High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri. M.Chandre Gouda S/O … vs The Chief Electoral Officer on 18 June, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Sri. M.Chandre Gouda S/O … vs The Chief Electoral Officer on 18 June, 2009
Author: Ashok B.Hinchigeri


ire was mar: cctgéw er? xgmg?Am
SIRCUIT Emma A’? mzaxwaa
zagwg “mm TKE 13% ms? 9? saw, 2€:€3?§’f”–«_VT’

Efififififi

“mm §§G¥§’$LE am. é§§$”‘E’§CE fiasitlfiii 1:5; “z4:’:’§i’i;;:§ii’a§§f;1;%:’L- u ‘*

§?.?.2%:e.$319o1aa5*’i9 €’§§i*§£«RiTf3*3::4’
§3E;f§”%J_é§;EZ§1E¥§:

SE43? EVE. CE-§.£?€§}RE Gfj}¥’!§§}é .

53,? {E §”~%ARAS§§%.«’fii;% RE§3*.§?” _
EGEEE ;iB{}U’F $3 “fEARS ‘

§:;€<:j?;<f}as §i£.3"§:fi 3133*' ;;w::;2_ 'T'4§ri_i?: €;£a?€{}§£}A'§'E;
§?€§}'i.£§§ %s;£e'ésL*:";'<i;§»¥;*:,?z;%4 Ci:}.z§§?T<:;*::§§:g;%S

<3' ggzgiamy {ST} ?A§:L§;z:si'5§\:? €;3\:s’E*:*§:;§::~é{:*i
Rf «:3 :3 :5; “–*§’J§A’¥’§€E;$E§§%?U;E3’i%.”

?’§E};%-iééféé =$c;:.,_:¢¥4,’ gas’ vggwam fiéfifivfiié,
§%::.§L5L§£*§VV%C§’?;”Egém

.,. §3E’§’§’F§ if} E’?

‘-§§”%§’;€;§§?§ ‘éf::j.1§2’f’T:=:*,é:,%§2z}:s§g”§§§ ;%§~§§} gag ;§?€Eé §e:;:§g>;, m;>a:’g.;

A:ié;;§: % %

” 7:». €*’:~:?%: $§=§§E§’ §:.§£:z:*§2.”_::m§,. €,*:§e’;=*§<f:§e::§e2%

E<;%§3§?éA'EZ%}§_fi; $'E°}%'E'§~Z
{.';ii§BE€}E'€ Rfifiié
§,%?€{§éei..»{}¥€§-7?: «~ fnéi} €353}.

“1!
.4,

:3 T§-i§:- R§§;’i’E.E§%?éE§§{} iL}§33′?9’§{fi.§%3§7€ :’%E’w§§;”}
f=.».§L}E§*E’E’§{}?éE§i,« ;2:’}§:2’§’::§:’2f €;E{i)§%€!\§§S§§§{I}?%E3§% _
i£}–£§EiZ’»§.J,i.;fi§E%£”‘*;”‘ {::;’§*’§ §»>saR:,.:;a::;:§:;»~§*:* {2{}?=%S’i’E’E”E,§EiE’%E{Z7’§”–.
ET%%i§,§,Ai€¥§ E’~Ef3Li.f§§%’TY E’}§S*;i’Ek?EiLT.’I”ET’

. 1 , §.;§§§§_§:%::}€§ §:ii:_”s::3

($3.; 35%; §;.:«:, Hg%’§”E”§, :~§<':{;§3 .:sf:f§:s§% $322,; " V'

§%E:E§?3{}§'éDEE%i'E' :*~s,§ i’)E::LE’f’E-32:8 §£f_;”C;{>« .:_«;g::4;>8_;.r;Q’:::é::

‘§”§~%ES §3E’E’¥i’i{‘§§’«§ :3 §:=’:’L§£:.§f5’~~:,:?m.E¥:iz_ A3>;f;?:’»:::§::’£§”‘227§ mi}

