High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri M C Manjunatha S/O Lt … vs The State Of Karnataka By Its Chief … on 14 July, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Sri M C Manjunatha S/O Lt … vs The State Of Karnataka By Its Chief … on 14 July, 2009
Author: P.D.Dinakaran(Cj) & V.G.Sabhahit
. E»;

IN T§~§§ 2»~éI5v§~% mum G? KAQNATAKA fix"? 8a%%\%é?}§§L"f.?%'2:5E"~V.4

mwaa T'%--~EI;S 7% :W DA'? GF JiJL§';'~ ;$G€;§V.: '   * *

PRESENf-''§-''''''' 

?a~«§§ ;~zo:~:*a;.§ #e§§.?-1Q.DiNA§(AA§é;»§}§-5V_§'§~§E§?_~;.fi}'S 2*:%ic:§g.%}A k


"ms ?:~ea:~£*3ar;é%§m3:)é%;?:c:e"¥%zégasaaa---:;;;-£1?

wag? PE§'ETI€}%x%.«!§§;.14?51?{§§Q9A:fi,§}¥RE5-PIL)

figfivfimzé:  

2. §aé;<:v:,a&an§"a:ga.:ba..   _ _
Sfcsivviaie {::}_].i*i'IZ§{{:§{-;i_§§iV}}1iav"'--.,A =
iigfid €?§(}§.";i1i'£ ifiéi, j,l*C:§r~§ V ' *~ .__ " " 
ffiriver Vifi  S.  if;

§<Z§:.E:g§3." _T§i}ep?0';,  V _ 

'  H . . . . . . . ..
; Sf 5} };éZL'{£:i.§i1ii$W'8}'Zfl&}3§3.

. V  E£§$C?L~a§i?{?iL£§_§'?} yaars
" '-§é;g:°§§;11£t.:x_;ri$f:v,V

36 '.?¥'i,b?,.§¥1i1;€3/§:"a§1§
3! -':1 S;.§_znjee¥a§pa
_fl§fi£§;.ah£3%X'i 3% §'€§~3§§

'  » AA '3'i;;ri§uituz*ist,

--   gknkatagewda,

 3;' <3 Eais §f\§araya;1aswz:m}*
figeéi ahmzt 4&5 yams
éigiicuiturist,



5%} am rssifiiizg at
Exéazzdsor Viiiagé,
Bidarahafii H0513,
Bangalore East "§'a_1ui::
Bangaiare Uistrict.

g 33; Sri %<;.?sé.E€a~g*2i»:11:nar, mm€;.%%  J ' 3

Afiifiz

E.

'Tim State of !<.;a1nata;§i¥3~ * 5
Bf; its Chief Secrsztaxy, ' VA " '
Vidhana Soudha
Eangaiare. 4.: '

'§'h€ Rsvauué    
{}overnmL3nt--;of.VE<lafna::iE{:a "  :
Vidhfiaia _S{:.1:éi3iia, _ " V' "
Ba::1gaiv;3r{€'.~  _ 7'; '

'§f;5:;& §}s:§"t:tjg {j<;fi:%_1'x:ssi9;i1::::,--~
Eangaiétsxfe Rumij {'ii stgi;j*§7
E{,{?:_.§0ad',= V'   
iififlgaiare. "

u f 3135 ;'%ssi.;si:a:at Casmmissiener,

_?*§{3fi:[.¥2 S LEE-fiivisiony

Bhssii,

V' X sgmbsakajif 'éediiai

:'7E,,é'1

Efiazagéaig ra .

, %:'*a:;1as%;2dar,
fiangaiare 3:35: Taiuéi
' '~F;;'R.?1;ram,

Eangaiore.

