High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri Kambada Narasimhaiah vs Deputy Commissioner on 26 November, 2010

Karnataka High Court
Sri Kambada Narasimhaiah vs Deputy Commissioner on 26 November, 2010
Author: N.K.Patil And H.S.Kempanna

E? ‘§E§§;? Efifirff $@€}§§’ fl?’

$§:?§§ @123 mg 2:5???» ms; 3? E%?;””;¥§§%§’§?§ ££Z%§;$: “‘–«_ ‘*._

?§§;$ELE’§’§”

‘§§§§i §§{},%%’§§£ $3 §§$§::§: was :a%9é;*.:*:§;;i1

Rfifi

‘?’iE I?§3§§’§§.eE
as??? §§Q;3%§?___§’£§? fziéégé gfi:§:g§;::*;J

§r:§g,.§E2im”§,a.§aa §§a§*ga§im§.§§g«%§..9 _ ‘
.z%g&3;§.}§$:1§.?§y¥’::&;’5–~,_ ‘4 V _ ._ _
Sfaiata §€ar&:;a.r:§5;3;§a, _V ”

§;.2*$§’;aka=f€§2?£”£1.3i;§x;:§%;;;”i=;3; ‘ _ __ _ ” »
i§€a§;*§m:5?m§r::ai;$’%a;%é%§£%2§;é_§*;=’_§’:§m§;§?§$; ._ 7
:fi&E§fi§§§’?§§& fi§ . ._

Rf $§;§E{§am:m&§:a;;s§;£§;;a’%§éZE£z§g:&.._ _ —
gnzfi §*§afih§=;;.._ M b ..

§aa&§&§;é;#2:&–?aa€;9_ ”

fiwggiafa “§’§§;:§E§ = V .

;.%§§§%Ei§§5’£

” ~.§§§§:* Eéif-igazsgse %§&t;§%;%%m{;&%zfi}

§§ ‘ §§£§ga:3;.€.’f; figégfiéfiigaéfififig

V V _ §§.§E§4EEs}§f_§?£ igfiéfifi fiéaiséea

I . :;%Q ,§é:i§;’§$*§’;$fi’§
” _ am ‘V’*¥§§a:e;:§»z*& Egfififi fizzéswfliéwifiéggg
‘ ~–‘ E§;;§§§éE§.:%2~§&

” ?&§E::&%i§§g:;:

.~ V Eazzgalfira §§§é2%%r,E: Elgéiuigg

fifijigfiiggzrfi

&’§§§§’i§*”§$E

%; §fi§’i:’£f§f’ “§a§1i&§§;§§.§3g
fgfififi Qfififig
fiaagnagmra E-‘§§%}.zZ§
Egggaigzsrg Efizérfii éfaiake

$1, §ig_§gg§§&§.§

éggeai akauz S I. yga-;§a§

fig §¢§§m$:: § ._

1%? $g*a§$;mm§&$’@&.m’jg “§”%m§§§§

Eiammfisanéra VB ;

Rfi at.§€mma§&,fi§:*a Vfiaga

Lakafimigzxra Eéabfi?

E3fi$&1.§&§i1r§; F2232?

Eafisimea §%”$z’1% V A _’ V

Egzmgaissre Erkaa §§:£&t2°*%::§;–. _ ; Eiggggssgfifimzig

gwam far: A’ 1 ‘-

31%;;

fifiig {sf tfia §{&’£¥§;i£k&
High fimsri g§s§*:?;-.:g;?*;’§.;§%i;3;g”-7;§%:vL $3?-55%; ” ifia fifiéfi’ paazsfizé in
¥;a§B:§§g2§?4.§%;2A§:¢;§ gmé 2%.:§;§;§§§§’

Eifiis an $32′ §§§§im¥mar§* Egzfiarimg,
%kiz$ é§.§.§i;–. _, V;fi%:~3_iff’¢*%-“:1{*&§ fim §§§ §i

k Q E55? 32% :2′

vvfiuiiffiiiifi $13: :3? iizsfs iiggégmggiifiiig Ziféifié”

§a%€’§éa§.§§g¥é_{if}iT3V;’73’%§’§;{.3 Wggfi :22: %?:?g:.~;,2$?%§;2§:§ ‘my age

$33 §*fi§§fifi§;fi:’E§§f

§§f§$:_§~*§:§§ Si; i;§z3é; ’43 §§§’::%§a§&::’:¥ 2&3; as sgéiafzé Egag 3% “ii

A {Egg fiféfiffi §§$a%§ kg’ 32:52:32 szifig fiimfiggfi fig

gg mw éw $§” § Q5 wzgméiégygéng ffmfi

Szfié E§ffi§§ §§&f§;§$ifi§}”§.$. $E¥&:’§”::§?’ ‘§§&§E$ géiézfififii 3*:

