R.S.A.N0.16'/3/2009 & MisC.CV1.21959/2009
W1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE
DATED THIS THE 2ND DAY OF DECEMBER 2009»
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V
R.S.A. No.1673/2:'»QOS}~A..j1' '
Aldkjf _
Misc.Cvl.219S"9~[:::§T»OO9 f
BE'I'\NEEN: =
SR1. (I}I~I.1.EI,A§\/i Mc>MAMMI«:D
S /0 I,A'1'E SR}. ASGAR ALI.
75 YEARS.
SE-IOP No.25/{)5/2; '
SI--IOE MUSEUM __
1')I£\.-'ARAJ U RS R()AE3V, K
E\/IYSCBREZ 570 00 :1
V. V
.. " ...APPIiI.1,AN'I'
[BY SR1. R:_VI.3.SAI3!\i§§i_VA,}5A§'?A. --.4»,i.')"~U_._J
AND: A ' A T V
1.
SMI’.Vs,vv1,;A§sx1.A:<:si–.1M1~._ V
78 y§;;;Ar'<S "
2.V
‘ YiP3AR_3 v
3. 13152″.H:;$.S:€1″:xs.1vASA PRASAIL)
:\Cfx».T:E}1’L) 72.. ‘.r’£j+.3}_’§….Rf-is
‘ ALI. ARE *r_::1»n1.1:):2E:\% op’
E mftflaz SR1. H.N.s.1YEN(.;A.R
” 1 f ” AN 1′)” ~R/ AT NO . 936.
21 ‘£\E«0.R’I’}EAI MAIN I..AKSI~I1\/EEI-‘-‘URA;’\/E
MYS()RE 570 004 . . .I{i3SP(i>NI){‘1N’1S
{BY 1) R_1-«»1.s.s§21N1vAsA I-‘R!\Sx?\II’)—W~\I{‘1’&’ IN 1i?I£Rs5(.>N
ANI3 FOR AI.L(>’rI~1E1-:2 R§«:sP()Nm::\?’1’$)
R.§j.A.NO. 15/3/2003 (51 lV11SC.UVl.Z 1939/ZUUB
-3-
Court in t:h<:' suit in O.S.N0.29/2003 but modii"ie(i the
decree ir1S(3f2i1z" as ii 1"C1E:1l..Cd to p211y'11'1e1'1E of (i241r11221g@S/ i"fl(:'.-5116;'
profits. It is relevant to Stat.c thai. tihc-3 t:rie1I Court
de<::1"eed the suit hoiciing that there was valid t.e1"r:~*ri–:i_ejsfci_t_jh;
of t'€I1'c1I'1(.Ty.
3. Sri R.B.Sadasivappa, learned C01.1I1S Cj’:. aippc::1’r_ii:–g’~fQr,__T f
the a1:)pcE1a1’1t Submitted t.1’1at1f {he aVpp_C’i}ar11,*}’i;:;é _v .1)e:cf;ra
(tarrying on Shoe business in t’_hé’=.$’1,.1itV: s11(5p._’s’i’1’1ce g 1.969
and prayed for reas01ia*bI}:*, _ t’;’_111£{: .i’€_:~.. ‘t_1’it:? appellant; to
voluntalily vacate and to dclivfer V\raea1f2t pdsiséssicm of the
suit: shop ‘;_() the 1fé3′:éVp’:n_V1;1L*.gzhij55’/–1_anci.1c)rds.
4. Dr. H.SLS1*i11i§fa1saaA’ f?1f;-i’i%Eid # respcmdent No.3. who
appeelrefii Vin pef’s0_1i1«. submitted that the respo:nder1t;s
bci11,g«S_¢1’2i()r.AC4iif*i–:aCns are aged more i:11a1’1 70 years and
hc%1’1(T:c3 r1.(L) t..ir;i.”e-..1’rI;i§? be g1’211’1t:eci to th(-: appeilant to vawte
f.}}E;’. S111? :~:h’0.p. 4′
fis-
3,’ ‘ “khélve c()ns£cie:reci the aforesaid SL,1bi”11iSSi()I}S of the
1C..51.1.”I1’:(‘;’.C1 Counsel on both sides. Hat-‘ir1g mgarci to the fact
R.S.A.N0. 1673/2009 85 Mis(‘*..Cvl.21959/2009
W4”
1.11m. thc 21p}_)(*lle-1111′ lms been (‘.a1*1’yi.ng’ on business in the
suit” shop from 1969, it is 2″easo112:\blc 1.0 g1*z»11’1i_ e11′.leasi; “5:_ix
mo1’111’1.<;' time to {he appel1a1'H 1'0 v(.)lu1'1r2u'i1},~' vz1(ia1ig§_£'ar,i§i–1c)
delivcl" vac"2.mt_ p0ssessi<)n of 12116:' suit sh’
r<3sp0r1dcnt.s/ landlords. Ac(t<_)rdiI1gly.f'I nié;1§:_e7t11c%' §rb_l'i<-)wji*1g
art} 0 1':
The appel1a1″1′{./d€fc1’1(ia11t. “g1-a:1t.éti._ ‘S’i;:{V’ niQ11ths’
t.ir11<~: from today to xr()11;;i1V1;:211*i}y 'V:£1'(f.E.'i1l'f;?'A"–§kI1Ci to deliver
vac.:am: p()ssessi()11 of 1:'i1,e"$~h<);j to the
respondmltis/1a11dl0fid.s. "311 an g_)i:'h'<i'=;~.._…«– the
j1.1dg111e1'1t: éii'iVt1"–fii§égj1"€EfV/2009 -shall s1'.e11'1d
2-1.ff1'rr11ed.. 'I'I':.€: appeai'*é§_1~a.i:Id_$"'disposed of a(:C()rdingly. In
new ofdi.sp0szi1"O_f'H16e1Ap.pééil, Mis(.t.C\*l.21959/2009 filed
161" V in t: 9' ii in iS112;1§;«' t.a11T1(i.s""ii'isn.1 isse (.1 .
"'"5;~,,A;;%-tg
sd/-
IUDGE
i’s;j;)0s_§:ci of. «V
” hklj/’Ai;z_1