High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri Manish Ajmera vs Sri Deepak Rajappa on 31 January, 2011

Karnataka High Court
Sri Manish Ajmera vs Sri Deepak Rajappa on 31 January, 2011
Author: J.S.Khehar(Cj) And A.S.Bopanna


IN THE HIGH COL’R’I’ OF KARNATAKA. BANGALORE)
DA’I’E§,[) THIS THE? 3 .13? DAY OF JANUARY. 20}. I

PRESE-?N”.I”

‘E’H'{:’. HC)N’I%3i.,,E MR. J. S. .E{HEHAR, CHIEF

AN I3

‘E’H¥:Z I~~1(‘.)I\:”BLEZ MR. JL;s*1″1<:_I«:wA, 'S. Isbpzéfirégx

WRI"I'AP};7'EAL NO. 376/2Q1::1'T{dM":R E.S}

{363i,xvee11 :

Sri Manish Aj1m:ra

Aged boué 48 year’s

S / 0 Anan.t:rai C Ajmem-a’*–. _

P1101, Machialery Co:’p0ra§,i01:1

N0. 352. 15* Stage _ ‘

Peenya §11cia:st.1j.:is~1««Are21 _,

£3az1ga.1.0re W 560 _ 4_ ” Ap1.)e11an1.

(By S318 S_1.1.3fiT; ‘E.32Vt1.._1. “”1«’z1ci’£;%AV\}’; ‘ V./.:\_.dv..’ F03”
Sri S_idd;1p’pa,

And :

_ V 1 V, .I)e.epéii{.._I§aije113f)a

“S 1..-ate G B }”~i’2ij%g~1,p1)a
Agcsci abaut. 48 years

T Np 15¢ B Cross,
.2”.f}%:;z1:§¢;VW<2si. 0fCh<31'ci Ifmad
V }VI21héi.};:i_1<:é3}11I1i Layou 1.

E3z1’i1g;tsi’b1’t% – 560 086

” – ‘ ~ _ ‘ a2 “I”§*}V(;93 AL,1t1’1()1iis<:ci ()ffi1′<é –« 56$ UEE4

K} €.?4_%,gg'»*« Q31

3 M/ A.11iL.1s5 EViei1£?E:1.i.}'1ing; (I) Pvt. L-E.d..
No. 22/2. 3"-' .P}mse._ 5'" ME%iI]
i3'<;?r-stlyzi I11dus5£z'i211 Area
E-Bangalme – 560 058
R:-':9. by its C.{i3C1 8:. {)i1':?cr'E0r
K. M'ar:..:]z1sic%a1ppz1 R<és;3{3z'1d-r:n.t..s

'Fh.i:~;; writ 21p;')f1’:§’te Ka1’1:1ai.:.1_’ka..0?”-Iig}}.

Ccmzrt Pam. pray-‘iz1g..§ to asside 1’IT10Qf20I0 dated 13/ 1?/20.1.0.

‘I.’his:; 21pp<3ai C£)r1.1ing.g on for _E;';1eE,iH1i.r1.;§.1"§,r :f1'e=.é:z'i1ig;_éhiS:_ V

£13.},-*._ Chiei'J1,1st:i<:e €§E'.}i\—-'('3}'€'.CT1 the £1)11c§\vi:1gf' "
Jvnqyzfiiy

J.S.KHI3HAR, C.J. (Oral):

“iP?%x6509/20I00fikfifhy&%§g§mdentEfiql was
disposed of Qtfr’ iibcrty to

respom:1er1t__’. =N'(‘.\.__1W.£§–_ -Va giefjg3sj_t» of ? 60,00,000/~.

withizl f\v:£)\-.._x£mz2ks.’ (0 14.09.2010]. The l’€?.’I”IL’:1iI]iI1g

arr1.:c}_”1f:;.1′:1E}617.?” 35′;’OG’i’QGO/” was required to be ci€p()s:”i:ed

Vby TrespQ_fi:C1€e:1’£.”N0. 1. Within 21 period of thrcze months

:°e;i:s}3<)r"1_<ie1"1.i'. ?\E<":,1 e1(?.f:'1,:a3Ey d:2ps3ii:_:_1m’: of’

{fin§{14¢fii201oy

12.07.. It. is not 21 Inattez’ <3? dispL11'.c. fllat in

»:0:(%Q:fi}:;i.ia.1'ace mil': the :i1ire<::ii<;m iSS'L.I€;'d by i:.'m's (.7m1ri".

? E3€Li.00,(}(}{)/ in <'éo1':s~,:<::'1:;m{:30 wiiih the di.:*e:’:s,~; ésssm-‘:»:i.

