High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri Dase Gowda @ Chote Gowda vs State Of Karnataka on 25 September, 2008

Karnataka High Court
Sri Dase Gowda @ Chote Gowda vs State Of Karnataka on 25 September, 2008
Author: H.Billappa


§?a§ TEE §-iifii-=¥ {‘3§%.§R”‘¥’ §? §{§§?4A?A§{§, §.§;?\§Gfia§.$RE

mass ms THE 25?” mar ea: $§FTEmBEi%,2§55f3′ .

B§F3§§

THE HG%\i*B§.E ¥%!¥R..}U$”F§{3§”H.–E;%i.E’,§§,§;§e. I. A’

wag? @§”§”§”§”iGN r~sai;3::sf$;;%2%é@e7{‘«

EE’§'”¥’iE§§’&:

Sré Ease Gswéa @ Cho£e’TC&t_::wda*; ” _4 .

$59. Late Srfi Mszficie {§cwda., :’.’.$’§ 32:5, ajj 3 V

Ric, E23 %-éesahafii, §s.~*’*£a:”a§ava*.:.i.% E-érzézii

Eéanakapura ‘?aEz.:i<,_ '
fiangalore §urai,LF5'–qs¥;-.. _, fig'?-5'E;T"%TEQ§\§.E§

{By S%*§;_j§.3V'$é<ij*2:$%:§}e%2§;pra: V'éfif §e;:};Vy
am: % '

E, Ewe cf %{§s'?°%£a%<é'
Repgzay ifs Secretary,

V' . R$veriuea"%*.§e;$artme§t;' """ " A
.%'».I*%'.«$¢_8a3E_vi§§.2%:§,V
,__B"a§3§12%§e;fe~a-_53£'; €39" .

2} fi?§*:e $§;§§§é3;’ iitsmméasiarzer,
fiangaiczie P-Ema! fiistzict

. ‘_ ‘ V P$€3ié§§’f’¥ Skméé, Visveswaraéah fewerfi,
” V. ‘ §’.’ér,s’%m%é~3§z;$§° Seefihé
Safigaéare 55$ 39?.

3.; “fége fi.5$§3ia§’¥iCOi’?%fi?§$$§€§fi$¥
‘ ….§é’iama§’%a§a:’am Sasb-Qévésééng

Ramanagaramg
Eangaéage Riéffii fiat.

1/

4. $fi,Na:3gan R39 N%m&a§§<a§'
SEQ faic-'3 Srifiarnachandra Rae,
Aged S5 years.

5, Sré §<§%$hm§E Rec Ffimbafészagz
Sie, iafe Sri Ramacfiandra Rage,
gfiged 52 years' 1

4 & 5 ria. M43, 2" ma,

R,T.E*=§agar Pas:

G.?vJ%,?. ?\:’%a%a§a§:a§%§§
Bangaiere. %E$PC3§’~§§E§’~$’§’E;§

{Eye 3%. %’%E’E.Sa%%:yana£a§;fi.;€e _

fer respcndents T is 3. SrE’i’33ien§:a€ag;£ré.’-._
far £4 & R5}. ‘ . v *

This mi: EF’é;€:§%§’arz gs §EEe&”‘:asriff£9{z? ;éa:z;r~.§.e;~; 225 am 2:2? 0%’ film

$sr:$%§:a;sié®”: ‘af:i§ir:d%é:?~;5:*;a§¥’%m§-Ea g;;’asn” the 9:69: fiaiefi ‘$3-‘éa2{§{T3$
§::asseé.._by: gm $pea§
§%§e«$82f§7.3=_%;§é$ fi§?:aaxégr¢¢§5«–.ajé’§ai as it refiaéass Ea ihe peiéféaaer.

33%: ;°25és2%%i.§5e;_:f:.v::a§:*:§€%§ er: fa fireéiminarg Heafmg Er”: E’

V , V géfiisp g.a§%’1.~§§2& Cfiijfi mafia ihze feééawirzg:

fififigfi

..§fé»—iééiis Wit geiiiéerz amfier Ariécias 22$ and 22′? a? the

Q’ -,.$a-fisiéimiéén af Ergééa, téée getiiierzef flag saééed Er: Qii@S?§{3§”‘E the £.3€’§}§§’

__:§éiefi ‘§3-“§~2§{}§ waged by tha é<a§?:a%a§<a zigfiaeifatg ?s°§m;n$§

,5:.;§ea§ §'<is.882;"2§§3 vifié fi;:*§§'*;e:<a3re«{'}.

