IN THE HIGH COURT 01-' KARNATAKAEV».
BANGALORE _
DATED THIS ms 04"" my orgmztsi? 290% ' * ?
THE H()N'BLE M1uUs'1"1cE r1{:j,tiVADi;t:.mMEszi%
W311; PLT!I1.0._N..E' 0,; #1370 0 ' % '
PET ION Nos.1a2 . % %
1770 A % L 1955/03 1
1762 .
wuus Ia
1. SmtjR.Saiaswa§ihj; ' .. '
W./0 M.Rm{i," '.
Ageidgbnut 3.3
, ~Rvesidi1ig..,at'Cz'0 K;..Raman,
» 515.200, l4fi'«Mni:: Road,
,, _ stage, 2"'! Block,
" ~
~ SR) laté Kannappa,
about 60 years,
= 140.200, 14"' Mam' Road,
TBSK I Stage, 2"' Block,
V' M Srinagar, Bangalore-50.
% 3. smxayalakstum',
W/0 P.Kodanciaraman,
Aged about 36
3*'
Residing at No. F-32,
3'" Cross, R% ,
Brahapmam, Bangalom--32.
. Miss.Asha,
. Sri.T.R.Samath' ,
Aged about 30 years,
D/o A.L.Ba1u,
No.40, WAT Street,
Basavanégudi,
Bangalore-4. IN
- '=..1W.P. N'0.'%9370f07
S/o T.S.Rajagepa1asetty, V _
Aged abor;tS5 "
Avcp.ue- Iiaxiggaizyre-2. V .
. sxak,p.\:_1s:.i?:za.sac:,%%k Q '
15/ 0
A364 a*>9i*iV139. x "
Residing at.Nra,32-5';-._ * '
' 15"' Main,
% . _$§:£.¥X.'S,Ushmmi,
T.
W mm: 42 ymrs,
Residitxg at No. 147,
BSKI Stage,
' 11 Block, Bangalore-60
. S;nt.A.P.Lakshmi,
W/'0 A.R.Pand:zranga,
Aged about 49 ymrs,
Residing at No.5{)(),
7*" Main Road,
I 1"' Cross,
2"' Stage, Bani".
. Sri.B.A.Prakash,
S/o B.V.AchaialI Settec,
Agedaboutfiyears, V'
Rwiding at No.22, =
'SPANDANA' 2"' floor,
Yeliappa Garden,
Malleswaram, "
Bangalore» S3.
Sri.K.P.Pmveei1,x. f
Slo Parmasamfii, "
A8°dnb0I.1t55 _
Residi_ng'a_VtjNo.1?9/4, -4 '
H
Sh$'nkamp11mm""'
~ % %
DIi:..Pa.*fl1a'saz9athi,..._".."
~ 1. Aged' aho'ut 48 years,
. S:a:.K.v.shmaa,
" .p}'o K.V.Venkataswamy Haida,
Agedahoutfiflymrs,
H 4' Residing at No.229,
2*" Main, 2"' Cross,
NGEF East, Bangalom-89.
Smt.B.R.Umaprasad,
W/o B.S.Ramapmsad,
WK
.. ya
. Sri.H.N.('nIrm=ajame,
Aged about 46 years,
Residing at No.1 93,
"Vijayashree", 14" Main road,
BSK 1 stage, Bangaloae-50.
Sic. H.S.Haraharirao,
Aged about 55 ymrs,
Residing at No.22/13, _
MGK Nlurthy Layout,' _
Appurao Read, k
Chamraivct Banggtlore,-"'* --
Sri K Sandhyu va,'m;am%
_
Wfo
Asa? 'ab-0i!t45*'Ynnrfi... I. A
Nd l62"}fli c:esg%wirmn%Ga;den
Rep PA Sri M Satyanarayw Rae,
"'*$'*'*%% 8595* 77°
~ 811' H S
I __S/o:__Sti HS
gbout 55 years
" '~N(}l 3. MGK Murthy Layout
Chnmrajpet
" Kamalakshi
W/0 Sn' A Narayanamja
Aged about 50 ywrs
No 2'7 51%: Cross 56: Main Road
3rd Block T R Nagar
Bangalore--28
1151 %w%,F.m;:92.72/trz%%
5
Sn' H M Sanjay
S/0 H S Manohar
Aged about 50 years
R/at No 1l9,3rd Main
lst Phase Cririnagw Bangalo:e--85
Rep By his P.A Holder smm
D/o K C Keshavamyudu A
SriCSPrabhakar «
S/oCSubharamaia.h
Aged About 52 Years Rjfit-N'u~§0
RepbyhisP.A ;--:a m~% k
Smt 1 .v
D/oxcjxesshavarayuataa, A u
sr{K Q
Aged Ab-aaa_t_V R/M No 827
7 'I BSK II Stage
Rep 'byV_hi3.F--.A i+1c;1;ier
Smt G D/0 K C Keshavarayudu
$0 Yum
S/0 Fiamanjaneyulu
.{\ge::!--"about 26 Yams
u R/At No 93/2 Upstairs
Gandhibazar Main Road
Bangaloro-4
9.