:52? {>9 “mg: {::::§x5S’:*-E’ru*;’:s;>:\s?«.,,<23? §§%:;:A,' ?Rzf*;m~s{; TG;
ggugxazi THE ::v:F;:=:gG:~«é§:<:§" — _:E1Nf;1Q§2SE?'v1'EI'€'"I' mm:-3
2?b§5.2a9<9 ESSZEEE}'=-37':"_'}'TE%£%_'v§2'}E3§3P{}'"§*e%f§;}E';E'e'T ;«§§£;aR: A5;

z§z~éL;:;L;S*§*’A:§:’:;i; §E¥:%:*.ji:§£5f§i:4§:j?{:’.’T’W

,,/mv%§.3′ ?:::**:?:;*’:>:V:r:;jL”–zf§€;_,zx@:N<;; cm: §1"{"}E~? PEE:§,§MiN.:%§'€¥
2-:§:;a::<s:§~;.§; -':2»§:s'.;;;;:y§ f_'i"%.§.Ef3 {:u::2″§- smzyg “§’?§i%i: ?{3E.,L{‘)E%Ei?%{§;

Qfifififi

. V”‘”£§§*;;i§si ‘}§€%i§3iQ§1 is 5336:”? fig; ‘€333 fiésciitsn agétfli 0? Ehfi

0..

{§%.J.,§’~’. §.Ts’E 3§;:2.<31'°€} wag dmtiared §:"i§€(;"§€{i b_"fg'Lfi},:;?13'§}:Ei. of 2243

fiEk!.

“iseiifig $3363” L§”~§¢CT. ?a:”‘£§: cazseziidaiizn ii ES the aéisgaiian <31? {"338

patiiimzsr that £95, 0:' irrsgufiarities and iiisgaiiiisfsss §Z{3i{}§_é'–§31E1€3£i€

$1': $336 iazfiiaficit 03? 'firm C%iI}.{§i§8.'Efi, Whfi -5:3 dEc§2:3,%;%{§;.,t_;~jEéI%.%_.i§éd.

W36 fgietiiféozzcr scsughé ‘rim cszrfifiaci b

{i{}i”:11fi16§iES3 via}: his ifiqtziaifiaizis) éiatgtii.

{}if€>,€.”)§.2C§{}§e ‘§”‘h€ ‘:*€:$§Gmie3’2jE: ifififiéfi 621$§fS§’3%5fI§'{=.ia2§;€éE§.,V

2?.@5..2§g9 siaiiilg ihat :rm~m-.L.§§éz;;.,1?«§<: msm;:fig¢;+1gmem,g%

are ssalezfi mad kspt £17; 3'€3:<;.:.:g? I'%:".:i'iL?fifi';;'–.§:§3,€1°fi'f€)V}i'"z;'i %;f: ;$ céziééiéifi

e::*{::p£€$ camzaé: bi: issufici _T "

._ — -flit”: ~§.$:§z’13m7€; 3%’ fhig €n.s:”§m*§€:£:s§:€:,
Eéiiifi pmfiiizszz §E’s:– §§:<*Vé;~:€fi?£é. S372 fiuyumaih, fitas Eeazizeé

€."3g§;::is4%:E fer §3€1:;i$;§e::§:" suhmiis "£333? £216 yeéétignar 31$

"$5 égispeci a3} flit? émumfiizég 8.11% 3130 cshiaiia ihfiii"

<;:.@§€:;:{$r:é.11z:%i 0%’ E-:§€{f’E}}£}§”i Rziics, Efifié. Es: pmyg far 3

€§§m<§£i,{,:;ii '$0 $5: zerspiméezzt 3:) E3325: $316 gimgéaé aioazzmsnégg

fi;§%!.

:2

33 Szii Haiti, £316 ismimii G’%f}i?€§’flfiEfi£1f. §’Ee:a:’%c:1*
a&p§6ari;f;g far this “i”€iS§O¥i{§€§}.’i gubxnizs that ‘fix
E3’u..I*i. arc§<~:~z*$,;'J*§h€"*3'£rti{§:1g z;<,m§ima;:ai1'11'Gt EM:

G§€I}€i’i{§} far that purpese 0f ” ~. 2 VV

4, Te: <:£§€:i§ié,—-$%.:§$ iraaa, –"i€€'_§SvV?fi,€C€$$£;£?i}'-ii?"fiifiir $9 'i§*'if:

p:'"{fi”‘a<:€.é::§ V?:&§:%i%é§:2;c5E.s;:§*éi'*~
"'§;%. Frgdizagén .::;;*?2;:i irsgpedéasi af eiediwa §§'§;p€?"8.*

