WW W WW muum W mmmmm %~£¥fi¥°§ mum W mmwmm MW?-% cu
mnmzmacsamr GFKARB.?ATAI£& A?3;wGaz¢¢km%%
mama arms :2?-m' 2518 9.4? 0FpEmUAR3§2m;9 5':
BEFCERE
1 SR! K crmwvaaagju
AGEE ABc::m":*__4& &'Ea1¢f$
2 K
AGEI}.a§E$3U*E7;5C' Yfisuza
3 K
AeEm'a_3«:3rLr':*.
~ %g;;EV;2%g_13;.wLrr 49 YEARS
L 5
AGEI} ABGLVI' 30 YEARS
L ~ ' %s.Rs crmmmzx 0?
'mm V rmzsmzaxapr Arm
ALL ARE Rssmma AT
$33.13}, 91'?' MARI
RA EKIEESIGN
wmacm GARDEK
Bazvsamma mimmsm
{By 313'. S V BEAT, AEIQCATE}
,vV:.L\5"'%!lW|k'%*2tI1"W40-££!""W!fIr4f#""$ EW wwm an WWW
Inwluvuunn-3
I "I?-E: E SEXY
CC}-OPER£'iITVE BAKHK LTE,
C
B.A}i"G!&LRm-569 fiifi
REPR'ES»%"TED BY ITS
GENE-RALE!I€':.NflGER
2 *I'mAss.m*A1~zTREGzsTRAECrF
caammm ' [_
BAHGALWE sI.IB~B1vii&z:3aI
BANGALmE 1 =
3 THE JC}HTT;RE[;':ifI3TI?&H%3F
f.'.PE1?e'.2'=.'3FB__.4'i7:i._ .-érvm
ARBI'FRATmi3I'.£EEI.¢
L YES Famgmrxm L'm.,
BwGA1;cs;2z;& ...RE:sm1szr.:zm':~s.
{By 'Sri A 2v*;5:3r§rs:3}u~§&aNA Ram 35 an B :5;
mqs.»mra.a;?,ar;,xmATE3 miss: 9;
SIZE 1;: HAN%i'&I§'i'rIA.§?AYAPPA§ HQGF' mm 22 a 23;
% kikk'%?z-agwm-*mm imam mvxcms ma mm 22?
9? TI-$2; zsfirfimfwafimz ca? B§DIA mama as QUASH
THE ~aRDE;::¢: PA$$EE? BY TI-m R3 DT.5.5.200é
'cozW'm1m;3«~m mvzsma xwmzgms on Tim gm
'}'}Eg_ KARHATAQKA AELLATIE TREUKAL
[*k%%%gn*£*%¢9.A.4.2:sar7 vmvz 2%}¥ZhIEXURES~F' RED :3 as Tm:
% Erma Paocsssmss IS A mm as-mrrro
PR.QCE'EE}.'§GS ARE A RULLYIY Afifi IEERECT THE
?>-_ 'RE:3mRx3mITs Tm PM 'Item cosm me' Tim
~._FR't'.')CEEi3IRGrS TI*R%GHQ¥}'I" AHD GEAR'? SUCH
,7D'I'i"ER AND E RELEF8 AS ARE MST.
Ti-I13 PE'I'I'§'§€.'.'3§ Sflliflfi Q25!' FGR P%Lfle'II§fiRY
EEAREIG -- 'B' G 'fi'flS EAY, 'Fifi fififfi?' MADE
THE F'OLLQWfiG;
REBWHE Vuwflwmi Mr" mamnmm mmm 1-..wWa" W- mmmmm MBQM M
2m
QQBER
A Writ: Fatima by §%s_ $1523. Whcs am _
xfixmndeum in a
Rmpendait-Joirxt Rgfiaar g;>f_
Arbitratiann Cell, Bama1are:"'v%%4zrmVfig3_1%
ragamenizatixw cf who
2. 92' am V
legality :3? the artim*
dam 5;§.2s:;r:a5pag§[gd%y%'m%:rye Joint Rwnwu-ax af Co-
as-'-.
apmatiw in JRII)}I}"BF['3'732[fl4-G5
'F' in the writ petiéon) and
M 'gm dated 9.4.2097 pmwi in Rwisien
an tk Eve of the Karnataka
at Bmmom. M Rasriaien Petitnlon
A 1 ' rim pcrmaat magnum came m be aimmmx.
