12¢ "I'HE: ;%£§Ci~H <;:0{,::e'1* :39' £{AE~?:f?JA'FAi{A fi£4f"B,fi=.§'§§£L{';}RE4_
I._':rA'?E}} W13 THE 1%"?-ii3A';'«C}§4f';}'¥§i1f°iLi§;._f2{§I§9 V'
:3 RE 8 3
THE'; H{),N'8LE i*»fi's'L*%';:';},{.§S'§V'.§'i:?--'~';E:f ~v£x§g%:::§h_:§:%:+§§;%»;i§3'M
THE }~§C2§\§'BL"¥3 ME'... fig
:§r1z3::7E 1%:3?;'s3;::3§:2:\::vAs§; (}€;JWDA
"i¥':*i'{:'~A-:gsS: §iaj3__«;e:i_a1 M; 1%4::é§'*19§;}2G0s {S-Res.)
Betweez'-55:, --::_ '
S:'i.;E£_. N , Chikkfigav-'sda.. _'
Sfrf§::fi:"af1ii*z':'f1I'.::§q P»-'-£033. the gewices) anii
_ _t__;'.at.; .S.3jiiEe§:i§mpa,
A Viiadiraxiagaz' Kmrempu Read,
'i:*§at§,%_é;i1.:a1ga}a viflagfi and ;}o€:£,
HaSsa;:n taiuk 85 13351;.
Anfiz
1.
Kamataka Pfismr Tfra_:1smissi{;n
Carpn. Ltci,
Rep. by its Cilxaimzaga,
Appflfiant,
V {By M1′ 3.Si.3bb::~_a1’a$ 3:16 $0., Aév, far ap;:s€.113:1t.}
bk? ,
€i3_1.1Ve1*§; Bfxavazi,
Bangalore —» E360 D09′
2. Thfii Cihixzf Enginttttr (Z83}€t;:1.),
Mangalare Zone,
Marxgalere Electxicity Sxlpplfim…
C0. Ltd, 1
2\t§ar1ga10re.
The S1:peI’i11tm1cii11g E1i;gi”;::e::r (E36614 T’
C} 8% M <:;n~c1e, ' ~ '
MESCOM, '
Mangalore and ' . _
Appeflate A1_1'€hOI'if:€. A "
‘ }%t3sp@11de11ts
fij<~::':i "£,1I1d€31' Section 4 mi the
KarnatakgEi1igi1._ (Pm §:;:';é1§;'i11g to set aside the Qrder
pagaeci in ¥i{ri£"V VE32*%'titiv<}r':V.._1f€:3: 1'?9<_~}9j2006 daiifid 7;'?/;2{}€}8.
.App<§s3v,.:':_0:11ing (3311 fear Pr€;ii::1ina:3i héizaring this
'V {3;::1jg; ., §e,§iva1*es::i the fiziiawing:
JUDGBEENT
appaiziiant. has chalierigeci in this appeal the
yasaaé by fins iearmad Single Jufigiit (::0nfi::*:11′:ng the
K pétnaity’ impesed by the }3i$Cip1i.:1a1*j€ Atathariigs. The
appellagzt, was warkéng as a junior engineér, Eh xyas
iSS’f_}€:€3 with a ciiargsi Shea? aifiagng that 151:’: hazzi kept,
pfinciing U16 iabem’ _.L’=3::::i’1ii::V:VVV _t§1f: i
charge sheet’ givan {:3 1111:}. §’€(:a€ ‘«b<::E:_1:g sai:'rs;fie.d «.xa%§féi:.. t:'31_€:
f:K}_}}aI1a§i€33';i {3ff€I'€{i, tii$<:i§iiV:"1af§.-;pr<3{:r:<:e:iir1gs3'sA%'as§:'i::'»§;I:ii;ia'£€a:E; '
against. him. The E2I1qui1"y {.3i'f_§fi%f€:£':_t:X§)I1f:.I;§ifJtf€%?§. théi appaflazit
and $ubmi"f.'{.€€i fIf3i[f}Oi'£ {$36 L}3iis%:i;3}j_§1;a713;' Atxilizoriiry. Ths
