ER’ THE HEGPI CQURT 0? mamsxgraxa R
cxnctm’ Barren M DHARWAD j 4.
EATEE THIS rim 9% DAY OF JULY.§0Q§’£: ‘*7 T»
3330232:
§i(}Z\I”BLE gems JEISTICE MMMLA
cmammn REVESION ?E%:}i~’z:§:mi z~zo:.g_Wg&M*€%z*o%3’$
BEWEER: 1 A’
$:’:’:. Emzaii
Sfa. HE3I}}[ii3;i’ Sab _ V
Agsd ab0u’£ {5}} ‘§z§21a-1’s 1
R/G. C3G§€’i_}?€?, _ _
Difit. Befiairy
?E’3′.’E’i’X$2’1ER
{B}; Sri. E&¥j;u:::’:a1′:€’1i;:£”&<§§ii§«* §§aE":a:i{az*, A€Ev::a§.€:}
“O0
» ‘E’3z’:e¥:j P:}£ie:;e* Egéspectai’
Eggitzé: .j_P’fc-.ii:g:=: ‘éétatiazz
“5\.f*5?A if 4′ A
Sigh €S3s:3i,1:”%.§ Bairggaiare
§’§G;’:}§)EL ‘E7§:isi§ Bfifiary
Regji. State Pubiic Prfisfzcufm’
Eiigh .§:i}.jiii*5t Ekig,
g§§;,:% 3?: gm. Paiié, mgié, 3?. far RE.)
i-J
This ztrimimai fffvifiififi petiiizm is flied under
8603011 39? R/W 401 Cr.P.C praying to set aside-.__the
jucignaent ami sentence dt.28.§.O5 in C:*i.A,N<x2».14j'TQ4
passed by the '.90., Fast Track Cmn:"t–1;{I, Hs$pet"-a3:};:¥f$€t
aside the ju<:i§11.1668/02 011 the file of £116 Addl. CLJ. ‘{-;_._Tf;’. f),r{.}é ”
JMFC1, H{}S}3€t and acquit the: petifigner. : ”
This pe1:it.i01″1 <;omiI1g on for 1":€;a::i:1:1g«'=
Court maae 13:16 fellowirxg:
0RDE§a
This revision is ._t:hc:– jii{i’g:i:§e11: anti
arcifzr (Ff ccemziction of the-T-amused_.i1f§§”¢:éQ;'{II”i:’::i:12;£ casa fer
chargefs _S:té{ian 279, 337, 388 and
304A gm-:2 an&%%sa:;:¢:;T[%:a%? 9:’ E.Evi.’Ki’ Act.
; F%g¢¢¢;w:A::;g i0 ‘i.%”;é pmsecutien, am 24.{:4.2a::2 3.:
‘”3Sii;Q71£,:’¥f. dfi}, an amount of rash arid ifzegfigem;
»AV.T’Vv'{§:’*iver sf trigaapar Ee::::{=§; bearing N0._§~eiA~
£}%EE»__’? ‘ zfifiiifi reversixzg iiasheé agaifist Egufla anfi hi?
a%1%::_5i.E1e’:”‘ ism? séafiaiizég bafiximi ii; baarézig E€a¢.?§’§Y’f ‘?’?8.’E§,
Eié=S::§€,§31g iii: Cazzgizzg ifiézirififi £0 {REE 3;} {$932, {$53 331$
“”g§’i§:az:,>z,1$ ?mjm”*i&s 3:9 E, ifvavigzciaggpa, axgho sacczaixabfiii £5
i§.}j1i§”§$$ iatfig’ $221,
EN
3. xfisffm’ {ha ::*0:11§;3Eai.1:::’f:: {:a:{:1e :0 be Eztsiigfid *–‘~-.