Sri G lu
8/0 C Ramaehaadxaiah
Aged about 52 Years
>é/
R/at No 98/2 Upstairs
Gandhibazar Main Road
Basavamgudi
Bangalore-4
1OSriBPRavi-kumar
S/ONP A
Aged about 45 Years
R/AtNo 110; %
1,"F"Main2nd Phase
Girinagar Bangalore-85._____ ~ ..,,,PETI'TIONERS
_ 1Nw.1>.No.1927;w7
(By Adi; )1 ~ , u M . V
l. D.M.Nasasi_mha_Mi1fiihy,_" ' '
S/0
A855 ._
No.'34/Al;
€ha;;3f;;§pei;i.: 8.
2. M.R.Venkatesh, --. %
sxo M.R.Ra1nacha£idfli S %
Agedabout52years,"' '
Anjé-nadfi Niiaya;%IJmmirs,«j %%%%%
No'-.'28'G,--. Sregexragat,
. I'€("..
I)'/O' fate
A _ shout 48 ygars,
' Nazso, 24?' Sroenagat,
..PETITIONERS
% 1;» " ,
IN W.P.N0.20389I97
' 1 %S/,0 Dlhimmmya Stray,
" - .. "Aged. about 58 years,
"Nc}:_:24, "Gckul",
2/
9"' A Main, 13 Block, Jayanagar,
Bani5600l1.
. V.Murali,
S/o V.Ch:mdraiah, '
Aged about 54 years, ,
No.34/Al, Pampa Maimkavi"Rofié1;"':v
Chamrajpet,
V.Moha:a,
S/o V.Chandmiah,V
Aged abo:it50y€:a$'"s,_ 1
No.34/Al, Pampa
Chamrajpat, A' V' " ..PETITIONERS
" 1Nw.P.No.1s3/as
(By &fS;%e;K.T%;Nagcndra, Advs. )
51.5.95 .4 A
1.
a
53$ % Principai Segfetary,
' ~ Urban Dgveiopment Defit,
2;:
" S,Building,...Ban one.
- %
« " Dave]-opment Authority,
Road,
% * . M/s.Vishwabhmuthy House Building
Co-operative Society Ltd.,
No.35, Rafinmvilas Rmd,
Basavanagudi, Bangalore,
By its President
B.Krishna Bhat.
W
..COMM(N
RESPONJENTS
(By Sri.Ke.-shava Raddy, AGA for R-1,
Sn'.K.S.A.bhijith, Adv. far R-3,
Sri.Ramesh, Adv. for R-2)
BETWEEN:
Sri.B.S.Vishwe.shwara,
Aged about 48 years, V
No.2] /1, Ragga Rao Rmd,
Bangal<1m~S%.__ ..PETITI,0NER
k j _ _ Am w.P.No.1762m
Sri.B.S.Shekhar, _
Aged about_5{1__years;' _ 1 .
No.21fI, Ratiga'Ra£3_
Bengali};-e«%i56'000i%; ._ ..PETI'I'IONER
«««« IN W.P.N0.1'778A}8
Ssi.K,S_.Naa:gag;pa, . '
Aged about 53 %
G-'74;=
__;Bangalore-:'i6_0O04.V: ..PE'l'I'l'IONER
""" IN W.P..NO.l'764J%
' Murthy & Associatzs, Advs.)
~ 'T Bangalore Development Authority,
' Bangalore.
2. President,
Vishwabharathi Housing Society,
N035, Rmtnavilasa Road,
Basavanagudi, Bangalore-4.
M
3. State ofKamata|m, T
Urban Development & Town Flaming __ '
eat, "
Vidhana Soudha,
Bangalore-560001.
