IN THE HIGH" COURT OF KA'RfNATAKA AT 'BATE\ICTgA'--i',jOR.E
DATED THIS THE 08"" DAY 0;? _M_AfiRC}E:i';"2'0,V'i~:£3_j: _
.BEFORE.....
THE HO.N'BLE MR. IUSTICE
W.P.No.16E;5GQZ29{)7(§--REG):
BEFITW HEN:
1. H.M.RAMACHANDRA_ H
AGED ABOUTV4-§Y.[¢;AR:}' _ _
WORKING AS
ADMIN'I'sT--R?A1'IvE;:¥§B~1aAr«1::H
CRAWFORD.PiA_1;1, = _ " -- .
UN1V¥:Rs3TY'01~' MY«SO'¥%}?i '
MYSORE':.~ - " ,. '
2, 4_;f13 NA_G:EN1j;%JAV: V ,
A<;E:1)2..,Ats©I}'1" 40 Y'iEA'.1is
» jv--J()£R OF sf:'Um:Nr WELFARE
* OFF1CE.¥gV.'i§EANASAGANGO'£'R.1
MYSORE. _
I>RI:SENT1'LY ON DEPUTATION AS WARDEN MANAGER
.. V' n v%1sL1T\;1;SHvARA1AI{ P.G.1-1os*1T'EI..,
[3 _UN*IVERSI"E'Y OFMYSORE,'i'UB1NAKERE
,_ .£\riAN']i)Y'A.
"3. 1:-i.v'.NA<;ARA}'A
ACEED ABOUT 44 'YEARS
@\,~n
'I
WORKING AS CLERK IN UNIV'£€RS1".I'Y
'1£NGINEER_I'NG DI.'v1s:1Q:N'
sA:R.AswA'm1pURAM
O E?POS1TE TO FIRE BRIGADE
UNEVERSETY OF MYSORE
MYSORE.
4. T.S.DW.ARAKINA'I'H
AGED ABOUT 42 Y'l3lA,RS T x
WORKING AS SECOND DiI'V1SIQN C1i..ER__K :_
ADMINISTRATWE BRANCH '
CRAWFORD HALL
UNIVERSITY OF MYSORE
MYSORE. V ._
5. DANE. KUMAR A
AG_EDABOU"E'v38:YEAREjg' V _
WORKING AS C1L;22Rg 1;\:'='1'1--£§a"'
EXAM1NATEO35'E'..BI{,}S.N(IH1., _'
CRAWFO'?RD EIALL;-».,_' . "
'UNIVEI{S_I'I'Y_OFVMYSGRE-.___V
MYSORE. «. 4 " V.
6;: Z ..... V' »
'V " «_A' 'f;x1s1'1K:.N'G.V'As_'<;:1,£m ABOUT 44 YEARS
}WOR1<1NG AS SWEEPER
_ .. {ZOOLOGY DEPARTMENT
UNIVERSITY OF MYSORE
MANASAGANGO'.I"H'R{', MYSCJRE.
i:;~\i/'v'x.§
1...:
8. A_RAVIKUMA.R
AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS
VVORKINC} AS WA'1'Ci~1MA.N'
SERlCUI...TURE Ef)I+IPAR'.1"M'EN'1'
UNIVERSI"_{'Y OF MYSORE
MANASAGANGOTHR1
MYSORE.
9. CNAGARA}
AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS
WORKING AS WATCHMAN INF-c)QD
ANI) S.C.DEPAR'I'MENT,
UNIVERSITY OF MYSORE
MANASAGANGOHIRI.
MYSORE.
H). NINGEG()W_DA__ " .
AGED _AI30U'I* :35';y.I«:A'R%3--_ 3 'I'
WCJBVKINGAAS*WA'§iCIHMAN _
AD1\rI'INIsTIm;I"IvTI3:-»BRAN:'(;';:'j:3A:I'a=,:§_II">IJI<
V Ac}v:I£.m3130'UiY 38 YEARS
._ VQ'.QRVKIN'G__fxS"'WATCHMAN
;r\_DMIINI.ST1_'3A'I'fVE OFFICE
UNEVE.RS1"i"Y 01? MYSORE
MANA_SAGAN(?O".i'}£.R1
" .. " I\k'I'..:fS()R.}33.
I2:D.IAI<
AG-'ED ABOUT 35 YIIARS
W0 RKING AS VVATCTIIIMAN
ADM INIS'1'TRA'I'IV.1'?. OFF I CE
L1
UN 1V E RSITY OF M. YSORIEI
M A N/\S.AC]AN(.}()'I' H R?
M YSOR ES.
1 3. IAGATH BAHADUR
AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS
WCDRKING AS 'WATCE':IMAN
ADM}NES']'RA"I"I'VE ()FFlC'l'iI
U'N'IVERSiTY OF MYSORE
MANASAGANGOTHRI
MYSORE.
14. GANESH BA1~iADUR
AGED ABOUT 34 YEARS .
WC)RKING AS 'wA'1'CH'M_AN _
A.DMlNiSTRA'I'fVE OFFICE .
UNEVERSITY OF,M'YSORE .. _ _ '
MAN.AS.AG.AN.C}C)T1-IR] "
M'Ysc3R£:." " * ~» 5
15_M.S.i,,Q'K1'jSi~£ " -
AGED A.E§OU*}.'vI%Z3 Y.jr.«:A=3S
wc§m<1'N'c; AS-.SW'Tfis1P'.'i-'If9i'5{
YWA 3jA}gys <:A_R"rM1aN*:"' 0:: 1_~11_<:; H 13:12 [!',DUCIA'f'EON
._ * {.}()V'I£'RNME1N'E' ()9 .KA.R.NA'!'A KA
.M.UE ,'.1'] S'I"OR}1{1') BUILDING
B ANGA LOR1Z~56O O01 .
