High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri Maltesh T vs The Deputy Commissioner on 10 July, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Sri Maltesh T vs The Deputy Commissioner on 10 July, 2009
Author: P.D.Dinakaran(Cj) & V.G.Sabhahit


flaw’-

$3.}

1

1
Kfixfifiéfia?” “” “‘

”’!”!”’!J1

: wfiféfifiifififi

I”

GU”? Gr

amen THIS THE :0??? DAY 8:: EULY 2099

?§-EE %-i2′..’.i:”‘~i’E:’..E’ ?’v”é?:’-‘i. 3LiS’:”EC’E ‘m3.,_€3’.’32’%5″‘ “_


s*.s«:~.§.x:~£f*::%.;.: ;:é,::L
aagzgiafisws :::f~if£_.§<%<A?Fz%
H:°~_»M?~_:u»;:.va_t–_H:rs.

A, u:au:*g~¢m;«u;'r–::x-
fiffi Ci-wiii'-f;–§v<$-<«.F':-'*'§; Gi32'{.£x?P;€x%'~§A':f;£xR
% ssg:c::;:49 YEARS

: §R;E; *§'k%:i£&??A as. rvagzzz
§;'@%2m-kuwa mag:

gags, ABQQ? :23 ‘(EARS

2-‘Ix?

” iéjru §E§f=AFP2’% 5’v”2Ai.i.AFP;’%
fi{}RA??§’x:’\%A’w.r’£*r?;.

H 35$ i’*%§§i.i.1’iP?A Gi3RA?P5?*.§*\i:’%’v’fisR

U1

ASES _A§C1LiT 33 YEARS

33$ :°§i?é*x”:’$-:5s§’–“?.5s ?fixi<?\7E§*3.i%§-"?,»'% %~"é2§§.E
35% %'-':?e§<.'§€';ER;%PP§s ?'v§fi%,i_E
AGED QBQEJT 45 EJEARS

s§;~+§;';'_ "

12
A

:’–‘xi.é_ 9232 Aaazczmu mgrs
a§sm§r»:”:’ GF aaasaszaz vzamss,
HAVERZ TALLSK AND EJTESSTRICT, .j
a’-‘E?E’E5E<'Z3_V?i%-?£'F~i~$
my sax av; maria, ia':}%:'i'§CFa"z'"'§j v %

Eh,'-I E:

1 ma BE?i.fT’:” c:3§»¢rvz:ss:c>:’E*:=;
H;’%VERi £’:ESTR§i’..'”‘%”,
HAVERE 581313,

2 “ma ST;i’s’§”E 223% a:Aa:»m;a&A&%4

:'{E?’r~’;E$E:”~iTEG 8%’ {rs s%aafa:’a§°’;:*–;R,*’
aE§>Aa”r;*v*:E:4T 3?” ;2,;5va*-4a;£% %
*¢z%;g*a;a 3a:.s:>;~sa’ L
axawsaaaxs -61 :

; …%R«E3Ps:%::E%¢?s
{$35 5524?.’ ‘f’.35;’»}UE?ER fi3x%.eai3;é»R’; $§xfi§’i}j’

t?Hzs%*¢T;%:>,&gw,2s%%kj:=*a;2′:’;%:»zss “50 quash? ma sasea
QT? Afxifl CERDER QTY}
:”}3.i3r€«.2Gs:1%_8. *¢za*»§.’ ,_.»5s?s§:”~£§>ai~{.’, Psxssaa av ms
RESPQNDE?’5T ”

“§j§{§k:3k% €.'<3*':E?~3×75 3:4 ma: ?:*:E:_2%v€z:;;za*:'
%;«:£»*am%a;"* "mess 5,593: V..G.$A8%~§AfiiT 3., am2;E§«t.aa 'ma

A

A j:;%éiE'E§§§'zé?$ M29 sziaém ta fie régifiefiis aim' iax i§&}f"é§""S s:=

{}R§*'"gR.

” ..”§”§2§_$ éuaic iszferesi éiitiéatiém Qéfifiéfi is siiéacé $3; ifie

mm

Egexrafiiri ?%§§&§€’1 in §’°§§’v'”&E’§ “%”a%::§:, éiééfiiiéfiififi E329 vaiiéiiy

{.14

2. ‘§’*v»;e%’xse as:r€-.5 :3′? Eami met sf 3?..”i«1» acres §§”: fiurvéy’

53 1

: é.34«i;A situates? Er: Bévagiri isiiiiage -if %-iaveri fiésififii was
fiéméiifiefi fa? éfiiéfiiéfiifiififi Gwemnierst &¥”:§§’3L1..iE”:fir’i7§’:fi
ceaiiégé. it is E’v”éi’i’éfi tfiai $:3:%”: afiiiéra :3?’ *1: EE

has tauseé area? Enjaisiicté ié ifia viéiafisaf

W
35:

M:

” LIL}
W ;

