32%: THE HIGH com? 0? KARNATAKA AT BANGALC}RE_ ._
EATEE3 mis mm 11% DAY 0F'AUGi}ST 2903'
PRESENT
THE HONBLE MR: JUSTICE A 4- _
Arm' _ . V
THE HCEBYBLE MR.Jus'ri't3§f;"a.5.3GP5N}éA
MISCELLANEQUS Figs'? g;?}53;&i€;«555;'2§0% .:Mv)
BETWEEN:
2 SR:,3aY§$é;a;§s:.a_Ré:nr_';-3: ' "~ . ___
5/{:2-.LA'TE f}BIRE:DDY_ _ _
AGEB mow? :sz'srRs..___
SM? LA;-is:-:_Mi~ _ _
W6 SEE JA'fA.RAMA§3EDDY
- 5:233:55 ABQUT 4sa*--:2s
Ex.)
; "B{§'§EiV'3'a§€'§ "2%fAT NO.31;2,fi'i¥i M.&a'.N,4'i'H CROSS
VBANCALCJRE 54
,...APF'£€';LLANTS
-533: 31%"; 3:"-2*' rx§'ijRAL:2<:R1si~iNA, ADV;
"M,-'S; K S E T C
T 'SE9; 8? §'i'S MANAGING DiREC'I'C!§'-E
"$H.e%NTH1 NAGAR, DOUBLE ROAD
' v .I3ANC$A§..ORE;
RESPONDENT
{B55 Sri : B E. SANJEEV, REV.) (Y)
M3
was APPEAL is FELED U/S 173m; OF :~«:v’:=~x£ifi”-1V;3*.<::..J,'*mE;1\.aE:s:_«:R_,' i\s_IA_Ci'f';
coum' OF SMALL CAUSES, E€iAE3TF:'f31?'JLITAN A'R£:A,"<1:_'
BANGALORE (SCCH-1'73, PARTLY ALL€}Wf£§G 'I'H_E'~(3~L.Ai:M–~.
PETITION FOR compmsarrxom AN::.__sEEK:.p:c; F}NHg%1*I.§IivP}1_'§4E1§§T
OF {30'MPENSfiTIC?N. ' ..
This Appeal day, !)VEEPAI-E
VERMA, J., deiivcred the foflgiwiugfz
g,I:…ueM ”
Heani ibr £115:
a;:>mi}a:r1::§’ 5:13. iti:?1*i L. counsel for the
respandciit, C-:5I;’é;c1;tva:fg1;fi;cnts heard an merit:-‘5.
The §fi;m ‘the pamnts of deceased Harish
§’ed:i§; hé.d__1net géifiz an accid-ant cm 4.12.2005 while he
wag his motcxr cycie. He was hit by a bus
2 be1:.:s}A:1’gf_ngV__tQ :m$p9:mdex1t–CAeI’poI’ation, which was being
I” “-__c1V:z”3wge[n h.y-its drfivm” in a rash and negiigent manner. 01}.
_%iCCU{IJi;§ of the severe hnpact said to have been causes} to the
.§§;Qt%>r eye}: czaf the deceased, he sustained bodily iz1juries
l’a.::ae: am spontaneously. “IZ’>
ma
3. At the time of the death, Haztifih Raddy wag. ~
as a Cashier with Mfs Hutciainsen E$$.:1r._Sc>utiiV
drawing a saiarf of Ik’s.8,5()(}/«per 111v¥;;11t}jV;;T..;I’1ie3€’~1§¥i<:té;V:éi;*?c"'i(_'
not disputed befbrt us. {$511 a c1aii31<-.pctiti'm1 E2-.j;}g7f§3é§iv11V3fVVt1§e %
paxtnts "fiefcare the Motel' Aceiéent {£61} short
the 'MACT'j, Bangalore, be passed an
23.8.2096 whcxtby Aagxd Vfi7]_f';€1Tt§.I_1}1€i*<'3v..1V'A have been
awarded 3 tcstaiiu 'of 1[5;?)8f)v-*':- tsgcthcl' with
i1}t¢3:1'€S'§ ;1:&§§ii:ed:iir}1e11%j~;t::3."*3f}:is 1 is im' enhanccnxent
filed u11c:ie 1'-. Sficfiéiv. jfigatar Vehicies Act.
