12 IN THE HIGH COURT OF' KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE WRIT PETITION NO38837~9O0~/20--QV§_f'C§M_;§§C) DATED THIS THE 9"' DAY OF FEBRUARY 2010_..__ BEFORE THE HONIBLE MR. JUSTICE AJIT J.GU3TVLJAi§:". '
BETWEEN :
1
SR} CHOWDESHWARI RICE’-}\{EE’L_L
&iNDUSTRIES _
NO_i8O es: 187, P. HQsAHAL;._.:.. _ ”
BELAG01,A.sR1RANQ’AJ?A’mA _
MANDYA D1s’:’R1c’:t5’7V1438.O ‘ ; _
BY ITS PARTNER C V SOMA-SHE’;KA_.R_ * . ‘
AGED ABOUT51 . – _ V
NANDiN~1».VRi-CF;._.’Mi1_I. ~
151″‘2;i3–..OMj; ROAEEJ. ‘
YLtI.I’m_R’Is{(.’)I3_1 ‘V _
PROPRn?:i’0R
K. GURLESWAMY
“AG*E,:) ABOUT 50 YRS
A. , sR:”I¥1A1.I.IKEsHwAI<A TRADERS
_ "<3/0 mm: GOWDA RICE MILL
= M. C. ROAD. KALLAI~£ALLI
MANDYA67 I 401.
BY ITS PROPRIETOR
K. ATHMANANDA
AGED ABOUT 47 YRS
U1
BSHWNAR AGRO INDUSTRIES
B. M. ROADJNDAVALU
MANDYA TALUK &’ DIS’FRIC”I’
BY ITS PROPRIEITOR
K. ATHMANANDA
AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS
SR1 SURESH BABU 81 SONS
NO. E05/1.8 BLOCK APEX/EC YARD
BAND! PALYA,MYSO RE
BY HS PROPRIETOR
S. SURESH BABU
AGED ABOUT 44 YRS
SR1 MAHADESHWARA TRADERS
NO298, OPP. APMC YARD’ ._ ” ”
NANJANGUD ROAD, T. NARASIPURA
MYSORE DISTRIC1′
BY ITS PROPRIETOP.’
V. PANDURANGA ._ j
AGED ABOUT 36 YRS
SR1 MA11A:>fi::§3_HwARA’*I>RAD:~:Rs
CHA.aaARAqAN’M_3AR–..RoAD ~. . ‘
T. :NARASI1?}URA,7’j.M'{SORE DISTRICT
BY?__I’lS_ PRQPQEIDR’ SURFJSH
AGED ABO UT
SRE KIf€v1AIx1A.N ‘:iRADi1\’.c:{ 3: co
4.05. K. R. E-.TREE’I’ –
.. NARASIPURA? .E\/IYSORE DISTRIICT’
-..B’Y 213:8 PROPERIEIOR P M NATARAJ
1′ A . W AGED AB(3!_UT 58 YRS
AESC’ .
SR1 FESHWARA TRADERS
‘MUNECIPAI; ROAD
A NARASIVPURA. MYSORE {)IS’l”RIC’E’
BY ITS PROPRIETOR Y CHANDRASI–IEKAR
AGED ABOUT 53 YRS
V’ “SR: NANJUNDESWARA RICE MILL
THAYOUR ‘1’ NARASIPURA POST
NANJANAGU D TALU K MYSORE DISTR.IC’I’
BY ITS PARTNER SR1 T N SRIKANTA SWAMY
AGED ABOUT 60 YRS
26
28
29
30
A
K A R EE\E’}’ERPRISE1S
YEDADORE AT & POST
T NARASEPURA EVIYSORE I)IS’I’RIC’I’
BY FIB PARTNER
R MOHAMMED SAMIULLA
AGED ABOUT 48 YRS
VINAYAKA RICE MILL
NANJANGUD MYSORE D1s’I’RIc’r!._
BY DB PARTN ER A M RAMAPPA
AGED ABOUT 45 YRS ‘ –
SRIKANTBBBWARA RICE MfLL~.._ ‘
opp TALUK OFFICE, _
T NARASIPURA MYSORE D;’s1’R1c*.1f _
BY ITS PRGPRIBTOR”. « ._ ~ 1 *
H NANJUNDASWAMY A
AGED ABoU”E>.76 YRS” . ‘
SR1 ‘ ”
c/0 sr;1KA:\:’P§;s1–_:wABA Rica MI_LL_ »
OPP :TB.LU§: OFFICE, ‘
‘1’ NARAS’1’PUR}”–§ My BORE’ D} :’5.TRl(?f’I’
BY ITS Pi2QPRIE’eTCR”»._A’
N RENUKAPBASADV ‘ _ ‘ ..
