E3RI.A.AI\':\E\}1)z'\ SI II"-"j"I'"'I"Y -- /\II)V .} AND: 1.
SRLP. m’A1′>1′>A
53/0 I’. RICIDIDANNA
MAJOR Ac;1’~:
R/O E4458. SUBI–~I1\SI—–1 ROAIT)
EV}/\I..)AN;=\I-‘AI.,I,I. CIII’I’I’OR I)IS’I’R.IC’I.’
AN£:)1~1RA 1–>RA1.)1:<:s1~-1
2. SRI.O.RAJ/\NNA
8/ 0 (‘).I’)z\SA§\J
R1::1.)o1,1«:c;AN11>A1.1,A
1′ 1/0 I{C)”I’1\\?’Al\EIC}Ai.I,I
MAI’)AN;\I’AL1,I.
C1—HITOR DIS’I’RIC’f
ANLJI IRA I’RAI’)I:3S1-5!”
3. I.\/1A.N/-\GI:3R
UNm«:I:) Imym ;\sSL,%.1.~:/WC: I<:– ' '
(:c»':Vii32\'N$;f51;rI:5'f:'; _
MA1")AN'AI?AL:;1-[.,A * _ ' –
/\1\I1″)1-1I”1I:2AI_>.I§::~31 1~..__ . _ . . .RICSPONI[JICN’1’S
{BY $1–<1.13.%(.;:-I$1::1-a"1f1V-=-;-IAAI2/\M:?\ mo – ADV. 1:01- \-‘\fI’1’I~I
VI/_(?) IglA’1.’I_.:”_,I.i) :3 1 .07’;«<19'09
«R; 'I 551'}:I'j._ /WI”) UNRE1?’RESI’3N’1’i*3ID)
. _ IS 1–‘11.1~:1′> mmala SI-£C’I’ION 173m 01? Mv
.2~.c;:”r Ac;;;-\INs=’1* ’11 II.-I §;uI:::> I)A’I’I£I.)
24~,o:3.gu~<3.¢s…V'1'u IN av-m,: Nc’).288c>/2<)oo ON 'I'iIIC m1.I~:
'. OI' ..'I;I'1I£ VII AUDI, JUDG E. iVII.£E\/EI::3I?IR MAC'I'~3,
Ai\/II£'I'RO._.I"C)I,I'I'AN /\I{I.*3/\ I3/\NGAI'.ORIC. (SCCITi~3}. I"'AR'I"LY
» !\LL,Q\-'VI§\'(}- 'I'III1I C LAIM I–'I.C'l"ITION FOR COM1'I-ZI\§S/\'I'IOE\1
' }'s.l\?I)."SISICKINCE ICNI IANCf§*IMI"IN'I" OF CCDMI–'ICI\§SA'I'IC)I\$'.
_zi/1.i'=".A.;\1<;). .1 15345/zoos; (zvm
{*3 Ii'I"\=\-*' I:II'*Z§\E :
U§\”E’I”I”i.CI.) Ii\EI.)L=”\ IEVESUI-{1\1\’C’II-C (7T.(,.).,_ I.’I’I’.’)..
EVI./\III)ANAI”3’AI,I,I I%RANCI”‘I. (AI–‘}
/’
I
Txiibunal 112153 t.a.ke1’1 the aw3.1*21ggc .in(:()m€ in tc;)t.:2 Whig?-E315
not pm’:nissi.bie Lllldfjl’ the reievailii pmvisioI1_S. izf”f.hc*”~
1nc:(m1e “ax Act: and what is permissible t i~1_. c1ec;:l1;,ssc:ti “W218 ‘.3 V
Managing Pamgner of an E1’1gi’1’1ée:_i’iz’1_g f’iri’1’1_ gc:ti.i11g salary
for the 2’1ssessn’ae:’1t’, yc._z«:1″_i%«-‘5 E’_99.?§’2Q£)VO’«._m: 31,04,000/~.
€98,091/~ and ?1__.18.3O6.,/ 5 the axrerzxge:
is iaken, it; c_:(i.1_11e§V ‘(;_§.3 .€’1.._G5V,132/.« <:i.1't;*":1*:*5Voa1V2’;:.} expenses of the
deceziségi. ._’thy:’7Iri:ef:f”<i1i'c:céinc – works out 'go "<'70.088/~.
Havin f 1"<;*1fi211'~<"1 to ffiafl Fé1~::t'4s3 and Cil'C'L1I1}SE&}.l.'}(3€tS 0f the
c21se3«,.{:a.ppEying"1';}3..e n."1uVit,ip]'ier of1'7'. xxre :'ewc1t:tr:m'1i1'1c the
pi' .c:;e,';;e;§ c1e_;1c:y at. % 2 1 .9 1.496/~.
