Sri Gopalakrishna Shetty vs The Additional Commissioner Of ... on 29 September, 2010 - Free Judgements of Supreme Court & High Court

Karnataka High Court
Sri Gopalakrishna Shetty vs The Additional Commissioner Of … on 29 September, 2010
Author: Manjula Chellur K.Govindarajulu

 '    §i§i€:ﬁ}g§,;§;£*:'é&».~§?§ 
ﬁg §7"§§§ EEQEE CQEEE? §§' .. . .

§;%"Z¥f'E§ ?§~§§$ 'E5
 §&E'=§§%§Q§;;§.f%;;§E
§'§:E=$§;§§T
F3533 E~§%§%?’§£E Eéﬁﬁs g§3*:*:§§ :2§§;§J§L§;%%§§§:gg.:g:;{%§; ” *  
ﬁﬁﬁ 
‘§f’§§E Eiﬁféﬁgiﬁ Egg, g§§:$*§§€§’»§:;, %;§:;:?;§:E%%i§§;:§§%;g’§g;*%;33:g;::
ggggs ésgg §;§§?$5%Z; Eésfgmiag gggqgg ‘  ”

;§wi§:§§;:§    % % %  
$3; §3=~$§a2a3%§§$§;§a %§’§::.;§%t§#<'"" *

35$ fﬁaﬁﬁa ﬁﬁaiiy A I 5 ' V  AA %

E? §;'§§§ Egg _..$3:5ii.%,%V%*3§s§K%a£ 3:3 pg:
$$'§§3?§  ' ; _ 7'; ' .  .

wag §%Lz%&§a %€%;”‘:*7f”é’;.”>%V;eé’?ai§%”~»__    ~

gé#::§§ «

§%§i $ %§§§%;;a§é.s.§;;?§$§:§;;%¢_s $%e%§§?
$z§ $%§§a§a?’a§;§:;% Tﬁié’-as; iéaiiam. Sﬁewki

§s.:.;;,~§a§:%; ‘
méag ﬁaﬁgé
   Efézirtﬁiy 313:3 %z’§.. R E. §§r:§§§.

<_ /
31'? {:34 §§:;§§ﬁ{a;.§ Law 33$" ;%é§eca?:g5§
A  *}§'§:@..éééii§§na§ ﬁﬁmmiaﬁianag

'~;é§-ﬁémmsrciai Eaxes
iimga»-«L ¥3:::i§§§aa ?'arige iéémafaﬁ
'  -Qagéégigmgar
5 §s¢ §ES?§§*%'§§§§'§
§az§g&§§2*%-§§<'£ 
fE§'?ﬁ %.s%§?" Q?' §E§*§'EE%§§§§fE5%.g i2*§%f3–i§;§€§..
€33? gag,  Ea %?'$é3;§§§%§r€ﬁ§?§ §E§§?§
'E'§i§ §a§§:%ai §$ ﬁiaé ﬁgs §%€E§ @§

agaézmt iim Egyigimz ﬁféﬁr daisé §§§§_§_§g€%§§§;%._§§a;$;3aa§ ._ "

:L:,%gz%§§%;@:§§:,
E3 E'§a',ﬁA€-E!§£§'%§r§§§§iw3;%   .:_a;ﬁ&' M

'§Z§i§§,é§"?!§§~x§§ $3; the ]§§§$.,.  f%3§'._ "

Sﬁmmisgiagms gf ﬁamm%:::*:§a%;__ " '§aX$$,–_ .E§s%r;«;-:41;
Emfggaiagfsseg. gmxisizzg a,;;§ '§§§%:::g 'a$£§§v *E.%:;$ .&g§:;§é3:$*;§"

iifﬁﬁf Eéifié §%3§$e§§:Eg mg ﬁiﬁéfﬁ a¥§__a:3$%s§%§:r;é:2i"3;aé "
ysggaéajg sf ﬁgs aimed: $93: a*:;.¥;.»§1T:tzg§:'§§§ atgé' gﬁégréingig

$€}ﬁ§§%E§§.ﬁg ﬁgs §"$?§;§~i§ﬁ §:§:;:;e%ej:'§§E:ng$. ' 
Eféaig ;§.§§$3}i ﬁ€%ii§'i3§§E§}g §§§"i.:_b'§§§§"–.§%;€,%ﬁ1.§§§§§2'§ éiégég ééaggg,

ﬁﬁangaéa Qkaiiag £s§ éaiivgzgvdé éfzéag:-:s._§§s§}§;s.2%'§{§§gg:
$33 ﬁéétg  iéégi V §é»%§;:*'§:a§ Qﬁﬁﬁgiiﬁﬁéﬁi
19%
§%é"§§%::+_a§§; '§§%€';i£~":s;"§_V~vf:,ga"s $23 afigiaaé 22%: §§fi&§i%§E3§
€33 ﬁg» &;.%;§éz;%%§3,ié§§;'%:V'£%.§; iax fa: Sag gzeai' §$§§;«§§§
 Q;-v<€}g'§ $37 %%'§i*§:§§§ 333% Sag ¥?;%¢ Egéég gig: $%§%§'i
  "§§§;é'  ?aé¥§:*::§-*-Egaé ﬁzé gaggm £3 §a:'::$@é§
   '7§§é,@___as§z§i§i@é facéﬁ ia ﬁha géyasazzi saga am
 £3 3. §:*3;§§§§:"§$§ eﬁgageﬁ ii': 33%
§E§;$}§Ei§f§é"2 §if'&§i$§§fi&§§§§i'i sf g§@§$§ Eﬁ ﬁm magi: zéf
 Jzgiy '~i:%;§?'§3§ $332 aaizﬁéﬁmagi %a§§::§?§zg ta 3 §%§§';§§§'§§?

