In THE HIGH couwr OF KARNATAKA AT aAn§£.Ar;n DEST.
P RU_D}§*A'SWA?.§'f = _ .. ' -
S/O LATE PEEKANA NAIKA
AGED ABOUT 40 YE!'-aRS'=
R/O n0D:31c;ANA.L MEDEKEREPURA
C-3HiTR.ADUR{_'1r_1fl'l TALUK AND D18'? APPELLANTS
'(B:,essi~i: E Ivrs:1;~3)APPA;"A't5v.}
.. 1
KL: am We LATE SAMYA NAIKA
AGED' wow 57 yams
R/O=.¥)O[)DIGAN.&L MEDIKEREPURA
" 'C;HITRADURGA TALUK
= .._A_2sZD Dififi'
RAMASWAMY S/O LATE SAMYA NAIKA
AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS
R/O DODDIGANAL MEfiIKE.REPURA
CHITRAUURGA TALUK
AND DIST
,3?
9:" «. éa.«i":;5s5:fi§.HARA NAIKA
AND DEGREE DTED 30.5.2002 PASSED {N
V' "€SR,'i.;3N.), CHITRADURGA, ALLOWING THE APPEAL AND SETTING
_' AS¥DE THE JUDGMENT AN}? DEGREE DATED 22.3.91 PASSED
O.S.NO.2}2/85 ON THE FILE OF' THE PRL. MUNSIFF,
«GHITRABURGA.
3 ONKARA NAIKA S/0 LATE SAMYA:i'€AIK2=.. A
AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS 7 A .1
F:'/() DQDDIGANAL MEEDIKEREPURA.
CHETRADURGA TALUK V
AND DIST
4 vzsmw s/0 LATE smm NAI_{~_:_A=,_
AGED mom 3': YEAz2sV_ 'A
R/O DODDIGANAL MED;:4Ea:EP:--.;gA~--.._'ȴV% _
CHITRADURGATALUK
AND ms'? V v
5 KUMAR S/-:2-' 1¢':TE'SA3_dYA i'€'A§KAA ' 'V
AGED A3013'? 3?¥,.Y'_EARB_ . .
R/0 ii)OI;3DI{_3ANAL"MEDifr':ER!§EfEIR.A
<:H1TRADug(3.r:'.{;fALLI;(- ~-
aNLs'D'is':1j:,
6 KAMALA NAIKJA .$'/'O {.A?E SAMYA NAIKA
AGEDAB€)U'{' 28"'.{EAFf'$_
R10 D1D'£::f§ANAL 'MEDKKIEEEEPLIRA
CHI_'}."RADURGA TALUK
AND 1313;' "
' $,!O"!,ATE«.8AMYA NAJKA
.;A.<3E.I;"z2..13oLm:_.23 YEARS
--A we nazmsmuan ME{)IKEREPURA
-(;'.HITF3ADURGA TALUK
A'ND"--§}ISE' RESPONDENTS
TTHISNAPPEAL IS FILED U/S109 CFC AGAINST THE
:2.A_n'<:».22/91 an THE FILE OF' THE 1 mm… CIVIL JUDGE
J:
This Appeal on-mizig on f0rI1r,ari1_1g,.t,_}_1is .( ‘£”m I”!:
dcliveted the fuilowing :
This appeal is filed by the Lt§;.:~.éV§1§§.-2’iJA2/35.
The tria} Court by its jud5g¥:{{:*.1t’ s.«~;1:1d;;_ 1.991
deemed the suit in »favour .n.-f V defendants
Claiming to bc the First
Appellate Appcllat-1*, {‘§4:n.n”t
by its the appeai and
set aside 1V!x;”{;.:¢:j,-V’ damd 22.3.1993. The
plaintiff V fl_f3I’.’.’!’€’:i”{’51″1′,V.vC1aE?!j.’.lll”iL’!Aig be aggrieved by the SHIBC is
bcfoIE’-‘:f}’iis:_€:o1z.1jt in {}.ii§”af:pe,£%}.
2 are referred to in the: same rank as
V zassigiéd befbm the trial Court: far the putrpose of
‘and clarity.
T ” The brief facts irading to the case are that the
was hcfom the trial Court setéking for a judgment
15
the: proptrriy bckmging tn the piaintifil The: ca.3gé””§f A’
defendants is that they have pInt*:hasar} the .Iv)(-;$é::::t’i1}g 3
Sy.N<1-.22/3 nmasuring 4 891133 tmde1fis=: It;gi'fi~€£3i'tEt'}' SL63}1€§"§i'3;€:iV1' V'
dated 8.3.1965 from mac Sri RTu_d_mp}pa."'–..The _;i'a:f§§uaan'ts§"'- 1'
fl)C"l'Cfi')I'€: Cfllltfllld that they are in 'vfmfimmqhii. .ai.1'ir! .£tnjdy:nc11t
of the land, which has them and
flZl6I"Ef0'I'B the pIaif:1.fi'-'r3;.' fdrfgfzy against the
deftmdants. Tfic '§30fight for dismissal of
the suit.
