IN 'f{'I~IE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAIQA AT BANGALORE
DATED THIS THE 03TH any OF MARCH 29
FRESENT
TKE HoN'BLE MRJUSTICE v.Go1DA1..A.j{';'ef§v:):A._ 3
ANI)
THE HON’BLE M:§fJ1;s’1’iCfi’13.s.Pz§.T.i;’;V ”
WRIT APPEAL No.3*2′:36fggpg{c§;’:~.e.i»§:.’§Lii;§jW
‘ ‘
$111 K I’ (“II mzvxPAKA{)1–1AMA&sxxr,A;M’y?–.
AA13(>:..n’ :30 \z1j«:_ARs:3. ..
5/<T)1,;x'z*1e:K,5.1)I_..m'A:3wA:¢1Y 4 ..
R/M1>R.::;:MI$:::ss[:23:-::;§;r<1N<T;'–.3:<A2&1}1. "
IS'? 2\/EAI§\5,:ii*R"i'zf\(i}£fl..'f. ' j A' »
MAHA1.,AI'15RAM » ‘
1;3A1\?<"';J-«.1.13?'{?3I..§;AE’€'{‘
V V .u”i.:.%}’.’ ‘S3:-:9.’ “E<_' §.'~7'3'E M ' AI..)'\.="',
I ;:5'i","{1'I£- 013 -K_A.§{.NA'_1'J=.I<A
3 '5'£f3\f T1 Ii}: <":1~11 {bi–7 V-93.1.'-;'<';:m«:;if\,:<\;.
A (;<"Ti;-'I€§Ié'J'~§]\/II.EIN'I' 01? 1<;x1e.w,'1'Asx11:;)1-M.
. _-“«;I.{}]_{{_'{L.. 3..
2 ‘ _ ‘1″I~1;5: §:;1§£).I’~U52’§’AR\’
—- 1[1<__:«.m::;-.:;51::p.zx1-wmEm'
~g-~:.1eNmm’1′ 01+’ K:’\.i”2’€\$’;– “§”£\.K;’\_
.. _ \’1§’}-E–f:?aE\7z% s;I3;::>1»m.
‘ “4..1;w~s<_;;x1_.c DRE?) 3 .
‘H–n’:: 1;;:1z2;~:<"r'1'< )R (.}ENI:3I"~1Af., ;’«* m:_,1c.:1-«:
<':n ‘{‘RAJNl.N<…} S3PE(.ilAi._.. mrais ram:
1¥:<__':§\:r”JMH: (‘)i*’i-?i’ZN{“&~ZE%.
<":,=w.:,'1':\s §-1:.:::3:-:.
1-=.:m:x’ 1—a.-x:\:<';,.:w may?"
'5
aw _.
163
I7
I8.
.1x.<,a*
I j 20
542R] E~3II)I)i\I{AI\*I:'\
f\»-'I.-"mi (J R I N A( EIC
:\s'().($7. 22ND CR(')SEE'»._ IST 'A' Mi\.I?\.3
I3? I I3 \s'AE\II§S IIWARI §\§f\('"ufX R.
M .-‘\( }:’\I) I IT'{OAII).
I'”iA;’\§{._’3z’\I ,( 3 RE} 5{‘S() (I23.
IKI M Ai*i.AI ‘) IFIV/7-‘xi AH
;\’|(‘). EQEIEZ. I.6’I’I*TI MAIN _
\=’IJ:\Yz\?\EAC§;’\R. V
IiI\?’€(_}.i7\II(»)RI§ 560 {)L§»{‘J.
b’i’Vl”I’I’f~3;\I.:._3:.35(.>/£34. 15′!’ *5′ CR()S$é>’.