 '%;§..gf;a:33é§ E5333 §?%".°%2*'§% ?§i:*$ -~ a f§g§$§&1?§§ §$&§%§ §3ﬁ§§§*
ﬁgrﬁaiﬂa §a§e§ '§"aX £3; §.§§§* i§a§$§~€%"%§%
gaﬁaaigiziiagzi §§' 3; §§§§2m§ aaﬁaé 
§éa:2ga§a§%; '§f*he ﬁﬁzéiﬁiiiiﬁii ﬁéiﬁtégfa §:.=,»§s%;:*%.§ﬁ;;2aa9'i§:§%€:§a.§§';"
the tmzzgii géags vgéziﬁz wag r§2;§§§§:§%%i:i§.;  af ﬂag gmm $22? $33
mag *é:3§§§§j§%§fiA5£§'::§..V§§"'§¥?i'§i':§

 Egg :§:§«g:§:%&§:s¢9':'-§,§ ,;'*:§;$@§ €226 imgzgii $3353 wag
§§$"s§e§ %§fg<_E%i:«:§:::%1f' {3%3§'<:*;§%?@§€§ Kazmar agé ﬂag @533?
@§§;e§:é§«é:3;s3$: **§§:e;;<:%:_ ;%§€%i§§%:e gear ﬁaszsgz égémiiieéiga £223
 .""';g§%'z;2{§$?é::?é§*§%;A' m ééézék §§% §%$'§§§&$§:%ﬁ miigiﬁéas ﬁgs

 ' Eég.-%:e§ 'féazizaiaéia Eta" ?$::§§c§3%§z*§i ﬁg ﬁe %a$§s 9%'
" ifazzgéé §ass {3'§§ 3% Léétéikééé a&§§;§%;
§g§%£4%:§2°:V__ '%::%;%3' grégmiéseﬁ time améaar ﬁg ﬁﬁﬁﬁgﬁ gaiﬁ
 §§'§%*§';E%§ﬁI:§; §§'§§§? gm? $233? §m§§$§é_ iax $3: 3.33% §%¥i%§
si
yeaaiijg ﬁg ika g@%§$ §§?'3.ﬁ$i§$2"§§§. The ﬁﬁﬂiﬁﬁﬁﬁﬁ
sf ika a§§a§iaaifaas&s£e& was apaﬁ {mm 'iﬁﬁ }é:_§'i"%?%§
Eye" 'ﬁvak §e'E§:$§ ﬁvﬁaggaiereg wkﬁ "arm §ne:§:f%.:s3'g;e:;£'{:.é§"

gaaég fmzn tha cemme§mma3::§'"e-§f.§§hsf%  iéiié 'E: V'

maﬁhgﬁ ika éggtigzatiaa aﬁé  1 
mag ﬁat eniy the $m:1$%i§.:?§:§:§$    <€Vﬁ1::*2:V:s§&§"
wiétﬁ ﬁg éiéé? $5 %.;a:a;§.é§§;f:Vg§" £¥j§*:4é§"<.§h$ t§sia':m$: a: %.x;%%

sitﬁagsk $93; *§§§aa2*e§'§:i°§§5;'5!;:§s.§.§%§§§§ §§ ¥eh§$§§ wag
ﬁﬁi Eiaﬁa §&' :19%°_:.a§:   éf iha §%z§,a§§§*
imgsssgé;  aééégé éaéeé 2é_:2.2®§3 5:;

mg ﬁéﬁgﬁﬁéﬁg.__.§§i3»§€::g ‘giéﬁﬁ as gkaw ikat gag gaié
§ef:§:**;…c§  éaéégiad aaé iﬁay %§i'”$$ﬁ§éﬁ§ ﬁg
.’  .?°£§ﬁ’§é§$5€*i§”ﬁ§;’¥’1 Qf §§s§:.”§§g§@§–* aﬁﬁ anﬁiﬁar Eggéﬁﬁgl
” ‘~;§;§’§’;?§ 
   wag ghaiigngsé %e§’m*a thg a§:s§§§§a:§a
aiz’§;§&:f_?z€;f;-*’.’ §~é§ Kg? gggaaé E3333} ﬁgﬁé,
Z Eﬁsg a§§§§Eg,%& aééiémziig Ea ikﬁ §f%§§a% saga
Egg iiﬁiﬁ $@i’Ii$§§%l’%%§ﬁ§ iﬁai ika a$$%$$Eﬁ%§§
 ….z:§ﬁ ikﬁ fﬁiiifﬁ saﬁmiiiaé §§? ﬁﬁé §’%§§$}f aé’ Eﬁé gaﬁﬁg
Eta” %§§’§’%3§§ ?@§:*$§ giagagaiégag $$ﬁ€§.ifi§€§ %§E3fi}V”§}§;§’«i”§§5€
wag gm €”§?§;§§§i1% $5 ma? $339 
a$§§.2;:’§:§§i§z2 iaxgs aazmmi kg iﬁﬁfigéﬁ £3: ‘§”;?E§’%£:%”§§i§§E%i=ﬁ§$E”3:_§ “~
agseggga beizig 3.5% $9 ae§§$«h§%:$§:_ §§3¥e ‘:;*we’§5E?e$;é;s§:§§.$ 
gsaéﬁ ﬁzﬁﬁiéé $23 $§a€%’ §§:;§  3Q§é€’V: §%§§’§.%§V§:;Vﬁ_:’3
ﬁéaia, §g§§§:°§i::§   ‘iéﬁ

Qéféﬁf $5 assgssgzzéﬁé’ g;.:$&$$§§{_”;§£’§§§*i: ‘§§,§et§mz §.§{2§ §§’

ﬁzﬁ $2? §:<§f –  i%§§="';e'%$§§$?£%%_iv".A..v'.§§.§;éé;§si§§§ez;$r Q?