L/%

'H-4?

2. 3%; ‘She §i”¥§§§é§E’¥$§ ¢a”§e.:’ 3% fi:2rze>:a:%e–§”;,__§§”%le*’ _

Agaeiéaie iE§$é.§?°§a§ fies a§§ew@fi Ehe agyeai ffied %§.E§.’ré_:’:’:es§#é:ndes€t§. ., 2

4E 3:55 5 amf has set aside §§’%é: §E’fij>j$;.§’; §?8;£.’=f§é€;f’§§’ f?’EvE,2§ §§3§§§

reagzaaéént aséée Annexugemfk

3. égggéeveé by ifiai, i§fz_¢ “;:.e i:T§i.§ne: §’§e~;:;;;; léwaéés fééeafli ifiés

%%f§”§i Qaiéiian;

4. Ezévbiiigff;-._E§*:e;?é:c;’;£’3 2 aéaémis §§’§a”%’2 he
was c:s§§Ea.:ai§;’ag ” .t§% :.éagé’$g.f*%§c:};§?é’$w::;f fiznefiesahaééi wage
rr:eass,:;*§;’2.g..3$”§.z;§’%*st$£:,§$ s;3§iér:’s:–:>~..;ai:jé:2a.st 3% gems 3:26? 3% R2′?
e:4’é:ac§é.,_far–.—‘$7 ‘§§8?3~$$ siarzé in 52% name ané
ihefefam;’§¥”1a4_ §;%§é§%’a:é mi jiifiiiflfié iévemérzg €529

er§e§i§fa3::s=$e§¥ by”§1§*:_e; éééérfi sfgspsenzfiiené %3’§{§% £rsr:ex:;re~fi,.,

=f;ea:*e’3eeé C§§.3§’3$§§ fa? i:7?*se peéétissraeg s§r°§’2e:’zée:;;:’e-«B fifififififi §’i3§ gugiameai if? éaw, Fée

aim éfigfiéfiifiéfi $33: 3316 Apgeiéaia ?;%?§as;*:a§ zvéiézwi $%3§’E$a§§8¥%€’§§ ‘£§*2e

” *..§”5§&’£’5&”%.’_”.§&a§ as”: zamgfi %’§a$ rweraefi $29 «wig; gasiseefi 5%; zéwe Efiirfi

– :9e=’$95»3é:£§e:’*:% arzé ééegefareg 5?; fififéfifii Em sissiaéneezfié en éaw. §”%§> gigs

~ “‘s?:;§%5:rs§€2%§ $33: $19 sgzséa sf Eéae miéiiagzar waa cagfiézsaéing fine éaafif

3:26 iézergafieaz iha §a%§%é$z”:e:* was azséiéyaiing fie iané am the

&/

fietéiianws $3339 agrgeais in the §”?€Z’; axiraaés fer %%2e.§geff»3zS;’ %$§’?;”**’?.E”:»

2% is @535-88 322$ §§”1$§”9§€*E’&, {fie fipgeéiaia Tz’§§:2s_;:§’*:a%i”_x.aéé3% ;*1<;%§ V'

éuséifieé Er: reversérsg 2% mégg §sa$se5;'§§:?ée.–:« §;*sé§§ :;e.3;":$€}m_;:f;a:v;:$i:;'~' iwie

aim §§ae::edi mééarzaa 3;": iém §f@£§$ésr': =§?""%§rf_sé$'–s.$."V'::a’s”:»e§

23$? iéas”. fiage 13:34 it: Ci”,%E’?’Eé?”é:§;~v.Eé’%§.§:’§ iééugéé i%f{e”v_;e:€%;:V?:§és”‘a’%e mi”

rs:-afig in we revenge rea:.::;r§F3 fig?-“aéf:*a§%€’~-gaaza;Aéé-é§m.~éfi:fées we
mafia far firm sagisgegueni’ ‘Vyg-‘:a;s,__%’§.= ‘s%:é%.;§§.§A.VV3ba:_Véea:;2eé that 232%

imam: wag €i.£§E§’§f£’§?§f_$§ t%:锑E5a¥;é§:. %§%r*2fa_§;$é’.§.E:3:%:5%¢$ :’%§§a§”:se 6?”? flag