AGED ABOUT 4 1«YEAR’S_ ,-
SBDBAKAR R1′(?_EA}NDU’S”1’RIES
FVIYSORE ROAi3;’I’ERUMAKUDA1.U
~ «*3 NARAs1PURA,:y;ys0RB DISTRICT’
A – gyms VPROPRIEYFOR M S SUDHAKAR
v .. _VAGEDAB0Lé’1′ 50 ms
“-“.__si=z1’vifB.BRA’D’HADREsHwARA RICE Mm.
A V ‘vIVBK;AN_.ANADANAGAR.
NARA.BIPURA, MYSORE DIS’E’R£C’I’.
BY Bis PROPRIEYDOR H M NAGBBB
T AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS.
a:EJAKiI.AK’I’HER RICE 1NDUS’I’RIES
‘C. B HUNDIA5?1.124
T NARASIPURA, MYSOREC DISTRECT
BY ITS PROPRIETOR N AHMED ALI,
AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS,
33
34
35
36
37′
, 5, VII
B A RICE INDUSTRIES
YEDADORE,
T NARASIPURA IVEYSORE DIST’R1CT
BY ITS PROPRIETOR RIAZ AHMED.
AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS.
SR1 BHAGYALAKSHMI ENTERPRISES
C/O SR1 NANJUNDESHWARA S.AW
AND RECE MILL, COLLEGE ROAD.
‘1’ NARASIPURA. MYSORE DISTIRCT
BY lTS PROPRIEPOR M P SIDDAE{‘&JI}.« .
AGED 54 YEARS
NANJUNDESHWARA DRIERS
NO.7″6. INDUSTRIAL AREA, ._ ”
NANJANGUD. MYSORE D1S’1’1<2;(:'r.
BY 1'18 PARTNER C ESHWAR
AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS,
VINAYAKA RICE ml; A A
NO/77'. INDUSTRIAL AR,E;A_ ._ S
NANJANGUD.' MYSORE L£S'1'R1<.:*1f.V
BY ITS PAR'1'I\fE}R A M R.ON.Ap"PA' V.
MANJAAS AG pvl' LTD
C /O USHA PAR "Bc;.I»1,1N_O' AND
DRIERRICAE M£_LL.1_ '
;BM_BYE PASS' RO.AO, HUNSUR.
~ '5gMYSORE DI'S*1?R__1_Cf1f
— ;3Y:”1f:S’A’MAANGER RAJESH.
= .. _ AGED ABOUT 34 YEARS.
AASEQVKAFERADERS
‘ ‘ KOLLE.G_ALAv57144O
CHAMARAJANAGAR DISTRICT
BY 8 ASHOK
AGED ABOUT 32 YEARS
:3/i/S PARVA’1’H[‘I’RADERS
OPP LIONS COMMUNITY HALL.
KOLLEGALA, _CE-{AMARAJANAGAR
DISTIRCT, REP’ BY M MAHESH
AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS.
40
41
42
43
44
ml
P N VEZNKATEZSI-I
PADDY AND RICE DEALER
KOLLEGALA
C HAMARAYJANAGAR DISTRICT
BY ITS PROPRIETOR
P N VENKATESH
AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS
HARSHITHA TRADERS
HONDARABALU VILLAGE.
KOLLEGALA.
CHAMARAJANAGAR D1S’rR1c’1′
REP BY N SRIKANTASWAMY ._
AOED ABOUT 45 YEARS
SR1 LAKSHMI NARASIMHA frRADER__S”« _ _z
SOUTHERN EXTENSION. – _
KOLLEGALA,
CHAMARAJANAOAR Di’S’I’Ri’C’i”=.._ ‘ _
BY ITS PROPRIEiT)R
A B SRIDHARA SA1::<U=- ._
AGED 57 YEARS, "
SR1 VIJAYALAKSHMI=RICE§:MI’LL=__ A
BASTIPURJA ROAD, _
KQLLEO.AI;A,–«w.._» ._ * –
cH’A1vux_RAJEANAO.,AR.DO1AS’rE1c’r
REP BY A S VI.JAYIiND=RAKLJMAR
AGED ASO1 :1″ 69 YEARS
.» 9A P TRADESRSV _____
– BASTIPURA ROAD,
‘ v . KQI..i,EQA1_,A.
“CHAMA1%AgA,NAOAR DlS’i’RICT
._ A£.{RAM PASHA
.3 V ‘AGED ‘ABOUT 51 YEARS
‘.45
S..Ri” MAHADESHWARA RECE MILL
NGYT12, 7TH WARD, LIN(‘}ANAPURA.