ﬁm:.:§;§::e?%..;".::_%:;'»;%;§5:'~..,  §i:§§'ic2;$@3 33%;? wag

35$ $'§%'v§;';'-%.$.§,ﬁ_§'.TZ:F§'~%',"_':* §"    ﬁza §§§é$ *§§§2§@3'%';@é

%§' §:é;5$ " 2&3 aaﬁﬁeai maﬁa: ﬁf'
ﬁﬁﬁﬁrﬁﬁgiééééi azgé-_;a§§._V §§ﬁ§§§§ﬁ1€f§i§ ﬁgézisia "%§§%§*ﬁ $3
 3§§;:;§;§€§:'%g§'af;§%.A::;2i% égéﬁzzgeai 'iﬁ ikﬁ vary awgiéz
 $333 ﬁat £6; iﬁ faﬁt geaah ?@§§§s§z&§3*§¥
 j§§1slé.3%;_v%:Ev:iée::% 3%? ihé $52"? azzéwséamsaﬁt af' iﬁé
 §2:;§§.f?'§ﬁ;.%§ra§eat Q? ﬁeﬁirﬁ Exgism §§§§§$§:az°::3z éaiaé
 E5': 33%; :'&§%:'3 $3 éézé miaaga $3' g§@§§g
  fTz&§§E§§§?'§ ﬁagika ix §s§¥§%.§:' 9%' the sﬁmgéﬁef aﬁé §§§$
§a%§;a:"§ §$$§;§ﬁ§ %§ 'ékﬁ §$%;:%;:%§? @$§:'2m%§a2;%,9;.§. ﬁéx §§§§;$§§
:3? §$§:§§§g§3:2~as:f*:°'%; "§'f%2% asgﬁgsizzﬁf aiiiizﬁsiiﬁ? Ezaé ifﬁﬁié
ii; §§£i§§§'%.§.$§$ﬁ ﬁégai: 3&3; iﬁa azziﬁgg gﬁéaieé %§ igtéga
ﬁﬁiiﬁigﬁﬁf zéié gzmva $32: sf ﬁgs Siaia' Ea§§%§:2_:_'?t§:z_§$
§§i§;'§§§§3;g% iﬁﬁ agsgﬁiiaie gatkazéiy 
E32: §&'?§'$§§§' af iha agiaeéiazaig $%%:§';;g;_a$§éfeT z§;2.g}~_..§;:*§5eg:;g " 'V
%%:§ aézggéz gag: gfﬁmz éaiéé 
m%§i§i§§§.a§ aaziééﬁritgz %:'.$$§§ _§'.:-§§ §%:§é*-é:ma%_%é:§V§  
$:m«=:§a%%,@ §:&?§.$§.@§: gzzé %§;$.%;:§:§§z§;.__a..§%§%§«%V%3s.$§i2 zzaﬁaﬁ

22:; gm a§§&$§%@ c!a§'%;§:§t:g   =%::;§ mzgaizz icﬁﬁ

aﬁmigzgiﬁ ﬁf  §§;9é?€§§€3§:;; .."a.s:;a;§5s:'<.-;«zs;aae §,§§aa§§£

Emfggﬁe   $§§?}E§3§,§%/%é"§ 53%

e;:$§§a;é:aAs;%§;a2e§; V"V'~':f}§¢%§}%%§§'g;.' 52$ E'%¥§$§§§§T§$§ §:'iE§§:§§'§i:§?"

fazzzﬁ éézg"  aggsaiéaiﬁ &E§.%§2§§"§§§? 53

%§:V%;:e;§'_;;£:i§§a§;a;3 Ea ikg éﬁitemsé 3%' ike $%;a3§$

 faﬁawimg fﬁaﬁﬁﬁﬁi
A E; – 5§"'§§ai§: agggéiagfgi $3 %%a mggzﬁr af g-§@§§

" -.%é'§§'%&§§§§'§ $3? Eiéagtéaa gmm SEE?

Eianmzrg 'ﬁg: faéiaé éﬁ gzzrmgzégz $9

"§"'m:1$§t gags ai iﬁa $133? ﬁﬁagaéz §@.§%
\\,\ J. .\
%.:;§i;3?2%%%§' $3 ggaé" §%E§§

= §<;;%,:$§e:%:+§&.T §::eg:j§x;*'€.*§*'¥ ﬁﬁﬁ @3533 '£333
3;? éiiﬁaig 63% £2? §é§§§'& ﬁéaﬁﬁgﬁg. éﬁéxz

&§${§'i;%§3f§? Eéazmagéi sar§e§§§§{%%§z$;§:"%§§%%f;—«._:

gigs Q: ﬁgiiikaie ﬁizascié gag: ::»;.§:x{$*mF' '

Eiazgﬁégr %$€§§§5a§ﬁ&§ 23:33: :2;-%e"'ié'e§€%:'::::r§$ '..
ﬁf Qizaﬁk §%§$ ﬁg zimféi £§2§t;;..§a§§;ag¥e"§§V_ ' __ A

rssg,   :§;§g;;§a9; :2  « .

tiimugiz $izec§§,’3??§s% ﬁzrggéi” ‘£§$;’i::”:jan;;*§§§.£: 
gasaég ‘5£&§§§;§§$

yags was 333$ §’f§v£3i%.;g:,:r;*e~n1§%;ea;af§=;€

tﬁaxé E? ce§:::a§§¢_é.i£&;§ -;$$etié€.:-:f:.___§;§§§?§:%§

$f§§’§’EeG ;g§cz.’1;§%?§a_”  j_  ” ”

‘$23 53$   %%

$%.§§aaE §:;.g’§’»-far ‘é1*{$:7L_§$1?f§F’ {‘§§:¥ izax amﬁ
§§;1’:2:§_i£§?¥= éaw  2$:3g§=;,___i& iggggg

gay-§aa:%§:’§;;_&§ V %§§f&§€§.7}«. fig V agaiﬁgé ééw
i;3§,:;§§;§;:ﬁ;’é§§*£i §”;§$’f-E§~§1§.z§; ﬁizgmma ﬁméfi 6%.”
§é§;d§’%w§1.;..V§:: éizg?” ‘§;.3:,,_$§ faf ciﬁi §%§§§a§
 kk ‘:T§ii?é;’3’iEi’i’%§¥’-~.__ E*§§§E\§§£§’§;E§$ wiiig ﬁg.
‘ >§§§s:’;.g$”T;?’?§$.e~$<;:§i§<e'f%?@ 3%
M 23% éaiéé