{B
(:1:

flo–‘lU

3:26 as sgcamai anfi fiéfifié, the argiéiiéfieg’ “;’;§’a:’g%::.__%'<}%jVVséiiifig

asiéa ifie iffifiiéfifiétfi €::'ée'r"_.;;'.~;§ss&€§« §'=,~% 'i§':E.é:ié:%§*e€}fE%i*E§3é'~iS=

Eiaiaié if} Eye Esefii fifiifié.

u
I12
:1:
5
WT:

m

iééfiifi ifraé’ “§-:,??£s§*f:ég”7§ :;§e.;%:’?sé§’ fess we

‘;”3Ei%'”€§?.;.s.;§’3ei? 5a sari .éLé&r?’2é;fi§”‘Ae:€§§, éévi. éaciwaafa.

if». :…éa:::%: eé Qfgiéiéfi-3:3?

§c”;.s§:%?ga§ €::s¥;i§=::§jr”‘aé::%§’:§Vé %:}&«;=.%’s “‘E%’::i%?::”&”‘§3 5%.: Efie €:§’€:§é”§’° :2?

. :’%*:–e_ Z§%§’«?€§§’§Qfi%fi2 Er: Qhaizgéng the LES%§’ cf éaaé fer the

%}’:.’§’3;§’f” fiaéaé, iéarraéé ;%§¥:’§.i”:a2z%. fixsévséata sfifimiiiafi ifiai

‘A’sas§?%A:§&:2t §§3§’E’:%§ Ezmé mas gear: &§?¥fi3§””§€Z&€§ 5?; ‘:%2e 2;’

4
“~§«
§éi7T:§”§’s.ié fifia ‘3.I’§§§&§&§”§ 2:2? §i’E:Z§i’z§} ca2’:t§&, He $2;§r§:%;r%’&§§~-.i§*:&
§E’*’n§%.:’§i”2é§ srfier.

E}!

5′. wé %”<:ave fiévéra :are%':.i_§,."V<:::%'e$§§,§%éé*a2:%.§%;;:3

nu: ,,.._,;. .

7:7 .’:;;1r ;

M’

céniésniiefis sf thé iearr-zed c£r;2%2s;a§j_”:’:>’i §§”:_e”~
samiiraizefi fire :”:*;ate:’§ai an {‘é92€L:T3_§”i§}

R

6. ‘Em maiersaé an ?’§:§;§.’_7.”§_’§’V§.._’iv¥’?i%_»i_»3§f3 %:::Esa:i’;s iaai
§=:!¥”i””a§§ iafié héi fieen :3!-éfsfi_§zE’§i&:§_>’z:r§i§. 1.Z’:3;::’es $22.27: as? 3?.i:=’:
acreg £2′: fiesiafiéri ‘§.::'{–§f:.a§r;:,, “–%-rig:-=;\;és?*§v_ «V§i,$§:*ict has iiééfi

f§%?§'”2€§i§’?§€Qf jfairj €.§§”§’;:S$;:’.i.§€Z.i§§i’_EV cf4.éV’.vf§<§v'r;é%;1:"'r:&i:"%; en§'is'*:ee:'i§*2§

caiieézj-;_. at 'afisi "I';E€!E:SSa¥'"}r' stem Er': tha:

yéfiafé §":§T1?&7E§=é3'&–fi 'i;é§a&:'*s'*–.:aé fééiiiiféé Eéfsfiéf s'"<:;é§e 3%? :2?' ta

W

Lagrgeji' é2.é."sz'€'::'::sé:-..g'§éi*., we iéé-iéiiiififz Q?' iééé ":32:-';'i§'E§:.';i"§&§" is-'sat

§;e§V%%:3i""§afé§'s-:3? "§'2§é Féfiééiaii §s"ej?:3::§éaf;Ea§E';:" ie the Viiiéfiéfé 55 mi

:2': am: "viaw ef the matieé', sérszie

J

:1 aiééfizaéicaa wéiéa Eaw ?'-"s~' -"me

mum.

:.;é;é*=;+:rii§§’:i’a§’;%a3′:*; ii ficma

:>a,e2f§f:$?& :2″? §i3%’f§§”%C% Emsfi. §E*%§§§'”ié&’;’§§’s§ ::;§§§e;*3é, we 3%: $2′

“‘A§f§e-Aééifiiéfi £523: iéaé Qfiiiiiéféfii’ is récsi a§’2%§’i§”:% fie §§”‘s?¥’ faiief

AQBQX3 –

a

” ‘V ~~§%”: .,:’g§;-:1 §§.§:;}§§€. éfesi §§§§§§?§§?{“§ gi2éa,s2::=’§'”s.

\/9

‘§s?r1%;:§.&é,,

vghg

Ian? ex –‘fe:?s§§§~::a ‘ __ . ‘*1 ”

§._zz_s.

AB’

*v=fi§%§Si:E%Sffifi.A

f3

;?s&<:€:r:§%:3g§§*;i, isséé férsfi ms :*i=sé:*it in %:§*:a= ';:sé%;§iis::-s

x "L –E'

1 3 Ts»: T E?

$