High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri G Mahesh S/O Sri Gujjarappa vs Sri K A Rasheed on 25 January, 2010

Karnataka High Court
Sri G Mahesh S/O Sri Gujjarappa vs Sri K A Rasheed on 25 January, 2010
Author: N.K.Patil And Gowda
'  (By. E31'ij':LE51,m'g:esI'1 §\/'i"i;a'1'.i11'. A(I1V(')("c1iICf}

{N THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATA}{A AT BANGALORE
i)A'I'EZI') THIS THE) 25m my 01? JANuAr><Y._ 
:PRESENT: '  n%
THE HON'BLE MR. JUST.IJC.Eb_I_\'I.I£._-- 
ANI) I '4 . ' 4'
TI-IE HON'BLE MR. JUsT1':i1;f:"---,B_fsI§{I4:E§V1$_rIVA:3LVii:  VA
M.P'.A.NQ.756VA().f5;;%OO.7' {h.r;,[."\}'j ._ 
I-3E'I'W1£E3N: V K &  ' V x

S£'iC}.M21§1€f$}1_ "  .  . 
5/ 0 S1"i3 C' K:j;E~.kiY?'1153321.31 V'    'V 
Aged.-e1ii;i()..:_.1i2.22  '=§.--V..O(':.t'%:{Ni}. »
Rfixifiuugmfinnawhgmhflnflk
E5?a'iL'ttf<;,Ij"i i':;.1'21Ii'1'I;i1 1) 1..1":'_¢1 (.)bh-.= .  V

C 1'1e:1II_2Ti§'u?.;r{,=_fi"é1§1..1 lg, '  . V _ H

(jfhi t'.r2_1<.iV:.11*'s_gé:s;.' 1') iS1.1ji"("--~t., ' 

 AppL?1Ed1"}1

E  Sr.' .IV{f;T:'-.§T R€1Si"1t"('€i.
 M21301". ('j)(~.(:: B1.1Si1':t-'SS.
H1 (3. Kama-11a. H(')usc=-r.

AA  K<)1'11'1ac1'1aI P<')s1..
 E3m.1'1z'1.c1. 'I'%'1c NB firis.
NiEg'i1'i.s I..)is1'1"i(ft

:5 "WWW

 



 

'2 The' Re;.§i011;1l I\z'f211'1e='1_:__,='1'.
New l11(:1ie.1 f\SSU!'&:1I}('(' C..I.1'.(l..
Ijliifgg P311il(iiL1g§.
Rfliss£or:}{0zu3.
E:.r311g_{z;1l:'(*~f3E3() O27.

   

(By Sri.IVI.S.Re1jc-:1'1<1ra Pms21c:£  i'c_:§i'--   
N(fi)IIi(..'L':" to R» 1 dispe1'1sc'ci with xj/0 ciéamd 12/;1'/ O) 

11HsA4FAisifled'U/S YKfii}ofWRFActaganmtthe
-J L_:(ig;_§1'm:1'1i a.1'1<i A\.m1'(i fimfiectl';_Qj5f}O7'.'2:OO6 .p2=1sscr(i in MVC
nu»2645/2004 on the fik:<é.:'. MAC'_"",' ._£E211'2gz'1EVt)":v,{:.  V-e';1{1r.3'\vi1"1;_;.§ tho 012-u'n'1
pc=~titi(.)n fin' (':_é):[1'Ipc--i'1szi*iion "E1116! .:se':*1ivisr'1.g c~n1123u1('<*n'1c:m of
('.c):'1'1}bc1'1s3e:11;§n f6'1""'He;-1z'i1'1g. this (my. N.K.
PATIL, J  ("£0 E i"'L?".{.'~%7.(_" (§ tire; '1%v.>.11«.:)\vi1'1g':

'f¢QDGMENT

 "i':}r'i}r'::4 £'1;~.)}.3c--al  (.*lai111a1':E is (.iirccrt'c%ci ag_§z1i11st. {zine

A'jz1ci;:I1i(>J:'i:'c- £1;"1'§E.;s.1we21.1f<:1 (*.1gu'.e(i 51" July 20063. 1.J2'1.<.'ssc<;l in

