VVI-‘ 138907/2009
IN T} II”-3 1′-IIGI—I COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE
I.)z\’§’§.*ZI..) T1 HS TPIE 193′?” DAY 01’ I”‘Ei*3RUAI’2Y, 20 IO___
PRESENT
‘¥’I–11:3 I—l()N’BLE MR.JUS’I’1CEV.GOPALA ~
AN D
‘1’:—1.1:: 1~~ION’BLE MI-2.JUsTi.cE:;B.PMIL
W.P.No.3890’7 /251,99 (<2."M.-;'.\'k1r.r:rV.s): "
BETWEER;
Sri Ma1″z0j.I–I.}\/§..
S/0 Sri .=’\/I0l’1zim Kumar,
Aged aI”:cml I30 jy’mIfs, ‘
I–I1’reshig:.;1.:’;.1 \’il1;.1;.g'<~2_' _
Goilibet-ac!_u. V.I.TlVc_)i'.5'1.i, ' "
Mtldigcmf Te-11:.a§§.’;f _V _’
Chic:§:1112;’1E9§;.112:21′ §)is’1:’n:Ltf.”. ”
{By Smfi. ft%;1i”‘ar’!_11jv:-g1 I-vV{s1.(}’.’VI?’,’.. F01′
I’)i’£’1v.”3′:.§(3 §5′;:zV_;{i1I%y21 A$;.st.§§.)
‘ ‘1 L5 a’E31,ai.t: €f>’.’7. ,1{:->…r”1′:.,2}f11211121,
‘ .M’ir1_i$1_ry. (.11.) ;iVi’1t-is and Mi11€3E’£1.1S.
V1’ d E :21 : 12-1 ‘Sui _: £?I1a,
Ba’1′:_s.;”211»or~sc-r1’;)I{:c’¥. by the
2 ‘ = _ V’ P1j:ncT:i1″5al El-}c:i: <1? re~.1:'a1y.
' T2."AVSe;':-16:1' .'43c'*iL.-':a§.i.$:s3;1 {3\/Einms}.
I";/Ii1':t%.s3 211m"! (}c::c§)1(3gy [.)epa1'£.11'1.1’1t,
a -M1’1′}<=3=. mi $C"*('i ion,
C1'1i(':1<:'21;.1;,_:fz'2}z1:"
PETITION ER
‘\-Vi?’ 38907 / 2009
3. ‘1’he I”‘)c’1)11i._\,»* Con111’1issioner.
Ci1i(:§<1'11e;1g'e.11:11' D1's'tr1'Ct.
Ch1(:1<11I'1a1gg2-11111'.
4. The “1’2.1I”1si 1 C321 1′,
ML1c1ig’c1’e T211 111:,
C11ic1m1z1g:1]1.1r District.
[By Sn’ 1{.{.f.’=.E*ic>11v. AGA}
>1′<=k*
'I'I1L.~; W 1'11. Pe1.i':'i0r1 is filed L,11'1der }"..1"1it-rles 2.?.!(5_1.5Af'2'27'f31;"th{%r.A
C0ns1i't1.11.im1 <11' india praying" _1.'<;..__Cli1'e(°ri.. 1:116 01*§3sj3.(':vndV(:J11ts 110, '
C0I1si(1e1' £1'1c-3 1'C':'.])l'€S(3I'}[E1U()I1 of 1':11Eapet4i'ai()11€s-If_dafed 11.12.09 at
the ea11:'lic=st. vir;.1<:: Annexured) and-,co.1:1seqLiem.1y héavoke the
suspensio11 of the license" Q1' th.€"'p€t1i§i0fie1_' and Vp'erh1it him to
quarry o1_'d§.r12u'y sand 1.016' _the ;_pei~iOd which was under
suspe11sion by issL1ing a writ in {The-"11'ai1.1.f{~:009.1: m__a11dan1L1s or any
0':12<31' writ' or 011101' or d}reC1a123n_."u V 0 " " 0
T11 i..?.c?1i1.idj1=':CQii1111ig–__6'n 'for Di(t{a{.i11g Orders iihis day,
B.S.Patil, L-71.111011. 1.)e1.iti011e1′ is se(–?}<1'11g 21 diI'('3C2U()I1 1.0 11:16
fie-spc)_n«.:;1.1I1i..l’§oV1’i~iies 10 Consider the rep1*esentaiiion subr:1i1;t.ed
on EA’1=,_l2.2,{‘0Q:.vi(i@ A1m.exL1.1*e~D and to revoke the suspensiorl 01’
0 “~__1c:«1s<:r 2;11':(11._§'ée pc1'111i1 g_._{1'a1'1teCI to him to q_L2a1'1"y ()re:1inz:1ry Sancf for
t.1'1_c=.'pc:1*A1;)<1 <§uring;' wluich 'Kim: lease was suspc*.ndeci.
