EN ‘T’H§: HESS 5:039’? :3? igamg-‘m:<;a A'? B1a;;~§f<m*';s;~¢;*'g_3;,;<:V;:e:._§':;:' A'
msrag 'E'§é'ES "2"?-{E 21% 95:5; :3? A?R§§,..,é§Q91.'.j.:'* 3
PREsgN?
WE H{3§%’ELE MR’ ma. D§Ng%E{A§;%§€ _,-..C%£iE:§?I’.g}{§’S’i’£C?: 1′
,2s::x::i3%. .
THE: H{}?~§’BL»E 3%’£.R:.JEj&:;”‘T’ICVE~i{‘G,SAB££P;}iIT
WRIT AFFEAL Ex:-vd.’ :’32.;;;;.=’—2§§3_V__
3%:§*wg’:«:fi’; ‘A 1 .1 ‘1; _
ET SE2: K M;=,r~m:’N5;*€i§
3; <3. SE31 §~i";VU’:f* 54 ‘{‘E’;§EES
; §¥’E?;QPR§E’:?{}R ‘
” :a:§gs,_H, KR§8.m%:~az;;H SEW? I’§E,’;, ;
Véfifa x
Efimfifé 23) MAEERAS I-“€(T?..%.1j;_ ‘=
zyasgavazxzimaam, K R PU§”e:AM..’ : M T ..
EANGALORE 15 RE? BY E”£’$fSE%’\?_§G§ * =
REGIONAL MANAGER ” é T ‘
Rgfrgia AND mm? cm§s:;~*_:’=1’m2’§;:a-». J _ –
_A.’rTRNE¥ smsgzségay _M:aL§~;m*-RA, ..R;E:$P::2f§~ms:::¢’§*s
THEE WRIT’ APPEAL ES__ i?’.,1_if:}3Q :§;§.__4 _é)§~ ma
KARNATAKA HIGH GGURT AC5? “REM:-:;~z<:-{ TC) §'s.SIi}E
THE ORBER 92383;)" _ LN ?{.';'F§~E–;Ei:f~ =:s.;sez*:" P€'E'i'Fi€)N
N{}.}8?3?,12GQ? SATEEI) 22/'?'/EvE33C3'8;. . *
This W3? 23.; u.§"fé£:t- Eieming an
this: day, SASE:ivA}§§:'1";k3'.,V £i.6I;i¥;€m<i_ tbs': f:3ii:§*:;vi:1g,
"C_3;§fiGméx?
4′ fiiéci by Kim §€§i”£i{}i}€E’ rig
‘*:. :2’ez::«a s;;:§;ez~e:n’é§e gamed Singée Jaége has iissfiizzesé :9
_.s:s:er§c§3¢”‘«.;a%:~§i AVT.’§:-ggsagctgmg cf this izaazfi; in View 0%’ ma
aiififfiaiififfi’ afificacieus remedy previdaci in $26 cgnfiraei
._f:3r raf$fi;iug the dispute ‘:0 arfiifiafien and acctemiingijg,
A ” ‘éAié§Cs$€d {:»f the writ pefifion,
2. “§’h€ apjpafiazjai harem féxiid “é»i.P,?€o,18?$’?f’2§G?
sersiezixig for 3 deciarafion that the Qzdsr §33ssd by the seccnci
\,-J3
i’€3S§93.};€i€’§}.’€ da’§£f:{§, ?éC?.1F3a2fi0’£’ pfi;:’m:i?,%”,.i’:1g”_’ V
agreemazri datad 6.12.1996
petiiimisr and the 36-cmzxé msgéagiiigzzt is’;1,”:,1§L’; far ”
quashing fizfi grcier sf f_£e.1:*mi3:1g:§i:ir::V;::f2″~0f%§:£€3l%I’5s}1i§ agad <:i.ir€<:t
the secoafi :°espon&e.:fi gmd 110%: {:3 {he
E3€€i'tim'3;€r*3 ret9.i,M::::;tEs€,'i'i'is::$;gv§1¥:%€§"'i$§'_ ifietifigxi the:
Efiifiififlfii" ' ;¢?~"'§€U"{f}§f.*:'§3.fi} proéuats
'imdar made 021 6.2v19§é
enmraifz . patitiensr 3333. {E16 S€COL§i
msp0n{i§s5:2:;%L?§s5a I SSH' AiV1?£:{.§V:é:£$§;4i'é3;r;Ei'%::t.rg31t%13m Cim}'31*ati0:1 Liii, “T3616?