$3} é"§é 53:9 mes£m:i§ {If #23 giisiricé eieciiarra

Eif§ff;§';§;¥2";:._as:; as '§'§m {me mag; be, 2&6 sreizzmskzg s,;jfice:"~

_§'a;_ éfw gscgciaefs 9;' -zmzgaeé fiafiai §3{2§;?¥€?'$ wig':

€3z}im.§e::faz'§s a.§€a,c%?,e& Eherefa,"

Qfl

{5}

{<1}

{{3}

{éd}

§

Effie gmskeis 5.2;' msefi 33513503? pcspem 2::E;§:§ §z£é'r'._V

vaiid, §e;2<§£r"@d or rejecieati;

the fiasckeés of €538 (§3?1?2i€ff{}i§.i§ E;-iégigi

VS,’

$523 pacigeisi af: ihe zfsa.z”¥.:ed zrfgégg véf :§ie

erfezsizrsraz’ ref? 9:; c2}:»:»,t}:m z3c2sé”m§:’§ -3&9; fifzgé E2152′
mafn£air2é§;§~..&E171{E€r I§:~,3§;»~.sféd;:i{}n ;’ £5?” Eubw
.5?8{1’§i€}T1 {2} Qfggecfigzéi 53 5,_2i;_ };e;¥f;;.:?}

2&3′ ffiizénkleaa. {:gi2;?:£:¢1;5:é’:°éi5,f?VV régisfarz; af vgéem

” ‘ ~ 3:31;’ f&;?%2″é,2 Z?”

« éééeg §;%§j:?§:éé$.~iE:e desfargzfigmég fig; £?§£,?C§’

°’ ~ iliflfi V§?.’i.6 £ts;.§§ e’;-ézaiian. {Eff “£5192″? Sfggrzzzfizzres;

‘;»_3:I2a.§E rm? i5€’s.:g~::e’%:2:2d and $3596? mm’e::E’s shag? max: 56

_ sfigag :32′ gmséuaeézi bgfare, {Kay §€fS§?”i er

{:%:g§?%:’§%%’§§§; exrmpsf agmier 352$ azrgieg” sf :2 mmpgignf

. “:::mg;~g

}’;§E§} ?°}2,e z;9:2.§r»:;§ gmiig Seafeai §m,s:£€:* §§E8 ;2r<23;i$:°w*'z;5

flf rags f§'?€3' gzrszi 3:53;? in fiw :2g.s§£22&§ af £93 :;?.z's%%'r*§c:'

fieazian. Qfifixéz' :s:§<:;(2Z§ res: bé Qpgnezi iéfiflg sim:£§ 33:}?
%§!

*3'

$23 zhfipééssiaeafi by, {Er pmdueefi bgfare, any per's0:"%T<§r.

auiiwyéiy exaepi under the Qrders 0f 52 ac3~:Vti};fi’€)Z ,£::éz_ih:’»:’ §’}fid_3:;?fsf?.g€ §*$2′.;’V

9f Such, fee as Sim Ezieaizfiyisi :f’3u5::}’:sV21§s,<;z':"§';z '

::iirec§,-

{Q} 91:’ <}£%z€r p€i§3;§§'S e§e£:i:"{:;::: $32335 be
aper: fig pz,§§3§s"{;_{;%sp£fi§§::%z; g2?;:.2 §'

{bf azgcsiézg. 'ifafifeaf fi:;z/E._.. f£:ppiicr::z2k9:z be

-. ;”u;m’§.::§:e§;A _

_ _ $53} ‘a2z}§§ga$V tgf A£–,§1锑2§:-zfuzfina Egg 2&8 :*e§’§,é?”rz:’?2g £2fj’?:x~?z’

;_Jf§r;:;a3*a?e§f§’:z–r:;22§e? mie 6%. as?” as 3326 mag mgrzzy be,

V’ ” _ ‘*:4::j}r?z;;}*§}€2V:-*:c’:§s:2:u,s.te {$2} Qf Suéwmie {E} if mfg 8% $%z:23? be

fig 25:3 méuméng gjjfiaey; di3§r§<:§ eiesriéaga,

" ,. ;:.;f§§::grfi c%:£sf a§ee::'§Qra§ ajjfioes' 9:" 5.529 E§g:s§§{;::2

€3$mm2Zs:$:"0;i:, azn gagmenf <3)?' afes if §?;§;?£} ?"E.£§7§:i':f$ far

€&C'§'£ mpg, 5

£52!

