High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri D V Venkatagiri S/O Shri … vs The State Of Karnataka on 10 June, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Sri D V Venkatagiri S/O Shri … vs The State Of Karnataka on 10 June, 2009
Author: N.K.Patil


W,» V “M-« ..

<:<;:?a*r:*3;~ ‘<5,-'"'::§z" '* s-:3; *"€€3é«.i,€}{~1E :3:

I
fiiik

1'55 YHE §-iifiii vT.}'G£:'R':' G? KAREIA ?"AKfi A T fififiiz'.-3ALC3RE
§:;~'{E'i=3iD TH§fS§ TEEE; EST}-E DA'? vi)?' »«JU%'€E,

EESQRE

:35 ;-:oa:*s:.£ 3&3. .3115 was ~.:<.P;§ri€;;;M f j} 3 j %

'».H.«*.p3~;0, 3544 0;' 20:19 4{a'}1%zZ'%'R;'.§f':;.

S Efifv' E E 23%

3% D 'sf V§{'~éie{ATA<'3§R% SfOS_£–§R1_VEE'4K}R'§§'\i3Z$';':€§ ._
:'§GE$ ABQU'? 52 "s'E$'~RS §'x§3fiCHA?i,, SEE §<}X§'v%¥'~§E5'$a_':51R}%.§u'*éS ER}
EPu\ifiSHA%'éF{ASi§ TE::"s;*':P'LE3 §<.r'?%:?'%§§t*iL§i.~:ii.§{ "
§'s%~§:"~'a'*4§Z'?%PL%RA HGELE Sf's€32§Fir§'.§,{t*§{ .. _

Si-éifvfflfifi. DETRECF ._ –. .

W)”

€83: S1; :3. ‘s<:!«*':::s:»~:.';».€.é;€i:§.-:..:___.m§~;l'~r4*;' "

1"'; gig ;'37§.%'§"E.,S§9'–.'r*~1':95!.RE%'.;;5-:f§°;'-'~é.C3,;. :’3#é§iGé&.GRE 536% am
” REP 3’f’:;%»;&E§ SEQRETARS’

Muh-

‘=?§~:’E”CQ§’s€2§r%%E3S{3F\3E¥i,
_ §}%?.§3!£§§€T?v§§?=§T Q;-“4” §%E’i§’«E$%.3 §–‘€§§.i<3§GL§$ f-\§'~é$

' _ "i}%%?3°~3éiTAS~¥.,';i §NBQ"crfia§f?ar'§£N?$;_ §:%..%..§ 'v'§§'~i§<LAT§"~. ERG
{§§'v3,fi§§&'Téi;RAJA?ET5 B:'32§'\EC%fi\L*CsRE 'E8

'1'? HE' §E:"5«'UT':" CQM§'€§§S8§Q§"4ER,
~ $§~§§5's'EG$R D§3Tf*2§f«T,;

” «$§w’§?i:’§G$:’%

V’ ‘.3 ma Asasemaé? <3QExe%§JEiSS£<3f'~£§R3

SAGRQ SSE $i'<.i|S§{3?*é?

SAGEKR,
iiééififiifiiisfix QESYRES?

{J3

WEE “%”§\§«%z’%S§LB§&R
Sfl<$:'%R T§Li.3K

~..t*~:.« ~-,'- ==.-: . '»'£ ,'.."."'
Eye "gig; 932%} i._.'f7.}§3.31T ii? :"\.ii;'iZ'«3}.; ?z§':?x R'? E"§§'~;'€<",;<-'3.'L,”” _. 2&3′?

EEK’ TEE. ERG}? SQLRT G? KA{§E*€.ikTn” I€§’x AT §3;”4.l’JG Eahfiilii. ‘v§'<P.; 1:1 3:-":ra-m" " sf 2&5?

9'?

ab.