4. ‘t:riavl v flflft rival eontgantions gmt
forth before ithzaa fi:s22I1i1»:%xi.= many as mven iSSl.I£’:S§ for its
_ VCOIlS’I1’E_’§¥:.”afi(i13, wh’iar:hV read as izcztztinder:
= & V the pmve thai he is the
‘ V « and 20 guntas of land beatmg
3 of Madakcrepuia?
Vtfilm plaintiff pmw that he’; was cultivating thr:
x ‘T efltizfi auit land o1}:he.*: date. 0f the suit?
:-
I’!
‘ ‘~ ‘ T,ing”ti’1e sI_:itV’iK?ifAhout oonsiciering the admisaion
d£:.fenda:nts being aggrieved by the same filed ;__ A4
appeal in R.A.N::s.22/91. The F’iT8t€;1fv::
rt:–app1*e(:iat:ing the evidence and i ‘.
submitted by the (.?»avn1misai9nc’r favas&V’o_%
ilamilar as 2314: Gaye put fart}; by’ sgach
reveraed the fillding of the: Jjjtfféai ‘g)Iaintfivf%t}i;:Iz2f0re
is hflfblfi this
6. This Cami”: flif: aplmal on 2 1 $3.200?
flamed thti ::fi.;g-}3i.Ib.’$éi,f:i’j?Vt”!’*.i’_ie’13′”‘i’1ijiEV5fifi133 of law, which
read as heir:-f:::;de;:_ VV % H
“L Wh;§i’h;érvvtt;é mart’ bfibw is juatified in reversing
judgrnrnit deéree passed by the trial court
‘ ‘1;2a;d3_i§§r defendant in his evidence as DW. 1?
‘ ‘ Whaffiéfiizhe lower appeilate cuurt is wrong in not
cénsidgriflg the evidence: of the court commissioner
AA and i316 report givfir: by the court commissioner and
, pfiigitting to consider ihe same aiong with other
i
etfidenca on record?”
the mattsr is mu al-(mg with the document at ‘ *
extant mentioned in the body wnuld »t!1e_
cf 7 acre-.. 3 27 guntzas of the Vfifldffi’ of tie: ag§p’.ii’~afit, :ia;.n 1j_’
area of 1 acre 5 gunfas of land” is mtiie
said smvey number, the elfifiiyfiicilt of
the actual cxtent af the ownVgf:;’V extent of
3 aczims 32 guntays said basis, the
boundaries whereby rim
€’.I}tiI’c cxt¢iif.”i3 This aspect
of the naaiiimrl _w#u.1dcrstx)od also by noticing
the onnizentiofiflf film d__efé,~nsti:aii.ts.
” Even a”a.3_1iii1ing for as mument that under the sale
t’x}j4e:.«_.’¢:3<'tt3I1t'" 'é:s:<3111(i'n1g kharab land, 7 acres 27
and $iIflC.13 hallnriaries iilclmirz icharab
' in defendants cannot lay claim to the mid
in the said stnvey number as admitftadly the _
V' under Ex.DI have purchased 4 aux':-,3 in
22/ 3 to which boundary is also indicated 3¢::cx)flii11g}y.
é.
Sy’.N{>.22f3 Whirih belong to them, the cam put
plaintiff that he is culiivatittg the extent of 8 Vvgiiiftns
as indicated in the schedule to the ;;1aint..3n;as* 1′
fl1ct3’ialC’.ourt.
1 1. In additinn in the eVi(iPJ_]R(x”:V_iiVi}i(fi},_I”15i§”IVV
by the plaintiff bcfnrrc the; trial {:’~:)_3L1si(i.§°.i”i:1gA the
parties’ , had iiofation of the land,
mam ware oontgntiing that
‘the e.asmi5L:.« ‘bo11i1d:§zi*§ and flmwbm the said
‘Kaila’ amags. _1Vafi:3_»’ hémeen the p}ai:.1tifi’ and the
” ‘d;2’&Ilfi§;3lLS,L. the B1izii’£’431:rt had appointed Stxlveyor as the
-V Cuxgimiatsiézner. The Clmrrt. Colnmissioncr has
suhmittbd and the report as per Exilafi? and (T8.
By t11c ‘szaii§¢Vs.’l§étch, the Court Fazrmmissioner has indficatmi
‘ffgaf fl1§ défcndmats have enclnaczhcd 8 jpartion of the land
..}jj.e1’5¢;-‘§g’;:’1Ag tn the plainufr. It is afim’ mtacing this asgmet of
“-.:fiié”Tmattcr and ctwnsidering the report submittcd by the
Cfifllt Commissioncr along with other evifienae which was
J,
-‘3
1?
judgment dated 22.3.1991 in O.S.No.212/85 gmsfféfii ‘ ~
Prl. Munsiff, (‘.5hit;rau:i1.mga is fl’3Sf1′.7′:i”t’td»._ &T1’_§§ :31 ._i_.:;
acreuifitingly allowed. New 01:33:’ as ten T *