oftm ordw 'm proeluoed as i§.I 'G' to thia
:3. The1aga1g'sundasaughttab¢urged£x:&1is
writ pefifinn umm &X"k:5 }:8 22'? of the Comtfizution of
$ww
Va t«""nI:'mta'-"m an
India ea behalf ezf tm patitionm-3 and as» aubmitted
Sri S '.1' 311431, 1earz'n-ed Cstaunsel ?m tlmi the
preeech"g' befcxre 'tI'1fiJOi1'1'f: Regswar §::;';V gt u
rasaalution of the diwute umier
Kamatalea Co-operafiim Scaei¢'E:ie:é_'£!s;j:t 1$?a:a :a
the eye sf law as whm1
tlzm pcmicners' fathm and
tlm prcnzeeding be;r;ga 1§u:;ii;Q;n% law, no
fixrthar ord~r:::ra,: of; mudiify the
daacripfi:n1_. flue pmmaings
Em in the ieyefif the Reg-may and
tm Trib1z;1gu"§.._}1gmeV; ' an ermir in m '
the fimt rmpondent-Eazzk to
filad mam Ordcr 22 Rule 4 1:9
~Bank*ht:: bring' anrwardtmmusmt
C,,,,.4._'p-pfifismrs' as m: hairs in pxaoe 92' the awn" 1
:4-.Af:a'w*'basi::fa:cm1ead?mtct}mab0ve
"patina am: in ma samnd mum nfiitigatimtn befam this
Cmzrt are that the firat 2-wpondmzt-Bank had mt
mtaina.m§£ntfiat1wfathm'ufthepe$:|hr1em. Cartam
'"\U>'¢»' w~m.wmmem £!kWE'& mwwarw wt" mmmwwwofifim warm LUUW aw rmwwymm Ewimfi W
remymeztt of the ban amount. it was d:£.1e_
t 9f the berrowué
raised a dfiputae and the mattm
Arbitramr. Tim claim petitizm' gafad V%
had rauibad in an awmfd. It was
aeught. is he axecutadg havhzg
rw.&ed the of ma an
appcal 't)e:ef:31::e.~~' Tribunal and
2-aspandent.
appeal of the erdsr dmzea
1e.5.19-99 Na.12Qf19'98 (Copy
jg; tn the ma-. mama) and the
h.ag:i mmaaa 25: the 91-Wm mum-iv.y
the ex-pa1'Be award rm» homzm 3. ma
£5 deciéa the mattm afimh.
V' 1'31' The prwfint Writ; Pefifinmmn qzzwtimsmd, that
k %% m¢ m w_p.sa.ca59?12m2(cs-RES) filed befuzam tlxis
"cam-:, wmch mm as be diamssm: by arder dated
29.2.2062 (mm? praduamd at fiI}I 'D' is the: 'Writ
This Caurt %.a absmwread; that it was
t/'
wnwwuwxmt "9.wf5"§ flu-m""€M"*MM1m'"*t1:EAF'"\7.l9£'€v.lI9"€z ifi"i§$V3lF'l£ MM
spam ta the Writ Pa ta ralm afl
mm' by the swim mm' W
ormma aumorigv and $1 'chm 'w=ak e:M:§f T
%.dj_,,g the mawgnmkfiimyfi gm
imtimma mam: me j J
bonaficie nzistakc am' the
an :11 am an
a;apIim41:.§§§:i'VV V ' ~V§i_fstA '._.§E£§fiandcn_t-Bank unstim-
Order 9 3f mar: axfi Smtion 5
of tha ajkswed w the: arhitzmc-r
13.3.2001.