§\sIaI1j::;’:a%:h Madiwaéaig 3 $38.86 531125: :0 bf: :”€.;g§;:i’&:i’.ef:r§gj:.”‘i”£%,:.’-T ‘
$316 afsova $a;’:<i §fe:1<::@$. §j3::1§i"'i3-gig '($6 _..£?<;-:\'::'s§.«._i'.£:.%V'».,
i:1sze$fi:§.gat.':0s1, $§2<";%;: ma.':"1azar gizzi
EEK: :11a*:.€:'éa;E cs§}§€:<:¥:. :w::'c§ ;:a::;1£;§ é;.
91%” {Egg wimttégaééss {:§}..:;e 13:3′ -.z._*;€a::éi:*’c’¥;€=:'{‘i.”‘ “;{‘E1€
a<:<::':1s%:{:i,! §3€§:'§i;é:::=:"1e:' ggiéégdéfi " Ema <:§1a3:ge
Eétirfilztii. Th€:'€i%%§§é, ifi. E11 3511 nine
W§fiZI"3;f_i$S€iS '§f§ii'€§ '€;xaii:§:";é:;§Z.'jvvfér—$15géfesficzitiawra amd $€:*€§m':
{?i{}C*:4Efi'i:£"7€'}3§LE34"EfiJ"'€f?;'f§'1§i};2?§§'§{§€§*vT.3¥:33f£f"i §'1'<;2§:2 mm §:1at::1'i;a.§ ohjitcis
mad ::§0'mt:4$ –. cg}? <f.}*:f:e3 -gigécekzgéézi .
A :”E’1€i”«E:;6a3*z::%{% ‘i:*%.:a.E éucigt: <33": garagsaé (3? gm} amt}
u':f%:::z§:;;::;;€;;"fi';:3.:'§,; .[ '~€%.7i<:is::3.;::$,, &<i:fi€pE.&d 'ihfi case sf {Egg
p:'€:7s?€:::z:2é,§:;;*:"" Wifiizh cama :5 ha esiabiishsci zizzrisag the
Laizifigizzfé a?' PE} ami 93332 ~» aya '%'§?§"{.i"}€SS€S far {he
Ezfacitifzzéai am": @::;:§;f;e3{?: iizat €323 Sfifiiififié '%§?fifE§ :*§:$;}9:"2$§J%3§€
V mféér gtzmsimg EEK: acsifiezfi, in q':,;é:sEie§: §'$$i3;§§§.I§g in zieaflzz
ef thfi {'§€:<':aa§§e»:i siiufi 9:} big 3:'3$}iz ariéi §.2@glig§::':i cirivirsg.
CG1}.§f't $316 E;"Vid&I1C€ of PW3 -=- av;-*1}€:r' Gf 'ihfi i<:::".r."y 3131 qgiégfizgxl
{k:nggi:1g engagiag the aczrustzzk 33 his drive:' at i%1§;é'r.;:izé§5aé;f;£'
§3€3iE3€ of time, HE 2159 §"Ei3;i€ES upsn L§.m c1'0s§+<?*Ss:ég;fi3jT::z3,i;i:3:: af"
PW9 C{}'ii1'f{?}1(}i1'ig that. eva=::z1 ma: izzvsigiigaiiiig é:"=§iE%jc:1*._ja<3;::r7;fi'té;§
4313?: a. £21135 €3.36 came ta bf? :*{:g;;iste1'e::€i—- gaixiixe :%:1s3L,.3.:1::<:2 0f*.'§;E'i:3
cgwmm' 0§ {he gaiage,
8. As agaégnst t§:1i«5:s;7 ih: §§::*3.1*:1s:;r:§ “{t__&dii:?m’:a;é Eéubblqs
P:”::»3e<;é:1t'G3: {3}{€'S F316 £T0';a§'i– {E1170 :1gi';,Lfi§Lé'.:w'i§£.s;'i:t€ 0f E3"\£§1 and
?'§-"«J=2 ami co1;~.g.;m;%s_V @3131. Eli ii3€':x_ ébstzléus of 311?; sgmiifg
':}€%%.w:fi1';:_ ?'s?£§ 2'"x&;i:"§'§'§__ ihté aC«;*.us€:c:i hfirfiiri, {hers 953:3
Em :"téas;:3:s}.'w}:fgr iiélerjg "wl<;;:1§§'c§~§:wQEv:: §IEEifl'C€'i1i. §}¢:'ssx:m 1?}: E}.