éeaésmsz af .é:§2§é-3. :*£,%=§3<°:;'%e:§§ §§"3_j 235%? East 333% 33%}? is
cmtwé,%_g§s:s§$s§»;ség@s ?1E§égb%§§~ a:=;.;?mg::%:;.::s am am awfier has mi
§%r:§%£3;,;}a;s;:2eef:%"'é§'*§§s':%:}E:2_%%'§:@_azsé-fiance. Ha' iééegafare' S-i}§!3'§§§E%€§

$23? iéée é?:*;g's%.;eg§";eé'e:ar§::2§' §:.a§**'2;*2L;a5'{§e susiaéfieé is": iaw.

figs "fiagaéészzria t?2.§3s Em §?é&§'?'E%§ wzifsaéé $23? 2%

» éziss-s§:;fc:s:§v2:3jts..§§i"ea;ff:§§ E5 aubméfiaé firm: Ehe §e?z§iém":e;*/\ £39359? suéiévaieé

4/

" ~*;%§*él5e-._i§:3:°:3é"! ':%'§~.%:a';:*gfaE'£%% ans' ihe ism has gm: veszeaf éfi ifze zigzag ans!

i%°2é§:aa2%'aar*2%2{,. 'E§:"z5é Rgmeéiaia T?%%=as2*;aE baa %°§§§"%'§§"§* rezsazaeé 2% ::s=§'§§&f

A;;'*%%5;*~5$e§ '§y {Em ihiré s*§$§m':€§§:°2§ am §?%€€%§§§'§ $5 @9951; mi aafi fa?

';%:fie:§?ere:::::g. éée aim %;s:.z%2*:*§%i%e§ am: $23 §ei%%§¢»ne: $233 {mi

.. –.;%;e§;§§e§ amyééxéng fie sfiaav iézai fie was cuifévaiéag am éaad agar in

'§»«3«i§'?é* 8% 33% 3;s§m§*£%e§ £33: éha yézgfieiiaig ?§*§%;..maE fixing Ema

le/

sceszsfieratizzr; ma: the mad Efiafi fifii éssesiaé wsia the ffizaze 3% me

rzama sf iiéza gaiiiéarzer éees mi agpeaa" $5": the ysgaserzam :'a<::%.§ffi;; §::%';§e'§

éa E»-<3-'§§?'4? has régéfiiy reva?se§ iiw agégz maseéfi _

rewondegxi arzé éfieiefase ii @393 am? mi; 2%: Snéerfséxertsés V "

'3'. '$39 %eame§ $€?%!8§"¥?E'§3§¥"1'§{:'?§$£3.§§¥f:}~?"v%§§s§ $a2;§m§i%é;7d..%%§é»*s%:

iéze geiiiéazzei wag my: the terzawé ;;s.g=j§m' Eat)'-f§4§'i:1'§§"?%'£:m…§§:¢ra;=2fs%e

ihe Ameéiaie "§"§%m§:a§ has zx%erse$1 .§_rfie§'ba$$é& we iéééyé

iesgssndeni am thereéwe,__i§";€aes§ ;*:£;::.c;'3a'iE._f:'s;"§;t§Ee:€e:e;'%ce.