5
2. uN'1_'vI;Rs:1':1'*y 01: MYSORI41
V131~:1'vAv_1DYAN1LAYA KARYAS()[.J'Ii)']--EA
CRAWFORD HALL
MYSORE--S7O 005
REP. BY" yrs REGI_STIRAR. . K __ .. _
.R15:3'1i'N.'I)§::':x§"rs;.___f
(By Sri. T.P.RA}ENDRA KUMAR s1J'N§;;:Ay;----ADv_, .I%'Q}u{ 1'{Q_ V'
Sn. R.B.vENKA'1*ARA.MANA, Hcjqp tE'Q.R_;u '
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA Qtf:ASE~§ TE--IE
ORDER DATED 25.9.2Q()7 AN--NEiXEF'R.E1~I,) PASSi§;.E.') BY THE
FIRST .R'ESPONDEN"I" jI_%1'j_7_'CZ. . ~ _
THIS WRI"'l" PE'fI'1'EC=N ~.._V14'1'Lt1;"'1:3.. V'E_/:'J'f4%a' 2:27 ACJ35'
This petition C0vII1'iI'.g.:L311V'fi1{')I7t> 1"1'E'.'EV1'}'."z}"1..g';."['§'1iS day, the court
made the fo1lQ'w'i':;g3*
IIJER
Erfithis writ pétit§t}%i'.»tthe pet.itio1.1er.<s have prayed for a writ
in»»'¥~&Vl.1e hziture dfvceV_3__r___t_&i(;Iar.i to quash the order dated 25.9.2007,
V :.+\t1vn§eXv1,1fe?_I') xtté--2:116 writ petition.
' S"e_:Ct5}iti respondent appointed the petitioners dming the
y’ear~.19;_93m94 on temporazfiv basis as Clerks, Sweepers and
;We§”tCl1me.:1. In the matter of [“6-?g?.11£i1’iZG{jL)I}. t:>’f’ p@{i[j.()11E’..?.”S and
___isimilar]y placed employees, .<;econ<§. respondent – '{fi11i\4-'c;*.r.rt on 16.EE.1996.
The Syndicate vide resolution dated 23.6.1997 accepted the
recommendation of the S1llf)’COE13§33l'[l.€€ to regnlarize theservices
of petitioners. Accordingly, the services of petitione.r.s_ c;n1’1e’tta” be
regularized between 19982000. ‘.[‘l1ereafter__,M_the–…(}o_§iernrrientV’9′
issued notice to the second respondent M [Lini3¢ersit’yjlto sl3.~:§’w’ cause
as to why the regt1larizat.ion_”of the. pet.itionersWcgnniot be,”
cancelled. Since the second resp(3nrlAen_tl*«..E.f7n%velr’s–ity {hiled to react
to thewshowcéitisellllncsticeisstiedl’hywthe Government, they passed
the irn_:)ugned– Anne:-;ure~D dated 25.9.2007
cancelling the 1=es’olLiltion of the Syndicate dated 23.6.1997
V ‘ «regtJiari§’.ing”t.he petitioners. Hence this writ petition.
a Heard arguments on both the side and perused the entire
” papers.
7
4. The Supreme Court in Secretary, Stare of’ Kgrrrlatakaa and
otehrs VS. Umadevi and others (2006) 4 S(}’ICI 1 held in pare»-f33 as
under:
H/’E’ afso c/a21’1’1f_’V that 1’egz1]a1’r’2azr1’r)11, ;’1′}9n__*;”a;’re;2~d },?”z12as«.<;I'e?, ..
not sub 'ud1'ce_, need not be rec) 3er1e=c?.bz1.s;e5a'A. -5217 i!.71L¢~ 'Lr'd:'»i72.e:.2£j"' 753111"
rhere sboufd be no fi_1rzil2er -__Z74;1'2;;?_a:»".s*1'Jjg '_o1" ride "ct_c_§"1'1;s°£;1f11'1'rJ12a'1' V'
requrremenr and regrz/a?;';}s"j12g,0)' r13g§'.£'1bg; perrrrérrerirf, those not
daffy appointed as per the c011,9r1'ffrrriej12g_;J._$:;'i§3me.
Therefrjere, irr:-p»L:g_n.e<i'"Order passed by the C}overr1ment
is liabiezo be qr/Iasiaecflh
:1. *1: is breu ht to Inv notice that in iéentical
rCir.g:umsti1'nces;_,"' the Government has withdrawn its order
cancelin {he resolution of Syndicate in res ect of Kuvem u
' P
iiziiversity. Therefore, there is no }ustéfé<:ation for the
(3-overmrrem in continuing the imprzgnerfi order.
\x'm'/Ii»
6. Everi citherwise, as per the resoititioii of’ synr;1i{;:1te 03″
second respondent A Univ’ersit’y on 23.6.E997, peti_zi’t5iie«r$ :_theA
beneficiaries. After iapse 0;? one degade. re;’sp’o’1idei1t’s’V.without”
providing an opportunity to the §)eti’t«%’_rS”}3aSiéGdA’t.he ‘§§’§”;_’E)’tlgAI;IKQ’.(.}
order and as such the is’–Q1.ip.L)sed ta. pV1″i,I1(C’%;p}C-.SV'(V_V)f\ riaturalii
justice. Accordingly, tléié*fQ§1owirig§’ V
dd .._j\\x’ri:t._ peititirirris A hé.reby..éiHowed.
I .in-«-
\._~/
‘,:i’r”.r’1Vj1\_:>1:gr1_’ed order dated. 25.9.2007;
is §i quashted.
Sd/~
EUDGE
Diire. i