2004. on "'16? fiic of the Xi A(iciiEiE0:'" A<~.1'11. (.?l2i-Lims "I':'ib1.maL

 IE;i'>_é.L'1;;;i-i.1():'e. [ {Or 5E'101't'.. "'I"1'ibu1'1a1' } for enha11("ern(::'1t of

' "-~c"O1n}:) g;§roL.u1(i 1I":2.1.t.. tht.' <':.1'1s22-1E'E011 of

"'f'wJ______,_,,"..-1



.JJ

Rs.1.47,()()O/- 2'1\\'2'11'cic.'cl in f21\='()Lar of the c'.'i21i1'11;§1:1E 2'-IS

z.1g.2,:.'1ia1.<s1 his (21;-zin'1 For Rs.O5.(}{') lakhs. is izm('1(:'qz1a_16., 

2. The z,1ppt~r.1]a11t ('la-lims to ix: _.;~:g1" in wine Ei»_I'1(.)p..-g.§ve»1:*:T1ii":gV'*5: ';=:{§;:_:'_1'1=:g,=f

Rs.4.E'3()C)/- gm m(:)1'1i1'1. '1.'ha.__:_ on"'c)s':n2fi20C'5;».;:_;- a.f:;ac;r..n_ "

2:15 1'-\.I\/1.. when the appc:Hé'uj11..w£1s g.()ji'1g (an Ba_j2:1j

P1.11s.sz,u' \:*cl":i("ic* 1.)t'£ii'i1;1g§--_zN(')fI':A--§$C;/4HVf»4iA7"5»2 on I:T3e.111,g'g"¢-tI()1'c-=;'

Mysmre Road .»nea1'V.-Sa1'1ga};21s;wzin21EiQ'dcii Villagfi', of

Ra IT]211'}Elgéli17..'$7.2-11L1§::§{.~_*_&:1=.?\?I%if'L1Ii \:j2..1:f} .\vE":i(9 l"1 was <"<)n1i1'1;,_{ from

c)});.)0s:j1t- sici~<;:i5»\v-x-*it19"'1 *11ig§h s;)cr(*.c1;m in 21 i'E1S1'1 amci 11c;:g'1i;.§c?111

1112;1.a'1:1(:* 1'*. '(]'(.1.shg*("i :<1\g'2--.=_..§_i'1'e3.3V~" the m(:')1.or cycic' of the

;;1])ppi1.;..aa1i. \x.j'i'1i1e-V' <5\r('.:i*1z5t1<i2'1g lht'. lorry 1.h¢1t W218

p1'(V')'L(:.'.:".'t.'tiLiAz'1;_';'.111 i":'()1'1"iW(.)i' the van. On ac.'<-.(')un1 of Ehv -said

€l(2'._('fi(']7(;II1 f':...Eni'1C'-%.1.§Df)('}.I&1l'}iI sL1$1'2:i.i11eci gricvo11:=s m_j1,.1:"ies. He

E<'.)<')~E.<; Iz"vez.:1.V:fi='1<:1'1t_ at Rz;1_m.e1nage11'a (}<')vcr}11'nc1"1i Hc.)spit..al

"   :_1nd £:i1'¢:--r"ee1f'1.cé1' at -Semjay Gandhi Hospital. It' is his <tas~se

'~F_i'1'z31i--A" he }'1a.<5 spa": 1" ("'(")}"1$.5i(f§(":'1"EiE3}(F a1'1'1(.):11'u t'uwa1r{i:"e

'~-cm")\»*uy2,L1'1<'ré=r nourishin_c__,g foc_)<:I zmcii a.t:t:<;:11(§e-1111'. ("1'1a1"__2§c55.

W'WWM_,,,...w



i::('.'iu(.ii11g l'11t'?CIii('2--1% <pc*11.scs and ';i1<.'1"r:!Z")1'*<?. he §"1e_:s 1.0 be

c():11;)(.~n.<;e11c==~(.i 21(1c(.;z1:;-11'.v§'\k.