'§'§<.:€: p::'::'":24s»;3i ssf 333$ :afQ}:'a::-.: '' -*f3Xi'i":'i-f':%f3;§'f€'§_ 1 §L:"2Z§€,:'§%'7?§.$:15?f%1}F.3»

z€v€:a_1s '€i1a;.€ if 31352.}? :3?" Eifm gmzghi {§E;;;;7°a;z:1€2:%.é 'fig:;2r:i"'%,:E' A. { ii? _ '

{{2} e::sf R1335: £-'E3 {E}, ihs: fiéifiiéfif S.E28_EI§ §:'_::";?;T..–'§":t%<§§}€t:éé:i. %é€,~,_§1%:;3%;;}€<;Vf;é{i;; 'f§:1;§<:_§; .%ZZ¥gi§}f§'}.{'é?

E35: ;3.:"Q{§:.:{3aid %fé{'}§£3I'?'f a1"§f:§ :-"21§&'{h(;fi*i'§:?;f:€::a;:?:~::Q'¥.;. arééfr {sf 3
<t£sm§€f{efi%. £f:<::rm*£, saafié E2126 'S?é3'{€-S
fiizaf; fiubjecé' €93 321<7:E;2 $5; §ay'm6};2€ 9?
sfaazh. Sm afi-§;'"'i13.;'£'"'A';_:,;:§ifi'fi7%i¢;}féZ c§§.r€%;fégfigiifi§;%,§§é:’ shag gigs bfi fur:1.é$E3t3€§ G31

:::z§§§*i§:’g $i1::~: 3;,>–j;3.§tié::*:§§.3§.<i$::…

4?' %2$ §.i3?g?;::;2x?,?ir1g {§.€3~:'"E3.;}:I1€3f§§S :39 310%: iiguys if: Euia

.§;;%.::;$fe3¢€;%k%é:§

2 :'V"§"§1$ Ceznggfiaérzia :3? ;"'&c§2;s_§s§i.::a:":3 fiiazj fig Eékss
carzéegiéfig Cagzfiéésiiag §';~:':f<;a:°e 'Em': Reiumézéag €"}§§§c23:;*,

$2} $33 Szhs §35'Grz2":3 argai 235%. °':§?§'i§'§ §'@$uE%1: S§'3f:€:":i azéé aié
€525 Feyms 21$? agzci 12 E. E1,

{3} fi1:§§":=f2ré233t§:2z:. ii? {iacéam 'ihe §%3sz:E'i,

fififi.

M””‘-.

(3%
MW’

{9}

M
M .

N

8
Thai c§:::2;ma:’:§ wh&:%:i§’.: ?:§”:r: vgtes aw-:§’€:* :*é’_:£2s}:’z_:§_:3éI.£_
€325: at;§d*§*;.§0§”:a§ Colizliézig Sézaff,
Thea C§{“}CLEIfl8fiES fiziaiizzg 31:: “‘Ra:”:{§ci”§”:'{§?:%?E§:’}<:£fi.g'; A

'Fae iapés crarziaizzing x$i..’§%:3ra.Tge’ ,0ff”–t§”ié:: é::g:I::::§r5Ls

affixes? 55: Ehe }’;’rD§§§”s:g ba;<7::%;hs;=::»r: 'ihé .:§a;3~* 6%" :§.’§Eir3g”<

aémzég with V§§,E€{) Cévsfifage @p<:§:":%:1g*«:2.?3 Sfétgmg Raomg,
Cauming §'§€?..E§8 az1a§"{}é::§é;r:3%;§::;fi 91" §<3ft'§s?'%;..':E"£'s.

Narniriazéion ' $a"e¥'<::_ * *m3§ti':_ "?§r1é:~,§,!'~§.C. anzi E.g§.F'.
93 . . V .

‘ ~c{:~:;7″:c:ii§<:: , W

i%§:””:si~”s;x;}{:;’.r;£%.3r’; mzztaizzing u:§1::{§§’§¥:–:;3 ‘asédéze a:=.§:>%:-€:§’:«::.g€: :3?