*2'; 'V in the or@3.a' ' I ,
pr;-;a¢e 'x 1§; ffézit Petitimzers as is tizxaeir trait, wales up a
A x % ané rm: presaz-M Ravisixm Pemn am.
hefam :21: Kamatalaa Amnam '§'r£bu.naI
k A that the ertiar as gamed witiwut awarding a
proper' oppamniity m fixa pt-mam: petitimnnrs 129 $3 their
objerzrtioztm et;c., Em 'had in law. 31% t fiunzi
V
awwnewmamwmm aruwlm MWMWE WW fififlwfiiflfluw WW3" flag
favour with the Appellate Autimfitgr in mm emf
mdm' dated 2?.8.2fl(33 paased in
Hc.97j2002 (Copy pmduwd at u " ~
Petition; and the arxtier allcrwing the
Arkaiuatnr was set aafie
to the cxrigiml autkzzritf to
far brirlfing the lgal Tltzsc dccmed
Vjiriahzlaiah as to
the pmcn ia ab-
izzitio-void. Lixppurtlanity of being
lmzd tgbozh %/
&~ .. x 'finch hfimry, thfi appficatian
1.£1;'__ "" Err nrdmn cm 5,5.% and the
to be ailowed as pear the order at
i 'F urdar yet agahzt was qtwsfiszwd before
' But Witkmut sueawa on this aexasion as
K « dismiasad the Revéaian P'e1*?Jfio:1 as par its
datad 9.4.290? {Capy pmaums. at Amzre 'G' to
W1-3': Hetitinn} and it is quamonsng them orders of
thus orifimal autlmxity azxd the Tribunal vac Anmures
'F' & 'Cr' rapectively, the pz-want writ petitian.
/"
x
V
'W 'QM
as 'w"w
g. sumfimm of $1 3 V Bhat,
a on behalfnffiw pea-_:mm is that %
immma againm a ma. pm-mu; Ea:
which ia a mzllity in Law, .b§
Order 22 Rule 4, Gmdcr 221% [ Swmn 5
ar the Limitmrzn 4%.-:'.:t__is anf"z'1.:;c1a3maxt-
Bankwas. aim?)-5;' mntizrrue the
33191'! whiz had already
died being" am mmdm, it is
-V the prez-mm arétzxa 9f the
mfi as amhe mm are: aquafiy
1 k%m".k%tI: 3 saw me aabmmm that deciavm a
x « cfthfm mmmmmgh an Lmhsch was film'; in
_ if1'w%gar'n of appslieatim, mm been allmmfi witkwut
,vir*t11a11ypriB
t£s:pe't:£tfaoz1.ersr¥ghtt:ad¢fmd the whbh wag
@1'1ty of the I§ wifich had been he-augktt
amrmawwwrwwrawwm uwwaw uwwma we" mxnnmamfifl nmm LUUW U?" K&fiWfi'¥"5M(& Mfifigwi Cfi
agmt the dead pemsn, 'fimrefcra, aka the
badinlaw.
:1. In supw-2 crf this submiséfibn, A
rein' nae on the 3%' ' ism. Bmch da>£$is£ mf§.'Tef
Caurt in tin: me at cmmmv
um:-ts, mmm, xe§§1;_ed *
293 and axmthm' Caurt in
the ease of aemct v.
awmmm in Am
12. the Divisinn Bmxch csf
vim that a suit imnzmea
yeratzxn. ia. a Nullity in law and the:-mm
under Gxfiw m Euk 4 ram: an
fim Order 5 Rule 1? am he ma-mm' ed in
A M and diamiasmg the suit. along with the
_ far such puz-we was the prep&* warm: csf
ta1nm1byt.hetriaICo1zrt..
13, In tm dee$im:3. of the Suprme Cam': in
Mfsfishok 'Trmzsport Agerwy case, a 6% nbtairmd
:1: ma xmwwwwwmwawmt K"H%m'M"&1 WM
:16:
agdm the dead person wlrml waa sought ts
mmcttad warm the maxheim, 51-. was resimd f
4 readwith Rule 10 of me, while
tr:'IaIC;am't, it hafi been V
Rmzann Fatima under
was agin %ed by thé appeal at
theixmmrrxzeaf the the
Swim Ceurig Grder
30 Rue respect of the
" not a - 'p
cc:nom":1etc:uI,;\\/._VM% _ . é
Ran, ]aa.rz1sex1 Ceumal
fir-at rwpomcnt-Bank weuld
' that the gresmt writ petitien is not arm
by the High Caurt in an Arfwle 22?