(“)1-«”1″-‘ 7’I’£~i c:I~2(‘_>ss. NEE)-AIR SLIM :sLr’>},
(I3/\YA’I’}-IRINAGAR. £3AN(..’:AI.,C)R–§:T:23.. ”
.’%Rl V N,-=\RASIa\/£1—IA Ix/:tJ~§’>;’}”I=»-i”{*.I 1
.-‘\(i.’,’xI.i1I_’) (:50 YRS. NO685. =51′-l’II Mxxléxé 1–‘_§é*;i.;:}’,j~. I
I\’§C§\”(“3I§3IRI I..fiI’Af\3A(.i}AI”§.»?x’ — I’ I
I5 I111—-I IN Ii) 55 U. I'{.’-“IN A. C2 C11,]… If; (.’3.I?3:.
I::7$jxEw((,,;f’\§J()Ei3»’§:£§£;5O’DESO”. IA
m~:,1> 1–3Y;r»¥1s:’_c.;pA- ~H__1..£>_V:_:rr_I-2 §rm»’
.<…a;'amavI I \1*"I<:-_,=' M33142 'fl: '* ._
\?L' !_ ¥.<.I''n''a_-::,..g,_;)tJ.A§1\: 2’\/Iz\! mil) 1=’~:wx1?1.s
I§1\I\§(:zi:\I§.”() I{§L§ 5§.s(;<j4H."*-..___
SSRI M REaMA!..§ Nam;-.i\1–1' «
15338 1, 1.91' 11:33:\x:;g-x'1z\z I"{'k")AII)
ms .
_” }_ .~.%<;;.x1
I{}:§__ 56(') {)4 0.
I”hare!”‘1?»/iI”1::3()I:>:3AJ.,INGA.IA§J1
‘ __>e ‘A’ C,ROE”5$
“~:<)'1,!’–“~£’~.’»(Ai;_-“‘~.iJ()I'{II~Z- :’36(} 070.
: L._E-3RI ?X’I’¥II€R F’A’z”k~1IMA K.I~~I.§\N1.§ M
;m.2 I 3211:) Iv’IAIE\I
I “‘§’«.»,=’7″~.~.”*$¥II}II,iI’s/L’~’=II’\J”‘ IAIAJI §’€;-“x(‘}A¥{
§.,.,»-“x Ii Iiikéifl II} I’3i,T-“3;
E3/”s. ( }AI ,( ) I «E If 338i} ()3 (‘3.
SI-{I Ea 3′ zx/:A1TT1AN*.:’A1’3I3;I.
{T I” I I IEJI7 IZN C} I ‘ ICIEIIQ
IO”
.,;J
2;;
K!–“‘£'{.’.I. §\I§;’\g..} OR. ‘vV()RKS Z(‘):\.?I’3
Ti .”:\./E£{1_%’I’\’
FSIU {-3 S 2\/L-‘\§\§.}{_.?§\E.-‘\Ii’WK
.’€{,). E?3r1–%–. -“H11 (,fT\'(.)S$
LZ{.)’ H-I M x’\£ R(_).»’\.IT,).
ZNI.) PI'”l£\SI:’I. ekI.}-‘.Nf’x(..};\.£–{
§”>A§\3(“}f-‘xI..(‘}R.I{C 5630 G78.
SR1 (EECIQAIIJ L; A Ha,»-x.Nc’:1s
N'{“}. -:17/1».’. .”§RIj) (“:1″aos:;:;
m:’1’ari—-nwss ROAD. _
S’I’.’l’H(..).M.AS *1’0w;\: T
1-:3A:\zGA1.,oRJ2 560 084.
S.’i’%Zi K .”:RI’;\?.IV/\.SA
.\'{“:. EU. 2(.)’§’iI ‘}3’ (II\'(‘)i%’-SS4}.
IQ} I H ,’ IXA.
i3:’\N(:.}z.’XI,(.’)RIF} 5360 (H7.
SR}. 1:…AK$I-1MAMM’A _ —
\w(‘;>’1..m’1«: I{RISI~IN./-X T ~
N(_).12. ‘:\:1-:;=x 1-2 ,r\N;JANAa«>:–>,+x ‘1~;,rw–<'qLw;:fi' '
B.€_t..<'.t.1,_:\\{o! i .
\—*mA’yuxN;rg([3: ‘* . .