2:2:.§?;§¥;'%'?f1 in yiaﬁr af {Em Jzzégmgzit
Vs? §i§:;2:,____§§:s§ze:f§§ ﬁxéazgig Ekﬁ faaig
gggvaéegzii £33 ika aaga §§ asgessaa ma
._ '~C_g;sf§e§ éiw €§$i$ sﬁgiaiiiefaﬁ %%§? iéckzé

.:'~.. §f"§4f3§EEx;" Sgagmmﬁ CQ§;:'*:§ &§Zi§ %.§;:%:m§Q§§ E:

'é'3.?'z:$'s§§ §m§§seé ﬁg sat agiéaa éksa
' -aéggeagi
méer §E3 gg far ax ﬁg

gsrmgisimas ﬁg' §e¢$§$:: Eggiﬁé & §$§ are
.. gmscezzmé agzé ta mmii tag maﬁa: 9?

§?§ far §:*§§§: €§§iS§§%?&t§§§’§, ﬁg’: ﬂag

Eighzi 9%’ :§:§ akavge jzzégmaaig
‘?§2e§*%§:*s:*& ii is Ezémﬁy §m§%$&§ ﬁg ﬁﬁi

agiég ééza gaiﬁ agyeai sgém azzé

aiisygiaéigaéy 2% famii f%§ maiigf ‘ﬁe
“§§§%§§§:&?:£s§§? iéw asgéays ei’ iha agggaeﬁéaig a§;$§°;z’s:?§:gff€Vf:%__”_*€;éj:2:ff’é:.A
3″€”§?§$§§ aaé $&§=&S§§ﬁ., “fézﬁ sréearﬁ af &,$S€5§g§ﬁ3{ﬁ§fi ;a;~::z_§
pagzaﬁy af ﬁga ckgaég gag? §§§’i§:§j€#§.§7§,§§? %¥§%$:*?e4″§§§§;%;¥as?:%%’_€?i§  
$5 ﬁﬁﬁﬁﬁﬁ ggogﬁ £2?’ iﬁa §£§:§§as%.i:a§§k§v§4é§%;é§::’§é’*-“§*$;.?;-.___.  A’

3%? raaéig $§ zméeg: 5  ‘ ‘~ A V *
‘”§§’z”§;§$§’:’: §§ gaiéﬁﬁ ;*%;:§§  
giaéa 333$ Egsaw é1*2?.%§:’ag:§§i’ ‘;;&é§sf3;.i §E §f§é”§2ere 5,

Eméﬁaie §;$’~.§j:$kr;f’§%%f’§;§i§:4fg;:§::»§a $.a}%:§;ea%§e zmsﬁar

iéés gggzg  ‘  V   Q A’ _
 *§_;a§   .§.%3§é’é’ m;;§$§,§e Eig-

 %??G°%.§;iE§ Em aw? §§&€:&

VA  §’;L§ﬁ iﬁiaiﬁ 333$ §ag§@§

_ ‘_ ” €{_§§.=:r§%§g§§ ﬁgig Siam; <3:

V  ..  V” azié °%§3§3§:;%§; gﬁﬁﬁﬁ am éigzggmiaé

“”” H §::*:§ iéw giaié fmm 333; gage

gaziﬁiﬁa §§Z’§% ﬁ%i§i?;§3i’§’ mfzé $§.3$§

gaaég aw %%i§:g aarﬁgé 2% 333;

. AV §§ac§ azgigiéa ﬁm Siaia

H ﬁgé §;a-‘*§*:m: m? an? mag: §ez*$§:§~§:i;«$%&:*ga $3″

 gawk Vgraﬁiaie $313}: §:;.§.z’;2:§§§:, $33 ﬁéﬁﬁéﬁﬁaf?

§§:a§§§ﬂ::aiE§:: agmé aﬁiaiﬁ 3. izfagagii $933 E3
§§2.§§§§:::3.?.:@ ﬁﬁiéiaiﬁiﬁg 352$: §s§§ii§::§a,r$ 3% way
§3% §§f’§§$§”i§§i§% émm izégg §f§§§&:%§:§«&i§azfg§ ﬁf iézﬁ
§§.§§§: ﬁkézsk gag: as}: %m°§:*§§z afﬁg? Eiﬁ em§§;§ ‘i::m
§§:§ Sféaiﬁ $52’ aiteg: zzwﬁemeai ﬁgs 
ﬁﬁm iha gtﬁée 33 ike ﬁﬁﬁﬁ may ha?   ”

gfﬁaegv gmgmweyaﬁ fa: §i;;§__§a§:§i$’$:e§ts§g,§’§’  ‘§u§-<5"
ﬁﬁﬁiiﬁﬁ £3; af §§€ﬁ'£§$ﬁ §§3;3_«.%,..:;§;§¢a'§2b §2;:{§e§%z:.e§%§.::g:n:.'
9:' tﬁe gaaﬁg %§&§i¢§;s!2_ am»%:%Ag &§£:f'f'§' '§a%a=. €§3.é'~..
Sate ﬁr after :ne?&'z§.'$&:r3t E133: %£'-,*–€.:§;::9:_,n£1£:–.*%§;é'%£%2s§é 
iha casa may bg,
gzyrgg a;»mgA9g gag :gm§gi¢; a§gi;;kf§::azge ﬁg ﬂag

