{¥'EQ§ N _ ".77r~%&RL £5sD\r'%:'%TE §3QR R2 }

'féi".b

'{§~w'§$ '%'u'R§T ?*E"§"§.3;'§{}€'\§ $53 FELEQ UEQQER fiaRT§f3%,£$ 22$ 3%? 22? G?

' "§H§ %3€3€'-38'{%T$..:'"§'E<;'3%'«£ BF EZ'~§§i£i i'F'Ri~'a'{E§'~iQ 3% Q§..§;'~'x$H T§~%'E §?s§?£.§Q?%EE?s

§E«§{E§i:'i:i"}é§$3é:E{i'é'}:%;7§'{L:'£~*"§;m:~¢A_';';é;;a;;a 5-»-;;* 1;;}§:.a::;g:. :L iE;s;:a 22;: ;3if~lé{E":":"_ée&§'i;§¥; Eééééa

VS'

£35 @313 EKG}: i§Z.{;}L§I3.'§' Ki?' §{AR?$E*£§;–'%.KA T B3'a}'é{_1f~=.L(}§§:EZ '€%'.F'.3'~E-gin} E 33$ 01? 2&3
,1
'-f

digrrzissed fine mid eppiicaiiafi huiiiing that; ihg:%a3.is 3

deiay sf aroufid 6319 "year fer which there is :':_;::'~+v;;*éc.*;§;*:§Léf:9é.§j§§Vi::a:1

Gaming farm fram {he side cf the pet§ii%.–1";ri ef;%.Vv§:%f:spiiévL:"c§

stsfifig ihai ha praceefied $116.1' pg-;§:é:9s t.:§: t%§e";rfi;{iv§c::;'ia

and céeiay accurred whéie ';$§e–g:;aringv.ti§eVa;:f:)éa_§~{:.3;1.efie.:3i 'atsé'

ba§§ev3bie. Acc5r;§§ng¥y,VAV_.f}{g.._ "F{£_bu.r§§§« /ivgajzfée t3 the
cnnciusion 'that the ta affer' sufficéenf
cause for c§2nd§;sj_3tic§r§ _%f.:'i:re§ a§§f~V:':%'sf"_:'..z':g ihe sppeai far
diépasing';'£53—-s»%:'%t'5V'.péf§fé§%§"' fbég Cami Sfifi digrrsissad
the '$1 '3§§';%-"isfe"'é.;§d by the sréer émgmgned
;:3a$$v:'e3:£Iby ':':®%§.t§c::1er hereérz feif zraesesgiéaiéfi

in .;3.re3e%%% .v"pé%Etié§z seeking apgxrnpriaie reiiefs as

" . _$ii'e::€e%§ $az}t:r;a.

heard Eeamea’ ceufisei fa? peiifi-me? 3:25?
%é?arfis§:4§ tfiuiései €33′ %”ESQ€3¥E§&fi%S.

After safiefui pefugaé Q? the arder imgugfied;

§aésea fiy the éégméd 3′-“”r23%d%s2§ :”;§%’f%¢&2* 9% EM “£”§*ibuna¥,

‘ ii erraergeg €52: the Trifiuin a §’¥3$ cammifiefi 3 grava arm:

i3»§mf2i§%§£”§3§i{§§~é”ifiiéfigé,’3′ {;::«-T :_zx2::;T2 E 13:: 23:5 Km

§’;=E 31 E17; iliifiii ${}§.§§?_’f GP §<j%.§{';§EA'}L5;KA § ¥33%.2*»§i3.;'ai.,{}R§3 'A-'.E'.?€@j"§ I 3%? GP
32
U

fhe appeai canmt be beééeved, am. Eu: §e§§€§éE§E? _?za$ Er:

facti, expiaified the daisy in fiiiawg at

sf the appéicaiiafi ihaii there wa$_$§ef_:3e %2_”‘i*”::’*?:’z~s:.:.%»:*;’_Vvs%2:*’§’~:.t§f:~..€,-3 §i=_éfT .

9’? fine ieamed Advacate wim d%s7fiefi_’_’iE<§e hit

menticméfig the skate G'? ap'1:"2§_': ¢'a:j%e2':,A"a'.§afa_'*ie: {}'§ . §'£§?3%:3§?i§ -the

szertified craggy sf the vsrfiar ate.x:..§§i::'2'§-r{;efét§5r:§.ng,*viimf the we
dates canmt be a the agapiécaticzsrz
csntrary is V:.i_$}%.?:s:;e::i by this Smart.
The 2 ieniem View af the
mafifi merits cf the 3332 am
permi:fEe§i"t¥%e' hag' griavarsce, énsfead