.i..3A.N(‘Lj.’~.I’;(3} 1: ;.r1;}_ ‘4c’)\.«.A___
SF?..’—- E’-v1. 1_-aim}: ‘fxizg:-;x_.\.z_::«:1.s:I.\}It,:_Lj1:§INN-Iiimg3
s;s,:1:\.;a z~’k~}..–§MI<2I')-
1=\. ‘2 ‘~.’:’;\2;$:’,~ ‘. 1_~;}.«;:M J’:x~:A’N&’;’1′.–::s -( >;. :>’RI*)V T*”iv-{_”;{.)I \”;–. W541 .~.:y1A:’:\’
1511′. am’ s’s’§T:;\(‘;If:A ”
I~3_r\§”\E€..iI’z.5’~[i”,~.f..) R i.«; zgég.
‘ J “7.’: .».\._..s–~:v
” A_,r;.:;21; ‘:*’3E5(.) (1)94.
«’ 5§..(.fi3I€.AJ
i E. 7* EV./IIs\I:”\’ }«:;xs..s’;’
?*u;,\(§j;°s.’§”)§ (“fl—I€)§%I’) R5″):-‘-XI’).
K5 L} ‘;”‘iY,/”7-‘a _:”x( E3’: R
V L ” ‘vi’;-<?*~,*;'*é £3': E»: 3 R [:3 ;=.3s:~;<..'J (:35;-{:'§*4
E~§P~%§ E?» R-"i§
\m/
.-1’1′:–§ (‘.’§¥3{..)SS, RP(‘. 1.mr'<_.;:._é":'
V L ;..:\m3\sA< EAR 2 D S' I_'..»\ <1'. 2-~:
1–3:\§\§{.:Ai,(I’)RI-C rm.
54 5312.1 \.~’1.«:I.£;
1;-2.1I::. <:.1e:. ((13) I{P'1'(3I.
\'(.’).’_«1:’3. 2.§\’I..) MAIN ROAIJ
{“1 -I Ia’€1\?;\I-‘f”.f-\ (.}ARI)I£N
I3.3§-::\;s,<;N 'I'wN 1>0s’1′ _
I-5/\;\?(.’}AI.,(.}RI¥3 5E>’U (ms. ‘
9?
Vt :
m1″2:\?’A’1’AKA \r1I)YL.I’i’I»«I<':I–IAKATHI'N’¢–:I<;\I<AR;\, * . 2
ssm1A.I;’:m$s
:1’ia_y .sr;.L’3;xSAvARALI’ }'{..r;1~ mu in-fs. I=*t1.’>s-;a m ’11:’: {:21-4.
$I”‘{I.I~¥.I3A\»’Aj\FA c:I»11’AN13_RA Szé;i£3’_:*I”‘a_. x:.;=\.;. FOR (iii:/R113
.9121. {-3. R. GUI-{LIPRASA~I). ,A1V’)’\V/. :’1’«'(.;>-13 z % ] {~-
SR1.s.s113I.>Az>r>A &v’~I43£2.I;’ié5.S1_.§].\’.[I,I)A’§fE”‘ ‘ ,~
:’\I’)’\/S. 1’éci’>I~’-2j’} ‘ –
WRIT v- –_I’:€’~_,’I§1«;«1’j~ {.J=,«f_s T.’ :13: I{.Ai{:\?A’i.’;X.i:{./\ I—–EH31—I
{T(}IER'{” ACT!’ 1>1_:<A'-{I 135;; TC)'E3_E'1~Tf;"~§3I'ii)EI’«1:’;V’I.’T’I.’_I ON 138:3 *”?2:€,2,{30€a_ 1:r.»j_\’1″I’%:D–_ (5.! O9 / 121 1″! 39
‘}’§”‘1’i–*s \¥”1’i¥”, Apps-,~:;1 ¥'<:g.5r;:'11_1«~:.g2; {"311 fin' T'z"<_r§%1n£11;-iffy' }2.c;.*an'21§_.,:_'.