=f5.V”figs: :?fribu1’1a§ has rightly etwzxrdeci just: alld
IT€E1SOfx3E§Q1f:V c:0mper1sat.i(m tic)wa1’ds loss of <:011so1'1'.ium
":\:"3.A:V1FlVVCki"'*..;'.()S$ of est;21t'.e at. the rail:-'3 of 310.000/~ each and
t'Eaeref'()re, it. does rmt can for ini:e1.'t'e1*<311<.:e. HC)\-V€\«'fE?l.', the
Tribu:1a1 has not awar(ied any c()mper1sat,i<m tcwvarstis
loss of i<)ve and affe(:i'.ir1. ‘}’11e1″eE’re. we tieerzl it. ju::é;i:
and :’eas<)r1able to 21wa1'(i $15300/~ at me: rate of
My/M
?5.{'')()()/« to 0210.11 of tin-= ('*1z1i11m1"11s. ?l().()()()/~~ 1"z-1(.1 %:>0(1y 21ml f111’1c1″z=’11 cx})c=’r1’1sc.=»u 111
2.111, \.\’¢;* 2~1\\==z-“1111 €’~”1’:”3′()()(,)/– m\.\.»’z1:'<1s the.' (-011\rc1"11i.:$h;:11
lwaclss.
(5. ‘I’1’1(> (‘E2–1.imz11’11s :»11′(* c1’11.it’.!c(‘1_§’._L) ‘~–.,2=-1′{ ‘i<)1.2=:11"~
c1I11:)c1’1–sz-1′:”ion of i’12,:3(}.3,¢11-E)(.5/– asf_z’.1l,fab1,i,1T’«1…$T.1
21wa1~c1c-ad by the ‘1’1’ibun21l. ‘-1_’_h_c:i’t’3nrt.i1,’.”5-o’:)n1crs:}1<5A
%86.808/–.
7. F01″ tho i”1fi«:_1;g _1′(.;.1sc;_;i.”1:4;–V.3:136A;1p1_.)c21i i’i1c=-mi by
the (_t1;1im2:m1.s. LG. I [\/1.E*’VA~. (‘1is.s1nisssc(:1
as (.1L”\”i 3_i(1.'(‘)’i’V1:1’VI’f?{1″‘§.I;;§;« “71’_}V””1’¢_:__ a1..ipca1l 01” E110 i1’1sL11′(“1”–‘a\/WA
I\?0.i.1E’)45/”=2’_()()(3 ‘is’ ‘ $1}.–1g$k*..:ct’c:.1 in 1’32-U1. TIM’. in1p11_:_g11L”(1
c(,)111,:1§1¢c)1’T1’~_§1.1(“i;3;imi%m’ zmcl 2-:\v25:1′(1 of 1.hc_’ “1’1’ib1_.11’m1 d2.1%(>(‘1
N.28F%()/2{)()() is 11’1{>(1i1’i(‘ci by
1″c~:;’17.i1..eV'[:=t:’c._)1m)@1’1ssz1tion a\.v2=m:.iL~,(l by the “I.’1’i1′.)1.11’1z1l
E’.I’0l’1′] ‘§13,V2.3”.:3(.)4/~ {.0 ?’i2,l’;€$._4»E5)b’/~ ‘1″hLié t.(.:)12.1l 1″t*(:’l1.u’ti(‘)1’1
‘(..’.(A:)Ifi’c?.:7;’a 1 “‘3 86373 ._ 808/ –.
“H10 ir’1s1m:1” is (1i1′(“”(“1IL:’.(“1 to (:’1c1)sit: ilw 1’L:*11’1ai11i1″1.;___>;
(_'()I’1’11.)CE’]SéH’i.(..)£E \–\.-‘H11 it’11(‘£'{“Sl’ at (5% p.2==1. E”m1’1’1 U”I(‘ <12;11.(3* of
{tilt p§.i1’.io11 1111 1’cz1lis:’11’ir)1’1. 211″1.L:é1′ (!e(:§1._tc_*1.i11g.g ihc :11’m.)11111
21111-‘2~1(i}.,-*’ (“§cp(‘).<.si%c(.1. wi1E1i11 1131.11' \\'(:'..c1<.~a f1'(::)1n 1.110 (121111: of
1't"L'Ci}Ji. of the <'('1'{ii'ic<'1 r'01)_\_.-* of $116 _jL1d§_§13"1m1I"' 2-1m} z=:\\';u'(E.
The .21p1.)01'Ii01'm1m11' u1'(1c;'1*v.._I:l’E.§=?
<:]21i1112'='11'1'i.s~s Ls; in be })2'()1.}()1'Ii('}1'1£':I_('1}-' :.'v(111c.'c{1.
'E"11c'= SI.2'.1{'.1§I.():'_\g' e.1m0u111'. in (i<jr1j)»o:},?””1:*’.v–i1.<}}*~v ,i1':Vsi.1–1fcr__
511.2-111 be 1.:'2.tns1nit1(~.c1 10 1.1'1c jta:'i:s:§.'iiu*ii<'m;f:l'~ 'TriE.:i':;J-l__12'?i};;'
i"()1't'1'1wi1.1'1.