The Chahman
Manager Grama Panchayath
§.'§£i}1£1c3r.:: V  



Bidarabaiéi Hobii
Bangaiare East 'Fai12£«:g

?, Vice Chairman

Maszaiarer {Rama Panchaqfath
Fsfianéaor Village:

Bédarahalfi Hfibii   ._
fiangaiore i:1ast'£'aJs..2k. :

8" Tim S£Ci'€tf8:Ii'§«', T.
Mafiéoar Grama Panchayath 2. _V
E'J§3.z1<:1G0rVi}lag$,  "
Bidarahalli Habli    _ .3
Bangalere Eagt Ta}uir _t,~§:':,"j:g':«:__-:":-- }

 :~>e:;%:;;:§.:,n €;3 'i'i£e€§_'11ii£i€r Articiss 22% araé 22'"? sf
£216 §39:i;sti1_:':z"£i:VI}§VGi7_»E:;u*:§iaV§:a§;ing ta wlzfici the R1 :0 R5 and K8
fa §:'1i1j;3'£s zagpzegriafis  i€€.gV€i1.;'3;CiiO3f1 for the iiisga}; cmastructien
am} t:°asp:-ms-mz:::'1--r.: tinge: '£116 pmperties Tsearing Suxvey WQJQ8
and E 15 w§*§;;i€:E1' 811%"-V-.'ElI:f{i£§i'E':;'§-;IiiZ1€:5<1.l£'{§$-é and B unfiszr '£3.25 *Ii:3W§ng:--

J?}§G?0IEK"§'

 '§i%:§S -.f§ub§i€ ixgiarast iitigaiiem §€t§?;i&Z3. is fiéfiii by

A' '   "§:§€':i€iQ§'is319s 1 '£0 4 W319: are the §:I€I7"flT£8I'1€I}f£ reaidanis 3"

 Viiiage, Bidarahaiii }~£0§£_i, fiamgaiare East 'i'a£u£{,
'  ifiangaiarrzt éjistrict. it is avermd ma: {$13 ianas fiaayirzg

u wSu1've§; f%9.1i£&. maasurizzg 253$ acrw :2-:3 gunizas baiaags ta

V5



Ens {}§"i.9'€i§'§Ti.§fi€§'i'{ 3;"; fxfiaggaism 's.:'§§£,age. Sui Gf Wh'i€:E"1, an

exiazzi 5;?" ::§ asms hag §.}€3{"Zi§1 gi""8_E1?Z€d in favaur ef gazigalere

Maire '§'ra§;sp<}rt Cmgsorafian, fig': extant __  '  "5

gzmtas has been grazified in  »  »3':1'=:3» 

$:13§:.N,V.Kaiavatf1i, wife Céf }._,'Vg?{LVf;:1:":?<6sV% 

gumas magi witi} {he Gesv6z*r1__§ffis?:i:_1'§;;VV_v 2?: '§':;~:«.  averreci
that Suzvey No.11&1;_..':%ins2isu.j;'i§€g~-fjfii"aams 18 guntas,

siiuaéieé ai Mailéififif 'gfiéiéggé, "iziabfi, Bangaiore

East '£*a}u§.a:, fBVé;i:.g;3V3;§3re..%V;}i.g§:_ic:, azegt with $316 {30vemm1e;*3.t

and 92:3 $5" €'zv_:f;i&c§*3, ?'%-- %.:a:g:,;"@$' E2 gézmias has been gazztéé in

f23:§;3 :_3:'-" <:a:f 83§1i:Ag$}§:*€Me$r0 '§ra§:s§0ri C0r§8ra.%::r§an Sfid

,%;*:iz.}:3a§z1_ig;§;"; 52:21:: 0f 2 assms 5 gtsataés is szasé Wéfh aha

1'{f¢%<"é*s?€_Vm'1';},e?;:2f:.' ;§'{" is fu§**€;;%;s3;' avsfied thaii, rémaimfig extents

V . in §;§é'3ran:é§§  328 53:36 33% mi" zséanéaor viiiags, fiidarahaiii

u¥§i<}T§:;.i§, S'7a:1gal$1**& gasi 'i"a,iu§<, Bangaiam .E.}§.3i.E"iC€, :13 gigiii 3;.

 is-:é*;%€:9r:m@n: lanai, in %¥§°fi€f1, at the §flS{3i'1C€ 93'

"  :'é;$§;e:}€i$:1:s Nosfi and ?, same ef tbs stmfigers B9396 pm

:1? senszructiafi during €333 manth Gf Navam bis? 2388 L6,.



.5»

23:1 20.13.2093 arid daring tbs firs: week of 

1.