t.1T1%ss (12..1.y, Gi%a::’>wi::;t_’,m.g’:T
‘JUDGMENT
PE :-i:;;-11*.(.1*«i,V§:Tia:: _}c’-%211″1’1€{i (.’m1I”1.s&é1 1’01” I”i’n_f ;”>z–:..z”‘£.:’1′(ic.*.;” c.iz2=2.*:.<'*.(i 1E3.Ef%_2()€f}9
1::j:,{ ("Sig the Eeaarneci Singie LJ1.3.d§_.?:C' in WP E\E'(__).Z38§f37/()9
4.,
” .. . , . 4 M . ‘V . _ K
v~’c:’;’.r*j(“”.E.1:an to 111?;-‘:1’I€1″e: q1.2e.1.s}”3.1:”‘:;; <':~§ ihv <_..z-‘v<7 z"nz7'1<*n 1.
.__"""()z'€ie1* (‘:21se 2igE1iI}51 21})pvE%e;1x’1_i’_ (“:0 {I’:€,)D 12:1 i.hc’:?
<mnipiai;xzzmt. iraclgcsd by r'c:s{:)c:')x':cie.1'1ts in 2.13 is»: (_T§"l&.k1I(?I2§.§€'E(".1
in 11'1i.<.; ;"'\pp2;%2.1_1.
K:
IS. “l’}:C.1’c is no .1″1(:é<*(.E £131' 115 {'0 E1(}\-"<';"§' E E31:–* f’23.f Elm: lea1’r:ed Single’. J il(1;__§t;? llas (:12:i.)(>:”2’1t’c;-.13?
i”E’1c:- Ilictis; amil e-:.x1I’a_c:1, I\/.Ieu1ua1 with 1*<3ga1"CE to e1"i:t.1"1.£.'.i"si.i'xag »’f_ (.:~21b¢:” “i;§>’~..t’:i1’e
COED zmcl also .ref’€r1*eci to {‘.i”1.:f ‘*~’-,rfar§{1::~a. J:..1A(‘if;;_{1r§1–.§a1% 1.1_;:):’1V
wl’1ic.’*l”1. the st.3″(31’T1g .I’€:’.1iE1]’71Ct’:I is p1’éi(:é (.} }:.)’};: 1cé”i.’;”1″1′(‘cTi (.:m.1z1s~;1
for the p<:r£':it:i0ne:I' and 1:126 Fxc£if.1″£11 2*e:g_§2-1r(iin§,3;
c=-:x<:1"c::isc=~ 01' pc)we::',_byf {hie Stz1'.!f(: -<:;z:w_m:.;1_1um: 1_mdc~r SC".("._ 1713
of % 1'1. ct {"Iri1'1'ai=if'1a1 ,fF'1'V6'€:'6-1:1ui*éff.(§§€5'C!.e:,;
4f;{')1..:_1'.;21;VtC;f1-i.i'(5'n W: ~-I"1fi}"«;'ii'(':f('1 1i_)§;* :}":c '£,:;r;i'm"1mi ({'§()1.:.:1\s;s1
Mr. I Ec~;n”nc-.~:”dm’ ;”évii1″1 1″t;rfE.%’1′”r::_1’1VV(€er tit» A1’1I1(‘:’X{..1l'(:’YS ‘K’._ ‘L 2.1_z.1(‘i ‘M’ :s;{“1″1(:5s
f1I’§’1’£!.'[V.1.t’V”i’R.<_;*',' f"§K1:'a.1"'A1"1m:xu;'c-r~K is 21 {.'}()\4-'('i"i'§}}'1<:'?}'ii (}1'dU:' £'lai.c:(.i
11*-N2.S:}{)(}E% ";3;iss;'c;3.? pLI.I"SL1.f:1I1'{' to :5: r"u_é<;';'z..ze==:s;t. §:'m1'1'1 the: ('.I'.0–
()p1″ps5
“..Q”‘f’ .Dé?E”.j,,«’c;:(‘%ie1..};’ I,U.i’. 5-1r’1 i.1′”;I=m..~s2i_:’1izgzm;