$eCs:;:.;;&’ 1ffls§)0I’z:{;eii’i;¥CO:pGrati0n carries ()1: the §31};S:?:1€s@ af
zlfiliai sale “”” ‘iof petraisum products afifi mare
fsfitroi and 6.1636}. ‘file jfirca S3363 igiaraager
{R€%§fl} 0f the S€€f_}§ii{i mspenfiam: ingpecéed this
-.p€ti£i0i:t:__if?s reigfi mifiafz an i~}:§2.2{}§€i~ 333$ in €56 C-{)”t};I”S€: ef
” §.%;::,¢ 4″‘m:3§€cii0n, $326 ifispacféng efiicia} neiizzsd fiiai the
p§13?s§.ca£ Smciq if high S§ee<i éiisszsi was Vz§_z*j;i§zg §_'%{3j;-'"€35§'E{§
permissiiflfi ijmifi; and susgenifiad Ehfii'. 33353 and £093: samplrrtg
of EEK: gméuct iiifipmizsaai at {Em ;}€i§i:E.Qn€r'3 miaéfi <;u§ie%, €03'
\v-5
5
psiiiionar tfimnirzaieé fhzi: daaiershiy 0f the §}€*€i€i{).Zi’€.i:i;’–}3}”
ietter dated BCLEQVZGG? and being aggrievad
Qrdsr, wxiii petition was filed cvsrztendiag fI3é1i’§”i}%3″i€I3:fi}%i}3,§3ifii¢§I}’ b
thr: dealtitrship is ifiagai arid it; * _.:1ms,=
zznsustaainame and ‘£heref(>re,_ }ifib1é”.. trfibe s;:é$: gisiée:
lfiafilfid Singie Jufige after c0:1§–§§3;:V§ré’1fi11g ths
Eeaznmti counsel appssaréng for’.AE’iie’A;’rV):£:3’iV?f,i9;1er a§:é”fl1’é iearflsfi
ASE’, appfiaring fer Eiaiad 22.’?;;l3{}O8
heid ihat $33 €§%1:?;..:::f_ _€)’f V t€;§g§i§af.iQ:1 itself séaies £213? thaw is a
cfiauszz fa:-w..ré:’?3:rr§:2Vg fiizéé gitiggfizie is Arbifiraiiezz am}. :13 via? 0%’
{E16 Eifiiifiiijfiiiiffi ésfgéitéziiatéve mad aificaciaus mmeéy, 13:} $2136:
‘V”;i?a$””malE§€ :5’-e..*.’§£ for exercising xxgsfi juxésiiictégian sf ifézéig ceurt
akficséiifqiitzfgéjg,’fiispgsseé of €316 §£7E’ii ;3€t%”i:i<:m with 3 €§i1"€C-iififi
ma: fi1€..§:€iE.i§i0:1:3§" wars to imzeéezfi '£316 aI'§3i"%_I'aE:é02;3 2:231:36
-.,wi’:1′.:.in” days fram {E15 {Eats Sf rziceépt of {Jim mfifiig $116
‘ 1’ssg;3’:~i5;1:ia:1%:s shzaj} am. in tszms 93″ {£26 afeififiaié ciause and
‘ é.i§’biira:€ the {1f:$§}E3.f€f. That. %3s5:§;2g aggrieved hf; the said Grader
ziateé 22.?..2{}{}8_, the W113. pfiiéianfir has prefitrregi E2135;
appeai.