5., an 2.2.2{}€}’:.? amt} ihcmgh Ehfi Saié i1§,€,ga }_’~–::§3f§§§’£z}:14t%ic?:;9

am; ‘i;r€:gf;}3.SS W83 brought f8 “lcgif
33:2}; action agamst ma Eiiegéi” trespass,
33 E’: was gm £é:;3’i%{§’§’*;§:t–§: {i 3; $16 i.r§ii§ue;.3¢e sf
E”€$?§3=£3I”i§€§}ES $3 Aaasii _..¥.’£? ;§%g:.} é§’€%:V%££é§§.\’/’.’?@rS0I1S is thfi
iiélgznéiysr ‘_:E’8;T1::’:#:ii3gf$ét.’:_4V V’ ‘s;£s”:I1erefo):*r; fig gfiéponiients 1 ta 5 and 8
$9 §I:§;§a{§s’.A X kgfai action af ‘aha iéiagai
ca3″1si?z:{§tiQ%1 rgmda {War {he g3mp€1’i:ie.$

beagigég Survsjs 3:38 arzéi 33$ Whifiil am at Ann€:>m:*es–

§*%;’a:§1:i .i:{:é’:h€ WI””i’i gaiitian.

::;, _ ‘£«¥§§.S igaued ifi 3:16 refiponéaiifs ami

*55ta”§fiz::’:;’:.3’f§% sf Q§§§CiiCi§}$ _ hag iigaam fiéfiai by §’€$§3i”z€§€1′}?;S

ii 5:3 a’%§@3″I’€fi iii. {he siaiemegat Gf Gbj$£%:iaI:$ Ehai

2 f;§:_:iit géatiiian is fiat i§.2§33i§3.t3i:”2ab£$ fiifilfii’ in iaw azzfi .’§3ct$

335% {E13 S311}-3 is ééabis is be éififliifififiii. Tha %3reai{»w:_,1_§ 0?’

\;\.>

{:3 ;’:> 33$ 8, aha f’€$p0§1€§€f2?f3 3 t.0 :’Ei_ tagzfi @6179:

-5-

Land bearing Sm”s.:c:5s {$0.128 0f Mand0GrV.VVT’».§i£§3ge,

Bidarahaiii Hobfi, Baflgaiore East Taiuk, as_.:§{;atér_.i-

siatement of objections is as undey:

1. Land grarizted and Saguvaii*Ciiit$ ‘
issuédr ‘

2. Land g”aI1te{.{” :9 :s.e;1;*i:=;A~::,% 3°’ 00

3. Land §”a3:1t,ed 1 {:0

4. Pubiic’g§@gve 1 97

5;. 3%;{3pijica{E:zns”pending”fax’
:’e,griia%ris_af;tio1*:..MVt1zf;_€ie2:’_’ Section
“‘._9é~A and ~s;«1,B»Qt”T’:h%:; KLR Act

Farm f*4e..5{§A”g:1’1t£.. :

UL
{)1

2 1
‘ 5:5. _ Ha1;:kU.,p53.£ra:fl issued. under
” Vgashraya ‘S-3-331:;-tme under Sectian
” pf tl’}€ KLR Act: E3 ()0
be regulariseci t0 the
‘ _Ap-§)}i5£a11:s flfliifii’ Secficm 940
the ELK 1510:: 1 00
8 éfinauthcrisad houses constructed : 2 {R}

V’ ‘fit is further averrsci if} the statament of abjectiens

T ‘mat, as many as 114 houses flad bean unauthofisediy

K,3>

4::<:rssi1°2::;*?.€tI3i{,k’%._1:;p$§L§:ré,$ ‘afa ‘i«s3$1.?;§:r.i i}:'”i’=, j

I’€S§€C’ii of 1141» persmis. §§:::§&ri
in respect 0f 11 ggersans §e?s ém;s{ ‘£’1V.ia**s,*:z:s-,:f;t?:11:::1″o3.cE’;€{t§
upon the iands jfiéigfi iaiien. €91′
regizlariaatiengf :.3z;1a;:_:3:§{:{3r1.’;r§;<%;;i§: céé'§£:§éf;§73n made? Section