faisga ;{§;§;$.€i jzmé éqiiéig} $316 €.§.§§}E':.E1€;3.§f£3§S 52%' ms {§i€€€:aS€€3_ Ea: gs:
}3;::::%:j;, §{e'a.$&€}§3 fer Cfilifiimfififii} of fim jaiiigfizsizi of
E:::1%’sgr’:Le;fiAE.és:>:::’-«’::;«:s«* iifi’;s?:–v”tW9 Cceuris beiaw,
?’§”:”f€ §’}Oi11{ {hat vsszizézlii arisa for €f:m:ri:”s cmlsiiifiratioix
£3′ ggiigeiifiéi’ the Z”€’~é’iSi€3fi pfiiiiifiil {isscweg :0 ‘ma afiowfid?
38; E Ezgvé gone iizxxxzgia; fixes: e::§3§:’& svifienssfi, $0 far
ézg {,:c<::ur;€e:::<:€ ef aha ac:'ri:§a:'3e§ ii: {E16 gaztage: <}fTi1ipp€§is;':.%my,
f.§'}{"3§"'i'Z* is 312:: (§i§§§§1E"§.€. Si} 333:5 fkzéifi is may aéispmzs ztgzzriiizzg
"E3951 aizzi §":§\§2 *&::}:"E{§I3.g izjr. 'iilfi $a4éoi:1’§: <3? $312116. Pwifi iaavizzg {hit 103?}-* §a:3;j.– 3_:*§:§'§§:-*:iiif§;—
'§"§p§:eswamy'$ gzaragfi is 333:) mm: in V§iA§§V§~:.§:;1.1't,s._* ""i"h.ti:f€£%3':::;~
§.r€ss§:11c:e {sf the Egsrry in qzx-as?;i<m E1$:;a1*i1;j;g[ f 'is; A'
mat in Sétrimis tiisptxlie. '7§'hei-3' 1:/é_1}tireV":;iV_iSp1;te T. ti);
Wh{2¥h€;{‘ §,’:1{~: acciiifint £11 }€}’,L1e to
mschanistai fififfici”. af a:;;§f:§3sr ‘E’é:::.E\t§”‘§A”v ‘?’?83 to
¥’i2’hi(,?h rfiiiairs w’tj:f: 1E§}f?1%:]’1gH anci Gtilifrs at
‘£335 ‘E’€§3va1}T: })(}i1iI i§§T *§;:£i31§v._, cf:3$s’z-qggxagzifiaatiozl (>§”§e1£~’:va§1t
Wéirgesgéia i3}? <ie:f":§'é::;=;?:'3"2a5=i,?<:;3;1le:£_ iiidyicz"-41:5: 'ihaii 101?}? ?~§4¥’v’£’z’§”‘
‘?”?8i3 W352: bifiiilgf ~1f€/’;f}é:1T%;f?_:é’i’-.§sIi’:»:.§. «as §§”;£:’€% E-‘:«}S ea €i<:sW§1 gjra<ii{~:§';2§.
E13 §%'<3;'_:E" sf '{.E'*_§'s.% Sé1逧v}a:3}; i:=§}E3:ia*: Z'Ei§}£:3;i.?['3 221% 'i3:':}i.::g C:€§ji'£','§iE§if§ on,
a€..':C{{:§E::;:Eg:£§§}* 2.31:: v::*:ii1%.a;;:'ié maveé (ins ta': §3;:€C§1a1:.:iCa§ {i.sf€:{:'£,
§§3:.'if'f§°€ff{;%E'€v,_§:E1'.4i5W§f§:{V3i,"5~%iiT§€ZE2.§. £15523 »::»(:€;:;:""1"€:i§ ii: 'Sim garagfi :'§;:.:<'€-: :0 'mi?
