High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri B T Dinesh S/O Thimmappa Gowda vs Sri Maqsood S/O Syed Mehaboob on 3 December, 2010

Karnataka High Court
Sri B T Dinesh S/O Thimmappa Gowda vs Sri Maqsood S/O Syed Mehaboob on 3 December, 2010
Author: B.Sreenivase Gowda

1

3%” Tffi Efifirfi §§§§RT Q? §{£R3.’%A’E7Al% £51′ 8P:E€Gfi.L{GRE

mmm ms Tzm gm my $9 §m§;:a«%$R,«:2§:<Q

BEFQRE

"§"§~$ Eififé-'ELE 12m.g§$mgE A"

yes. FA N5. 15% ;2m§% (Mam;

u-»..ws=.,_.«..-.__..,.,».=..«-.«

afigaffimgsfl %
5; G mflmwfi Qcrwga
Aagwsgm
aim :~L§§ea1§f9;~.1?a:*:ss*r§;::<a:P§ga; mmis: %
%i§;?R 4% '

L"

5 . £?PESE£A%

:3? 322:1; 3 %§: *:”;’:ifi%§§§i=, ” ‘

1 , — fig: 3533335553

% 39:; gzrgzs-.;%,:§,;E;~:;g8@a§
§;§2i§<§.1§ 3% fi:§E
§§«'i"Ef"§?4f%i3EgREi, §.R,§'I3'EA '?§.§£f;3§§

" « $}:;;m§Q}:,%:3R Qwmcfr

&_I%§.?%:'+:E}§i}
$._§m§;§§. mfifiafiwgfima
fiifigaa 3? £35
A. §'::s:;§§as. 3&9; 23,;

mvmaagw
gawwfi :3? -_
Ea? K&«1*?.~§§~42fi2

‘ 3 QIETFEB fififiifi fi§$E.IR§§.£*f§E fifififiafi

fiaamzi fimagg am 21%; 133 131: FLQQR
.- aamasx, wkggamgfi

karma mum:

figvmaxw
Emsaggg 9? . .

1%. :§A~:m~g.4g52; j
RE?’ as? §£§’I3IfifiAI.,- mrmxzai?

RE$?fi§%”3E1?§”3 ‘
(mam: aa :3 ?w§&cm ma Eaaggg ~

2; & mwyeficg mswzqsm Wfffti 3:2: 3?: $2135 .-fig;

Czfifi B §

Mg 33,313 ms 3.’?’3{I} m:* ‘:~g§é’%_A.%3T
mnamm Aim Aimm SA’-‘SEE: i.$§@.2flEl?«§”Ez%$E§?} ‘:3
we 2% éfifiifififiré {>151 1’HE-v.,_FELE $§*..’r2:E ;s&.1:*:m;;.'” mm: ”

335.3992 AEE mar, €HE&A%La”Js_,LI’.§fR, ¥fi:.?_§E%;:’ Aiuowmar
Ti-IE emm ?ETI*:’Ea1>z’ Em %€}E§£?EE{éiA’f§C2§¥’&§D.–2§EEIWG*
Ezrmmagmm my {3éC2§_§f}?EEf;%j;?fi{tZs-E§.w .

T}-I18 swag; emgmfi; (51% 7s*.;?7x:a.f>€.*.s,:R$ wars B31′;
THE gags? 1fiE_;i..»fi{ERE§ wmg

% 53%] mt §;..§…r.fl.Z9fi..V…….fE.j..;.;75;¥i.V_:.:’;35.”VVV’
far azzhancamfint
af %€¥m §'<%§;E£§€}}i'1: fig ffifiunal.

" g§.grg;,;;gg agpm: is sgméttsa and with ma

; far {ha

:@k€Z'i 1:? far fine} disgmfiai.

'A 'J Em' $2: aaks af mritaaizianm, 'aim garéim am

hi§&f§;i""z"fid 'ca 33 fimy am ffiffifffié ta; fig ma ciaim gatitian

R hefara $13 'E':'i'mz.3:;a}.

