High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri G B Narasimha Naiker vs The State Of Karnataka on 27 November, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Sri G B Narasimha Naiker vs The State Of Karnataka on 27 November, 2009
Author: P.D.Dinakaran(Cj) & Byrareddy
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE

DATED THIS THE 27TH DAY OF NOVEMBER

PRESENT

THE HON'BLE MR. 13.1). DINA1{A13.AN, C1-i1'E§§_.IIiSiIQE.,, ii  1'

AND
THE I~ION'BLE MR. JUSTIQE   ii
WRIT A2?}?'EAL.N0. 17D"su _ gob?' '{i',V;A-v':IJD:2v='1]
Between:  AV 'A i   

E. S1'i.G.B.i\%'21i'21simha N'e1.iVkc1Vf,  -.  ._ 
Son oi' Ii,a1i_.é ffihikkéi "{33az:}_:;fe1i"' .:'.'3-§j.)z-1 IV'-€aii}r.7'L'=.r.
Aged e1i:;£<.)i.1'f'D;u7-' Yé*£.u~.<::.-. =  A V  = 
{ii3e11§=i7i'i"~r')<i' :§_(;m'_i(j1'.C_i1iz:§:1"1 --.i"1<..',§i v<'l2;1iIne('§]
2. E3_1_ii_,_G J';z'N':1F:'i$iIl'iI']'§:i :",_21jaI « ._  V
f5011 Vtiii' A.P&5.!'ish19ia1'.~;\»_vé'D iy Na iid-ii.
Agczgi '¢11i3€.)i::."'€§O'Yea' s':=._ ' ~
[f3§'iI']e'.§'if' Oi'S'c:i1~i(.51*Citizt:-1'1 not (.'IaiI'1'1v(i}

  

3 . Sri .V'e1sAa iii 1. £1 at p {x 1.; Na;-_1.ii'lu=, 1"
 S011 ofChikké11'125i-2'assimha Naikci'.
  t1b(_){.1."i~  

[:i::5%CI'1C'fi'1. of Se;1i()r Citizen not. clailiieci]

'  "  S.;ji.}"1.'i*xvti.iasi1"zm'11.1.

. 1 530%.. DE' He. 1% Ch:-11'1C11'a1)pz1 §\E2iii~:e.1'.
 Az~1;,j.§<§r;i" £1'E')(.)1.1i 30 Yea1's.

Q"!

Sri . i\E'ci;'2ih 2-1 I.'i .
"SVc)ii-1 0%" 1.231%: I~{2'1ja])§'.)2-:1 Na--n'.k.:;:1'.
Exggtici 'c.}.§fJ(){!l SE3 YL?2;i.1'.'$.

 All are I"(?Sidt"IHlS ofE7'eci<ia1:12.1.g2:L1'lLi \:'ilI21gc%.
Mi 1. E.{31'I"flE'l£'f Hobii.



i'321gc?;)21iii "1'a1nE<.
iiolz-11' D1's11'i('t. ...AI}I'I«)I.I,AN'l'S

(By S1"]]'i..L.V€1'1kE-if£1I'21I'E1E'E Re('Eci_\,«-'. ;\(:.i\:1'0sc*11t€d by its Sc>(.'1'€'%'u1"_v.

2. The E,:«,111c.i A(:qL1is1'l..i<m Ot'1'i('.('1*/.V  -
Assisizmt. Ccm1r1'1issio1'1e1'.   
Chikka'0aE1a.pu1~a Sul3~I")ivisai(.iry.  T ' 'T
C11ik.1<abal1ap u ra, *-
Kolar I;)1'st1'1'(?!.

13. The I)ep:.11._v C011u_nisssi011g'§1_'j; '~._ '
Koiar. V J   A  _¢ V 
Kotz-11' I)is1,1'i(r1'.  ~ _   ; ''''...;."R_E€SI-'ONi''.)I§N'1'S

(By Shlfi.B.'V'7CL*I;fl£'5'j1E'§'§'Ad€§_i{'i'()I'1£.1} C}0ve1'1"1mt-H11 I'1c'éz.1dc1*}

"l'I'2és "-.\/V'1*i1 A_1')15:;féiE«...--iL's 1"1E(?c:E m1de1' E3c'('?l,i{)11 4 0?' t1':(%
Ka1;*.1_i21i.z1i€a1 E'"Iigh._CToL11"; ACL ;)1*z1yi11g to sci aside the Ortier

