IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE
DATED THIS THE 27'?" DAY OF' NOVEMBER 2009
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. P.D. DINAKARAN. ~ E.
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUsTIcE;Aii:AI~I.p
WRIT A1>PEAL.No.4o1A:0_:«*'-2609 . «. "
Between V 4' h V V V E
Sri.I).Pillegowdzl. . .
Son of Latte I')0dd2m1:1a', ~ _
Aged 79 Y<~;%a11<?.. E J
Residing at Ij)2;11'g;3p141r'a ['K1_1v(:1i3}V)£;-i.;___{I1:1'
1 W'2.1rd. ET)0c,.§dab2i1"12;}:31,11151 'I'()'\'.x,'/~'.';1, _ V_ '
B&:LI']g2.1]()£'(". Ru:1'"aI " _ "-QJ'.v!\.I.'PEi.i.AN'I"
[By Sf:_1'i.St';1'1jI "K:-1':-rV1:1'21I»','4"A{i':«'£)(:s1-tee for Sh1'i..'I.'.SI'1csa1'1z'1gj1*i Ram.
AcIv()c21i.-<;* for /4\p})c'i1éfI.2'e1t.E]
"I. . ' S'1.;11,c: of »Pi211'"r1at.a1'~';a1.
~ ' D6})al'EI'I}t*.fIi« _(__)_f_I<'v.:f§*.é~ } .
2} V 'I.'£1j;fLé1_n'€1'['1*ib1m21I.
f3._()(%dz'{E32£1llapur laxlxzk,
~~E'321:1,1'c' Ruml 1"f)is§..1'i(r1..
R(;*}:)1'£"_'.'~SCIIEE'd by ils (.','.1z2:11'.1'':13a»-11e1.
'' _i3V. 5:311'.I\E2mjLn1d6:s\,=vz.:1':;-1.13;}:.
P. Nar1"j1.1nciappa .
6
Son of 1.2110. Pillzzll-122a.
Agepl a.};)m.z1 €53 'r'c:z11's.
Res 1 d i :3 a 1. 'f"§'1yagz-11'z»-1hja11'12.1;2;2.11'.
\-Vard a'\§o.2.. I.)<.)dclzaxballzmure--1 'I'c..)w:':.
Ba1T1ga}o1'e Ru 213$ Ii)is1:"i(..'t' .
4. Sri .'I'. K. i":'a11«;21r'-;l'I .
Son of DOC! c1a}<.a.z112.1pp:'1.
A;__i_ec.i z.1bnu1_ 48 Yc.=2;-11':s.
5. Srifl'. K. Su rcsI'1.
Son of £,211.e Docidakaiiuppzra.
Aged abmgi <16 Ye;-ms. *
6. Sr: fl'. K. R2.m'1€s1'1.
Son of La'1t<? Dodd 2,1 EiE1}I£1f}}")§:1.
Aged about 44 Ya"-11"$.
7. Sri.T.I{.Umesh. _
Son of 1,2111' I.)£1,V
Agecl zib0L,1I 42 Yc*z.{1*$. ' _ K i.
8. 5 ri fl'. K;vB';1121 ié1. f\c.id1'1i():1;.1l C}(')ve1"r11"z'1m1I P102-ider}
'v'é%'(.'/rit. Apperai 1'i1ec'1 unciez" S{3(?.E'.i()r1 4 of the
"'KA3:'1'1a.t.;.i}_«:é'1 }T§i;2;l"1 C<)1.11'1 /\.si.(:l¢.é t".!":e (,):"(,I<-.31"
in Ult' Writ. P<:£ii.ic')11 N0.E7538/2(}O€3 clalcdz
_ C.8§':12.2o08.
5
This \-'W1: Appa;-':11 (..*211'i11g on
this ciay, ANAND BYRAREDDY J., c!c*i1'\.-'e1"(*cf tho 2"(,1ii<.)_va:'_i_1"1g:w
JUDGMENT
He211’cI the C_?ou11s”Ii’au’1A1. ”
2. The 21;3p<?ll;:1.1';1'. was fi'}(;','. {.)e.i.i'(,i_<)i'1.c;§.1* l)e!"<'§v1j*_:{ 'i.i=:e' ie.211"1'1v<A:%(:i'-.V
Singie-2 JL1.dg;e. The pe1'iE'.ione1"'=hiict s<'):.1g:"h1'VE£) (}:,t€%1:§;1iVt5i'1 £"h€ V
o1"dc:1' of E.i'1c La1"1d 'i'1'ii:m.1}e,1I. (i'?_'i'E"{?(.T} "i'2. E97E5'.'"'I"1i0 i0z.1rned
Singicé Jzrclgv 1T1:»;1vir1g z1cic11'c?;f;'sct'§~.!1§'1:* i'e:1_&<"tL1~s"h.zi.e:. ci 1’h;1’£. the
2-1;,:>1:)ll::z’r”1i'”‘}2-sailing iii “§hé.fi’1-‘S1′ i:’1é’1″é’1’:1:~_<3 sm1;_{l"n'. for <')<":m.zpz.1nc\r
01' the tFi:;"lé1.;s in rf::~s§§1'":(%('*i_..§.ji3.nI" ;.1(.'rc.' E0 ;;§111'1t21s c.i2.0L'<?u;')2.111s;;:)<:<?1' of $116
'_ s21.:f'n£:. _a_1'11dV 1.11:"-EAi3;}:);Jt*i5';;11.'%E' scC§<i11g 30 c.1ue.<;Iinn the $E.1I'11\f1″42’_1″‘p.g?ti’gi()1T1 2’-‘tfit.-=1.’ 20 y(%a1’s_ was not. 11’1ai1’1′:.21iI’mb1(%
é:1′!:1Ci ~’1″1£”:5-.’€s t;1{¥¢«.’}1fGI£t’1ggi_y’ di:511’1i.ssse(i I”§”:t’ w1’ii pe1i11′.01’1.