A that 'Elm {Eda pawad is may an an IA in a
pmmafiing; that a. writ patition alacufi mt be:
en'bax'mir:;ed for fi1t at m sta.gIa§ Whm the main
maths-zr fa afifl pemim before the arzigfitlal amfmrityh
W W" "W"-nwwwmwwm uwww H-uwwuu Mr nanmmémtfiafiu WKWW V-...UUi'H U?' fifltflwfififlfifi "WWW $3
:11:
:5. It an aim aubmmaa that the
tmugh was agairmt 11% dead pman wfhnm _
caw ta know that trim pcrscsn wag u
wmmfive shew have hm;
pi-swarm had} been %
the Bank was amt havizgfihe of ms'
the pmon; that the u of the
4mm pasaan. by the
preamtit W1-it tmir
@al smug. pamans and
in such gr the legal hairs had been
mugm fif the dead persmtx, the
ths claini petitimi was cured
the eiaim pefitisn against the pt-«went
withzn' 1% mm' him of law'; tmt the
tlrmwh wag mt twxablae #1 has iniua1ly"
" has mu cured, than anly legal
applicafisn was filed am the lam}
applicatinn allnrwed, tha paramzt
pefitismm ware subatimtsd in plaec 9f the 971-g'nal
xmmndemafisusmnaflmthfimaxnaofacfionm
-
Wfi e\wMwm.tt!n:r”vaH”§m\m”& nmuwaw WW
«ax wwwwuwx
:i.2:
term efthe impugmd exams are scught to be
from the Judi nf the fiupamfiourt in ~12
«pa-ua in Am mm ac 2&4,
has firawn swfic attc:-sntien £6; V
we men we and in the the
suprm Court in um #2:’ and
cums. in. that
was alse, jprsrson and
that the ‘ ‘ came
ta m®%mu§ m§%af gm dcfmaan: as was
agi xx”: the nafizze that had
and that had {wen
Paatal Shara “A&d1’me:’ci&* 22 Rub 4 of cm, om umcr
Swfimifil azfl 153 at? CPQ. The trial Cant’: u
nmrwnmawwuurflinflfl flihfiflifi VI-u\’*&t9*M!’fl’&% NJ?’ flfifififififilflflfifl
:13:
both the appncaciom bang cf the view
applimtian Ear subséttxtitjg aesendmz $03.2 m;4 % f _
ml hm and tha éarmiant j
the tiw for a suit an the
Thserafora was of the View
Secticn 151 carlnot be the
mm all applicatiom ‘rm
mam had been filing two
Rmian Pe£:itia,:§s Am; ‘clue Raxaiaim
the “tlrxat the o@1a’ ‘ I suit
wcaufi ham’ ,3 an the am gr fi.l31g’ the
proper View for the mson, the
5 at £1513 Lsmimion Ant. would
afthis mmm that the appiication £91′
ham. allowed, wank date back {:5
_ A’ gr smssmntm af the ‘ ms the suit
bear; itiafitutaé within the perm af zimitaaian fez’
‘ ‘ miief an the pmmte, the trial mart was in
diamisaing applimfisona and ages-rdir1glv_, allcrmmd ‘Elm
Rwkivn Patitisns emci the app1?m’tis:3s. Ayirmt. such
:14:
erdara oftm High Cc-urt, flm mafia: had beer: carried to
um summe mm by fin dasamaant, the f _
Cxourt epfixw that the addiwn of the =
aacmn {1} of Sectizzn 21 whfich was net 3: ”
the Limitatimn Act. was and had
1963 Act no cure sugh a
arm the: Caaurt was aatiafied
partiw m’t1:m~ as p ‘fi§ to a
miatalm made in tr:
correct witkmut, af such
mmaaxy stage and thc
prJ:*m1m’ him as? K ficrfixzsn sf law exwhlazi
as :2: Btlit, which had been
tht: mwly mm pa.-rufm as t.’r1a.1gh it
grow’ ‘zmI’2’I15t:i1:ut:ion am Ema}: is
vfiaavifinrx, tbs iriai Ccurt: was in max fa
the applbnankn an the graursé that the
mufi have besen barmd by Lam’ .tat£9n,
that the E-iighifatzmrt hasmlnmtime mzfracxtsriew
and acmrdingly afjsnmaa the appeal.
