High Court Karnataka High Court

South India Cements Limited vs Apellate Authority on 23 December, 2010

Karnataka High Court
South India Cements Limited vs Apellate Authority on 23 December, 2010
Author: Ram Mohan Reddy

fi*§’§’E§E mag fiazim’ GE’ i’-:-,_:;:»: 3?
a.a*§’m @333 mg 23% my 3? mgazgmmg e%.i2;§§:: _*~.__

EE§*$E?i§?

ESE’ Em § JUETZQE §a;3g,§tg£s:§§;2§’2§%;é§:=?é§* _

i. mmfi §$¥Z3§5., mmrrfi L1?§§rE§ ‘ f:
KAVEG ITS REGr’:$’Sf§’E-EE;B”a$3§?’E”I€§;¥’; AT 2%’;-2,’-‘
am ma R$A.§<,..;C:'I?.&E§{aRRJP.1§:?f%, =_
3mm;I..aRE~ 55$ £323 , a.-.;1.é3§:2
%1?§*'ICE XI' 3539, &~3-$53'; 3;;€;3;,,§5";'~§::3?zé;:z;%.:2%L€;;&12
amwmg Ez3§3A{3::3*I:2g 533 $32

9'

RE? E¥}5:I*:*1§-é:fi3:$§5'%*:*aE13- IF?'-"£._s'iE§:§8 – T-

”” ” §ETI’fIGE’EE..

:53: 8r§i;;–.;§ §a4gsa§Air;;§s§§§;’§;:§%s*,i3 ‘

, é L .» -5.§ P1i%;:.m*:9E”A§?fi:::arm

– flmzrgriaiaiz & ymficm

» ._R§€’;€3§¥S5:’RI}€TIG§; 1%’:-z ywag,
. azymamgg

A. ._m.A %;fis.3:.:gm§.. HI
X gm; .;’J3§§:L§éII- 13% $5:

A aéfigfi mg mfismm $5

“£”§-{E $E’:CEE’£%&W m TEE 3% ‘

~ : RE”‘C€}EI¥:§TRi§CTi{§§”, ‘ifffizfi fi§i&”s?A3§¥,

, *:qa 2; ‘”£”$§,$§’$:~f
A35??? 33213:» :25 $32

332 mm $33352’. :3 3E? “‘§EEE$*i1
$

3%
§{;’:%JE #2. -‘ $1’ 6? 2*: .

Sflszifififi,

Eafififiififigié K&R5!§£;§i’:%.¥_fis::– éfifiés 2:%€Zs 3.

.- _ =:.

$?’ Q€}§§§ER€.°i§%L ‘§1%§$$

fix 3?, E’;

M

§E?fi,,Ki”%Z%§§’£’ GE’ Gfififiéfififiifié ‘§’&XE%,

:mm%%§wmma
§mgmm&
~fifiw§%swag Q?’ §’§::V..:4.19,j:_§’:3é;7%5$?E:3 K?’

&.??Efia2L- 1-e:::2, zgsgag ?R{.’.:né;:cE§ as .__a.m§i;…é ARE
mxsagfigmxy 32:15 As;_m:E«VA*:*§’m.;§§:a&gR §afs:$E’%§ E?’ “FEE
EWR am 23,3439 3%”‘~3;i.§_§;&E:j_g%$5′ Rgzmwa yaamm
SE’ A smg $1? 123.13% ‘;.&;:3._sLi§f;*j§iE):».§, .

5533 1’ ‘ ‘ ‘€§.}5*i1%%5;£=§f锑 mg mg

fl §; *1″:-13:3 ‘s’§;”a?; fr§:.§”‘s&:;E*r ymfi TEE mamwma:

. g.H§EEER

_ .’§%a€e §;a_§:1:;.§5§:i5§§i1’été5″ the ggsifianw -« fiamjaany hafi

‘aha sawrafi G%’fi3i’§Z$§§ tzzzéw the

m§&’fiia af ham’ revimfi £3 Ehfi péffiseedm” s

1 Efiéafifiiffififififig

ffli’ §.fiéE.%..%'{:f:’§fi§ mé

Séiék kémsmfai finmgmiw fifipfimiai F%m;:’,&i=:ms§

V’ “~:Lf’ffié§;’*~«_¢§§$fi. m &at vime” sf tha mafia-*, tfifi Bearé fur

iigflusfiiai mi Fimanaia}. Rac$z13§’2.1cfim1§ ‘Q1! ardfir égatw.

V wéflgfiéfiflfiéi fiimgtaé; ‘aha §6m?€3E§m%’ ta gm; R33 cmrw ta tfiai

tawarfig gm”: gaymmt af ?£$;r

QM

Qammwwlal Tax -‘::- 2

. ~. _

Gutsiafiéing ézzm 3:’ Ea.§§§§¥§§,%3§§§– as gm fiEifi«’E–.’«._3fi$§5>

Efifii aréx whm sarfifi £3 fipgmé E%E&1.3§;§fi?§*§:. ‘L{2$;§fvv@r§

fi.£:2£&§2E3i§}§ tha Aygaiiatfi fim”:§e:,:£i€.§? far

Einmmi Remn£t2*:m§§m,, Raw keg

erziw fiatm }4.$§s3§i§: §§%:§e;§h:i§

i Kemmg ragwé ta 1:fiiaV:VV.iz:.§i§1a:i?,a§E@ the V

petifiama? ciafms is §a fgagamgééfig sfzézzié; §e”:?Ve§i1mé, as
gxcgyfiafi gm he takém :§flé{§%:.¥i_j&j:;§ E43? iha Efifi 2’3
iia axéfi azmzrezs ta; {ha
¢§mmw*¥i£:¢.i” agaimt a zeta} flaw sf’

P;s§§,:.i§1$;§£§%§§¢«..§$.ms.. S”§..e.§3§:é$$§. Sgqumfiafiy, the gym

impug§%a:i_ ami — j;::-:;. fig ardw 5%’

the ii”-3£”.%?”fAR gézafigzét’ fig xfazziitagi with; fititiazz ig as¢a3:éi.@§

53/5
Indfié