§;€§§'§i5gf:é1'1<.%&i:§"i_' 31,3 §&?o::"k51°s in this: garage 3311?}. ii} 0r{i€? is
_§5${ta};:€:.. Ezéizft iéaéiéfiijg, ms €}W'I}€I' of the garage has ibistsfi 3
~ fai§§é:" '$336,
3.3 §§§ 35:1" $26 a2s'.éé.€z:{:& €33': ;'e<*.s:::'€E§ £2'. £5 S{"3€"§f.i $33?
" §E1€:'€ "»§£{'.E'f: '§*W{} éeazftigiié at '£;§:;E: :"€§e§ra:i:3; §}t3i§1§ 0%' té::1.§:° iii: {E36
g:'~2mgi*. :%i:'.£.}:'."§. ifs; E722:-:%;:*z-*e;':':€,é;':tz "fizz: ms-'<3 Em"z;'i::*§¢ i.;:.;":.;.:/2. §'}s:§{:.2':g2";';g tars =:}n§:
§}e.vaz"t:{}(i}-* w'a$ sgmppssi am} EVCEE §es:a:"'s:{i€iy xvasfiieaéif
saié Lufla when 17:16 acsztidfiat happ<":11a€£. Aajca;-=-:'{i:§i3,g iii?
prs€<::':1*'ii<m., the Ei1f3C.h8I1i{T'S in 'E116 g€¢:;,1'a§.§_r3;x§.§%e:.';=:t» é:§ta1'1£1*.%:;g; icy f
$16 rejpeakrs 0f MY'? ?"?83« E13. f1"{?11'f:§,*._§)f'§§'.:.€§ ._eje=.}id iar:f§'; iaéfifia ééj-'93
Sifiilfiiitlg and bayanfi iisé iiuna, i£1V"{§:iEi'§;.Vi$§€i"§V$}E3..':1§tt., KA~
§1§wi'Ef}':'5'? was sfamiézig." –'_i}:})V=.:*a,;_’:3§;;L4>’31:*fs c21$véA tax the
affeiéi ma: this }£>r:j}; KA–§4;§é?yei3e fiirresrfiezz
and Causeti the Luna, but
aise causizzgi. near ti}: said iorry.
‘§’E1<: €V.?'i%§ t'.;',1%{V?{""A'.VA perused. in {E16 aniirrf:
§iVi(iE:'E'§{?€f, '}f '?'}1E$3€ZV {12;?§:;.:i.¥§¥;:ié»s$;z:3, them: is no iI1{iiCEEfi(}Z'i £3131:
iiiéésg –%.?a:{3 ;:§¥€:"$%3;::1r~';{.'– Exziiviiig 3:13' aitfir motivfi <3: maéafiikt
'%.¥Il'{€"Jéfi.€§,€}i?£;":§€3'".%_E}}§1vi§Cé.{§f'"§:;:€ izzzmczzfit §}m"Sc;:'; ii} Gififil' is give
L.__i}5:é";:;efi%% ¥:i:=3} e::a;:a1§,3:%:§:.= if the aztcuseti was met, $6333}?
pitgéfiizi. g: §:V;3A[::garag&g ha vmukl mat be: k;1msz'i11g that Eimrs
n.:x:as Sc"§3fi: mechanicai :ie'fe,c*i in §;€:1""§"f; '§'€o,§*s§'fY '?"?33 which
"« '_;=;:ij:c§:*;§¥m.g :0 Egim said; {:12 have mmzeai (£116 :9 naechafiicai
éasfaci, Thass Ewe wiineasss "wars 33%, emimical iaswazrds Q35
&1€3{'3i1S€€i.
