High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri D Nathmal vs Sri S K Ramesh on 27 October, 2010

Karnataka High Court
Sri D Nathmal vs Sri S K Ramesh on 27 October, 2010
Author: Huluvadi G.Ramesh
1
E5 'E"§"$ EHGEE Cfiffil' SF K&R§'€?xTfi%, ff? Efifififiifififi

EATEE3 ms TEE 23% my G? <f::m'-0533 

BEFQREL

flew §-zméaag hm. JUSTIQE gggmaafiz»  ~ 

cmmém apmax. gm. i£i%:%A?22 A<3§%§% %&  3  7
Bflfifififit V   A

SE at arammz. 
A€:'rEEAB§fiT§$¥'E§;.R%§   - 

maymma :2? ms. Kmgfimfi ?;a§sg».a2%:a'z:;
Et3fiRB,E'fl.§'f61;1$?.IL'?'1£§I'PE}"F *     

Bmgaiaafi ~ 53 '- _ 5 '   ._ 

REP BYSEIG 3g3.H;.aEEV&F§a,.."A "  1   ..,.a?PE:.mm*

  @?£"Isa;».¢s1zs.§:éfi&i¥Ei?;é:5:¢;é;§ 333%,;
am      

SR1 3 K     
$16.9 K%%fi£«.1.%§-:5?  '  
aam AE$%"f"I"'2§ fifiafiifg V.  
313.54; 2, ?&;¥:;1_*§E;a& iz;3,.52¥.eu._ 
mfimszfm mémferizfi 3.§am==1!i¥
 .2: 129%,     

 

" V  ' ..... V'
 ;B.é~.:;1;;ss:..:3m_-'~$:«'  gasmamzvr

    - .  m' 31% fififififfifi Efi E%'E§L¥}I%§

 ""§'§E§-2: éxziga is may :z;3,,:i?agé} atzrma mama 1% gm asmg

  .}'{}'I.'iVG££%"f E CR.L.A H€}.i363;'fifi GE" 'ZEE Ffl;E G15" EB {?I'3.'¥'
 F?:S'.?__'I7£!§;CK {SE$$IGH} JEIQGE Bfifififibfififi EYE? F°§C--§, BY I'£"S
" ._ "fifififii-3. §"I"..E1.3.§$ 332$ Qfififig TEE GRBEE Fésfifififi E;
E3;C£{{}';3§§#~5!§3; SK TEE Ffiafi QF 3fifiI 2§E3§&., & XXIV fifififil,
 i)'§Z26,§.85 £3? 'Tfifi E%1"fiIf§§m?I7'!§;ClCI.3'SED BE

  f -.c1::2:vm*2*m mg 'ms emmefi Fiifjfi. :35 33 Emmi

.~ Tfiifi § &}'.¢ :°;???§fi§¢ ¢i}E%€§ 31% Effifl E G TEES Ef§Y,
13$ Gfififif fi§LI'§fEREfi TEE F'§L§..efi°'§é"EG;

V



2
J U {I} § 55 E E? '? H
3% appeal % by 1&3 mmgiaizmi eim3Etr1§'§gV_ :'§i,'*i¢V ¢rdar

cf fiw City Faat Track Emsémsfis} éufige; 

a, pmea in Cr1.A.E€&.}.333/2€.'§}€s.__;iat:i:§ V""i§,;'€iZ¥£.2§$3

ciffimixasing fins mmpiaizgt mfi aéicigé   $§' ' J

wmaimian passad agsimt   V . 1
23 Awnrafing €:2z_.-- gm  " fivm .:.*-Qmzsazsfi was
pumhasirg paper  VA ?i.j1j'!:"3f"v:,:'v*,'{§§.;1:j':',;*zpf§g}'z'.:aaI"3.'EZ an creéit

bask and '£c1§&2.:f{;i3.   i£;s§%;1$.:¥ sight ahfiqsms

  sf the chmgum, it

was fiisfzé-e.:_2'ce}:;r&$d.. "'*«a:""§Em_ra 'me:w& aymxzgamafxis' an

I5.13§.§;£¥3§.l.  lfiai zmtizte, aizm the awusefi éié

  aémpxagnt cam is be fzzeé, The leamzfl

  zzrmxvm' ted the agcwd mid srdamaé

k %  to p§§r a»-.§,.n$':'.V'@§ Rs§:,2§,am;«,, £21. dsfazxit as aufibx' 3: re: 22

 ' 1: whi£h,, the amtxsaci. ymferfi an aygwi in

.'.A".Ci*3€!,i§p§£p&a1 §ia.13Q3;'2§fié mam 222:: my Em 'rm;;