»vsm’«’x\ wwwmu mm ww”uaramawa”‘¢nafl”‘M€V.fl’\ aunuafrl uwwnl WT WHKIWMEMKK WKWW MKFUK3 LN” Ki”-5%_%_§§fifi«§,§fi&%fi&
:15:
16. 1: is this amman which 1’3 1-aim apex’:
mm Ccmxmel gar the {amt zmpnndent-Bank _
that the appfic-afion kmvkg hm bfj’ u ” ~
autmrity as well as the
not only by the Judwnt «sf v%
am at v.
so 2324, but
aim by the 3tatj.;*i:a:_fy 11? :::f the
Karnataka Aaentim
is amva g%§zfar’ @ 1;+s§ectiarn (3; of Secfintt
11?, whigh _’ 7
is 3 my :9 the
to mare than one reiief :31
‘ . the mime of amen’ mm; dam’
k«w¢a5ga,fwm reIi9_,fs; hm rfhe amim m
‘7cl:zimfi§;f_£*;I1s1xc:v}z refiefi, Iwshail netfinvwd
V ‘#5; far mm reiiefsai fimiwsci, wcmpt with
A. , fifths Rwfisbww er arm mhwpazwrz
whom a dispuha £5’ mm»-w fir dwision
wxdermmbn ‘F11′
it is submzm’ that in ‘him mm’ sf such proviniena
the authozrity m pernzdt tm additinn efa new
defmdant car when instituted in him mm at” wrong
:16:
ptfificfi text ads! thc fight pcrm at any ataga sf
hm:-zag cf the dfiplfie providad that it was _
bonafide mistake and in ma pmmr, A
mam bm% am as expbiruad
apfiiaatlms are: W33 sustains-;:i_ 3
wovm if mm um um
thwefiom submim :16 i$_ _
1?. comma:
£31′ the first gubm am the
addition ‘ as Raga}
jusfi.fieé an gm; as
the positiabn af guatantars and
nt in famur af gm Bank,
Vfgfgaymmt and ware wimmaexs. to that
fatihm; that they are wmpwd finm
J
t9 the ecntrary and if 9: pemn ears. be
g ta’: 13:1 their awn mm as d t, it mafiam um
VT if they are dmcribeci as mal haim afa ciawmaad
xwuorz. and fish:-e submfi that Im m is
mwmmmwrflurfiflffl E”‘HlQn’?fi”l Emhdfiflfig ‘Jr
:17;
18. liomally, 3% Ccsurt wauid mt
such wntenticxzm in a petition unéar Arficie
Comtimtziem of India, wen the ” ‘V
prameclings bfiore the
quwtion is tak¢1’1 up for
and 33 submitm by the
pefitiarm that the Vdaad parse};
:15 a Huzlity’ 53%’ ._1awj=”‘ gumiminn,
madifmatiefi, mm: ha
19.’ in law mt dehatabie
any ta “‘ixsf$;ki’v€erith;ari::;:; that pramewrxg’ agmrxs’ t a
dfisad’ Kim in Easy. Only €§1Zi$fi£.!1’i is in what
T3 atifi Em mam’ ta.1z’mc1′ aad
_vaMa’ A suixequem &s*¥:iz::r:…
_ V L329. ‘I”1’w @103′ d1’&’W”.£’1 by Sri fi.
_ Icameé Gamma}, far the frat rwpx3nd¢nt-Ba.r1k is
V W1m1 once a party is ad% by way af 3. t,
subatitutfiosn €131′ aafamwrka term asf’ tbs provhfiom af
fltisn 21(1) much date hack to the
S?”
/
/r
x”‘\auM”m ml: WM!» mwwwm WW3: mwmwnnwmamnm I”KiH£€Wfl WM
:18:
data: af tithe arkyéztlal ixfifiaiimn $1″ 13% .’ 3
therfiare hwxm valid im an autfifiy whfi _
eitfm” aptiy agzrplicahia er éjmcw =
pr%t 3ituah?o¥’1- Qlmtisn ia nut ‘«
pmeaurmg er the naturzz 5: u
rwponximzbfiarak maid
meurmeras iitbed ‘m as fr:
whether it had .
should belrmfi m:.§e=
ammpm.m;, had tlmemselvw
soug}:r§’t:.~ hgal rcprmentativm :21′ the
appea: befisre the Tribunal
a men alkwad and tha matfm’ had
tn the firigizml autimrity fixr re—
fiéisx an mazrzlrk If such is the mrfim
the lwl rewamntatfl an mm?’ awn.