'f."12e 1':-iciis as home our f'1'<.}m the p1.ead.1'1'1gs and the
" ie1Es p]z:1{'ec1 on 1'cco1'c1 1"c':v@aI E,l'1z;1E. 011 16.04.2008 the
VVP 38907/2009
p€t.iii()1"1c1' wane ;.§1":1111.eci lease :0 qua1'1'y the sand for one year. A
1'10U1ce u.-'as issmed by the Competent, aL1t.h01'i'Ly on 13.11.2008
alleging i§lc?g;.1l q11ar:'y1'ng in violation of the i.(–:rms and (r();f1Ci'iiio11s
of the 1c;1s..+c? z-111d (ralling upon him 10 submit. }.:3._1'1'afi.i;cj'11A.
PeLiii()1';m' (T1£–1iI']'1$3 to have approached 1*es}3o;1dé1.1t :md_
i11f01*r;n€(l him II1211 {here was no v:i01a'10i'On. of €1,116,Vt'e1':'11is°e11id
conditioma 01" the lease.
3. By ;.111:ted Véjiie1’1’1’yi11gVV
lease g1*;i1:’1£’cd wz-,-1s suspended ai’n_ong otP1€:1″~E.11i11gs that
there has ]’)C?L”‘1’1 violatiorl of ‘qufc1’r1yifig*’ legise f’g,1fé1:11:ed and death of
three cr1’1a{l<§1'c1'_1Amid_§)(E(;L11'rjédV1163211' the mining a1'ea. P€.1.i1.i()11e1'
made 1'L?1':)1'c':sgcV1':'ia1'1'.io.1f1é3–1,0 14'"e-r..;;(i1'1é-;:i<.ies' the 11'1a%.1.er and 1'(':\-'()KE? the
SilSp€l].f%§.!.)ll of q1.1..a1*1"yihg 01-seause.
A V"'1.n €~r|"'1'o iV"11¢;:tz-11'1\.v11i1cé. the Deriod of 0110 year for which the
1VeaSe_T.wé4i;;vgagliaS-1:':/£1V_f:x;3ired on 15.04.2009. The auth0ri'£:'es have
newi:1j£..ia1,<t~(i_ 0$;.«z.{:ps to auction the sand quarry. At. this stage.
-‘«.__j3e’titi01[1<:€'x-.0{$15 file-rci this wrii. pet;%Uon.
5',*._i,é;:;1:"11fl”;.1()1′:c.r1’ as 11dc.%(i lI}(‘-‘ iczxse amci 1,}:1e1″e13y {re-ulseci loss {.0 i'”:i1′”:'”:. Rcsc1″\~’i1″1g
sucld 1’ig’]’11. in l’£.1\*'()Ll1′ of the pet:i1.1’0r1e1″. We decline 1.0 i111.c1″%”e1″e in
this Writ p<é1i'1'i0n. Acrctomizlgiy, writ pe1ii.1'0r1 S'L&11"1dS dis;3o§3é'd of.
fjfidgQ
53/.
Eadqe