‘VJ;
4. W& havs heard the iaazned ceunsei a_§a”;3éa;::%i:g _
the appeiiafii,
5. fixaamatti cmmssi appea:;1:?i::g_”fIia3§§e éimzz mag? fie
grazgteé $9 a§3pma«::.h ihs £’§r§_1?;.£°3’E»::r,
:7}. ‘%3§€:” f; ‘:;.av£€’Z_ ‘g§.$%£«;1’ sriatzftifui cansédmatiozz ‘:0 ‘SE15
<:(m€e::.':;%é;;:;1 af t%.:§§é:=;§;:3.c5€}.._¢i;%m$eE agpeazing far file appziiiani.
ami $<;mz'{.i:i'i:'-Aefii fiiifz mafiéiiai can record.
'.'AEf§1€";;t_1aiez'§a3 911 record wernxiii cfifiaziy shew that 52135::
§}_€*£i.';i0::i£:§4"'%%?a:;é'u'eciltrusfiefi with €333: dsalemiiip 9.?' §ai2:'a0i€u33:
pre::i'<;3:.u§«:9th$ 36901163 mapondent faméer agreamern éaiaé
K 1§:96; ami an §.:1speé’:té0n_ sf’ ‘aha retail cutie: af E56
” :;;f;>é-§i%.i:¢f;nar 911 Q Ei2,.2Q€)6 it was faunfi ‘ska? petiiiansrr haé
VA .. __’§%’iiG}.fltfiii the §3}’%C3’£?i$}:011$ of eiausas 2?, Efi, 35} 28, 4:2, 4’? mid
NJ
338(k) of the {icaiership agz*€:&I:1€:»nt.._3z1¢:}{»f£$iir3%.::iavg ‘
irreguiarifies Wem faumiz
“L ESQ vafiatzlazi b€yGfid’~~.§€z’m §ss§é;1&
firs. _’ _V 3
:2′ Free fiir 3:15 .’£*}a§&1” §3¢’§§:§%’j;;’;;%;s.._go: afiééilavfiie at ‘£336:
3. }?§i’St .%§{?.~.1«:§i: W33’i?»*%)’§”&’§?é?é:ia’§};z’gVe§1’§’.’i:’;3§€Z”%:B1},’E”.I€¥1.
4. Fire wE;1’€:”‘afiit 9;=.2ai§:§bie 31 the eufiets
:3. D3€’i€;&xi§4:i},f”S2i£;€ts:i:;¢I3. ii;:?:;?.r: £153.33 u3:1iferm””.
S}:{§:£?f~r;a11£$Vé :::_é:l§j£: was iéssausd $0 the writ yfiiitienézr
an 3:’? i’;}2,2i3{}6 ‘:»331i:i’:_pr¢3ti?iii11§:z–~xrepiitid :0 316: said Shaw Causa
natics <3:1 i2,é%». '12.V25¢i}$f;_ $15 fix: émguugzzaci Grzier has faesfin
'V V' ._ §€::€és§§¥::%_A–c:;zz 1{};,'2G~S§'"as pm" Az1ne:<:"u;"€—E~§ ta E125 writ petifisn
_ £323 iwhééig i'?i. i:§_Sé;:%tsd as ibiiowsz
in Ca$€ jififi are aggfizivsii by fizais
. '§é%Arrf:;§%ia*{i0:; if}. €'i.§'i:§3' magma: Whataeszver, 3:91: are
'e.~;;{'::::€:c: :9 invskfi étiavse 55 fig the agazazshgp
H Agraemsnt which prezysvicies afar rsfezsrmg tbs
fiisputes ami ziiffsrencas for aéjugiiaation ':0 me
mia 2r'm'.trati0:1 af tbs Efianagiflg Eirecter ef €116
Cmpmration or 9;? an Gfiicea' af thfi Corparatiorz
who I33}? be zwmizzated by aha saié Mazaagiug
\9..3~
E}ire1!iS§finS 0.? the Rrbiiiaiéfifi’ .. 5 »
Cusmtiiiatian Act, 1996 gzsmaantijg in vsgésg. L” M