12. Tim imsasizigmimz dflllfi by the Envestigaztiizg
agr:13.c_y did net reveai any ‘£i1€:Ch81liC8§ ciekcéi of lair}; N0.
“‘?’?’83, 1:9 itauss this accizzent. mas’: ami §>\,3;.;2. j_»b7¢_:::’,:g ”
mscfhaxaics and £136: time sf {ha atrssident biting 1.Q.’f3iQ.€:s:.{A_}§;%’)L;é}7″>T’
mi: in the raeraing wotifbzi 0:11}; i:1dic3;€t: tliaflt 11:33:” -1;’31’€§ ss:;:1;<:j€"a'{
the time of aciticiezzi, was quite naiurai'va€17v:i_ *£h€i1' j.f1f€iS6i1C€i. iSs.' 'V
not tiisputeé. PW} and PW? W613 éigc azfi¥.1;aiftcVci
Their pmsezlce 3:; ah"'5%av:iyi_ stataiisfi' ;ii.{3€_. in éisprutéé. The
c:<mt<:nts sf spat mahazar wE;: icl*iL-iéi' 331a1i*k%:ii..é1;: Ex.P2 would
.7:rzdicai€ VV€i:{é: " §%:%§;=.sg€:1tE::f;%' s::'i"'»._f€ia30 }._i$i*:*ies at the spa': af the
ag~:;:*.§{ie§'::§_"-,_' "E"r_;.eV c::2§1"€.'Ef£1t'3.._;iT§-. mahaza 3" fufiizmi imiicratafi
damagfi '?';<;{_}_:é '}"§83 E0 filfi flex}: be:}m1e¥;,
i'3d§37?¢_;i'f£"'vE1fiS€}3}'§}V};}'..§iL€3., ézfgéi iim §<:':ur:'§,.? §§,§{A~{}’%f3?5? €X€f€}§’E
if§1::.¢.3.–‘é ta E36 021 d{}i?§’I1 graiiient §0$i’E’3L’::«11 311$ if
due iiig. \:§:i<':'::;.Ei'a11;iCa}. dfifact, ii mzsved fm"wa;r&, ii Gughéi ta
'égavs §Tflé:}V§?Zf§ wit}: {£31606 '222%1§ch w:3u§{§; haxzé giraggecé €313 1.41213
3113" a§o:1g wifii it "$315 1°53; ggzfian {sf €313 i:',§§)§£§° 13:1?'
. '_.0::;-g§_:t £0 havé ffiiiifiii 5,"-€:"i;a.i.:3 ziamagég, 'E'h8i'"€fG:'&, the iieffifice
EE:::r3:°§,s' Ehai m{%CE';a_:1ic::.ai <:if:f€;ci Qf 10:13" ?€{).F%¢'iYY ?'?83
93122352 far {:16 accigieiit <:a3:1n<3i bfi acccpted.
