High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri Armugam vs Smt J Manjula on 12 August, 2008

Karnataka High Court
Sri Armugam vs Smt J Manjula on 12 August, 2008
Author: Subhash B.Adi

IOURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT,OF_;KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA EIGH COURT

3»: fifi 2-gm izmm :2? :m§m*§e.3<:A M 3ARea:J£::§OEO%OO%Okk«A O

mg :2'??? ma' 3;? m3*{}{3'S'E' _ A lfjj O

BE»???-3%

E~{%£%E¥'B£E MR,JUS'i"§CE:' sfs:3B§i;:a§sz~1 3 a.O.r::1";_»O

–*-s:ar~r Oz. 5, m fif 3%

EE5§”%5EEI’i’:-

gm gimfi; =T§%§’v’E§3fi$§?AIg§’§,'”
g§m.,a::*:’m w $*:*;;’:£5E 37$’
&%{ ; E§~:,;a.§c.§-1;; K % % _ _ O
i..”:’.’:E~%’fi%{§.§;§.£§§ fififl? RE; SEQEEF.’ __
Q? rgamyfifiafim, – % A
E-§:$;fi;’%i’A}?%.fik.’§-§&E..«£.§ E_X”I”E»1’%”$§£}H 3

‘ ~

amrmmaafig

. § .P’E~’§mGNER

gm’ $2: 2-: 2: RACE; Amag

4″ O 5 ; séfssfii %3%O’§§$A»%§g§z:§’?§g;§
#55 Gféfifi

;%a:;:*::}”:-:%:: we ‘2~’%.Té’~;RS§

‘&5.§::§:a§¢§*§O :3? fizamyagamfia,

E. ;i?é§;%T§$§§.?i%3§a§¢LE EX”FE=I’3$i§}f¥ ,

% EHT

iOURT OF XARNATAKA I-i|GH COURIOHKARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA “HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT

§’i”‘é’f_’i;:*,?,’=*s.’f;. émamlia 7

. O O ff1§*sa;.’.ifit;°i”§;,%?3,”:15,.:**:g’: {‘..”3a:§=:$baz* mm; s

EEY Eiéfigfifiéfififi &,&SS’TS.3 fiDVs,g§

mam: mm $353,392? Rg’_§§iV .$Efi.é43§”{3VE..§3.CQ
gas’ ‘mg §%;:w*:K:;a?§ ma 1% ?§;’I’I’§.’*£G:t€EEA§P§’fi7xYfl¥_£’}._’I”I~I;#gT 5
‘§’i4~§$ §éz3§%””%L§”; mum my BE Ff;;EA&:E§}_”‘i”Q= 32;? $313-e;«%%
Gmnm 2;: ::mayON9,5;:.??% mam}

A
E$,%Z%;E_x?:}$ $.,,:%a*::x §€%;’:§;S”‘TQ§E firm 3§;a¢:§§s:mI “QF”FR*§3s
a:;:-@::1%&e%;:_2g%~g§§1*a§§%O 1% QR.§gfi3€:.z§@.m:3;xzt;a §a:§§;§Om.12Um.

pvsstfimfi £fl day? fim

Ci:;~11:*’%:E3$s;iE aha: fsailswirzgrv

rg*j:%%§::?a?§$;€iié’?:%:%E:%::iAw.f_a§&ir;;§.’%.’ ‘aha éfiffifif passefi $111

»&.as. ..

$E'”L§s–§?§%fi..E*§fi.§Eé4§§{§ 2335 an the fike
mi” ¢,;:%§«=*::§ in rmg? z~:a.5;2§9? an

;::§f %3§,.£.zr’z$ §..¥*:.3.ég&§ $ m fiaifi

rwgaundramifwfia fiiafi & under

makxaazmnm, aflging

am §fi’§§.$is:’:z1’i¢f atafim. Iimawing mfi tamum” ma

1t”%}%E$fi§§.?, am? aaughi 2&2″ fiéusrm mt’, anfi fix vim of

éjrra

ZOURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURTA.OF’_;KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNAMKA HIGH $URT OF KARNARKA MGR COURT

this mg: gmmci ta liva sewats in an gem mug¢;

‘£}1i.a: Em: gefiiianm gnaw ‘mt my O’ O

R&2§.§3~<%§– m.$ ' Ea terms af mi

f35.l2r2Q€i§:."2, ffiéi Fefimmy

max" ::%:£:I'2&§fa:i:e mfi 'I:&%P£ar $5

aha r*$s1m:'1:."§:::§:.*§. has Ea aiwf

3; maid "5{'§'i.II"r:}-*"§§-:,a11i:i*3.:–':2.V~': by me
23$: sefiately anti
3%; we 33:13 :3 mt 3.:3.t.iti=e£3. fer

éfixufifi.

gm: hermif $a,E3.5&€i as Fwd.

:{V’vO?=sm1%.%£:»n1£:%. e:e.:%*@:f1 as 3%»: and has: BEG
__O§:z:;v..:a4x:é1O:i;*2.e::i KW-1%. nm Emfil ‘in P4

as: REQ wwc xmrkw Em. wéfimw.