§'&hi$i$  §¢&§'i§4§*é'§f¥   $ii§1.E§§;§%§ itime

3 §€%§§§'–..§¥§f%§L§E~.§?&§E$i% _§é:=a§;;:§$ :9§'%%%a§:2aé Ezﬁéar szaﬁm
$%$§i§::–§_§;§_ :5 §§ﬁ§§:5e:?.'if_:§f§§e£'47:'Eﬁ-aﬁarge 2% iﬁe Eagi
,:.§§%;é££:%5§:;}é:f»_g§ §;:;?g* §k§::a%§,ffﬁ§r'._'§b}?é§%er& kig emf? {ram tha
ﬁiigégg _ V
§3:§ §f :§£'V'§a:fté§.::"§.'-"'.':_'§'?eas$ﬁ3 ﬁg ggaégi ea:§§%$ E3 3
 Egaééa *§*&§'_:;Vi;§c§& §.§:*%., aftééf gm???" igzié iha State {ﬁr
§;§%,§5z? Aagmmﬁaaemeﬁt ai m§'§§%m§ﬁi; as 2&3 
$  —  mweé mi: %f' :53 stage wiikiis. tﬁs
 §§§:F;n§§é'j__s%§:§§:2§a§aé :32 ikﬁ tmzigii paw? ﬁgs awﬁar

" .§i'atfh'le geeﬁs zgaéiiaie shall §a2mis€h ﬁg ﬁhe affieey
§§§§s§%&?&é $3 $33 kehaii' éﬁe mama fer gawk
 éeiay anﬁ sake? mxiiaiziarg, if my, %he:'e$§" mé
mzeﬁ afﬁsar shaii after éua enqizirgr exiaaé ﬁza
-.3
éiggga gs? éxigé ﬁg; $E3§%a%:§§¥ ﬁﬁﬁﬁﬁéiiég $15 %:%:”:;:§2§*£:
yaw:

§m%?i§€sé iéizai wégaza 82% gaeﬁﬁ  .

‘§’%§};§;§E& am? aféeg iﬁgig’ ﬁigirgs §£%iT_’%~”‘~’»E§1’%,£ﬁ§”~$5i;’%’§;z’:’?_, gift?  
aﬁay ﬁamzitiagmﬁgzaagi af m$*%%a9:.:,*§e’::.%%;’as;;”:  §i’;’i§3j$§7
ma? §}%§ %m3:2§§§§%%§   
ﬁﬁiéf ?§’&§;§§’%£’;?§§ ﬁg’ €:;§§3xij£§*a:1:%§e,»_?:§=:§*~. {§m,:.§ $§'”~W
ggmgirgg iéiai ifiiﬁ ga§e;%€3’é::. _§:;a§s?e .E3%.§.%:%;§;.3.§§§V:v§? §’::§%2*r&§

ms: Si’ éiw §s§,a.,,%_é’:M«-SE3;-.%§.V§E aiﬁﬁéz 9? gm

‘5§%§:§$§& wéa gwigi-§§:§§’§:’i’§§*§\.é;[g%.j%i.’»’_%..’_§z§ gagég iifiiiié

232% §i%%:+V%{   kk     
 “”” ‘-§ﬁ§s”§2:§{” %;€§f::;;%%V~. §a:%§’%%ée:?  $$%@:* §&§§§:3~§::-
:{_E§%.§.3’jg§::V %.”.’*.§-.§§’:§ ‘§§”§Z§i’.?i§ éaas 32$ $933333; zgzéiﬁ
$%;%§~–$$::%;eté’§fa’* §f’§%;§_;”…§’§’§%a,3;E jﬁﬁ §?§§§;§i§$é iiiai éézae
-g$§§§§ _£§a;2t*i?§&§’. éiéaéreéy Ezaara §&§ﬁ sieié: aavigézégg
  :$€a%§”?::§fg;>’—réiga gsarzggz §§ ﬁza *§’$§i§<'§§@ aﬁé aézaiaég
:z;v§%i%§*;i§§i§;$t3.::éx§§g azsyiigiag §$:§%$;§§iﬁ§ 2:: s§.s%»–
« %si:."%;4:;§~%%:f§§:s;;:;"':f"§§ 3%' gegtiaﬁ. 5? $3 aﬁﬁﬁéﬁéﬁ $3 :33 %§
%_§2s.'s: %:§§§%§€z $m§m2§'%§a& iza ﬁzég %@§§a§§ E23; %§£§
" 33§'&$m%i%§%§ ﬁ§.ﬁ§§'§3;§§g
§;§j:§f ikﬁ agsmer §§ iﬁe ¥%§i€§iﬁ gézgﬁgigzg
'A €:3%§a§;:3$£ ﬁm iragisit gagg $3 §§*a§'§é£eé §.:é§'.%§%§
§:§%»»§€$%§§:": §i§ ggiég §§ é§E§%m$' iéaa sagzm as
§§$'%E?§§$§ Eéﬁéﬁi" $%,:%»~g$$§§%:a§2§§ Em $3133: %@ Eiafﬁk
M}
ﬁg §:%3.,§§' ﬁg? $33.5; $3" §%:ia§f%§: 3 Siﬁﬁ ms: &K€%€§§§§

éazzbéa ﬁsa agzwémit 3%' ma §€%%?"i$;§§§ aa iﬁé .;g:::2§§$
éfmégyaﬁééi,
§§§'7§%:a amsaai §§' ﬁax azsé éééa _gp§§£§:§%€j;%.:'§é4§"§e;é§ _ 
ﬁﬁéﬁf @333 ﬁﬁaiims ghaiiﬁ§e'*:r*§:.§%z.%§§é§._ §}zg—i2:§",éé:A
§?&$§§§§€§ gifxagzgfgmu
§?§§¥%a%§§ :55 §z§ﬁ'é%"*%af  ééww
aﬁggggeé is if.-;a§; §,m:a";é'r-. '?$:.;:%«gé%:£§E.a::::.7 ééég §§

