High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri H D Anand Kumar vs The State Of Karnataka on 24 August, 2011

Karnataka High Court
Sri H D Anand Kumar vs The State Of Karnataka on 24 August, 2011
Author: V.Jagannathan


€fi€}N$I%3QL?§3N”§’£…’;-‘ £}’IS{3§~{AE2{2 123:, mzé: :;>;.%_::vr’:’1<:";:-J1+:R §:*RM
‘:’z~’v1:’«:. 4352213 C:ASI€:.. *

WES E”E?I-T; *zx::~rx: {,’1€f§é’.\:Ih”-EC} ow mi-ia A_;.>:xxz;jS~i§éi’:3’r£_’ .

£52′-E_”:’C TEE E7} GER} EEK’ §\/LiX[f}§§ ‘E’E”:I.}?; }?'{T3LI,O’»V§N{}: _

@R95g

‘§””I1is; p€1;:if:.ion is ci.i5_~:=g::Qsi:¥d..V of £”i’;1ai§>yf éa_.f1’t:£::~:j'”}2::%;;;fiz’3_g =

£92-1§’:1e{i sztatmsel for i:§1§:.p:1:t:iVe§::«a ‘
2k The p€tii’,i:1€.j£” is-.5?_’:5e.f<_;r€.fééii-3 <::<3z:1r'§ bz:-sirigj

2:§;§__§3'§eve£% bj;j€;E':'::_V !c_':=:}:.1:5i: b§3§._§€::«w~.di'S:;5iV$S£':'1g Ezisé-a app1i<:a'§,ic:}r1

fiiezid s3:5a;§ :éo:.ms;<3E {hr the
})€i.§'§{.i(TfVE:1f;?E' "S'E'§:§T3'§§Efi5:$VV' €:_Eé21f£f; b£%_f:§'%€ éiizéé r:,w *i;E3e
p<:éf;1'i',§.<é:<::3:' Eiezxf .1j2*si_:<§f':?:.:i't-Iegfinéjztea}; g.§'r<3':.'::K§s in $u:p;::<:~ri. sf hiss

E-£§§§§§}is"..E1'{.i{'}f1""f§§€'?{§..3;}:/S".22'? sf €:".P'{1 sséeking <i§&s:tha:";,§<;é,

-‘E”h”:;.’:’3{is :.’:§g€:{§ was-2 E’ha€.! the-‘r pez*s.;u

3%Ei_s>ge;§..:V’=%:i_a::é’ Ef:21§{=:é §}€:<=,:z p_:°€.s;{§::;";i; <§12r.i:1g;;;; €:E";:=: i§':s:i:i:§{%r1%: if};

<;z.:;e:?:;:+s%.,§;}::~ szifééi sssaizi {£2 E':a12;e :"em;’3’§:.2.é%:am’ E1213; ‘:zzi;’§ §:§§%<:2:z :':3;a{ie 93:27: ;::§%:::,1¢%€:{§( in

' '*éJ'{j}'E'{"§E:§§ 342% ;<-;;;.~:§<:§. _'§}€;;"i'§:Fs{,}§'1 §€;*z;;§;§':2:é;25:;::;32: ssaéé R: %i:g;.2r@,

' " {ha-3 <'}§:§*:;%':'";{:<% zmii E35: '§':a:::~.–.'–; 'i":{1}éi §"£"T:é:%.¢i'.§€;'T' E-§€?=i.??;,.éE%€:'.'{.§

§§§’£:.E”3E=,r ihingg’ zmd 1;:h<=: v21.Zi£§'£'i:.:,,7 Qf $16: s;2,u'1<:£f.io2'1 rc£:’:r $2222.11
be {mi}? g(“32’1€ mm by €316. ei{:«w {i1:r§’::1g %;i§’:x<;_:~.z::_§<?;-z._<;:T.=:.~;e.

{)5 {he i'-rizfl.

4. As far the :w{:::*ss3.t’i:::1 in E V-b§.:t’.fé:€,3;i:./’§j)@:f;

<:2,1m<1em. is; {iTOI'?{{_'.€:'.I"E'1€',{L éhe Ee21r:'zé%{£=.;:;:<3m':s:3%;%i £x:.§'€:1*:":3:i'"?§3%.__f€:}2;;%A

s::’:xr::::-sat’:i{>:.1 wh.1’f{§€h %::::<i
£~'s.m1ex–F to the p:'eSe:;1%:' sf tihs:

$211318 wouiii gg;{:= £19 5;E:§;i*2;1:’;.’?2V_aiAa%L%:E.}t:§u. as alieged by
Eihi’. <:<}n'2pEainar2§;did 1:fe;§'«:a;s -§§E:21é:'<;?.,_::, i'.E":<-3% {)f{§€':}' 0
the €3{)'{3'{f,

5:, s;id€::~:=, 2:2. per:.::s:~;aE Sf
i;.}:3.e {ii:<:;<:1<;;s~3e ass {:0 $3»-*}1€§.}";€r 2151.3?