3
%. ‘E”E1c fbzfiaef facts Qf 231$ cam:

€33 whczé ting c1aima.:’}.§;– ‘f”L:4s;§.%;-3,43

graseefing 3.5 a, yfiiien ridar in

metemjg-2&5 bémfi 92%; V

the mam mass: is: Kwgpg,

Jemilars, fiche firiver ef

regaimiifin Nc3..KA~.§::?a4¥%é-%$fi’7a5:[_fl”jgfiiizg izzé; Bash aad
ncgiigmzi magma? éiézsa mstarcyaiag
$5 a rfimzét, %ghgj%L[¢;a;.m;: E33236; he
gm é§g%”E.*i.:?.ia:z;jr;’- heifmzg Mam; %’3h1′}m@&1:3r
seeznézig ” 1′ éf Rsfi1agm,ma3,!¢, mg

Tribmaé. _ = aivfifdfifi» ‘ 3. Cfif§§€£’iSafi%1.’3; Qf

” fi;«:i<'§,3.;€§:;fiI*;'~ mm: 3.1: 9% §&8M

V' 3;" thaw fig nag fiiaputa

¢{¢e;:%1;r"£%§%:m1€7~" §f agsidem, nmiigamm azxd W 3f' the

:';ag$;_u;;aa';z= Lei" ihfi Qfafifiifi whisie, 12233 $11334' gasizzt aha:

' '~§:*i£&s far my mzasifisratimfi 32:} £135 wgaai :3:


"mzemer the mmgerisafimzz a.!.szarded___
Say the ffibunsel 1% just and :'ea§:a:z'ia2;}a_ §_:*..4_ T~.V_
dew it sail fist' anha–3'J.c$n3ss:3.t?" ' A

6. isfser hearim the

appmtizzg fer fig mrtieg aria

ma award 5:: the Trfi9un(a,1,_’_I A§fV-the %’

mmpensaxitm avémfiaad by ‘fiof’ju$t arm
raaganableg it $3.3 e:3;;._ _%;;h.c –i¢2:;§’:f ~ izénct it is

reguirgé ta ha A

._ __ E”-331$ austaéirzagé fiammimztefi
avacturé fibuza $371313 mags: Egg. The

i§ij,§.3§§’i§E$~ smgéaizfiévd $33: $13 siaimmt are evidant fifim

‘A VtZ;§’1e:VVxz–%;>f§:;E1+i:i:&”‘*;;’§r’€;ifié:a.£g Ex?-=5 39 Eexfi-1 attfia aghast

k E§§;’€.3wvE;VGi;–‘V.’g,3§$§;alB£féty efiriifiaais gxgmsig }{~m§z& E:2m.{3«4

afigggéfieé by cvrai avifiafica af the s t ané

5.’ ” qgmgr, xviig were

as. §§}i%-*1 and 3

iféfigeciively, ?’§’J’~2} iha éficmr Whfi {mated tbs

313%: h% $113,256 mag ihfiffi £3 af 2.5% ta

aim Eimfi ma 9% 2% the wash hwy,

5

8. Genglflering the naizxra <73? §.::3j_1.1.;'i* rm: §”a§&A%%§é.a.Aie5;23a;- am
Zhfiffl E ahis ham.

” imaiizafi % i§3§aiZifiI’1’£.’. fez’ 3.

parigé. Efifi Haapitai; Exs§ax1ip3.1.

i§;锑**;’iurati@:: af iraamifint, R$fi,@fi%,:’-

tbs Trifimmi §:axa=’a:*dg inaideszimi

€¥E}!Cf$§§”»fi§ ‘£’.,¥S:%IC}’1 ag afifimyancfig rzmxrizshmaszi wxfi

ggtexéiigjist ahamm is $2 the EQWEE’ fiififi azzfi ii is

£6 Em anhafimd. by mam: I’i2$g§,€}Q$,1-» and 2

k% m,1a,em{~ under ‘£11333 ham

&

E E; “§*h§ C§ t rciaim is E’:-fl an agricuitigristg

but me sama Em; rm: agmbiégfmé by §mfiu:ei’:@ :«

eiammaizizs, In the absrcntgs af prmf cf iuié;

jam: ma grape? ta: assess 11i$;”§§i*:C:::rmaé;.é a.’.;£ ‘-‘~:

pm? msmh. The rmizsrs sf i:1_§§;3;::*§éaxa suggasé

must have ham; under rmt”&iV’§af:1 t;*aae:.t3?:::e’i1¥: -1fuz7*»_&;§5rieé

9%’ 3 mazzéihs mé t_*Ir§;c%:*aefa¢:;,~g}§l””‘:§i} as is
awarfisfi tmvarés .31? Iaifi @
._ 3 dimbility gtatzed by the

pitififi

éeetsf tar; éisaamfsft arzfi

ma%LJ%A:%g,%3a§m.::t zindezga 3: his mare fife,

.__a3¢§a:3*§¢d his ‘rim Tfifiaznal tawarés ‘Essa

33$’ gust ané pmmr 313:’: tiara is 11$ scam

fm” é:§i§§n£fimnt mafia? thia head.