SAGAR
S§%§%e1GG§ G§S’%”Rl'{2T

RE§3?€3?~i£éE£%§’1″S

ism rm v:sw2;ANA?H 5-RGA $0;-2 RESP’OMDE.”«iT€–3-“% are 5 , ”

ms arm, :3 was LENDER ARTSCLES 225 géésfa ‘*=’f ‘s”*’;4Ev.
€..a:-.*s1′:’:’:.;*n<:,~z-: <2? §%~£fl§A, PRA"*€§€'~%G TS amzgczr "FHE__Rfi.SPQ!_'=éDEf'u"%'S'TQ
aagasa "{'%~%£ EALANCE "£'A,$D%E< AM{}L¥NT 3:: RS.' 29?'%;i?;€fr«1;'»':'%€'«s'D A230 . _ "

CG;'\£S§B€§3Z PA"{{'=e'EENT C3'? R3: aaemi- g:€'::4éG-IHE'.4Am;'3:.;r:T._5s§~*2;:~:': ma
%"'u"r~!i"§"E waséa E§.ECTR:C:'{"{ am. as %..5_:_NE';E?af.*:?T £X?E,§'33E$L'~. , , .

was \:2.é.;"-3 cegame SN FOR PRE£&;4:ééAR'~: " I:4;–4:;<:"§;%;*;*–,.L

'§'?riE CGEJRF MA{Z3€ THE ¥GL§..fi" '§?~E{':i _V
:GR'9 ER:

“§’%”:augh this rraéiier i3″‘§éé{ e«i: ‘t§day ‘fér “Pre%iminary
Hearérzg, the matter’ isV_tf127’§-:ier’:’.”_i’,2§;°f:V’fc3:*..fi;*i$§-._%:*%sms2i, with the
€3$f”¥$éf}’ii czff E4eérhe¢*”«.Ac:£s1;:’fi3é{‘§ ._f2’§:§g§£;w3:9ér:§ far bath the
fiafiéég. ” 4’

_ 2. “3”~Er:é*;3§iZi%£§§ff:’é;’~.–“‘i’z/1 this gaetiiéen has sang??? §ar 3

~ . _ fa %é:e é*e:a§::§néeni§ ta reéease fine baiafice Tésdék

2,?8,354:*’- area aim} C5fi$§de’f’ §§3’§(Z’fié?”*2″£ af

Q3. being firm amoamé spam fa? whim wash;

AA eiecfrisify béii arid gundsy expefisesn

3. “Fae mi? grisvame 3? the pefitimraer in this

“fiaiiiiafi Es? gefifiafier has submifieé gaveraé deiaéied

/

23$ Efiflii i7€}U§%T <3?' EQAE3-*3'«3A'§¥'£I";' ES E-*s.L{}§3lE 'é-"\?.§\3<3. 35¢? =35 '§;€"}€}f§

{NEE EEESEE if-3{§R'f G§'K?s.R':€?1T2=%.K?L?~,.T BA}€Gi'<.LOE.Z.E. '€«'.?.}«§<3, 351$ Crf 2{?€§§'
.3-

feereeenieiiene is the reeeeraeeete efzd whee tee eeme

were net ceneidered, he wee eeeetreéeed ie iee;.£e,ie§ei

nefiee threugie hie eeuneei er: _,_:Vfi”:ge

Cemmieeiener, *r-iinciu Reiigéeee e_.z’.:+.r;3., j’f.Eeéewreent

A

Depeffmeet, Chemerejpet, 3erz§;eeiere~

ef

receipt of the repreeen%ef§'<§e:£;_V erie 'she iegeiieeiiee éeeeeae *

by the eefitierzer, E"eSpfifiéS¥_'3%Sv.__fi8Vé eeEh,erVAvf3;eneide§ed
:13? have taken ezéy?"eeeieéeié.VA?§e."'r§§-;§eeee tee ameuni to

which the ;:ve%:§%:'iener;_'%e":e:';%:Efie:i;'–.iVe 'view? ef the eireefieee

Eeeeee' 'e¥y-?%':i_e {ifei.:ri"é.2j" €%1e_"eé?§ier reurze ef i%fige€ien_ in
View {:5 ifieeiieeAfje:"i"%§f§e«.part ef {he reependeete Era net

eeeeédeiéeg reqiieef ef the petitioner, he was

.Veeeefr3e£§e:i._te ree%eee hie grievance befere ihie Gear: by

._egs5,_;y3 ihie writ eefifien, eeekieg eppregerieie

di%'eet§.ee,v ee eietecfi eupre.