By im Secretary. ..COMMQN}
(By sd.K.N.Pu:tegowda#jT%A4v. fix-R;:,% %
Sri.N.I).R.Ramachandra for R-"-2,?
Sri.Manohar, AG». for R-3)
BETWEEN:
_' %
Rasiding
1' Block, l0"»',.B--M§jn' R 4%
Iayana8fif;T'Ba:§:zn50i*%¢¥'i1;"-Q
Represgnted by iiis'v-?.A,H€.'tlder' '
Sri.D.S.'Mtmiraju,_ V.
s/o D.G.Sfi;;jv'a.s, X J
Aged -abm-:t3'9
'V ' S10" Venkatamat: ---Lingappa Bhandari,
"'Age_-1 §mn:%7e%%yan,
No.33, Um-amiadm mutt lane,
j L Chifikpct, ..PETITI().NERS
1%.%%%%%jsn--uq_G.B§1a;i,
IN W.P.N0.2089f08
SfaG'c-vindarajaseny,
Agedabout 48 years,
% -. Residing at No.1 823, New No.8,
A " MRCR Layout, 23*' Cross,
Bangalore-".79.
2. Sri.N.Anand,
S/o late Narayanappa,
Aged about 45 years,
Residing at Clo B.M-Ramanna,
No.10/95, 3"' Main,
2"' Block, BSKI Stage,
Ashokmgar, Bangalore-S0. "PE*r1Ti=sme::z.s A ' 2
§N"W.'R;NG.823fl!3 5
Smt.A.R.Anawya,
W/0 A.H.Ravindra Kumar, ' L. »
Aged about 53 years,
Residing at No.4 1 O7,~ .
5"' Main Road, K.R.Rr5ad,?
BSK [1 Stage, _ 1 __
Bangalore-?O; ' 3 aJ'E'TFFIONER
"" IN W.P.N0.l955R$
' -'
Agod"abtmt 55 yam, ¢
Residing' at' i"50;20 & 21,
Neelaka'ni:a,_ _
- A "4"'?Cro§L:1 Manjtsiiéthanw,
' " ~ .,Ragn14an_aRa3ly,
(P0).
2 Main Road,
%%%%3a§ga:nm. ..PE'l'I'I'IONER
n fi(By"S..ri.G.S.Srikanteshwara11, Adv.)
IN W.P.N0.l954£8
1. The Smte of Karnataka,
By its Principal Secretary,
Urban Development Department
M.S.Building, Bangalme-
2. The Commissioner,
Bangalore Developnwat Authority,
Chowdaiah Road,
Bangalore.
3, M./s.Vishwabharaflay House Building
Co-operative Society Ltd., -
No.35, Ratimavilas Road, I . AT '
Basavanagudi, Bmgalom,
By its Presidcmt _ " '
"R_ESP'w{)N;DENTS
(By Sri.Ramt.sh fer R-1,
Sri.Shz-mlmr Narayaiaa Rabgfiiivv. fbi R-2,'
Sri.K.N.Pt:ttcgowda, for LR-2'_,~ V ' i_ --
Sxi.N.D.R.R§amac1:.;an<$ra:'V.MQ;~A::iv. re: R-3)
maw,\
$mt. Rafié, S V '
% abuts: years,
-') 'N9«.202,A 15"*1s/mrisa;
% a.s;1'" Stage,
mngaangaessoovo. ..PE'1'!TIONER
IN W.P.NO.l768l%
{B§}.1Vi!§;.H.R.Ananflzakfishna Murflxy & Associates, Advs.)
%% 3 LT Amy:
1. Secretary,
Bangalore Development Authority,
Bangalore.
2. President,
2/
Vishwabhazmhi Housing Society,
No.35, Ramavilasa Romd,
Basavanagudi, Bangalore-4.
3. StateofKamamka, I V'
Urban Dcvelopmaat & Tom'; " 4' f
Vidhana Soudha,
By its Secretary. QRESPONDENTS
(By Sri.K.Kfi3hnh, ‘*- ‘ *
Sri.K.N.Putteg0wda, Adv. thr R-I-,_ ” V
Sri.N.D.R.Ra2:}acha3i&a.:Ra(s,}%dv. Ԥ'<1a;'R'-:2,
Sri.ManQhat;AGA3.fmi1R#3)'" L
S
S:i.M.Kfishaapjm, ;
Aged aims S6» fy'ae=a:s,_% ,, % "
S/0 '
R_/o NOL40,"69f ' "
V» Bungalow-569027. ..PETI'IIOWR
a Sfi–..S;M_,Babu, Adv.)