” * =. KOLLLEOALA,
CHAMARAJANAGAR DISTRECT
A’ “REP BY C NANJUNDSWAMY
AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS,
SR1 PARVATHI TRADERS
C/O SR1 MAHADESHWARA RICE IVEILL
LINGANAPURA, KOLLEGALA.
47
48
49
CHAMARAJANAGAR DISIRECT
REP BY C SHIVAEVLALLU
AGED 34 YEARS.
LAKSHME TRADERS
C/ O BASAVESHWARA INDUSTRIES
KOLLEIGALA,
CHAMARAJANAGAR DISTRICT ._
REP BY K V SRINEVAS GUPTA
AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS.
SUMUKHA TRADERS .
CHEKKINDUWAD1, PALYA PO.S’I”;._
KOLLEGALA. ‘ ‘ _
CHAMARAJANAGARDISTRIACT _ ” –
REP BY UMASHAz\H~;AR_ ‘
AGED ABOUT 33 YEARS ._ 7
BHAGYALAKSHME – _ A
NO_3’7.mCRQS_S, . _
BAsAVEs§{w5ir<ANAGAPL, ko1j,EGA
REP BY RAi;HAPPAJ1¢_RA.iv'A- '_ A
AG.EDA.ABQU T733 «Y A
CHAMA,-RA,.3ANAc;–AR D1.S"I"RI{;'T_
CEIRANT RICE'. MILL _ ' ._
APMC ROAD. Ko'L.LEGA–LA,,.
(:HA1»1AR.AJA1~3.AG;AR _ms'1*R1cT
REP BY"-A R» KR;-s£~1;\_:A=..\
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS
V-.?.,SI-IIVU TRADERS "" "
' u , HQSA E-£A£\~?AGALLY. KOLLEGALA.
_ "CHAMARA1JANAGAR DiS'I'RIC'i'
._ BY" iTS~.PRQ'PRIE'1'OR SHIVASWAMY
'' A ' 'AGED'AB0'U'r 33 YEARS.
uPAI§VA'iV*I~I1 PARAMESHWARA TRADERS
N033. HOSABEED1, YADAKURIYA.
A 'A SATYAMANGALA POST, KOLLEGALA,
C; ANAGAR DISTRICT
'BY PARASHIVAMURTHY
AGED ABOUT 26 YEARS
SR1 GURU SA} RICE INDUSTRIES
HOSALLI CROSS, HU'E""I'i ROAD.
SINDHANUR-584 § 28
54
55
56
57
58
59
L9.
RAICI-IUR DISTRICT
BY ITS MANAGING PARTNER
C H BALARAM MU RTHY
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS
GOKUI. INDUSTRIES
TI-IIMIVLAPURPET, NEAR BRB COI.I.EGI:”,.
RAICHUR. BY ITS PARTNER A LAKSHMANA
AGED ABOUT 72 YEARS ..
SRI LAKSHMI RARASIII/II»IASWAII{nr
ENTERPRISES, NO.12«1–129/7′,
GOSHALA ROAD, RAICHUR ‘
BY ITS PROPRIEIOR VENKATESH
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS. ‘
RUSHPAGIRI RICE I,-NDUS’I’.RIES’j= _
P B NO. I86, B1′[‘TAG__OWDANAHAL1_,iA.V
GORUR ROAD.HASSANr573_2CiI} ‘ ”
BY ITS PROPRIEFOR _ ‘ I
D SwAR0OI:~I–:III\/IA:-:”‘ ~
AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS
ROOJA*I’RAO£RG__OOIyI–RAI\Iy’I_ I
.AP.MC YARD. 7’; ‘
H”ASSAI\Ig5’7:32O’I’Ib ._ I –
BY . I’i’S._ RIAORRIRIOII. N’A(}}3SH
AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS’
; SRI GURLI. BINNY RICE MILL
‘QOFP WARE H«O.U_$Ev. B M ROAD.
HAE3-SAN»5732OI
BY ITS. PR()PREE’1’OR
V ” ‘ {“T_;}AGA_D’ISP£
” «AG,’§’,I). .45. jrE,ARS.
I<I:I*I'UR~"TRADII\*G COMPANY
CHOUKEPEFE, DAVANAGERE
B"'{._.i"I'S PROPRIEITOR K JAYANNA
I' ' AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS,
SR1 LAXIVII RICE AND FLOUR MILLS
KEREI"IAI.I,I«577-4 IQSORAB TALUK
SHIMOGA DIST
BY ITS PARTNER
VENKATESH VAIKUNT KAEVEAT
AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS
61
82
63
64
D1
A0 13:) ABOUf1″’54 YEARS
40»
M/ S SANTHOSH TRADERS
C/O SANTHOSH RICE MILLS COMPOUND.
VEERAPURA»577301.