‘§%% ‘E1-‘£31 Camrt mnaicisrirg the svidcrzcc gave

tfia figazzdfixg fimi the rm-pfimiaesxzt is Iaaéim afixfltmus He

aw §a$§m*§.¢:’:t 33$ mt figgaitlad far izaagmitcnanm ifl mm

2%’;

I __..

IOURT OF XARNATAKA HIGH COUR’lK’,0F4’_;KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT

” O._§¥§’€i€..%2e:>:i2i?:; ‘:?.i:t.VwFéii§? ifit himalf >

:35 mc,12:3{%;§ :21?” C:*.?.C~$ Againsfi 121% rejaatian 0?

a§p.§%:3«&”;§Q3?1}= am mgaxfim: am 5:33 F F

fiwsészna Qézxégvm ‘}.”h;5

<:r1.R£: mam that the afiuiifizjs fig}

m::§?'£;a*§'}* inamnae amwt mx1s1:.i"a.:;1::é:F'a*V V m7fin–
am awazfifirasfii maanmémmw' 1' the
ressspwssfiexziz fiam the é:za%fi sf and aha
fifimzfi iésrs in rmfiee in
time Ezmmzt-2 sum fa

Esaflg' – §%:a14':gz*g€:e.:it%1 .§'t$§.¢fi£:$.

 _    a§§  far 113% yetitiaw
 2  a§ the afiagafian mi" aduhmjyg

as KW-1 but aka

 

V%:a\.<§v.:4.Fg}1't::e:* as aw»: mfi she in the mm-ae $5
figs afiamfi that '[213 rwpmficnt is lwding an
fie aka 131% an Exfifl 139 point nut 'that,

;:"£%§<:;fw?L$nit has signafi 'ck cam éhmi eaf as. kmpitai ta

{hag {$13 xmgmnéent haaé mken cane Sarah agaiztmt

xfaaréwmz afigyagtima $3" aauitcfii 33$ mafia, He alas relied on

.Uu:<I U? KARNATAKA HIGR COUR'{.GFf KARNATAKA I-RGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HGH CO|.RT O!' KARNATAKA 1-ilGHCOURT OF KARNAWLKA HG?! COUR1

axamizmizéaéig 3&1: has: aém 2:221"?

that she: "

Emmi: Umaesh amé aha Ema that j,

«_.a’

af thé ?%’?:*%?~:3′.;:::::m’*

axyfi $113 p:a’§.?m7m;:§:§?gii~*””§:3$fi._t6 J

fw: lmmh. and dkmar. Sim ms aka adfiziftfid ‘V

an wifiich £5
azésewz? aaézi fiuzwh no
:me wag ‘£:E’2mw in gig; mfi aha has
s»%$K.d sax: aszmmzt s_’i<;f" that Whfifi
Eurméz *§v*$.$ k"££hen,, his Q
wag ..§;'§*.$'§.3l'€iIg in wt fail an the
i . g as't»:"2*s=*sr:~":_§ %?ite_:s_:g imapéial and ha died cf
ifiaggfziu far aa am mfianes sf KW-2
is %}::n~gm ms:-.2 mam an anmzim of

zmthar, 'fiat. $1 the crraaa-«

~. 5455 aim 32%. :3 am am who had

V éwgicesgg mmrfi abcsm fig rasgsndemt ax rward

{, .. A :m§at7%mm§p fiammx the rwwfisent and um

f f aamasm

ZOHRT OF KARNATAKA I-I£GH COURT_OF_:KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNAMKA HIGH COURT CF KAINATAKA I-IGH COURT

.V 1%; ;§;'i&:#};' – : : — ' —

3, ii is mtsa. ia déapaiéfi aha: aftar the dmth ”

:%&.ug§a:’ém*_,, ‘fiat wag mm difiamanxzm 3 V

mfizévgmaz «a né; fim rwgmnfiem The

pz’$a:,1{:&»d Eaxfiiig wlfliah ahrzws that ‘anew V

Efrme saparam E-“éxbjamtt M mnfiikm
pay 2% mmaamm. ‘§’}°m mg dams
mt gsmvfi éthfi are
memismdg baa: thg asked him
aaugmy m the ma Sureah,
ibis mmms Ila fig him? tha yetitiarm
Ezimsnaifii” fm mike mate :3? the
2 fidmitmdgx, gatitéana has
:2.§.*c ‘z:*.a*_2_a’.A–,§j.:;&” aariim tr: the fifing sf the pefifimn

1%@g;?zh%a’r:s§g:¢::;i¢§:%;§q:;:i;¢.e2 $w&2§ 31′ mars. if that is ac,

mm agmwnt 53: aeparafimn 51%.

::~ it has mm in me. aviamm sf

€§% wfiitimzm wantafi; m haw a fiimrca from the
311$ in am z%§§ tiame Wsra sarimas quarrefia

the r:3%:§w:’2dam:i startcfi iivizg aaparately.

-v\