15. O1} a(*.c'm.:n1 of th(* i:1~;m'ics S1.lf~_51'c1l'l;}..t"'_(.i i.i'l* 'fhv(',.

21(*(.'.1'("iem. the 2.1ppcIla1'1€ fiiccl 1"}'1e claim p(*1'.il.i<'m.VV1')i7. RsV.wQ5{QjO:'

§21ki"1s agai1'1si' H16'. rcsp<.)11c1c*nE_:s. 'i'hc 'ssaici (j?.i23;.i.m  pt--r1'£':l{i(")11 

had (':(,)1nc up for Considm*a1t:iV(3»::.1"bef01'€§ ~:._hL1* "i'rilr§;u1'121i on
5"' Juiy 2006. 'I'i"1c_* "'}71'§i):1i1'1a[,L"--£;i71,¢r, (::<')1"1siclc:1'i1'1;z, {me

rc:.*I<:*vz:.111i n'1at.t-.:1'iai 2,1vaiE2':-1H1)Vi é p11 __i'il;c ai"1'1vcEV'z%1.ft«r:'=1' 2»1p;3rC.ciat:i01T1

oi' the (,..?i"'J;'*i"§v z,1_1 11fi d5&1'1-I1'1"i3}.:'!'E:2ll'y'CVi'€'1'él1(?C. .:«2IiowC(1I E"}:":c=? ('.'§2:1in1
pc1'.il.i<m' i:'1° 1_)a'ri_. e:i'w.£1.1'cf¢ii'ig.. 'a._.s1:n1 of Rs. 1.47'.()()(') /-- with

ime:~1'csi 2;11'"€:SV%vpVc1-'_ 211~31'1'rm'1 from the claim of pc-*£.:'1io;1 U11

'W/_1}"1c'._' (:€2'1f:j. of 1"(éziii2:--;<:--E:«i1')11. Ba-*.i:1g (iiissatisE'it?ci with the

 C12! 2»-im._1.1"11.1»«t}{"(*g_)V11npe1'1sa.1E:i<:)n 2-iwzjutieci by the T1'i},)I.ll1£1I; 111:?

;1}')pe?i'I2i1x11 'iS_Vin ztppc-:2-1% before this Com'i.. -sexrliirlg

' ,5;-=1 :}':2411'1t{r3n'::1e1 11 of (.'(.)I'1'1p(;'1'}.SEE1E ion .

 u .;.1_:.id lc*211'1""1€f£i ('*r):,.11"1Sc§ Ibr

 W-'c-' I'12.1\~'€ 3102-1rd ica1*1'1ed <:I for z.1pp<:li2mE

nsu 1*a.11c=.e Company.

  
 



 Aftva' (*(..n:sic1t=*:'a1_§(.)I'} of the sL1b1'1'1issi<..):'1 of me

}£'21I'I}('(,E ('()1.11'1s<--*1 for Elli' p:;'11"1.ieS 2;-m("l 2'-11101' pm'11s;.11 of {he

_jz.1(Ig':1'1(~11I. e11'1(.i .';1\.v211'(.I p21s.~a<:(."f by 'i'1"i1f)1:112;1.i. VH2' e:1._a'c%_V(')«{_iiEi1vc%

opiamm i}'121'i., the "I':"ibn1"1a1I is.-3 j1.1sITii'i£;'d i_:"17-- .21\y'f«\-'as;:.I.f(j1--i1ji§;_--,ij.T *

(*.(..)n1pe;'1s2;1iion of Rs.3().OOO/-,~~im2va1ftis 'g3§;ti1i"  _a11C¥._ 

s'-;1tfft-%1"i11;,;'s. RS.5().O00/-- 

1'()wa1'd:s 1'"ncdi(%21I cx})c11s;--3w;1i*£iVsV"loés 0f 

2ir1'"1c1'1i1 ics. (:Iiscor1'1f'r,.> 171 ;;m--ci.  2 1:1. 1'} i121p}:§i1'=1.s.s'. and

R.s.1.0.000/» t.(.)w21:"cis Ci'i:9_¥.-kg'.-';l.ii7EiVTIi:{I)i'},"~_H.§?f1fE€T, it C1()(:'S not

(:21 £1 for intt:1'f'c;1<cr.1Aic:%c .