E3, Then :a:::’:e1g to the avifiienfifé’qf”‘.£?§&?3*,. h,&t’VEggiéfiigg
‘£116 «::rw1T:::z’ cf ism? 1’11 questiail Wouifi “,Q.?it11E”8.L§}’A cie:1}; u_At1*i'<.~: V
iiabilitjg of his ciriver as he sar0ui:}}.L::=i§t:.§1e1fi.i 'aha
action sf his ampiayaflg \"'f;'.§_;§11 to the
aliegttd aémisgiarz. of PW?' :§'5: €119: instance
#3? 'him Qwzmz' (3.? S€}.'}£€I3.Cfi, iht:
s;i’at<éms:11i: ' is registered at the
iE1SEé1¥.i(':§:'..'C}f.' Tim very next S€Tflifii}.{',€
agggziizi i;;&éé::§;é f %1éL§; Q16 suggestiezz <3? fiking sf fake
€fé~T1Stj,_§: 'V '"5226 é'%;=°'§£_;§ii?f§-' (:9? £133 esviéezzceg aspeariaiéfg §':};'£)SS
€f3?}éia£'};ii;£?£:"{§L§€)§'}.'{Z§§f fi1{'§§§fi wéiimsfifis 316 whefe ;%;:1diC:.ai€t$ '{}i::ai: he
iiszqzié-['.iE'$'i31§«é""t§; g;¥V{<;f;'¢e':§:«'i Eh: iizaozy af iii'-ffifI1Cfi is}-7 a,gr€ei:1g to ihfi
Suggméizgié ééiéi. O'i?-E17361' ef the gamge wag raspensibk: 'fer E213
:13}3:i cagaf {ha {ha aihar hmxé, he Qéamiaai 311 the suggfiséimzs
';;:.i'§;».'§r;? him aim? ibis: fiiffiffi avééeizszfi Weuiii magi}-' inziizrazfi 33:23:
V. .,h.2:é was {"§€i1f_;«'§fZg Wm; Sim saiggesiiagx 0%' Zfigifififiiifii} 93%' 3 {H335
V {T336 :55 331%: §1':3'Ean{:€ «:3? <;aw:':$:* 917 29:33; amzi d.:iv&1',
Ii}
34. E§’&a<1:L:"ig (bf $'i':£::«1j;-=' S€i'1§,EfI1€7.'ff 0:" $313 =99-*:;3:'£§S §1jz:rf,»._;;:1:3§§
fizfixe, {)£'1{"3 ca§.1:::t: figriin ilk: €}f)i}’1iii}1} Whilti 21pp1°$C’ié-r€:é–i:g.
:3-:visE§:11»;?::”:. in 911.1%” :0 appr<~':1″1. the Vi7i’i’1’ifii$f:’. _4’i3;’&2:§’V”z§’§’?i:,1g” :39 1′::~:2′:’;%;’_”£’.1″&
f§–:;>1:r€ 02:1 oath. At 1:29 pr:;i:’1t sf fhals Eggs Wgiven
22:1}; i:::EiCaIi011 as $1:gge::’.$%f.i,::;’: £)§g*V”f;j§’¢ cefiifisévi fer tha
e:1.€f€::;z;re. “flag {rial (191111 :¥:h€.:_:£3;;:é3:¥.’bEg;3§>€l1ai$ Ciauri.
we::z’2*:: jugtiiiszi *?{“_i3.i.s ¥i€r1_g4t.%.i3;’~réi3Sz:;>:;14£;r.1g czerder how {£16
§3:*$s€:;’t. patiiityiieg’ iiifiztsfiegiigibia far” the 0€CU.rr€31-::€ sf E316
.:,2<.:<':iu:1eE::3.§, « .§§–:2w.i:1§§; ._§%iA;. flit: 'fact 1.113%. 'Q36 astafiiidiint. 313;:
{gm*:$ti<}::'s. ::7{7€::*§E£,§;. a”vgaj%e:g&, ii: {‘.’£’3i£:id imvs heal} 3ES'{}id%”5iIL
J V’ «-331% ilfjzsf I1«’.3g§;§;g{i.;’1.Zv’ev.”37iif”{}’:§y’¥ih’:f 133%: 3.122% Iéésgéigexli, {i:°;i.vi12.g cf the
_§’1=i_’:’5Z’§§;’§£’;}’7§.’}.IE””:V§-f,,,> *£3iEi _:;{§a:é’1t.”e1:;3 {if $€:3.m:::m;f:. iI}1’E}§’_)S€{§. bf; {ht ‘§’:”§a;E
§a%f*
{Li<§;}:9§E"$§ aisL§§ji2.§§¥ifi€d'
é'a:c{;:Yi%:1gE§¢; péziitian is €Z§§§SE.Z§'§iS$€€_3§.
S&/~
JUDGE;