95;. Afie? eevieg ieeerd ieereee’ eeueeei eeeeerieg fer’

AA”§ee’§t§eeer end Eeemed Aediiéeeeé Gevemmeeé: Adveeete

eepeefieg fer rwpeedeeie eed efier’ eerefeé eerueei ef the

/

3
K

‘§’§§Z- E3331’; <','{}Z}I-Eff £3-F 5'-._'"§ 3935513 '£1' 363% G? £3'?

Bx' TXIZZ EEEGK C ,9-'..3'§%.'§ <31' {§'&RNA'€AKA A'? EAEJG '?viP._}£e. .:§£'}~'34 {sf 2i}S'$é

-4»
materiai avaiiafizée cm rawrd, ii emerga that Qetiiianer

has subrnified sevemé f&pfESeffi3’f§Gfi$ arzd gist; igsueé

iegai natice thmugiw his C£T3U§”:$E§ viée An:1e>cur’rg,~»ie§;f«.§éied

8i8i2Q€}8′ But the same hag bean naiihar

any deciséefi has been taker: h ‘y”‘i%1e. f*a.§_

Keeping ‘the request ef fifie }::aet§*’i%%§{$r’;_e “:*’~_[i\:iT abiévfiafrfiaé éé§i€§–.,§€atVV

reieasifig fine amaurét as séqfiiéé fer?” ifziyi Ehé; ;527eff’§%5i’ér;:er

the rwprsnderfis is r:§::s*2>.,at 247:5″ ‘§héféfére, without
axpmsging any apinisAf1V_vér2VVE§i_e5» §f;’:e¥’~i’Té :i:’ij1::’*;~~§’erneré*ts ef this

casg;”if'”‘wei,i§d thé5-s_”t;’:b5ufi: ta éégpase 52% gm writ

@e€itiiééz’–3 firiffi riiiz-esstéans is ‘the respsndertts.

.. i%:£.$’*§% ;’é§5§z3g reascrss, fine WES? pafiiiafi flied

A?:§§,—- ‘:’p52é’§§%iéafi:Aer §r..~:«:v”3Efsp§sed 3?, with 3 déraciiafi is the

. 2″‘é;2;é0r%é~r.=;§f:%§§V-in” Cé::”3$i{:ie?{” tha ragmsenisfiafis and ‘me éegaé

mascej aaiefi aiszmaa issued by am pafiiiener fhraugh

Ahis-*:~,.f_ aéunseé Vida Ar:fiexure~§< anti is fake apprcafiriaié

° d'ééé$iQr: $1: :3(3E'¥":p§ia¥":£e 3% the fiireatiams igsued fay ibis

" Smart in fine &3f§§£Ef" raund as iifigaiém and éigpuge 9% firm

K:

i

HQ THEE E33323 C{,’)§f§”§T OE-T’ ‘é:?s§&«é§~.”§’?xE. 5%. 9-3′ g–§.’:,=f’}§{EZ ‘é=5.E~”£*££:. gt-f Z£}i3″:’

1%? HIE {£1611 €L’f.Z*J§3′.’E”‘ O17 A’? §’$A3’a’-‘€Zi ,;%l,€.”}fi. ‘%s’.P.E’J0, E234-4′; of 2%?

-‘C
..W,…

same, as expeditécusiy as paggihie, at any rats; _m§§i%§§n 3

geriafi 3% few: weeks fmm fifie date 9? reseigtnigxfv af

ih§$ Qréer.

Cfirdered 3C€:fi?'{3§fiQ§§f. 3 -I’ T

is???’

3&3 EEEGEI C=f,§{3§3,’§’ 53$? %Z?xE?..Z’véAT;1’u “‘ AT ‘£JP,§’«§c:. 5% ” ‘ 253%’