_  ifi'i.11(' "W1'i1. Pe':.iI.i.1'1 N0.f"_"38iE3/2()O7 (:i2:1te::i;

T1'; W;"i:. [\pp<:'aI (*{)1'11mg up for I?'1*e1i1'111'na.1j\,~' E---i.ea1"irzg on

 '%"h1':=; ci'::1v};*'L'[.ANAND BYRAREDDY J2, (1<%1i'<:e1"<*c'1 {ho I'oI1owz'r1g:~

6



'..a~.:

JUDGMENT

“‘I”h(? ap;:.)<::1§ (*01'1'1i11g_§ on for 2i'1'<?1i1'11é1"1;1:'y }1e.z-1.:'i1'1§__;{ hezird

at; I€'I1§E,?}'].

2. ‘{‘I*:1c: eiippeiiaztt” alzd 0t.}’1.ers had fileci the W [_”;’ti?:.’1I”.t’,.i.V'(}’.’I”1

c1t.:estic):’1i1’3§_j; the e1(:qt.1isitio11 ;:)1′(‘)<'ee{.ti11g's while ajI's*() sci :i'1"t;,{"z::

d1're1’V”2:_’mz{d

in ssu1’v(-zy 110.79 artci 78 of C}1.E.:11}}€1t’Et}:3ttlii7 Vii!.2;1§g;t?..’ 2311.1′

‘Fa§.u}<;. Kolar 1")§st1'ict..

It. was t.11<;?. ('else 0f_t:}1t% 2.1;.)1)__}1 “13~i–1s 5lfiE:’.\'(3″–bf-jé.t’I~_ 21(?qt.:i1’ed as per

[~\l1.I’IE:’X;t.:I’€F5 3′ _2:1nc:'{; I3 _ ‘t’.(3 E}w \,\4-Twittt pct”it’.i():’1. The (;:assv: of the
first 21;’)}{:£::II2:11t \i..-151$’ At:_’t’i~”..z_f1’1:’.1′}{§’».i.s..–~z-113:) the uwnez’ 01″ 541.1 :”\-way 110.79

whi(:h._t.h.e .4$2v:tcVE 1;)(;’t’;.i’:4:'(f;vt_1éI””had (;>ffe:’e(.l for t’om1at.1(m of road

V’ I’1’e’f:?__ t’)f2_t’-?.(‘)S’t~.. ‘I’his锑;’)’1’t.3p0sz1l wa=1.=’s 21.11530 11’1a.de at t.h(-3 time 01′

eI1.c1t.1i_1.”y–;.»_ t TI”hg)Vt.t’gI’1 t1’1C’. Lana} /\(:(:1L:isit:i()1’1 OI”§”i(?e:’ was not

:ewC1*Se t:()”{7<')r1':' the road in the £.1IE"t?1'11£1t.iVv;' land that was

()ffe1'€d the pc*,I.iti0:'1m' 210.1, £"t{I'(]t1iS§i1i()I'1 1.):'(.)(1(;-iedixigs Itavcé

'<)éc:"1'1..'{_':()1nplet'c:ci in t'<':s;')e(1:t 0%' .~st,t1'vc},~' 110.28/I and 29/2 as

('i;1'igi'na1}.y ;31'0p0scc.§ to widen flu? ex'ist'1r1g road 'c'.1I"1d it was 21

6

a11t.h0ri1’ies;. ii is 1’1mrc” <?c)11\!v:'1ie::1' For the §g;@.1'1c?1*2:1i piiblic and
{he alt:-?1"11z1t.i\.*c: as p1'(.)p<").<;c?(.i 13y 1.1%: firs: pc.'1.it'i()11vr 1:2-1\.*i11g
bee1'1 11ege11"c?£i. 'éhere is no g1'0u1'"1<i 11T1£1ci€% out fol' inI'c'1'E"e1'en.<'<?.
'I'}1e appca:11 is 1"<';'._}'e~1("1.ec:i. T119 in§£*§'i11'1 order of" .<s1.:;1}:' g;".:i';_;11.<?Ci

€?a:*1ie1" sfzxnds \7E}.(,?E11.(?.Ci.

sC1,!g flAw ‘ H

.

II1c1ex:Yc&s/No. _ _
Web E.–1()S1.: Ye::~;~/ ‘1″‘\*’Qi ‘

§1\-‘