VT , rwm’ im the: proceedum’ an bgal
:repa’we2″1tafi::fi, The queatinn is um: {me sf
mm aa lfial mprwmtatfim, but the qumfmz is as ta
whetfi the cxriginal pmcmdirxg as irmtituted agairzat a
%’
…. ”
ww”H “MW” wwwwm WM awmmmwamwww I'”ill’IW!”! muwsu VP” amamammm. %'”$§?£;$i'”§ QWUENM CW5′ §€t§aRNfi:g’fi@%& HWM flé
as its the vafiéitf’ caf the
:19:
ficad peratm was a. xzzullity in law and if an
has been gut aver by any ether
law.
22. Even fer a 1%;
canmd that the 0&1′ ‘
fherefam nathm
23. In respcmdem:—
Bank has mt what was»
an pemson by mung
the ~2:2″RuLe; -1; Grdcr 22 Ru}: 9
of ($93., Limita&n Act; as even.
” ..~ r an recaré as
k cm mg matter having been
W 1- m*a1 % $5+:r;§%amnase Tfibumi. The qumtinn 53, if
‘_”_;__. a;zch pesitian af tm proowdim befem the
A 3 — wimm tame was any rma say the m-imam:
as mail as tam Tribuxaal E have egairzed on the
3-_ wI:1i3e
examming such whsfiy uxmwwfiaxy appfimhiona unda-
:N2:¢£WmW~«*”‘va anwwarzzh Wmwwmi WA MKRWNIWQWEJMFQJW lI’1fi\¥N”E flaw’
s:< 'Wwn<vwrwuv'wmw
:31:
order 22 Huh; 4 er Rm 9 and Sectinn 5
Linlitatinn Act.
24″ ‘I”he mum: addIm&:f:éi5AA»V:§§1.,bf’?-31§}f_ ,&
rwnécriis that the
not suppazrtufi by the .
A.Madhuau€1hana c;:§§i;,m1 em
autlmrity
for the far subsfimfinm.
af 3 13.3., eafidixg af 3.
plehfifi though such adding
cafths p%a.;~:y%§gg:zsg1ga¢r peaifiiafuma, it ahcmld be team
. . . . . .. ‘ 1d’ A in law, wag mhm*’ warmmnd
iwaitian of law.
appfiaatimn F21:-$3 an behafi’ cf the
44 A’ A,t befare tfm Arbittamr mt one ‘ea add the
” it: their awn mpacity as partm tag: the
i.e., by way at’ suhsiitzmbn but may ta
class:-ibe ‘chm as lagal repmmtativm at’ a dead pm-sun,
apmsonwhn haddisw e:\am1attI*z.eix1itiai:iar1afthae
1- mmwmmwmm Vamtrws ‘6’i«$””‘|b£W.LtVfl3f””&.Ffi3″’65l\aU’I aiswau WW
:22:
preaeadE@, the impmwd erdws cscmld mt have
chma as am s:a1&ti:t1g the arigizlal
It *3 ea dfiwmt maaer if the Mp-».f:1;:’.tz’;ar;~§’&’*a:;-i u
have been batsught an mm in éa§pa§i;§”
defmadanm am: as ta whemmjkzmzg
way mama to the bemfiaaf ml the
clam: as agajmt than what was
athamptad an the’ cf anfi
that having ngni; claim the
bmu; af .i1’7[3}(d} of the Co-
capezrative Sgoégfimifi ‘ V’ _ h ” ~ ‘
:23. ma §r£§e abmae: diacussfian, than Writ
authority! Ammrurw ‘F’ 85 ‘C? are
quashed af a Writ :31’ Cafiorari. It in capm ta
its plzraue the matter agaimt; ti,-1:5 prmnt
VA anly in the wdsting ummcity as lqal &i”rs,
. w*%:3::::h atatua p¢r.i:;s:onm-s flzmtmeivaw ma dmcribed in
mgommarrmumzmmmim raurzdand
itisalsamada ckmrtmatitfmcpmtotlxcprwentwxit
petit§mxIemmurgeaEEsu;:h1%s9zfimi::naa51:m.ybe
//
23
opw ‘ea mm in the faxrtkwr gmawcifims bcfarc
Arbh1’at:ar.
Sd/-5
Itxdgéj ‘
Ev gfiwfigfig ax; x§§§.§ $55.: §xu.§m#iI$¢.:u.§&.¢s£….%e.n 2119 ;..:..§_. …..Zi, …:?.§..,