4. Tim iea1′;i’ced”‘{:m:;jsc1 far the: appaiiants submiitzd
thai Cflllipfinsaffiéfiil zfsvaxfied is an the lower side and
V. Liésexvés ti) }’13e*z:g12a;1cec1.
ES. f’tii;”.f:i11 has been awarded, which calls for no
. -:..l’§;,v;¢£fcr<:11c{:.
6. It 5:3 net in dispute that Ex.P.6 is 3
Cczfificate issuad by $111: amplaprex’ to the éeccawfi *
Rccidy, which xtveals that ha wars’ ‘ gei;t*i:§_1g .« a.
Es..8,5GQ/ ~ per mfllith. Accmfiésxg to f§’ir:_’ even ”
1’3 assumed that the deceased bbachixeéor
59%: cf the salary fair hrimsttif, V?i3c–..i1:Iiiai;1i11g” was
beixmg given to ap13c11a:1t3″”i1i§;”£irf1_ fil:é§if”¥i§B.§}1QOfi. The}?
have been dep1:iv::;i:¥::-f__ I ~ per month.
Thus, saffifkvyvaut at R3.425Of~ per
mémth. ‘Iv€’}1ea’1s_a}Vs<3 that lceitixxg to the age of
the app§i1an§s';<..ti1e iéaiiiifipiiex' ts: the facts cf the case
'*'e?§fi'Z3li1ii: if13 riaihefV'%i1:1:3««13 which has been adapmd by the
—:_:ia:i111a11.ts have criaimeti a total 511120312: £122′
Rs.’r%,5s;009’f4;%; k
‘flit:-..i&aIned counsei fax’ the appellants Cfiiltfilldfié.
31¢” a.1$;m:::: of R$.1(}_.,{)0{)f- awazfled by the MAC?
T:::iwa:x*} Iowa and afi:’:::::ti{m is 011 the Iewer side and d£’2$!f:I’§!€S
V:v;3_1*_»%€ e1111:–;m
ftmerai expeiiscs, less of estate and t’1m1sp<;33"i':aZ:ics11 of
bgdy", a sum of Rs. 15,009] — awarded is tax) ~
ttzaraitare it shmlid ht: enhanced to 1:
What the appellants tlztzmselves izzsivt: :ihe”*i(_’
memoranfium of appttal in ._?*3c3s.’. ‘i7.’,V: C3
accoztiing to us is jtisfifiegi, cm 4%:£:runse1
an bfifil sidas. the aibmsaid
amomlt, file ambtrzzt lf{i.”‘V:”e appellants
sxrguid wg1’kou:’t; ‘[ a1″ : ::f%¥’;*3.8,:2i),f){§G’fvL»».. {Rupees Eight Lakha
TW€1}t}’ tfiougéné fihe awazti of fllfi Tribunal is
mczdifiezi ten €Cif:_ ‘C§£fEZ’l1-l_’. £i1;it,f}f;e3* would be entitienci ta receive
fi*:$2i£~V£1:;§::__17{:s§3011de11ts iI}ChISi’%’€ of the ammlxxt
tg1v:s_f§i13;<::d .3;?;3k.fl2,§"'l':ib1ma1. Thfi difference 3}}}€)i}.I}.t will Carr};
inie?fié's.i' .;"aié'Vof 6%; fmm iiiw {iatc of applicaiion {ii} it is
4 V'F1;e amcaunt which is already depcrsiteé $1131
K " * 'z;~=e:;;sié:%:ad to am mm and be adjusted in tin: mzmsaia
The R€(Z?€Z}1'¥3.':'i may be rctmned to the MACE,
T V'B3;?i§1ga301'c, izlzmediatsziy. ..
The agtzpaal stands a’§i0wt:d to the €Xt€11’I: Jif!1.1f:VI3Aa’;;_’i.£:’i$}Z;¥§3i}K’ b
}}€I’E]..I1a-iT)O’¥Ct The Ccsuxmei fee at R3.2′;{.);O0b/’_ is _
hm