¢az*§§?§.::§g a§i&f"–:€e:;i:.:.:§2L ﬁsvgéﬁgvmsﬁig 3&3? gﬁﬁéﬁ
iaﬁgaﬁiﬁ agiéag §,%s§s  ;%.a§ ﬁg: ::é;"g§a::§;;§::;é vsésicég fzamza
 §i§$w.§%' é.§::i$$'§§%fr–.§§:,%'"%§a%ﬁ gm" Eﬁ$%§é§§§&EE'§ §§@i'i£%;
335 '{§% ﬁiéﬁé mag? %&§ %§.'§.€§
%§:§_:é§g  §§&$& mﬁﬁiéa aka Eéiaia
is?  §as§.%;=s.e%:V:g éégmazgiz §§§§ 32am 32%;?
 §:§§§e;%§::*§%:a§iE'—§:§«$%z§ri%§ may §&§§33§§§ imm gzézzéz
  m%§§:§%:*"~–a_:: azzzmmﬁ aqaiwaieaﬁ iﬁ wga iimaﬁ iim
 %;~,%;g.. V_%a«:»*%§§§§& ms gizeﬁ gﬁﬁég améar ﬁzig ﬁg: 33
§§::ef;:3§:§*i.é5§§:

.. §$§”‘§f§@ ggasgréfaéé aiiﬁafiig? aféiay ﬁﬁizzg
 sﬁiﬁﬁeﬁi iimi ihﬁ gﬁaég aaffiéé ézé %;§$ gﬁﬁﬁﬁ
‘aigéﬁiﬁiﬁ 3:3: :%§§§&£% $3? ‘%*’§§§§’§ 3&3 §§C”%.i§”§§i§?
§,,ﬁ”§;$§§,§§§ ‘§§§i§%3″ $:.:%m§ee§§§§:i’E§ was $§§§$a%$é§ E233
§&$§ﬁ§ §§2m§§§%z $33 gigieg siaaéi §&§:§§.g:§V_V’-§;é;§§§
§§§’§E?§%§”‘ agitaasami m %%e ﬁ’§¥23%§7s
§§§’E’1a§ gagaﬁﬁaé $,:2§§§_j@.:’;si’.§.i§ $3.5?  ‘4 
ﬁ3*’§€7§’ a§§::§%§: t%z& 2¥hé§&:=__§r,..g:f2§:,§aff’i- é,:rE§”<.L V

giemzgiiy ammmi §§§*§g.:"§s";e5zs.§3?: azgizgégzsé é§

éax $3: §&1?ia§'€:§? §a§va§§'&: '%2:a§§§ %:§.;'i;:;e.$j$:;*::é:%é§€§; '
$3? 313%; @%§§:2$§§,
Ex§§a::aé:i$§i~~l Egg  §€::§§§é   z_?2. ﬁseéziﬁéa

€3*%§§§$§ _   j§=é€<sj;%:f$§§'%. R_ is? 1«§*:§¥a§ ibg
§§a::§e.§§}'§§i%§i§§3  '3__§,g${§:;§E$. 'gywgagaae ﬁﬁiﬁi'
%,gsé'&*é*§..¢*:;sT:§";;» "§:§:*–%s=;§*–a§':3§e":va§2§{:§& shaéﬁ iﬁf

?§..§:$: g§s§§"§§§{:}g.a;j:é  '§%s$§m:§ $8 ééﬁiﬁﬁﬁ

. V . ?§
is %g %§%&":§é¥;$'2:3<""::3§;4*:§ :& ¥%§:;£@§&§
 ?§7e§aa§§g§§*§§§;§:'; ééizéﬁﬁ §%.§%»$é@i§m: gag: af gas;
–  :2:;§§$§§,x€%§i§ £3 % m§:§i%,§%;*:§€
  Z§$§§:§:a%§a~ p;*%.§zm:§%§§§§ waaéﬁ Eigiéaié
 §ea:_:$::!:;’ Agagaizagi azﬁgam iiae imgazﬁﬁé aséaz cama
 iisfaé “gaésgéﬁ %§ ﬂag €§%%§:=~§§$§, ®§’§”i$er mast éa %%§iE%
 $3.§§$§§ 3&9 gﬁéﬁﬁriiias ﬁat ﬁiﬁfﬁ W33: 23% ﬁ¥’a§§,§§§
 ”  gmymﬁgzi afiax. E?’ $325 iaigxaéiigzg af §’;§”ii% Egﬁgiazgge
*a%§e ﬁg §@ iégaé §§:$$§%£%§%¥e Q? gaymaggi 3%’ ‘mg 3:: iiiw
gmﬁﬁaa iii qazastémzg §a:a%*a::$%a.%E% §§’$§3;.§§7i§§§€@ﬁ was
a%?§;i§a%§% ii} iiizg a$$%§§&&§ ﬁiﬁii %%?§§%§§%§ ﬁmge; 
ﬁﬁﬁfﬁ gaﬁéasiﬁéf £3 §3;§z::aat ﬁf igx $3″

igmiavs-aifga Egg vigw af ﬁg Vigei %§;::g.5i:= w

a”§*§:i§§m% %¥a$ aiiaévéaé ta §e §§”§3i§g§§.”§L’ 
’31?” ii: Emstiaxag ii avéziisﬁ §§a’v-swag %i€3– *
astaﬁiish iizai in §a§€ E’?  ai exit
aémgia §@§§: ﬁé’ témi €,§:’§;g§§z§.§$j. §§f,%s;::§;:§?:::§§:§e:3; éié maﬁa