IN W.P.NO1569f08
I S mte of Kamataka,
'Rep. by its Secretary to Government,
AA VT Urban Hove-lopmont Deparknent,
M.S.Bui1dings, Bangalum-560001.
2. Vishwabhamthi House Building
Co-operative Society,
No.35, Rathnaviim Road,
Basavanagudi,
Rep. by its President.
3. Bangalore Dcvclopment Authority,
Chowdaiah Road, Kumampark West,
Bangalore-560020.
Rep. by its Commissioner. ..
(By Srils/fanohat, AGA Em” R-1.,”
Sri.K.Krishna, Adv. for R-3, X _
Sri.U.Abdul Khadcr, Adv,f_or R-3», ‘
Sri.N.D.R.Ramachandra
BETWEEN: %
Smt.Vcda:1i,
Agw about 52 years» . jf ‘ — _
No.21/I, Rmsga1’Rao;_Road.; – ‘
Shankam9um:fi.&&%& A I % if; .
IN W.P.N0.l76ll%
Aged 54’§,*ears,
.. 1310.6, Rnjatajashwafi
_ A -,,.M.NL;.Kr”§shna R§ii’Road,
% % Ba-m-nasisdh
“By GPAj_h§€ilder,
“‘~Sri.B.’S~ Ramachmadtn,
A2e6:58 years,
A. ,__S1o’Shankan1amyaaa,
._ 21/l, Ranga Ra0Road,
” Shanlcarpuram,
Bangalore-4. ..PETITIONER
IN W.P.N0.l763l08
Smt.H.Usha,
Aged 50 years,
No.98, 17″‘ Main,
B.S.K. 1’ Stage,
2″‘ Bzock, % A .
Bangalore-560050. _.*;;«PETfi”El}PIER
IN %W_r.No.1 76 6a’fi:V8 ‘.,_’
(By M/s.H.R.Ananthak1-ishna &”A.qspcVi§iag,.}XElVy§;’)
Bangalore Devcfl9pme:;i’A:1§hotii.y,
Bangalore. %
2. President, AA
Vishwabh§Jrathi= _H<*__»asingf' « Sbc?i'ety,__T A
N0;355 4Rén_:xavivlgsa' Rm, 1; %
3. Stafieof
_ _ Urb5a:1_ Vflevelopmétit & Tawn Plamimg
” ‘ ….. .. ”
Baitgiflme-56600}.
« %%%ay%i:s%TLscmmy. .. COMMON
RESPON DENT S
(By $i.U.AMul Khader, Adv. for R-1,
Sii.M.Keshava Raddy, AGA for R-3,
” LT Sn’.N.D.R.Ramachandra Rao, Adv. rim R-2)
BETWEEN:
1. K.Vijayak1nnm’,
Sfo Aliallappa,
>2?’
Aged about 44 years,
Residing at No.27,
63′ Main, III Block,
T.R.Nagar, Bangalore-28.
2. Sri.A.KaJa;m,
S/o Adiyappa Naidu,
Aged about 70 years,
Residing at No.27, _
6″‘ Main, III Bloqk’ *
T.R.Nagar, Bangalore-28: . _ ‘ . ‘V
3.
S/oR.KrishnamaNa’idza,~”
Aged about 57yea.’s;~ ‘ ‘
Residii2g_8i~No;69Q,….’: ”
Ashak 1; %
BEEKI:-S$,a’ge;*– ..PETm0NERs
%%%% ~ INW.P.N2).3448i08
W10 35:)?» Jeyakpmgt,
Aged ab’out”6{3 yé;-ars’,
Resésiing at I,
J 4″‘ Crbss, Am” Main,
Smgc,
Bangalgre-560038.
A 2.v_v’S’;r’i;§3QIV2.Satyanaraym1a Setty,
.. ” AS/0 B.K.Ramaiah Setty,
about 58 years,
12/2, 22″” Cross,
BVK Iyeagar Rand,
Bangalom-55.
3. Smt.C.V.Nagaraflmamma,
D/0 A.B.Hanunaanfi3aseuy,
Aged about 55 years,
Residing at No.1 54/21,
1″ Cross, 22″‘ Main Road,
Sriflfim’. Bangalore-50.
