44 g(b)
4.' " = 3/0 LATE 12?. SNARAMAIQISHNAN
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT ~
BETWEEN :
DATED THIS THE 2311* DAY 0}?' AuGI_;sr
PRESENT
THE HONBLE MR. JUSTI§1E warm; V :1
AND= V: V' L
THE HON'!-3LE A,EQPANNA
wnrr APPEAL
"
s/:0 LATE SR: I..QI}rs4i'.azARUs
sags -ABOUT YRS"-._ 1- '
R/A'? FLAT 2~xc>;3<__3~:., 1;);-;v»»K:RAN Amammnrrs
CLARKE ROAD', RiCH.AR3)S TOWN
RE 84:
BANGALO _
.» S§RI T' 9 SNARAMAKRISHNAN
" -s/ 0.m'I'e:' SR! 7.3.
' V. ., gags. Asgu-_-r 55 Y
X 21¢!'
ARAMESWARAN
RS
.'. "?9»'i'EARS
s.14z.-fineamaswaaan
" . Lgesn 29 YEARS
S.S. VISHWANATHAN
S/O LATE TZP. SIVARAMAKRISHNAN
AGED ABOUT 25 YEARS
Of
ALL ARE R/AT FLAT NO.30l/A-I
CANARA BANK SNEHA APARTMENIS
NATIONAL GAMES HOUSING
KORAMANGALA. BANGALORE {W " «
3 S}?! v v SRIDHARAN _ '
s/0 SR1 V N wJA¥ARAGHAvM
AGED wow? 55 ms V'
R/AT FLAT No.20]/Ad _,
CANARA BANK swam APAR1-ME;~rrS.._
NATIONAL GAMES' H0?JSIéNG,C~OfiEP'uEX _
xoimmanmm Bancawiaawr ._ "
4 SR: snxurvas VAsuDE}J.KAT'rI " V'
s/0 SR'! 'i.?AS1JDEV.SRIfi!WAS- K:-.'1'r: ,
AGED ;g::;r;z.n*~v.%3;sYr L N RAO, $12. counsm. FOR em K N PHABHNDRA )
SR! LC KHSHNAMURTHY .
S/O LATE SR! L CHINNAPPA
<2
K}
AGED ABOUT 35 YRS
R/AT copoamon WARD No.33 ASSIGNED«'W"ff£*i ' H
K!-IATA 240.132/3~C G M PALYA
NEW THIPPASANIJRA, POST K.G.GOI.0:'fl M M " V' " 1.
2» MAIN. BANGALORE sou'mfI'Q ' 1 '
BANGALORE
REP. BY ITS COMMISSIONER
HUDSON CIRCLE L' '
BANGALORE 2 V'
THE 1331301'? COMMi.$8iOfiEI§ » V
BANGALORE_MAHAM;?;£';ARA*--Phu£§Ev_ AV " - %
MAYoHALx,.BA;m:RANAc3.AR 131' swam:
BANGALORE 38
7 M/S METRO amxsns ENCLAVE
REP. BY rrs meopmmzrx
sm vysavmwruxmam
4311 AISHWARYA MANSION %
9'11»: A MAIN ROAD ;. A _
INDIRANAGAR 135- amen mnmma-9; % ' .
(By Sn': D.N. NANJUNDA REDDY, sea, COUNSEL FOR
Sri : M SHWAPRAKASH FORE': --.
Sri ; R. SUBRAMANYA, ADV.' mg' ~
M/a ASHOKHARANAHKLLEA Ass'0 oz 199/mos.
Tiiis for F-'n:hnzQ ' beam)" g this
day, DBEI'A4!£~V'vB%£., J., "';7lclivcred the following :
" %%%%% .'..nmeu1-arr
V 2 Rae, lcaxneri Semen" r Counsel ii)!' the
Sn' D.N. Nanjunda Raddy, lcmncd Senior
respondcznt No.1, Sn' R Subramanya, learnt.-d
% fin' respondents No.2 to 5 and Sr: 9.3. Raju, lcmned
for Impondcnm No. 6 and 7.
W [
2. Admittsedly, the appellants harem war; %
to w.P.No.1o922/-06 decided by the kaarncd
01.09.2006 (1..c. Krishna &%.;y;-A%A
Mahanagara Palikc and othmfs).
order passed by the tltuzir
righm and therefore’ , Tso::_gij;t; ._ in pmfier this
appeal mzd the have are before
us. H
an-nior cotmacl fim’ tm
appellants to the order passed by
occasions on l8.0’7.%02 in
and on 23.9.2002 in W.P.Noa.31291[02
competent authozity had already passed
V VV _ the Eiflcxifi. m, the dimction as has been ocmfixfl in
” ” ” ;i:;411ptvi§1ed order pasaed by the learned Single Judge was
‘n.rft”a€’:afl mquimd. The learned sccnior counsel went: on In
‘ ‘V that the dimcflan has been obtmned by respondent
‘W
No.1 hcxem’ by suppmssm’ n ofm.v.ztx:r1a!’ – facts smut’ :2 ‘
order of tlm Assistant Exccfitivc Engfnggr 1_i’r’hit”:i1’: ‘A 2
in compliance of the earlier
notice of the learned Single Judge,
nature would not have been %gie’
Jucige. ‘A } ‘
4. it that pursuant to
the cimad 1.9.2006 pmed
by the in _w.P.No.1o922/06, am amm-
has aim} 33; new Assistant Executive Exam
an Anncxmu:-«X. Again’ at the said
the builder has asmady
before the Kmnatakn Appellate Tribunal
We were taken through the
K dafi:cl.Vi1.3.2O04 passed by the Asamumt Executive
Banaswadi Sub-D1v1.-nan” ‘ ‘ . whczcby cumin’
[._d¥:p::§seni;ntions have been made by him ‘:3 the new sheet. The
abaczvations also rad’ ma” ts that it is made in
place all mean harm the lemned Single 17 4%
aocorcfmg to them msultm in pasmhgflqf K ”
which was not at all required to be
this natum, we are of the
the appeimm wauki be Smglc
Judge with all the and
mean of the earlier Single
Judge finds in mm
including orders could be
made agi V
(in. ‘I’IVidi1:Vfozr,,v’tE;c facts and cimumatanocs of the
to the appellants to tile ma
bcfon: the learned Sm}: Judge
agam’ flat dated 01.99.2005 pmaed in
«Vw.p.§ie,#1éa92¢2′;os. If mvicw petition is filed beforc the
‘ Judgc within a period of3O days hereof, the
may not be dmnnaaod’ ‘ on the gmtmd of and
itxéhall be considemd on maxim wt! in aoourdance with law.
“ry-