E3i5.s?a’s iSS’i_1fid to fhfi Eip§3f:fl3f£”}i;
§:=<;;si':":€:Ai§::gr.m_'t. X32I1}4"'§}'iSCi§3Hf§§iT}? Aut'i"1G1"i'£y diti not agfie x2a:§;i:§1
{hast f':_I";<ii§3$g5"~:f:f' '£;§":€–. C3ffi(:€I" anti he was aaktigi :43
_;.'54§'1<':i$?~f':.:g;3;%"aA._:${».:,z TI1é"'a;g}j:»€1§ant gavfi E113 ffifgiyfi Tfiarfiaftei' {E16
_£1ii3;c"i§:«§i§i:_€¢§; _;w'%f.;.H3":c:1"'i*{§.: <iiaagr€:eii':g 1$ii_%; {he fineriéng
récfgfdfigi E56: F313<;ui1"§; iZ}f§'ir3<:%.§' Iafslci the Chargfis iesséilfid
-».ag§j1″25:£___ i:3′”1r.:t ap§€i}a2″”:’i, are pmvfzii, iishfirfiaftex” i:3;1p0S@€,%
“f3ii17£3f§{T§z* fin” aa2’ifi’;h€}}dii1g {WW0 imcrezziaéiizis with ::t_1n”iL11at§vfi
.. Tizci gaid Qréiér was €:i1aii€:1g€~’:{§ bfiffiffl {his £f3::sur'{. in
V’ Writ. E3€f:._§?_i.s:::11 ?~§<},23825/:Z{l*€3€;} anéi this ifiizazlri. ailxiiwrf.-}i:1a:’j,?
Aut;i’:G1″it}? on ramappreaiatimfx (if t2fI¢.:.. ‘é1’i{“.i_1″‘€: ‘i:1;§i§::?iéi.T_’e:1 ”
recorii again held that’. ‘iZi’i=’¥fi ‘«-<:;Vha1"g'6;.s 2 Erivfiféiéztii ':ag§i.t33s–t.%
appfiflarit art': 13r0Va&s:§ anti iii";~;72<f}l3tiIi:i p€::r1a£'i;y far
:=:ithh0}d§I1g mm i;€'{.§ii'=f::z1:1%1'1t}js:%¥.{§:i:§*::"..M<:1.;,z':1{3I£é§3:tfzxi:=: t:fi1+:::c'£.
Against tbs: 531136 stattitofy 1a;p:p§a§.jé;:as.£E§%::(§ which game m
be e:}is113is.se§.3.4 -.§§e::a£i1fi1':§§11i:;g_:',=i;?";¢"~@:7¢:};::;r3géf this: {}is:::i§1i:1a:(°§;
.i5;:1th:i§"i1:};[ '~ uiviévo Qréfirs thé: appeiiaxifi;
p:*€:'fe:*:*£:r§ {he p3;j<%:§;s5«%;<1?:€'s;.z35i'E"4;}€:ti'v:i<::s11.
2* '.E'ha:: 1éa::'{i{i€:1'Si:i1g1€ ajzidgs aftai' {:a:'°c:f1::§ (§{}I"}$§;(ifii"3?.i0fl
:';:%{i§;*§¢:;ti:311S I,u'gt:(§ haéi §':€§{i iihai: the fificiérig
I'€iE}f3§;€§,'i?.€§" {}iSCi§}1f§I"1a1'}? z3:L1%:E+1::'z1'i€T§; far i.::3p$i31g
.15.:-:aV igiéiast ané fjffipfil” afld ii<3€§ 1103:, s1::fiEr frtmi any
n Eeg_gf_;ai i:*:f§:f:2:i§:j;r, H{3:%?E::v€r 'fiza a.§';sp€}_}a.I:€. has E36611 givfiin ihfi
3::$€:*::'1éf§t 6.3:" 1:sa§;13':€::3€: {sf i1'3,'{..er€:s§ at 3€j}% _;:r<.=::* &Si'1i'E1§¥E1 013 the
' V' '§ix€:Ea¥:T6d 1T;=8§J3}}€}3§ :3? his :'€,%:iz'€:::1€I1?;f. belmfiiig, Aggieved $35;
\x,« "
‘ ‘M
the: said o:’c;iar 0f €116 learimd fiirigif: .,}”u{§g<:: t…%:€ a§;vp§é§..'§ a:1tT is
b€:f01"€z 1.13.