§f;g_:3';fs;*:1i§séng :§2'fe"apV;':z%E:;3t§€m an g:*m'sr;§ 5% deiay in $péts 6%

s§é:;§§§:;…§§raciéen fly this Cami if 13319 gamma was mat

;§§é"iisfa$%::2réiy, the Trébunai eeuizi have

:;a3':r:§'e;3éa:i&é the same by impcsing game feasénabie

" ~ abs? aéaéré-sf fna ;Z'}&§?§§'f"'§é¥"_ This sspeci sf firm mafia' hag

;%mt been éaaked Ema ¥"%C3f eafisifiarefi sad sfrséghfswsy

preceefied fa reject the agpiicaiéan er: hyper iachnicgi

5

i,?s:n_:::.;:=%;’:’ £12; 32;? %%4é%§3E}.51L(.j3i°;%i &s:.;:e»e: a_éi«’?Ai%%,%éi§é}%

E33 ‘§L§1EE 1E3<L§E}C?€L3UR'.{'*=I}}7 §<;j–ER,?'~E;5'{}':'a}€,;'~'s. 21.'? §,3z'%.§'«§:.f:..s"%.L{}'v§%.}iE. 'ég'CP2"«§<:«.§ H36; GE' 2.638

7 .VW…m~..__…_m..-..,.mmW..__.

gmurzfis if’; spite 9% $19 gpegific fiiféfifééfi 55; ihis rm’:

ta refaef the agagfiiaaiisfi an graufid éxf ciééaya “:_’:§

in View an? nan mmpiiarace :3? the d%;”es:.fio :’1 §S§L§6§{1:’::”§f§’§f”E?’3’§S
Gmzrt as referred shave.

E3. in the Eight” gf the c§%t:iL2rz*2$;€&3H:.*:ces 3% the

_ sage, as siatefi 3b5v95e’,’ jE%*se” §jéi%*§€_%$§i”»f§ied by péfiiiafier

is giiowed gagged fly the
Baht Re¢=a%~ag=;:gf?:it;ix%sé%(%% as at
fianggauiéreiif :§#*§%;:’a§€§ ‘ 2388 passaé cm
§_A.i’\iV§;£§%36I2§fi§ ‘VAi%;”:«_b’E’n’§H’f*’.%%2:E3!2’Gfi5 véde Amemre A §$
%”:e2:fa~byf3é§’ A V’

reasgens géaéad at paragrapfig 2 and 3 Q? fiifi

January QGOE and ffae ag::p%ic:ai%cn éaied

5*” _:a:z§ua§éy 2055 am it: fhe Eighf Q’? the specifirz

“::h:§~;eri%3ti0ns made by this Caurt by is crder éaied $5′

‘§§c§§ébe*s* zaea pagseé in wag Peiiiéen ?~Es.325§£2Q§4, the

“SSE appiicamrz ig aiiawfd sasfbgfaci fa amfizéétisn that

f
2

K

$3.; is: E ézfgiéé {.%’r_i:%i_:’:«:€””<: '3; '.}é%i§%';¥: Z4' 3;-:z.,=.?«';é%.;F;,..-:4;L:E:§i:~ET*é§a£f;i%.'§:;s T: 13:; {;:~:4=' E {#53

E32 '"i'£§§i £i1%§3§}{3€3§§E{'1'{)§'9§<I;§a§E?€A'i'A§<Zf'~.. é';.:§'_§.fg43'f;§'m{§_;§_§:C2§{M§§:_T§3§1?_;i~ég,_§_§}_T C§"5:j§::2_§_3:}§

0 , _

:3

peiéféaner $'r:a%§ pay $935: af R$.'23,5:3G'- {R:2;:2e;eS "'€2.n:e

Yhméssgné ?-Kw §"§Ufi{§¥"8£'i Qniy) ta fEf'$'1f rers$c:1'§'_$_7:*ai:"~«¥%I"89$:'§i<;

anti' 3 gum 9% R33 £36233» {Riiipééfi {Eras

gecenfi respandeni which 331353 ?p$'i:£«1v'E:':_TT*£*:'i'_e*:2*_£: ';:»e:r;s"a"r}gVi:Ey

G? :hrz:ug'n iheir respectévie .§:3:..in$ei"an§? Tézzi? fiée .3 °mé%;":=§:§',

aiang with acknawie5gefiéé%%:«éfefgréf§'f§§;;§n3§ within
twé wéaks; zirem the sgpy sf fig e';'{§s§*_
Ewe ";'sf§_';:a:.i;§2§ :§$ fuzfiwer and
A;§km~ec.1 3.22535 afier
3ffo:f}:°.i'§r§'g7*;éa:$gi*%2géh§é §:§§§r;é§f%:;1ri§%y is the gisariies is tfie
§recéedr:r«':g¥s ggtéée game 3% §X§&§§?§%fiUS§}! as

§fl$'3~.§§é$.

sal-

Iudge

5§.4v%%’LL

3%”::’%éé3%;:%;’j§%5:z”:§.i’:.;$L4;E3.'{$3’§;é;»:%;é;’i”A§:}éé.”§f§’::§ _