“1’11z”1(.i(‘. §>_y ii. In st1;’_”}pt”>1″1_. nf}1iss >4;1_.1F’}:1′::’;~:s–;i<')2; Eur :-":::%._)z22iz"'%".m'§
5
E/\\?’:\{\% 1/’
2 V’
that” 1_1nd<.:1" xivhal, c:i1'('L.1111S12:11.'3("t6*:s a1".1d \.v¥1i('t11 I'.y;.) (>f___<_:z'1.'%t,"%s._
%.i1<3 -ffilzms G()\:'€i'1"1'1J'}"£C-31']I ('£1111 1"c::'f'k-':' 111:: 1'11::=1'{§r} 'I'*«_"'*1'f(')1"
i1'}vcrs;Ii;.2;2-1!I011 to t,I'1c-? COED. F1_11*1:.I1m' %"1<.;" 1'31'-V-'i%'<;;*(i.{_5%:.11" ;.1.:i.:":§1":W321
L0 1.1"1(=:: (-<'m'1p!ai1'1t: p1'0C1L1ved at' A1'T11'"a:z::;*<.a;11i<_f–TIV§ E::"iZ'v14('fI1 a:.,E ?-1f'1(i:"£.1.iv§€-()
1.11:' <.*o1'1'1p§2-1.im given to I-r__)l{e;zy11R.iatii} *-L-'\é.1':*)'E.-.)'(.)'1VkV'-z'. "<:.~f'~..V}'V1'i:_~r'
s1.1};3mis;.si;’1 t.h2=1*: in re.spc:i’r:sAj”:::1ei'<jie5"'i11 1.i1<:*
(:on1pi2.1j11f' s:1bmii;t.ed b§3f(z3x1"€', 0? }~Iig,{11
C}1'c'):..11'T1r_'i:'a Polim Statikm ;i1::1:;i'I'1p1.rI’,y
Rcg.;{is11’a_.1″ of c<_)mI1.1<..?t.ecE L110
{*'.I"iqi1iI"_\;* 21$? " V at' £,1"1<' IF;231"1'1z::1.i'.2z.k21
_A<'Iu1" 21.1'1’i’:i:;’m ;_:§;2;1j1′}:_si’ I’M:
C (‘ > ~ 0}.) «:1-5 1’73 5 I’H’\ :’Z 5&5) (ii _
Con(tc1*1’1c–‘Li. and -1.vE1;)<i)sc:c_'i ;'1<:1_ic")1'1 0? t:1"1 E51..e:1fe
(]}()w§'::V1_nV1m"1I" In_C1't1':1f1.1si;i.1'1g§ :I"1(~* (':2'.1..~s(.: ':":;s €_'{j}I..} E0 i:1':'<-~s1_i;{2–§i.
é1;!.}'ifi.;_;1.1i1'f 1;Q'-«::E<3:£Vi3.,i:§i~~_jeoparciy E131" 1:110 appr;–r£1z'z.1_'":f:.
.. .V\/'t*. have p£:1"1.:sscci mm: f.i.:'.1di3'1_g_»;s 2.11"': (Ti z'{*.21.s.ecn':s5
I ;f§'-ri’€}<;:<*{ by the leamed Si1"1;___{Ee Judge' with 1"f;){(':'.'¥'€EE'3f_".f;'? ix') éhe
2:-:r':::..i cr31'11i<:?rmfi()z'1s t.11';,f(:c:E b},-' §"',§'1<?: l€',e;:';;:.:':'2(–*<i fC[T':;:.1.r"§_..<~',-{*1 Em'
_ I}}":c }J2'1.l'1'.ii';'f;:3. Thc? iee1r1'1ecl Si1i1g'§e? Jz,1.c:ig<: he-1s~+ <':2:'1:":3:f"1.1.l§.}:
&?x2"1:'11i1"1c==rd ca(':1'1 0r'1c: of 1':i'1»:% f"2.z(:¥z1::1I 2-='1.:"'1<I I{.je3;e;-:1 <:r..'zm'.<:mE0125;