Qf {he {i{u}’;f}.j4E.€§£?_V*£,§{§iT2§§ ‘ ;:i’:a.§_f..’L’ £7asard $33? Em? g3€3:§i1?E,i<}:r:€r':§

{f:{}§_§'§';§'f,}:;-f'§ "wgew: (:'5:§:":s:j;§;j_§§_e;'<-3d :10? ::_E':a<:é {%<é{:is»s§’:’:s3 {:i%:€::i; h;«:v:;’.

‘§;;=eéz:.V V §’iE?1i§{53’.é~7E’€”:.4%’§ifi”‘iii W_i’1£;%:’: ‘i;§’:e ;:«e*£.§€..§{7»:’:<'~:»z" :*'2:.£:=;es3 S632-'€ifE'1?3;§

gg;E'°{}i,:':?a%:i§; '§:=iV'Lj*§;z};';3;.~;z*”é: af iuhss: EiE}§}.§i{?E.i§Zi{}E’1 ti}: Ci§f§3{Z§’i£’1§”§_:;,§€’;?,, it

‘.V*s,-mssa; §T.E:.€:” a:i:::”§; izaf film? a::°<::'z,m: %:§s:Ea:;1.;=.; 21:"; iémvs:-:=. <.?{}§":E%§.{,§€£*§'é3{.': 2-iii

'~:A:§'.§":V{,3;Ei§é:f~"{"f{}Ei'.1€Téc':f"§'E§{j§§'EE§ ;i«:_1.':{i §;E':%:: <_':{;}':.jz.:"E: §i§'§iEE'{fé:i§i.€;E§" wzéfié. §".§é',%'¥{':% §:<:2

' .:":;:%::z:'a<;:':.:%§ éi: ;»::::%<t_t:;=:;}§::és~; één? $2a§{'§ ,;:;:"<;:.::é&:=; z’1<~: by '§§"1€ <7<1)a..1r€'. bé:i(3W.

S. For the f:§.b{)’.:’€iT rt-32z5s(>:”:ss;, in. mjg~1._*2:i:c:i*»:+3; :”- .

§;’:2i&’.{.€%r §’€quér€rs 1’eIz2a:1{i fez’ 1116_p2v:;fp<}s=;§€"if"Z*1'£;é21§€:";§g;. -:31-"av

'E',§1f3 ;.1ppE§n Em’ {ii-5::charge°:.af:’§§:é;%’£ m:1″~:;s :é:.2V§(*:%i:.§ -7%:

etieem it L,:.z1m3c:esSa1:”y to d<i%;i1"'vg:it,E3 i:'7;'1:€: {?()I1'§V,€:%'EE.f.f{}§;1S":§3.iZi", *

f01*v=.2*211"d 1;'.<)1:£3'h.i:'1g.; 1,:p0;i'1 t..I'1e m_@:ji"£:S '<':»fEE'?1r1€: <*;a~:%=<ii,

F0; iihe abave I"4i?'.Ei;'3:€_1r_1'"A.i.i§.;"'1\'.Fif§".v p§iE'§.{'i»:31i a1§:::\¥€€i and
the §r;1p1,:;__§';";.e;i «€3;:f<i*-231* i".}_,}€;'::;?{"':{}«1;ViAi'"€.' E$3?€f1{}"§i?' fig sseé, :'~_'}.53i€ié3 emd

{ha ifiai :éé}§L.z:'i._"'–i.g§" '{i3i1.';°€t(i§éf3:;i 'i;:)__ 13 <3V:"¢:_I' iftaez paflifis af:'€:~:sh an
ihe 2zp'131i'{7éa£iV{}f:1 f"iTé:é1 §E;~:jV"dis;:Eé;i'*ge am} §;h::’z ;3m::t€<;*;::§ in

392135 ?i:§i:.:i:f<:i€%:'. *;:1 ::ur:iEe::b;9é;E–:;:§3.=::§: wfih igmn ii: :53 aim rzzeids

<:.§é?a:"_Efih;:f. {Eta"a£"Q:'<%:é::é2::i<§'"'i:»bsemr2:'é.§<ms Shéifl :2;§; I’:a;v<3 any

., ,,«..E}{fEi'i"§':'H§;i"*~A <}:d E§1fE:i£§r':':?é:% an i:;%3.<–": 'maxi; {?(".)'é.T£.§'§',9 £.:'::+;z}:f:u'

j__'E?i1§':»:a£'E'§2 «g§:;.:"i',i§–§-is {:21 §;:Z":::i–: .5}.p§f}§I§C.'&';},iiE€}i"3. {£1}? {:Ei§§<:.E2a:';§<-3

e1£'::-75%: {:g:;~11{':e;':':<1:e:L

3&5"

:§§.§§§§l