T " :{. S§éIssi:::r1s} Jfidflez Eaflim City, which Qa ma m be  §

u by settirxg aside 'fig ardar :2? me Tria§ §£.'3'E.31"'£,. Being 

 

by the mm; the mmfiafimnt is baefme this Csurta

M



3. Z-Emmi.
4. It ayymg E wag alga a 

wtvz" em; gm gum' far §g.lg,83§233f-- azzfi  

wmé be pay mamthgv   AV

 finm 26g};2.§%§'3_§ 
few §1'13?&h"n$f1'{,$ and  ggfi    V83
sf mm, $2 amusaad :£¢iB'*~v$fi}E_«'A§f,:%* :§;#vva.&.$fiéfiV"%§f §$.8S,,233f-g
Furtkwr, it wig thc  Em fikfi
a mama in   ef the 'Triai Scum;

tbs awussfi. is  E§'.2i3,$®£--- by way cf pay

% tzrdm  }::e:"§'§&s paifi Rs,1,€3$,€fiG!~ mfi

tht.  219%: ix: dispuis. The hawm

paya§;§£e"   awuaed is §a¢8$;233_l- ma: ai'

 was mficuiatad as pw the tesrms. sf

 _ amiint éize: tiéw awusw, tbs 

 at, Eeitwean flw ffafiffiflfiu Far the haiazwa

:.1: 1% Eycfezac 2:E':§§

 

 {§m:::'f£,. 

5. 'fire Apmfiam Caurt Ema npinefi 'aha': thaws ascscugaé

  ikeras mam paymmt in fimmmmm, Eiawagar, an 2&§.20%,

the amcuaaezti m  akmt anfi did mat mkza  ta




4
'i'1m=ae:£ara, flag amuam wag stiii fixm in a sum as? R¥?s1.__$8,233£-g
im djud t an m*§:3:$§ Amrding ha  
pweefima adagtgad by tha  ' ' '

    

     

.-:'::-;-- $5; "  'rim

 

tram . jg     

Tk aylhte Caurz hm   jg'!  'A

aamptefi flaw: wmpramfia     
mm--.inm¢ aamgm. Ag gm' gm ms; af
ciefauit,     swam far
that the   Gaurt 7% mt zawmz.

  ggmg  R 

 

gdum  Vfigitfééhcn tmne Q. mma'c' mks 2% mmw

   it in fiwir haunflerz ézixty to mwctrha

 

 

mf35i?ii1i¢§:'.éf...':1?1e _* 1;: hefcra it Fer the  -:'  

 ass pa/2* tba E$i § $3: hm m+dem& as gay

 

   cef Ratmwmg-. ma exam' :3: gm  

'   in w  tha ammfi; by way af Ewafizg %

  %  rm ciaeiatzit mama   be fmmd fault with. Wilma

onmthe@:sad.has&§m15t'§$;_t1"wg111i1tandi:£aviz:gfa§&iz1

W'



5

mkiig pmmpt wzggmmig it was rm:  fear ézém

::nmp§.ama.Iz£' 'En ptmawé afimh mma again 

the same Fuiagfififiita whn hag paaaai an nrdés-'. §::f 

ta gmfih tha aacusafi far €51:     _ 

in the aimnmatanam,   
impugzeszi arder pasisggé   City; is
hereby set aside by   'aaf the  fi&t€, it
£3 far 1211: am§sgf:i.__m  '  'ématmt §ue.:. Thé
amm ta    mm which,
ha hm 2;'-Eel  fifim 'm fiéfid back
the mag  W   
   sax;
 .....