ﬁiii 3%’ %:ka §%;§§.’%’.§, f?§e:§f:=éj:§’$;§’2?a;{;._§’:*a§.%:”§:§%§m2 9%?’ §$.§e
wiiixii: i§:;a ‘§i%,,_%é$, *;.§?;;€:§§3;.§§. gm? %@ a%:’a§,§3.§§&- Ea ﬁiﬁ

mggmgeg »
 ‘?; §:§ €§g:’*.:g_ §§’*&$:ﬁﬁ? gaga iéza gaiﬁazziiﬁzé @§ éﬁzase
.agaggﬁi:::;,$’§ﬁs§;$%§::%,§:%’ wag aa éiéaa ﬁgféﬁi éémé aiaéag
 %’%2%§’_v»–_;é::?é§’%%&§* af iéga ‘%%:i§§§§ iﬁg mﬁgnag §f iéza
g$§§i$” ;ag.,%§’§§. égaaraﬁéaé ﬁészéaagﬁ ﬁgs eﬁﬁgégzaf aﬁﬁ ﬂag
  §{:s:i§a:;A§i§:§ﬁ ﬁiﬁfﬁ eggs 33$ téze same. ?1°:%§§§@§%§ ﬁgs

A :§zﬁ”§A:*& farmgiiiiag at fézwa ﬁézaﬁk gag: ‘wag Eﬁaéieé
wéafiﬁz Ehy $33 :”&§m§%§%aii¥a 9%” am gﬁaéx Eﬁﬁém iihé
aériggas aayiza ﬁmaagiiy %5§{3§i§§ §§ iiéitaraéte ‘vgmgéé xii}?
 maﬁa  ézjémfmigia i§E?%§§§§a§§§ﬁ %s& 3%:

kaaw iﬁg éaéaikg, £§§&.f%ﬁ€§§ ix: iﬁis caﬁ, 3&3 ggaég
kaﬁ iﬁ m$?$ §’mm §§a::gg§$§e 52$ ?%:~:é%i:§§;s&:°§?§”‘%a§%:%’3é::i;%::§
ﬁg ﬁiiiﬁiéﬁ izim Etaia. $:;§-gas. {2§ ai’ 
émziemgiaiﬁg ikggé $43 gﬁsés i-;§.s;pm€€£e€§E V§_7§’ ‘ 
if mﬁvﬁé ma: asf ihe giaéeg ﬁé  
?§$$§ Lag ihe §§*i’?$§ $1? ti§:§2:§”;22*:z*sya;:n’..§§n%  iksé”
§§E:§€§.§w ‘§h§ 0 ;§?a:;s%:mpt§z§’§A’§2::§§’&: si€§;.§&=€;?:. ﬁﬁ-§ ﬁg

aéreaﬁy gtaieﬁ Eg a I’§&;§:3£:3{§’i”§:f&§::3§§ ;§§f7e$§’;:§ﬁ’:%_§;i§§2a aﬁé ihg

§.§§$}§&i§$ r&;§§’£’,%:+fg f_:i3§§.§ %_;%:%’:@2*«§1é ‘3:+rf_”ﬂ.%;§{‘. assamméﬁi ﬁf
ﬁg a@:’:s%.;:;é§§.%i-:*:”g§§z9 ‘%:?§2§$§s;:§§s:ig::é£f: a:sr§’ ﬁg gaaége
€32, E3%j:f:::%§”s§;:}i{%§:3§§i:e:% §§ ﬁm §f&’%%’%mze igag ix
‘%?§%%¥ a§”;%g;é’§t ﬁg itﬁa ﬁ§£§%~§§$§ §§?§m§*
 §e$»§%;;3;§;§§:2g  ‘€§i?€% ?%§:§§§ éavﬁgtigaiiam wag
  ta éég aaamzzzia af  %?§”%%
Egieéizfsm ‘;_§1%ra%§: éaigﬁigﬁﬁaﬁ wigg 3%” ﬂag §%¥é§EE§% aisa
A   ?§§§i§k&%?§§§ ga §$§’ as ﬁg §§:§i§@gg $3′ Eggs…
 ;’§§§1§&ia: Faim. ‘5§’%@ maiﬁfiaé that was gaaeé %§§@2r*%
ﬁgg aasesséﬁg §§§§$m? Q: thg iime gf fiaai ayéés af
2;

ﬁgﬁﬁﬁﬁﬁzﬁﬁﬁi iﬁﬁiﬁaiﬁﬁ avfhaéaﬁgar ggﬁég ﬁmi “§%§&
§:’:’;§m%§§§§ Es%i 3, gmézzci aaﬁésﬁ “::&§§§3$ﬁ $533 %;1Ei ‘–:§’a§i
mat ‘:9 Fégzﬁsiaizerggz aﬁé was $.§$§.§z*::i’%l:a?:§_L-“,j
§m:a§§;£§%e§§3m 3%: wag §”§§§3. ﬁﬁfiifiﬁﬁi $3: éﬁ;,€{:12[‘§i:fa§_?.§E;%;§€;§=$§  »’

géﬁafiiﬁﬁiii ai §m:§§@§:%§r§.; E:

éﬁiaimies ﬁat? ftéaai ﬁg-3,3 .§a§?§3ﬁ.’?§§é” ﬁg 
Eﬁﬁiﬁﬂ §&§a;:*%::2%§:% wag $.§$V%ﬁ:> aéﬁ, aw iém
éézgéégzgg gi’ iizé aﬁgéz:-‘2.§§’;§§–§*a§§§§§;’:§f’§,*,§%’;’.% éggémgg mzcﬁ ﬂag
a§$&$§§;§;ag 3g.2ﬁ:2_m*§%’.§z.~V%;25§f;§ ‘°§:§:sa%§&%;:§”‘-%;?’§s§:e aagaagmgzéi
§§*§::§$§:»; 3§;f%f:§ §.%%i§%:§g:%’5;, %£;;«.§ :§:§: §::%?@$ﬁ§%%;§:§:3 gag; 
“?;f,s”‘Z2,.§,$$§§.”§;§=_’,,7§*f §f 3′ $3 :*;.§:3%:§~’:;.:;sj§£sz:§:%;§.;iz.g 53%’ “§;§§§ ai axéé 
§§$$%:;§ ﬁﬁ §§§ 3,$’%§’i$;’-‘§§ﬁs%§§ ?§i§*$ 5.3 ammamaég. ii wag
 “ijégai «é.§§m %%:§ gsmég iﬁaé wage imgagiseé
‘%§§%a§<:3Af'E¢§.:"%;z«3;&%'*:'s2{'T~.zé§&§;§§ i;§ ie smzéi: Ea §'a:m§2§;€i:$:r§§' ﬁg
§&a:.£%§V___v§L;:§::~é§§§§;;§§§ 333$ aw: wag: 3. giagiﬁ ézzcigégzrtgi
 ?§§T§:§:*€=–§E§:£: 3"€§3'%2:'£E$ wag aﬁia ta asiahiigéz $1932? 2: wag
\¢'\
' .é§*§s-.:'§$' %§§§§§§;§E'§ éésa $f§:§;ia§ E-Ea $33.3 §¥;,3:$i§§§£¥§ iii §&§?i§3§ éfégafz
-‘iég asgaggﬁe ﬁg» Egifgg, ¥§?§%§§ §§§:§’§ Ema? ﬁézﬁﬁzégsieé aéi
i§;a§ %§a§§ $33.? ways §.:§§§§z:%§1 %§? tézgem gzzé imiéziggg
f3
?*”.:%§@§;:£f:£-{E §§’$§”§i 622% émik E3: ﬁgai %?§@’i%§ %§ ‘£T§’T£% ygsaéimg
§§%:&§: §:;a:,:% $33’ wags Qf §%%a:2%:€£&§ %E¥§§§?%§§§::$§.”~.._%.§§$
agspgiéagﬁ, raiism E§§é§§§ iéaa af$§§§§§’ﬁ§§f3;.§– ‘VQ4%§f’Ifi§;;%?%?
§€§’i$;§.§i§ﬁ§ 3% Eggs ‘i?§;a§%§§ ?&%.m§, iii ﬂag a§s$i7%.?:%::$é&§’?~$éV§  
§§§%f§ﬁ:§@§ii $:§§&:§’§§§$§:§g §§:a?§: §§:§é”;% §:,’§si§§’§é%;;’% “§§: gétiéﬁg-Z aégééég aka

awéﬁzg af iha a§§@§§,;§;:.e §i:§€§V§§§2r§1;§,.§;~–_ £3 3 iéﬁatéer 9%’
Eaéi.-§ gag gazﬁsgimzsaé ;3;_§§%§,”2.;e:::§;%,§§ §;§*é§”§V.i3%;-V*’€%°é§: gﬁfai ié
ésémi  iéiﬁﬁééeﬁéi-% &”%;5*i§§$’7;f:§$ :*§§§%§ 33;:-$32 32$ §Z§:§%:
w;%§:3&§”‘.;§§’._%:§:a_ §§:”§§;?:.§:@§§T’T:,:;g:$.;§§ gﬁzafzézezn iiza ﬁfémi 3:7 ﬁx

a$$§;g;%E.::g”ig2::%’,§§e:;:r_§.%*,§:_ §:§’g:;§. gaaaémé §ﬁ3;§f,:’§” 33% §E.€a;é%’&’
  €33; ﬁg §”%f;3’i::::=z* Emﬁé, ﬁm isaﬁzeé §§¥$§§§ﬁ%§§
 §%g&%§?a?3§.§2:.§:$’» ggamggéz. ﬁg %2fiﬁ§ 3% $23: Eéﬁiiﬁﬁ iézaé
féiérag §§¢;’=-§..%.§*’:,{}§f &§%%$§::§§::§_ §§%E”§£ﬁ.§§%§§§ 5% $1,332 §?§”§?ﬁ§{
 ?§§:¥:;§,f_%;%§ag§ ﬁm szzbggei §§§%’3′.%§” Q’ ﬁéiﬁ ﬁﬁﬁiﬁ 3:e’s?§$§$::
 ggiéiimz QE; $12: ﬁe revisiagmi §.§§§?:$f§i§?
_..§:§:§ﬁ§;;:§é 133% saié mrﬁiegr ﬁf asgéggmeizii af ﬁgs
aﬁmggigzg §§§£§:: ¥§§1%§: mace éiézﬁ arém Q?
ﬁﬁﬁvﬁﬁﬁmﬁﬁi Q’ %§;’$., “%?§%:aE§ ?%%§s§ Ema raaﬁﬁéé ﬁgzaiiifgg
i%:: %%?’£”:%§§§ zmé: §§ @§%§E ﬁg ﬁg §$§aré:3:z@§§: ﬁg 
ﬁm ggaészzazzgféiazz %’,§ﬁ§:§§:.” $z:§=~§%$a géé ﬁi’  
33% §F§&§;§§%§§ aasgé ééza gamé E3 13%    
ﬁg 33$ %%§¥% ﬁiégsaiﬁﬁiargé azrsé  §:é”% ‘_
$§§ﬁ§L{§§§.; §7i% §.§§e&§

a%€f§$?§§§§g§§?,, $253   agéﬁs

%:::r;§ §§a>§§~:§ $§ ‘%§§§?EI53″%i%’§$3§:§§%’§;’§;§  :§.a%.§§i%E’§.§:”§§’ €§a%:.i::’§

ﬁg’ E§”;§%§g”.  13$?   ‘:’%£:2§’%?-aifsaéé §r§f,«:.,,-‘:2

%,§:§§ a§§§:i§~;/fjétgggé  ‘  Q3’ gmiaiégﬁ 
  éézzaa :”aa3:::2%,%;$ 
?\
Sdfi

Iudga
3&1

‘Judge
‘-§;lz;*3:g;sa%
Share this:

				Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
				Facebook
			

				Click to share on X (Opens in new window)
				X
			
Like this:
Like Loading...


	Related
Sri Gopalakrishna Shetty vs The Additional Commissioner Of … on 29 September, 2010

Share this:

Like this:

Related

Leave a Comment Cancel