V’ ifi. ‘filfi

E3 ageé abaut 2″?’§’e3.m at 1313

V’ af aficificng 3.21:1 ‘aha muiéiigficr appéicabéé :3 his

aga gmzgga is 1?. 3:5 izmamfi is assasmfi at E$,$,%Qf~

Y

gm; Fwwfifi {ha aazzfm” v.;?h::’; tmagfifi Em siaimanfi 21%

gram gm: iherfi £3 diaabifity Q? 25% £9 tfza

‘£3% in 2213 Whfilfi may’ Tharxefasra, ‘£315: ct-€11

ins:-ama’ warm mat ta: Rs.§5,G%i:’ii”-i v:1:’.i’i£–, V’

x 1?; ma it is aawéaa

awgrdaé by ma ‘Eri’m3I1aL V’ _ V

M, as m5§srm;»- :31;%?e*€::1*§:%ft:i.._’§y é}§:&*’}E’r:’bu1″xai
mwaxds ‘future maéicél-fi§:;?%§:s;&t:5_:i£zA ‘y;k§;’_’t1’1v& lmvar side
anti it ia mj%[m%’%¢mWma by anmther
as.3,:;s§g mags 212523 heaé.

is entifiad far {ha

_ i¥::EEi;%fa%}.33.g cazfip$zf:s&.§.$n:=

gufihrksfi ~– %.4–£3§G$@
‘ __?m_;*3.’§:=;.:;d;?.?.;*::§.T§_e;x§%es » K$’§5,${)Gt
$3’ Efiflideiggzfi exmgmfifi » R$:§.§,{§9Q

$3 {g:;s3vLA{::*i!:mm$ éurim
.. ” up ptriaé ~= Egfiflfifi
£3 L~:’§35$ ef amaxiifiw » $123,333

» ‘ §},_ mm $3’ fzimre mcame A $353,333
” Fuiuw maaicai awmmg »- Rs.m;fiSG

mmmmmmmm durum:-nnuuasuu-m

mran ~ m%2;§§§as.§

mmuusw m m n m vuawsaewnauwnnurnnr

8
Efi. ficcaréimiyg 11% swag: is filfifixffisfi.

fifhsfi juéwaat 320% award d by {ha

maifiea ta ma mteni. mm. harm

clazmaat is enaitled fur a £:}§

m,2,m,ew;- as agaxmz km.

the Trihuzmi with aztemst §Ja; –«.€;*;V:*_:vv.¥:j1′”;:eVV&3€:Exifi’i;:a.’Vt1a::ed’VV

camperzsaiitm at §”1;§;t¢i’ 9f ciaim
petitien iii} the éatg af Ema ‘

3.’? ‘ ia fiiragteé is

szieyaagié ‘ahaxé:’§%”;§%f1£*«§'<.i%.§~.§:z;p:e::sa,'§<3:1 amcuili. mgether

fifiih iia*i_£E1ifi mcrmhg fmm fits fiatez sf

_ :*§::»%%}Z:§é*:L:~,:%f 3. £3a§2=:é} Eat' iffiis gzgdgzsnt.

' " 4:€fI.'.,*é=:;%..~sf' t§-3% € C%fi $$iB;§§Xi$&'§.i§fi§ '}'S% Q}?

isainéasted it; fixm fiemsit :2: $115 was Q?' s:

tiia. §2"fi§§Z'£§fiIfi&'€fi izcztarfigi ia fiffififfifi ta

in

'~§;;1g':E*I$.%.i$zLaEim§ Bmk; Sézhaduiad Bm1k;P%: Qfifie

"*;i§:* a perim as? 9 gcars rmawahié msmfi it: 3 ycam 321$

"With an aptfisn ta withfiraw ixziazfiizat pgxfiaéisafly.

§

Re amaant with przgmrzisnaia izztarggt is

fiffififefi is he ffiififififi if: favam smf ma

immadgfatsiy mar {ha damait»

§§. Ea mag? aa ta ::@$tg,_

3%