&§’fa::a%::2: fmzzg 573$ §§;§§f;’3};€;E 332$ {Ema Em £3 afizzfiéiéfifi; :52: @§:€’§§:*:§:

fséaa @333 mg? vzramfizig aha agéié $r:::§; fig iém

$331 §.»§.3@E’:m§ §§§:a§£:§.;§m$%§&.m§?”»,_ Egg 33″: ééfzgsz

izfztfigwi :2? m:é§.:–;’?;§:;Zf?_;g*’;_L ; ”

2″ €§$§§fi; :}f €.;?:4::*””‘é::a%§ gr: Ezaxzé. ifi

‘£;§;:a$§ fim at $233 Egaimézmi

?§ar2£:’&§

E€a%2*3¢a:§3i;::§”zg§:%:;§al:%;:;§s«.._ …_ _g§fi%;:;a€5£§ 3;? :=: _}
ég fig’? figs Qraéwa wagfi E3?’

33% §§§§:§:a§’:§::§i”:e::;é%;§s:::*%{§;i3*a§ he :3 2::§§§:£’:E§§; is; Efifféffili 332$

fim iiwzéé 53% £2 Efigifig, ;$§.?§ fié’

:§2:&””%£§fi&§?:é%;*_~ ‘ ‘ééfm

§§”i.’}fiE {§§,.é§’§°§z2€.”3§.§§ far 5;

3″? géaée yam: ‘§”::§ aaié. $2133: fi$ mzag gig

§’22E3§= swig? E%:&§: ihaafi ififiiéééf Egamiai avg

my firgmkiifi. ‘£23 §§’§3E§12:§ ijfié;

frefim ffiigfifisfifiéiia ‘?3§:§g’=$§$§’%§ $23 wag

5 a fifiiwégé §””$§:’%§§fi3?§”§2%§f,§ -am €i3§::”}@¢§@§iZE %$§;:§§;

)/. MJ_#__A,,»…,.

1;

ta 3&3 %a%§h agié Efif fii;§’:,3;g§€. as _
‘ gmzfiantg is %:a% >g§§:*a::§%:>*i§.azz:<%,<9{'ga»a:7iifi;;*3V;%éfi4
gf éha ?§§:§*§§;$::'2&:£:;z: §i;§£*.s%x;§[ ..f'2§

E%§ 333$ %m3*'2§;§$'&§* iitéé'-..§§:§z"g~¢=; $3? sf –. L'

is ma 3% 2'%§@§:<i§:§':.i fig -3% rmwigéami

gigs: ';:

593% §’fi§§$§2.,§€§i%5£ ‘is; ia§§s€”*; siayfi $3; }:-:;.;-=-

5%? 233$ ‘%m%. SE25: game Ema gm: .–E:é;.§::

imyiémgntfié; magi fig azagfiar was $3.::§,§:3g ~ K

fizargffirag ks: wag mmfiiygéfififi; $33’: 33% g §%fiti§g::-

§%.§§£*3g §.=:§§m§:”éa:$ aa amgéfi é€.:;§;:§f§,_ – ‘

3%, 321% mié; Efifiiiéi’ hag; z;$m%::.:§;.:a§?§§ $$;é;.:§’i:;§A&€*$;§§§::”‘

kéfare $33 Eingig ;.}’:2L:;§fié.,g::

hfififiiig Em wai ax::u:1$&;§.__f:§§ é§§£§,%§,;::§ é:’}::%”‘E§a,:*::w3:

fig-§a §z§ §1m£gr fa? mzgi mama}.

far :*a:«r§i§zg:i;4e§c¥»i;i::’é:.~vVV§*%%V:s:-é;:’:”~:;=.:E;%:s_ ggazgzzggz éiéfii 3:; am
aywikszé’ ?§;%%”§§i$ %:%’;g E” rmggzzfiszzi wag

{§\§%?i;§;i”‘$ 21$ iaiia _;$;§§m§°:i*§.<§:& fi§i'?;§%'.:?§'?: 31:: ri""é.$§':€}:é;'"e§$Z'3€:?§ Egiiéz

V. _»§;i'":§i§A°~ the ggyiiafla fig %&:€"§§§ gm ggmaaéfiéfig 235%:

e:E14r.é':":é"":;':%=,a:'f§' fmm Ezizg §%§f£.@: €22?' s:'=&:$2i§::%: :3? €:§g:§; sf

_ iém é;é35-§E §fi:'€:.§ié§*. fiaiffag I
2%: '?E:t"§$

zéégficslfiéiiaigzi ta §§§%$£§§Z? ifém

E. SE15 $§'§'§$2i" §2Z3§ fi§

$ Jzzéga iézg fa:

2% &§ %i’;’:fi§§”.;E’§g

” §;§i§33″$§f:E§.$ miififg $3 éifiififi gzzgérsgi

‘U’I5£

4;: figfi Eiaafi Etazaaré Ewzmé a::§}”a:§:*:aa3§. fég $33 fi§§%}&I’§£

afifi Eefiyzzfi fiiéfi; agg

Em’ €323 ?%§§:3§&:§:& E

5%, flier Qarafgi gmrzzggé {sf ihfi afiisar . .

gxfigaafi E; $33 Ezgmmfi N

a§2:i§§;§§ WE gig’ ié:_§’:§'<.

fiffafif izf iawg maish 3&3 waiifizésiéi f§§*1:%’&«gf§3_§;ar_é?::§~*”_”ézags’§”‘ §riV”%.%;1$”%’*1;_:

mzmfiéfififi ami %.g% éggg
mfiazi ééztraz agm; mfzagafi §’:*§_2f;é§V”jA’?::.3§j3:é:;~V _;v%£;’fi»3§ 32$
i§*:&§§ $3; ‘gkm: gfiasig ai” éiéé figs fiezmtaag
tg éfém 32% ffigkéfifififiig ‘Egg §1zE}:::§%>é.&§;

a £@’£a%é *3′?-gg

:’:m’:%£:”‘E;”3.ag ~.;?’§7?:’*v..:a.§s:”:3.§–»:i§;a%::*a§§s:}:”: a:::a:§; 3. éafiaiafi
is ya’: ifigmiwggéafimi; igéifim

$€m’:.%é_ faizazgg’-~ i;I%:$_ ‘,-g:£é:§:*;§:’::§’:&:*§ &§:s§j§:EE$3″:: gzzéfigfiiiéfifi mg

.. 4. ta ?;§°z& 33% §*%§§§’:§g::§: fifiiaéi

L 3;.$%:%§;’.2:é;;§;s%*

H éajimgfiaimi. g§{s.«%§§ fi&?;”§’§%3″ mfiagg :s§ §§j fifi mi
113225 gmga a§’§mf:.*%”%:%§3 %§”:z$ mazagr was 3%

::-fié:’a§.2″‘$«§ gflifiifizg ziszgi 232$: 152% %§
g:z::§ii§.E;%& gwga fig fig ifizmsé fizéiéa afiazsssi éfim
am zéfifihaia. $12: at: iha hfifiifi $5 21%

Fm;-§$:*$ €}a§”a3:%::; §::z;;’§:i§’L:§§i1§3$i€§i’fa$”f5 “§%a:”¢§’::::*&§ fim Egarnaai

Siigia Ja.::§;g§ hag rigéésiig s:§§§?2:&i fimég {fig $§§§’i fie-Qkm

ZQ mmmarzt sazg an aim r;§§;1:’-€33 $5 téfzg mm?

fiifi mgitgef Emg Eééfifi figfigéai Efifffiffi é

Csmmfgaiamr ‘£3 %sei§ £21 azffiéiézjg’ g,§§§:mt._3’~§:–:;%. ”

$3 mkfi aggrgprzigig fififiisfiéfifl amé iii} %%.§:.*:f%i2; §?§;?§’:§§..’s§j§§;’§§a’3§:§’§§E5§– .’

wagié rm Em aéimzaafi is ggrfaflgvzgt §w1£:;}§;;. ‘i,:f’*:V
iamgfifz azzii a§§a::s $3 gear “1-‘.,’:”ijfE:’:=.§~:;§*&§”=:*fi:%’§*:~*%VVi: [_ :f2:#%:s3:}§:*a.§s’af
gmsght far ‘izém fififiiimzz wag
raficiafi 322$ i§:§f:;:@f§: figwggfifg a
éfigmiiméz m §_:::32″3;£31;§éE gm
€fi£§§ii:§””°f;g_ $%f::;=:§} wifiz Egg? witizizz a
grigfi Exfig —-‘?’;i1$ -éaiifi af :”%&§§i: Q? E mg?’

3? ézhe 33% reagamfi géwa far

– V. A’ fghfi fig gag: fififi §;:§*§§%:’ magi 32$ gifigiiy’

§:”:,..V%::::&§}i§€§3: §:::a ‘§Et;§:*aa§a:*¢g we:

_§i&:”;§,if::.§§ mggaéégar §% mézkgéfi aszsght. £3? fizz flag Wfiz

§’§f €323 §§:%g$;§§% rgggazia §;§§%§.%; £3 fiégzéaéggmi as

iti fif mfirifii

Lgamfié fiiéfi fig %§.%:°*m.i:%’.,£:i €33 §”:£§& §%”§fi§§i{f} ‘– €3§

33

:

§a§ag

{Emil