. Sri.K.Govindasetty,
S/0 R.Kantha Setly,
Aged about 50 years,
154/21, 1″ floor, 1*cmsg_, A
10* Main, Srinapt,
Bangalore-50.
. smt.M.Ushmni,%%%7′ T
Aged about 56 years;
w/0 Mar:3tinappfi”K§ga§i, _% L
C/0 Méifijfiflhg
Resaa:agam¢.4135$
“Kavya’TS!2ree”g.’ V
‘ ifigotiabout 4’I”yeaz>s,
” ~ ..S?a Lifigappa M,
. ‘ ..Re.sidit1g atNo.417,
‘ Shine»
2″‘ 2″‘, A Cmss,
‘ ‘ ‘ , Additional I Phase,
” are-85.
‘. Smt.S.R.Sha:ila,
W/’0 Dr.Ravindrm3afl::,
Aged about 50 yam,
Residing at 140.210/C,
4*” Cross, Jawt,
, ” 1 .;ms*n’r1oNERs
” IN w.P.No.3449/so
II Black, Bungalow-I 1. ..PETITI0N E§as
IN
(By Sti.G.S.Srikanteshwamn, Adv.)
I. TheStnteofKamatakg,_ 1
By its Pxinci Secrete..ry”,~… V g
Urban Dcve
M.S.Building,
2. ‘I’l1cCom:nissioaie’r;:~ ” ,
Bangalore Deveiqpinatitv Auth<$rity;'~ 1;
3. Hansgfiuilding
Ltd”,
‘:._No.35», Reggae-arms Road,
Bgsamnagtwlfig.
By its President
….. .. RESPONDENTS
B.Kfish1;§Elmt;’ “COMMON
f ={B3r. Roddy, AGA for 12.1,
._ Adv. for R~2,
‘ S1i,1$I.:D,I”{.Ramachandta Rae, Adv. for R43)
Bfifzfiwgz-;N:
3 = sm:.J.shakuum1a,
W/0 Sri.K.Subrai
Aged about 55 years,
R/at No.25, “Sam.pige3′,
7’1′ ‘B’ Cross,
Stlohn English School Road,
p(,,/
Amruthahaili, S am Post,
Bangalore-560092.
S-ri.K.Subramanymn,
Aged about 62 years,
..Pm*mbNER
IN
Sic Sampangiranaaiah,
R/at No.25, “Sampige”,
7″‘ ‘B’ Cross,
St.John English School Road,
Axnrutbahalli, ”
._ ;.’PE’§’ITIONER
‘ L. . ._ IN W.P;N0.2’706.R}8
Smt.K.B.PushP&4¢Vi#’V & A
Bangalore-560092.
W/o D.V.Na_gataj,
Majm’. . % %
Rfat 1~1<)_.41IZ!06,§28_"* _ .
4"?B1ock,k
(By iiszaaau, Adv.)
' V' " 1, 'of Karnamka,
« "By_~v_itsv!{'rii1cipal Secretary,
'Development Departmem,
" . M.S.Building,
% ' The Commissioner,
' Bangalore Development Authority,
Chowdaiah Road,
Bangalore.
3. M/s.Vishwabharathy House Building
Co-operative Society Ltd.,
/.
>9?’
Agad’about47 I ‘V
..PE’I’ITIONER
IN W.P.NO1707l0B
20
got the registered sale deed in their name;
Society had assured that possess. ion to
them afier approval of the layout,’
According to the petit3oners,’ $6″
genuinety and gem-ity? the
sites in favour ~t_!}e and that
has certificate as per seniority
by Qjlouing sites to the new members
” ._§;béforc accordingly, it is the submission» of he
‘A For the pcfitionms am an appmpriate writ or
issued $0 the respondent/EDA to implement the
¢£the Government orderdahed4.l0.07.
3. Heard fine foamed Counsel representing fize BDA and
the learned Government
W
they should be considered on priority as against 0flf:erTpe1sons
who have been allotted arid) sites and
members subsequentiy. When specificafly
Societies Act has provided a
authority, without e)dzaustir1g. §e;aedyA were
the petitioners Sims this
Court is not a rlmt toe in the writ
proceeding<.i,:;e3l_theee of with a direction
to the Registrar ef Co-
on serving notices to the
ef me mawer in accordance w1'1:h
aame sWy_
Sd/-
Iudge