BHADRAVATHI TALUK SHIMOGA
BY ITS PROPRIETOR
P SUDHAKAR SE'{E’l’I’Y
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS, _
SANTOSH ENTERPRIESES
ANANDAPUR
SAGAR TALUK, SH} MOGA. » ‘ –
BY ms PARTNER ‘
SR1 T N SUBBA RAO
AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS.
SUPREME RICE aNDvs3’rRIEs g
CHIPLI»L.iNGADAHALI..i,?. ‘ ‘ ‘
SAGAR TALUK, SHIMC-GA’= A _ . =
BY ITS PAR1’–‘NE–R GIERISH ‘ ”
AGED AB:%_3U’:2s Y}E2ARS_ 4_
MoHAMM15;D_.wAsAD’u_i;:;A
NO..3,_DN».3″251,-I;;.__ _ ‘ ”
K;?\’I’HUN MANs%4:11. _
iNDIR._A1\EAG§’A.VR,_V * ‘ ._ ._ *
B}~L4xDE?;AV;3[.i’}~I{.45T?’?3QS}’— ,_
SI-I11′./E.(,)CiA. B'{I’1″SV’i”RC3.1?RJE’I'(_)R
MOHDS.’—.ASA,DU-LL!%._ ‘
. . PETITIONERS
Sri, Basavaraj, Adv.)
UN–.tO’Nv OF INDIA
BY ITS SECRETARY.
MIi”€IS7i7RY OF FOOD
E I CIVIL SUPPLIES AND
..CONSUI\/KER AFFAIRS.
KRISHI BHAVAN ,
NEW DELHI
THE STATE OF’ KAR§\EA'[‘AKA
BY .iTS SECRETARY,
DEPARTMENT’ OF’ FOOD 8:
I114
CIVIL SUPPLIES,
AND CONSUMER AFFAIRS.
VIKAS SOUDHA, BANGALORE
3 THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
DYA DI S’I”RI CT, MAN DYA
4 THE) DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
MYSORE DIS’I’R1C’I’. MYSORE
5 ‘I’HE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
CHAMARAJANAGAR DISTRICT.
CHAIVIARAJANAGAR
6 THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
SHIMOGA DISTRICT. SHIMOOA .
7 THE DEPUTY CoMI.£ISSIO:f_\IER. ~
HASSAN DISTRICT, HASSAi’~T_
8 THE :)EI>LI’1’f;'”~COMMISSIO3IE’R._’»._
DAVANAQVEREIDISTRICTI ‘ ‘I ”
I)AVAI\IA.CA.ERE’ ‘
9 ‘TIIE”IjEIéI;%T’Y C.7OIwIII2IISSI<3NE'R""
RAICIIIIR. DISTRI'cf1','IIRAI–CIIUR . . RESPONDENTS
{By Sri,II,.vD';'Nég'a1~.§}";»Rw COC for R1.
– . Sri’;N.ar’-erxdra Pfasad. HCGP for R2 to R4)
AL§I’E.SE wRIjfI’ I>ETITIOI\IS ARE FILED UNDER ARTICLES
226″AIID’2r2_7___ TIIE COI\ISTI’IUTION OF INDIA WITH A PRAYER
‘FO’DECLARE.._E%Y ISSUING A WRIT OR ORDER ‘I’HA’I.’ THERE IS
NO “I-AO\I_EI«I-EN’? RESTRICTIONS OF RICE AND PADDY FOR
_ T_TRARSpORfI’INO IT FROM ONE) PLACE TO ANOI’HB3R WI’1’HIN’I.’HE3
V STATE ARI) ALSO OU’ISiDE’. THE STATE. –
A. I -PIRESE WRIT PEZTITIONS COMING ON FOR ORDERS. TRIS
‘ BAY. THE COURT MADE THE FOLL(_)WING:
te’i”ms’.*— V’ ‘
ORDER
Mr.H.D.Nagaraj. learned CGC has
appearance for respondent No.1. Registry t4a.__’s11ow”i’
name.
2. Even though the ‘mati;e1-‘s ‘ for
preliminary hearing, with eo_{1i’s’er:1t–,.._»_the” are
taken up for final dispijsai. _ 7
3. All i.he.v_ieaif§1edizeouriaéelaiiiiinitffihat the subject
matter is W.P.N0s.i7723-
732/2008 “”” ‘V decided on
17.03.2008. — ~ F;Oi’}Q\./V»li’if1;£H5, ‘i:lfi:e’.feasoni11g stated therein,’
these writ petitioiis vaisoi-staind disposed of on the same
H ‘- :’4″.»Mf.’£”IV.L§);NVagaraj CGC and Sri.Narendra Prasad.
learnedéu are permitted to file memo of appearance
fourflweeks. ”
REESE