3. L€:a1.”i’1€{l {:{§1}}_’£S€§ T
afisafiing the iZEi}”)3.jig’I’i$C3 raiféizitgj §1a:S;..’f;é{::1t#€:1′}.{“§;és;V%g
the 7i€Z§’:qz_:i:”_s5 C}ffiC’i’:”.–I’ 1’ec01′”€%e€i 31%: 110%”,
1Z)I’?;¥’J1E€_,’1? tbs §)isCiTpfi§~g§f,? a s3.eri<::us
f3.I'f'(".'31' in I19? ap§3:'eciat§:§,g:~. t.i';:%_§[L§;.z,3.i'{ihh' $33 as p1'0§3:=:;~
persyactgaggéq was juS1iifiC8.'¥Zi(§}I1 fer
nest. fjsiiiiic-:p;a::"§3;1jg°=;.§';;s€: §:}f:§ft3 .:D1i3.:3, in ft"ar':f: he aatstigiizi have, Tkze;
16:2-2533: w:a}£3,;'€:f1,1S%%;{i,"' 31*; 1f;§;a*iT vimssf of {Jim '{i'1§;iT.3."..fi7F it i;. ha
s:;3;?%.::f§é€ that thfiuéigfigifiiiéiilf, is guiitjyr” af 33$: €3§’:aI’*gfffi’= §;:r::>Vtav:”§£
3?. “-§Jé:–.V.€f§-«f} .fi§i. 365 any rsierfii. if} W:.h:’-3 saixfi :::»::znt%:£1″tis3:’:¢ Thé
£:iafH::”§a3 «fin ffiflfiifi t’..fiS(33*3S€i.?5 that. 331%? appéiiaat. ééd ucrzt
” V§:;é:9%:§3a:”§ ‘Ehfi Erséiis zré’ ihé carzfiaatars far a p«:::’i€::<E €'}f 8; §;<3;a:'::31
'Hf: has siapi. aafisar mzfz 311:»;§:::::rE W§'1€fi {Ei:'€:Cf§Q§';; was §;§s5u:;=:€i
E112 Ssimghf, fax" isavéz 2:0 }}:"'{i;::::~13$%: fiifi E3133, in fact Efiavfi EVES
€:.§:1iEEf;r g:'*ar:'i§:t£ §3'€)I§1 1&9, 1é}9:_'E% ti: <»_}.1_EfiE,fi'4:?<§€:$ 'E'h6:s<::
matexiais C1ci*aI"1y @:~:.'t:a.b1ish {ha}: ihé {T}3;fiI'gf:?$..fEffif'{7ti7§§:'i:{§
agamst the appeiiaiit that. hf: did 11a:;-:1 p1'c}:ii%é ' sf:
c1t~":a:'3§«' staxids éistabiisheti. _
5. it is 1mf0r°£.1:r3af,t:, thefi: app&I13I:i:’_’_’3;::i a }~1:1_i’1i.¢1= £1*§._Tg%1:i’%:%:1′
has fafieci to éfisgsharge his 0? .p3f;a513a;’i».if:lg”‘:1f.}”i€:~bfl};s afsc L’
arid ‘What: {ha V?v’€’}I”}{ is ,—-$GHi}31$f:${3 .”. E31 fact 3: :5: .F}i$cip}i11a1’§,:-‘
2’£ut}10}:’i1f; has ta}~:e:’1 ‘ ié:§i£§;1′:ii .V {ha matiei’. En
‘iihai; view; 0? iifxét- i:1-éiitttii’ %=s2ft.é_:’73i::._:§<::i'_.- ..§_i1':k:§;":<a§1}! jilfiiififiérfififlfi ti:
iiltsfizrfaféa *;;n.::'§*{§i.'1 .::ii€Z€'::"__ '§§;Ss<::{i E33: iizéf, £«::.:«3;:'1'1:’::§€r§:”1g ;33;j;’;::3éii’i?;’. :3?
” ‘~ Ea ._E.i3′:’r€:>, i-5′-€’3..s§;’G§1f}{§S ars “i;}’,ia{§.€; é:;’:.1′{,. ‘}’%::: ;3s_:;:2;;3@&,§ E3
t:”:a¥:i:3n {sf €i€:§a,-‘ E11 §”i§§:”:g 321%
appééi 3j$fC:~’$%:;i~§.§1{§s: §§:Zsmi$sf:{1.