spiis 0f {Em sxisienzre af ~~’ih;€& .§%riéi’i:”:;§%iafi’
agzfiemaat, in the awn? ii y<;§3,:ve3;1if:;%=a :2:-';to. fiéézig
any' iiiigation 331 any ceurtg sf L333: 3116 safizéi $1321 "
11$: ha mainta inahie as §3€§ g::rQvisi0ns'gaf S
mbgmfion and <:¢m1x:at':Q:Li'j;:a¢a,_,;99a3*';-« E
9. The fact mat “axfbiitrafitm 03*’ “§Ihf:’
£i€.§;§m1:$ ‘ihat maj,.5 a:_’.i$6 ?§é€i%ér7€-{in {fie deafiemhip
ag:*{:mi;€fi%i_ is :§<1s;:i':V-{i_:§$"§31:.'§::{§-..g132:i.' Tim fair': {hat wzii petiéiensr
has rm: éwaiiiéd s'u<?§3:f€*,'§%§;€}f¢3.§té{}31:s§ :"5me§;3-* is ais-.0 ::}<:sf; aiigprztczfi
amii ;i11:::'§f£::*:§, %:=.;:g;*§fi'fig régard to {is subject maxim" cf the W112:
";::s1!::2*ii:V."E:ss13'»*."J;g..z;§V%':'~,§;_s vsfizeihez" ihgm is my CO1};i§'3§?€,§E'&;{il1 9%' the
' zfigigfiésmfiizi which 313 éifipuiéfi E3! '£216 writ
§}{§ii§i8§{E3'; ixlnvésfjgaiiozg {sf {ha quasfiazi af fact caanst
Kb: g91§.3V__§:::t0 in the writ peiifica that ice Wham {hare is 33;
V"–V'_ar%§§€:*atiQn clause in the agrefimcnt is dissgshsfi the triisputé
that may arise between the parfiss ami themfsre, it is clear
mat the Gram" yasseé by '£116 ifiarnad Singie Jucige raisgsséfmg
Ks?'
'ihe peiitimier m an altemzativa am {;Z§fiC3:CiQ"E;%,4§."£'t?I"31€£L}'g'§§' iséi "
jastifxeci and (ices net. auger finm 5:113: »mjr0r5_ $I'vV'1f"}_:E'n%E3V:g'«"3§V{';~,-*'-:'&§Rf}i.,
havifig regaufi {Q the above Saié I3:1.3'3L6I:i'1_é;i"b£iK £'T€{ft1)3';{_i;'§'%'€'n§i%«ff:
not inefinesi is "iaka a W3ver, v ‘
since the time gragxiw. by ‘1:::_a::=r;_efi Siragfife gfizdgs far
making the apgéicatiam a;:E;i€n3;iiv0§?i–.}j3:§é%’~:%_}r€a(iy €§<:§§:'ed, if
is I}6€3EiSSE1I'},-* "ta gmfii :"$&3S€;2:a}7£o1€'f§"1;=;€:." : "
– §a{§.§:0z:€§i:3,g§;v:,” ¢{§§;:;e’V :a.f*p };§é%a}{“‘%s dispssezi (‘sf ‘ee:;3f:3a
}.:!hart§;: ‘:G “i’§Ai¢VTVj’fi;.3<=:t:li{%Z;<;;::;z€1§;"«V:%{'g'as: rtiiiéfiizag the iéigpute ta figs:
arhifrafien =::§3:5.3;g<:* *g=-2:{_:f;'§"fl?:j§i3}. fiafffi {mm the {Lime sf racfiipi
{sf ibis erdfif' .:ffi:'s;3%3.:24::'{r:i3"€£:s shaii C-Qnsiéer Tim sama as per
.. .. of iI§ie"§;:*::=a;;:1ed Singie Jufiga. },,.\
Sd/~
Chief Iustice
Sd/-y
Iudgé
" ""::§m1ex; *;«'cs;i~5~eg~:/-_
Web Host: 'ifif/N9