94%} of aha Spa: insptzctisn

has *%::€:€:":_ é{}§1{§.z:ié:EieS’§.fl{~:”£Ji”}.€3€ sf

::9;$;;i::*;1€~,L.:md€’1″=Séétiafi 39 9f the Kaifiataka Land. Revenue

iyfyz. biuie MQA Gfthe iéaxnataka Land Revanus

._.%%%;;§€s”_; :§”=;¥§I%;aE%};;§1fi actizm has been. mker; afiar faiiewéjag due

gééafiiés’ 5,->f”§a”s§.:* agaisizast such zinauihozisad @{:cu;::»a:1€$.

5%. Wa haw haargé the iaarmad Qauasaé apyeaiérzg far

‘ i3»§§€§§a;3′{s§ Eeamed P;{§{§§.{}Q§?€}”E1fi1€£1’§i fiiivasaia agpfiafing

fesr respandgntg 3 ‘:3 fix

W

mg-

5, igszafraad caunssi appaaring fer {$16 g::fi;3§iéQ:2ars

E”€i§€§”8§€3{i {ha g:'{>un(is urged in me writ

SL2 bmitted that fl€C§SSai”‘}? dir»~3<:.ti;0:1§' bé€%'A .f;ss.'.%é:.3.;é_:{i :3

resp0r;{ieni.s 1 {£3 :3 and 8 '£9 :i:s3T§<%€_'T=g;£:i;i–é:;»z;A"

éincmachers and u::au:§1orisé{£.V_ nccugafité &7E1_{'§" .é:3;ga;i:i;S*::%fi;V§”:e ‘g3§e’r.s<}:i$'*vww§'i0 have €ncr+:)a:::}:1€fi -me

iazzd §fi "§~:;_§:*%;€:3* :§*é§;{,"£i{28.§§7A_i§%}'g_§1§<)ar vifiages

E3, V_V'§':§'é;z: "g;i%%%;5§1 <:a;*<~:fui {:0r:si<i$z*2.a,"£i:3:1 'E0 the

"V-£:1©::*:.aEf1'£§£:sn$ A. 0:" tE:€ea""'}a:33°°z1fid; tzcsunséi 8.pp€8;£'i1'1g for the

éinsfi §_§£r2.:€i11i$€£i the ma"£.:eri_a§ 0:1 the regard.

"1"-Eéé maiariaé 3:1 §*e<::§rre–, Wtiga

appraharzsian 9? the p€{i”E:iQfi€.f S~ tf1atV’r<3s;3<:i1d?i:nf;s 1 is E:
are net takifig 331:; séegis 173:' f:em' Qsg;35¢.0f théé énazfoachezg
8:161; "amauthsrisadi 0::<:11p'é;s.§;it__been denied by the @€§§iiOI}{i}”S
v£@:.:l<i Cifiéififfi SE15)?" :£1$;%._s'i§p:3 have ai:*e:a::i§; baen zakétfi by

E'€S}i}§§fi(§€;§'§f{S "3 A. :5' 5 ts) avict i1i"}a{3.'£f}.{}}."§.S€& accupams and

i%£n iééiii be éizzkeijz agaéngt such z:;na.11’5E1a:*is€{£ zéaatzpants

ié-;3fibi§.’AA€IECE’Q%2€§}€FS. ‘.i’i”2ere:fr€, apart fI’€}iIZi récerdifig the

“é§.a:a1;:s:n§.3 fifiaéif 2:’; file siatemem sf ebjacitiazls and

§%:.:§s::;.”;i$$i{:::s mafia by {ha iearnefl ;%dd£.£}0v&mme::at

My

Mg}-

Aévasats, we imid thaé. the ;3@ii’£i9:1@*s aria ma” méiigégij ,,

am; spacifza iiiraafian iii ‘mig Wm’: gjetiiiafz.

Accairiingéy, w1:*i: mfiian is diSp0$géa%. –T’0:”‘»§:fr£3§’ 11″

éi:”?9:’5:saici £3§JS€I”§2’8.ii0i1S. V ._
%
; C.§:;i;e£%}»Iustice

.