6;. i"I0\vml'L~.i"';-.'{A1111 "'{.'_19ii:31_.:1.1.21E 112155 errc.-(1 in :;1waI'('1i:"1§-_if

€.f'~:«1.!..:c'I at:tez1ci:;mt' ("112.1.1"g&'$. 'I'hc saicl

 '(i(11'§'I'p§i211$§l3,5(Ni is i1'1acicq1.ad1.c and nctxls 91'1h2m('L%11'1c:"1t. for

t'1"1+;-7 "1'*c-*:;='~.1s(>i1 I_ijI'?fi11. ihcé a.ppc1Ia1'1i 11215 {.2-1k(;'I'] i_1'C&;1117'1(f1'11 as

r__i11«A pa1*~§vm;.!1. in 1:wo ir{:..)s.s;.>:'12"1_I.:a'. in the 21}:)se2'u"'e of any

'MV'(i.()cLr;1'1cn€..z.u"y c:vi{Icr[1(rC.. 1'1avi1'1g;" 1'eg2.1:"(:f to the 1'1.am.:1'e of

  ' :'1f;_}Ln"it;.*s 2:1:'1c.i the-' :"1a1{'1.:1'e )f t1'Ca-xilncélat. \v(? 2-1wz11'(i 21 sum of

fl'

 



(1

Rs.1()_(')()(")/---- mwa11'ds (_"(')1"a\»'qve11":_<.:i_ mid

;1Ho1'1(_1a1'1t ('.']'1;.1t'gL"x.

7. 'l'hc' 'E'1'ib1111e1l also orrocl 1'11 a.1v.'221--.'-7 <i"i1')A_;.;{._ti:"iI'y. V'

51:1'n 0!" Rs.13.(')U()/~ 1'_m\.=a1'('I:s I(').%'S'--«()I' «"4i11(";()':'i1Vv  'c'm.«§':n--ig,

i.;'c?:;1'::'1'}m1I pm'i()c:i. A(.in1it'teci1v I131? 2:'1--;_J}A'3L-'alla1"t'1.ij. i~'1.;.1.~; 't..'«;.:1"iri.(;V*.x1V"1'.

11'<:a1.mcr1'1E as iz'1--pati<:m_  in
the '(.1b.S-'»('l"l('(' oi' ilw (:vir..~3r.j}.111'1Q11I'é:-:.1r;§"j<'rV§5"iLr;1'(;'11(rL;'it; }j;"()\«-'9 {ho
1'11,£I1"1b('i' of dzzzys of    '})vi*cf$1.tn'1(r. having
1'c._ga1:'(.1 to iIi']('?:.1'1«2*':t!V1 1:-zit'  that 1'10 w0L11d
l1e,1\.»'cr t.z1kc2'3   --t'1'c2:1:mc-:11: 211": ci 1'v.~ai
;.1Ilc2zs:': "'flit'ai* f}?¢?;i:E:'§{i 1'  "I"herc=:tIbrc._ ]'121v:'n;__;
:'(TT=;_;;11*(:i v{"c1a  of {"113 apgx-*lEa1:1i and tho

ye-z--11'_<)_v1" 2'1 period of l.re;;:t:1ncm' auud

!'(>IA1c_..14w« Li p ~1 _1ij:.2£ i" 1'm=? u t..

  1.

I1″: fhv i1;g;1′}1. (‘2f£l’1c=:* fz:1(‘i.s and (YEI'(.’E,li’}1SfE:1l’1(‘LTfé§ of

‘ t _E2.c cf§:.s¢’r. as siat.c(..f a.1b(‘)vc-‘. £130 21ppe2;1l f:’!e<.f by 21ppc*lIat'1I

H'__w,,,,,/

am–.*rc<)1'1 at 6% per zT.u1m.1.m. within 't.hree wks from the

(.ie11.c of 1’t'(‘.€’ipi’ u1′(“<.)p'\_-f of the }11cign'1c1'11 and awe}

0:': su('}1 dvposit by H10. i1'}SL.1£'e,1I!(T(.' C(.)1f:é__13zi'1'1j.?'V;'*—-1_h€T._._ .

C1']'li1"(.' rsmn 5'-shaii be released in i';;3.\,:.c),1_._::" I_7 t”1″i(-:-‘* –2’1p;j’t*¥lé.11’1I».

immc(iiz:1i.c1y.

C)ffi£'(i’ to ci1′;;m.» a1\.\:a:’c1.Va£5′(=«C)I*cii:1’§§1}”. V _ 1

amxw saw