Eiizfj éirztirzs §3r{:e{:*€::=3:’§i:1g {:5 E333 ff§§€Yi}i§fE§’ {Bf §’2.r:2z::é:’:a§,.%<}n

g;a;é:;:é§:rs sssmfi v§=::Z5:s:3 ET°<,x::iag:: :22': '§E";¢:=: gzzzréiézzg dz-33:."

}'*'§'7:";a"::'€ £5 E19 Eagai i;m§;é:{§§m€:::i in iaszsézzg Sim
E§iE;%E'ESé3,3:;§ ':§s:;<{::.az§%::3i3a €323: Ehs athzif %.a{}€£§ ?f{§€::'5 fag a:iz.2§"§,s-'

" ?a;t:a:;_:a;_fz:.-'z:2a2. fiéfi rfifipfiflfifiizé Sig igsuei {Em 8;fZ)IffSa§{;§ {§a:*,=z:1.:m.€e:'1%.$ bf;

35!!

*9

taking such feea and impasing 311$}: C€3I};{i§{'§sD§}S as }3;;§§é':~:'{f':'iE"ii:§i

by the Eieejtian Czemmissiom

8. This C()z.13″§ ziisailaws £h=::* §3e$iii0_13;1$;;?$::::*:5::f§§.€3i: fgr

{ha isguaizstfi 0? mpées :31? the R€§fi..’;I:’I1.i_'{?§g,

ané i§1si:’a1n::iiQnS 9%” {E36 ?§i€C”£ir95114__{f0mf3f;1::§S$§0:1 C»E”i2’f;.:.§V}§a, ai; flit: _ V’ x

$3316 can 23$ had from any “§3%§§~z%}. $1′ ;C}m{iér:§mé§;1t Bepet’
£3 Pi)-:e:m N€;s.1′?w-2% ig yiaégés} u1′:i$é5;”:§;Z§._V_{V’iVV}’éfrrié}, ‘i§::”z:=:ques’£ mi’
€315 petitianer far its issuaime Ezfaediess Egg

{)%s$.e:£{é”fi;%i3’§: §§§,:€i€£:5i:;cfi’ majfigééaig 3.63336 (Bf the Eiéctéan
Trfah 231:2′; fa? T%;§:*3}3€§§”§;:1§gfv«{3′.§*A”f??§€£iiE:i§:1g ‘(ha f.?=f}§}i§S§ £3? {:15 :?{::~:::

M). E'”?f~1%3 $:’::::=.z1i::§ E1;-:3v._fi§é,-=V_b%:§1{i’bLV€.E¢c£i$::: §-fiiiiififi, zvhich Em ciaimg

” ‘~ {£3 as iaiaé 63%’ the W11? fifiiififlfia

_V ‘ii §}€’£§§.s:>n is a§I0i?5?€§ iii 3333?. “£338 §”§%r$§3fl§}.§£?:’.EE’i

‘E3 :”Ei;L’*€$1%r;s=fi”_v»iG~,f%imi§%: §’_§’:i€ éacumsms enumamiszi €11 §>ar§

?€x:3§E§* guggzsv ‘imfiicsiéatfiija 5%.”: fizis ji}.fi{?§§}1’€, Sm? Szmxmaéh

:sszte39_;m.i§S;”‘i§1at the glefitiiianm” ‘:3 Imaging 0:3,? af fig: Eimfiaiien

“§?::¥:*”£Eiing the €3§{‘f§iOI1 geiitiont Sri Eéaifa swim 0:15 w€5}§’S

53%

fime $5; f:13″z2.i3§1 tbs {‘,fl§}i£’:& C€}I}Si€§§3§”.§.E3g ‘i§::$_–‘;:i3″Ci1:If$i:a§;£:;é:%.

of zmzi :’€{;%_u:%:’€1′:::€:’:’€.s far the Cfagzségs. <31" 5E§1';£'i""'{-§i{:si1":§1.1£§'EfE}'}C{S§..v3:5»

:;u€.:»;%.i11, this {E91111 éirects ‘£}:€:’,41’€;S-“§}<).?§;{§i?f1?§f"'§§"§SSé§€_ ':'§'.:;:ém

'sx.;2ifhi}3 figs: days fmm tadayfi .§'~§<.3 {3:*d€;:: as :9 {:$$'£f.$;-.,