DJ

on 14.09.2010′ Out of the re1nai11i.:’1_g amount: of
3 35.0(),0O()/–, w1’1i<_'}'1 xwzs to be paid withixl a period of

'{.hI'€i',<;'§ m()1'1i'hs' he deposiiied 21 furt:he.1' 2.m1(:mr_a_t. of

3' 2':3.00'{)O0/ –. On i:}'1 m<:)r1t:.hs wass to expire, resp():i: €£e11t:A ""Nc;'i": '

appr0aC}1.@.ci this C01:1ri:, reéq1,1.esti11g_£.4 £'o1'T_ fm'Lv34I.."'i'3'}V.("4:I' V'th;7e&..,

weeks i:in1ca so 21:3; to enable him°f;o C_1e";)osi't.* _t he_ 'D2132:

ammnnii of?' 10,00,000/–. V of 'V

this Cou:rii, on 13K12.v2O.1O, §;V2"'21I}3j€ t:flifr1c:A ssfinzght. by

respcmclent’ No.1. imp’c3Vs-:.T;”1’1g’=–.1i’p()13_”hji’m;’~_ctosi:s in the

:121i:1.1r€: of(1011:pcfiVsz§;_;.io1’1_ qi.1’z7:nt§i__fi’ed .2j.t:s 2′ 230,000/–.

_ ‘*;: If1A’é;:’~ irzstzlnt writ: appeal. $1110
e1ppc%1}ar§t.V..11 21s5 order dated 13.12.2010, by

which “t:he 1<~:21r.1_1€ét1 Smgle Judge grarxted cxt,<:11sic)r1 of

i;}1.r_é{. w'"c&;i:fs"t;i_n1e to re::~;p01'1cier1t: No.1 .

s01if:a:'y <:01'1t:e:']t':i(:m 2;1dvanc:eci 2211: {he

E1a;.1.1_§is 0f.i}'1j;c% }_c:~21s.*:'11’i«;:iV¢7tT1t N13,} bani} hinlself 2.1c(tec1ec1 to the E'(.’I”H1S and

“::(i;s:.1_«:’1AE.–iions of the 01’de1” passe:-:.e:ci on 14.€)’§}.2€)1.0; zmtzi iihzfl.

1_c;Eé’w .

it X-V88 the1*e.a.ftr5:1′ n.{)i’ open to 1’esp01’1d<1'f;?I"iE~3i(}'I1 of UI"I}€? <31'jgi:1a}iy' g1'2m'i.rc.i to him.

5. We hax.-‘e:% c?o:1side:*ed. the sscjiitary x(.:.(_>_:;’1€:,§§.r1i[‘§r)f;..

acjlvzméteci at the }f1.2mds of the }e2:1:r:’1.<-3d <:(M)_1_,:£;–$;ei A_3"<)1" film _A '

app<~3l1:g1r11:.. It }1()wever not pqésibié' .f<)3*_ us;

the submisseiolia aciva1'1r::€.d a1'_£.h€3121iiV–cis c)TfT7thA<§' 1'ea£'fn"e::¥

c()1.1m3e.I for ilhfif 21.p13eIIa.nt. his
bona fide by dcrp0sit;izig'~M._z1 \ViT.,hi11
two weeks. in He
<?iep0sit':ed 21" «, out of {he

total 13a.Ia111l:_§: 2i.1"i*g;':()L1fiJ':'<)f/W. again \7\7iT.hii"1 the
st.i.;31.112:£tj.ed_ rj;::nIy for the b3.1a'r1ce of
'€" 10.00,'O0O/, £132?'V\:a?hiffPi«–..i;ieJJsought: further c:xt'.<~:ns1'0n of

t:ime.;' " The s~;ai,(1"é.Xte1'*zsi0:1 was gra11t;ed by the 'Iea:'I1<3d

'S§:1;t;';ie2 by zxwarding (:()s3{',s in the r1at1.1:re of

"{.:{_)1Tt_pe1§:33ii'e:Vi_01*j 'q'{121'1i11:.i.fied as 3 2,G0.000/»–. W'e find no

i11i'i.1?mii:.y in" the (fleterr11iz'1a.1',i<);:1 of fixes iea.rned S_i:1.gIe

._J::r;3g.3;<::. ii) the f'21c:t:':s and ci.rcr1,1mst.a:{1(:es ofthe (TZEISC.

' i1'1 View of the a1:»<:»Ve. the iz'1st:2mt: writ :a.pp€a.i

" V "§;3"rei3y (i.ismi$se£i..

Simfe the n1ai’n Wxit, appeal itself’ has been
ci.ismi:;s-mci. all Misc%eIE2me<iH;t.s 2é1ppEi<.:2:u'i<)1':s5 pe11d§.:11_g do
not. ss1,:1*vi\:c:. fix' car}sicierat:.i(m and the saris':-3

2:t<:crdi:’1g1.y. dispc.)sed 01′.

A ‘§33B§€§E

hrp