8. § ha*e.%e– efa$e§;;é%§’céi;$Ed7a§é§E Eéégé 3é;s’§s?%’:2é35:a5s3 mafiig by

ihe !earé”,s;eé ‘-c19as:*§:s1fz:,%%”:’i”as;f’:.%’rze”§g%:ée$. ‘

3 “”;.?%=;:e ;Q;:i’;f°e§ %é%_a§’§§%$a$ $33: my asaaégeyaiéen is? wfieiéfieg

” qf::;:;’~, §f the greiééiarser in ?9$§8$§ sf 3y.§~iefi;}’ii–£§ sf

_Ané§:@aa.Eé$E%§ ‘7.%’%%§age erg ihe gmuééfi’ iizai fie wag mi égtazérzg iirze éarzs

a:3r.§_ %2és”:°sés”:%e &§§$$§3 in féée revenue racarafa frsm *§§’?§¥’?§ 2:3

€V5§5t’i:E«i:8§ afid iéfie swfier af iize Earsfi Snag mt fierzéeé 2&5: tie

= ….§::éiéi%$ner s%za§ giving my? aézare. ‘ffzse figgeééefie “?”:ébu§za%’ %:as

V

mass;-2r$e.c% éhe szdar we $58 gmsgzaé 313.: the iafifi ‘figs §%Q§._§ea$%éé”f-figévifg

ihé Siam §§”§{§ 23% §’$£Q:’§$ szie mi fiéww that €§”;e””g:;;e§%zéi§$%:2éé* 33225

§.§..:§%%%;3i§;*;§ {$29 Earsfi §§i..22″§E”§§ éééa yea; ‘?§?3¥A?£’an;é’¢e§:%§?;§§é=’:_ %.éE§’ ‘EwVi§E£%5’e

§§;

3%. ii is zaievgat ‘Ea fiQ%e;’V’§%*:V%vgseigiéafiéér.§§}§;s §;é’%§é igs Farm
§’~és.?fis £225: 52% was a:,;§’I%v%_i§§’:§ :$3;:$;;:7ie..a?2e:s€VV”:’5§f: Vggeaisg mi,
fié %§a3 mi fiffiéiifiéfi §:§,é§?§¥§a§E%”§§ 333$
ianfi afizma absggi’ w.;£:§.§;£¢§é.,;§.¥*se;*’s:s £9 gmw iésai

wswa

the getéiésnéz’ §.~i’~’3é'”:::%i§*=;$§§j:%,§”‘%%?2§. §§.1*f;§=- fizérém m ‘§«:5§m’§§;l%§ wg

sa§’:ier:%;é’§i%*§é§ %&§:¥::f;’é:§_'<::$;}%is'*:$eE f_§:"'€%%2e gfieiéizmey "$323: $29 mafia Q'?
the ;2e£§%'§.§§:é:2.: aés<:2§V:;a_§§'*:%:gé:%z2'§~- iaaié afifi éézezéater, éhe gseiéiéeneg

£§'F%'§§§"sEé8§ §e7"–c::sé§§:;;a%e:._ iééaé £311'-:6} :3 aaséiiwai any éizasiéa am? :%7a%°e»%:e. 2%

sagségazjge ;:a¢::€.*;e.p3*1:&.<',.**a;…..T'.';§f"<3 £§a§?'r: gag mm 8ea.??fi as fim

' %£1a7':';*s§%<.::%§~§;g€2§vEefcrms fiat; iéée geiééésner 22:33: $§'E§%'§ '$2: he wag

mawéifi, «/

::;%,:§:'E*~;s*§§§:'*s§ ifga éfzmé 3% éerzafii grim" 'Em E'~3~€§?5; a:°2$fl1*§e awzémasafi is

casiiivsgafiza §&%"§°§ iéié éiza aésim was mgéa, mi, §§"s§ geiéiéamr 'ms rm?

" H §.:s;:;:'i§f;;z:&i§? a::3;*:%z§§':§ '$53 s%2$*§»; '$234: he '€':3§$ assézizsgiéag fag Eafici ixész is

7?»-:§»='§A§?éL Témrefaga, am fiygeiéaie ziéfigfiaé 5333 ;?e%r3&§? éézex mfieg

'' '§3a§e§i mi 32% iézgé :'%$§§:z§?'é;*::. § $€§ :29: fisééf my was 3? :%ée§a:':t*g

k/

%:'E ii ??'*:e§@f5{%, in my C$$'%3§§€?€§ *+..sée*g%,-1 §§"%§§"e 'gig rm ;':f:;é'é'z'~?;«§-,?t;'*s;%:r:':« %

gaiéiiarz and heme, ii £3 Eiaibia is be fiflészzzéssaeé,

'£2. fizscaadingiyzfiés éssmégsérgi

?'§?'£~,