High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri Muniyappa S/O Chikka Byrappa vs The Principal Secretary on 28 July, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Sri Muniyappa S/O Chikka Byrappa vs The Principal Secretary on 28 July, 2009
Author: B.S.Patil


‘~ _ Bfgfigafigrw _~_-= $6if}”{§{§..T%.._.. v

W2; ?E’§:a.C§i3,ééf_%Exé<:::iév€ Qfiiser 35

< . V A §%$§::g33fii:1':mga Raga,
., §";%Tz:a:";.g.*£~:}.{;r€ – Efiéfi $8 E.'

:Sp&cia,i Lané ficguisiiign ffifiicéygfi,

:33; fiig max 3333? 3? 151 ssmxg arr g§§§§§5.:.a.RE
gssrgg '§f'§££S 'mg: 23%: mpg? Q? Jisgzzg gaag
BEFQERE _ ' VT VA
Tm. Emgmm MR§§$?I€§ 33* I

WEE? ?g'rr2m§ E§a.224»§ 9§?2u2@;;§;:§§:§é::g;;§i3:;. .A { 7

3% mar:

$3 §%3§1z;1i3?ap3;>a,

Rgftsi zgheut 63 }'”€fiI’S,

S; C) <3h,i§«:ka ?%yz'a;3pa,

'gacisrai Manchazzahaifi,

Jigaiéi Hgfgié, fin€:§{a1'§'a§1:k5 _ , ' _

Sgmgaiore: Disztriiti, V — " '_ '1 ?'Ef}."I'£'I§1FiER

£33; 833;'. {}wU{§§1_a}&::}V ;§xr:=§«, 'V2 a§;;:¢_.–:glti; V'

Asfili}:

1, Thfi §3fi;§11c:L§.-:a,2;

Ce mmarsg ._a:::i. §~::»:_§ %;:$:’£:>.%.¢s;; ,, ‘ V…
éifieyarixxsznt ~{E§1d;:– £}5’é3:vz:Z0″‘;f:~§::i”f:13,’§},
{}Q’i6§”£3};31fi}fi’§. GE’ §<;ai°j§1aE=§a§%:a',
Viiiiggxgg S§<ms:iE":;, a;' V '

.§§;é{a<;1u-'£7i§;?'é?.V :*vE*5§€1:"{§%;1E:r,
'§€~ai*:1a§aE:2:%j i::':}c;'-iusts:faai Arc: ag
{'}m:€§:a_;;sm¢:2f:{ Efigarrzés
'£535? :'3j§0§£:s§°, R E3. Buiidizzg,

iéafilaiaka inéusuia} gweas
"Dsgzs%0§n1&z1'{ Baarfi,
Efié ?3'1Q0r, R. P' §1iZi1(i§11§}
§"{;:2.1§a:hzmga Raafi,
Bazzgalare -~« .560 {EEG E. fiE8P6H§EP3"§'$

'§"§':.£s; "~§.§:'i':i §3§:'§é":§.{m ':3 $235751 méiisr §::*ti:*"i€3 1326': 5:5 213'? if £316
{Ii::s::§;¥:.é?:.%»'s;':é{::§T :35 §!;'a§ié2: §;:"a}-"iatgg 3:1; fliéiffiti figs :'§:s§3a§3<§,€:*:§$ :9 aéiai
£23: ikaiariqtré": 3%} gu.;£3.§&1$ f Eafiai ssituafieai 1’21 f’3}”.§*§{34..3; E32 311%
£§};’,§*é.1Eéj€> 3%’ Jigailré. Endugmaé §§§$a§ gjigam Eéabié, ..»’%:;c:1::a§
‘E”ai:.:E;<':, Eaizgaiem U:'?t}a';.n E}§st.ri<7t§ ':33; ‘::$ic§::;§’i::’g’–, 1:325
i”€f}i’ifS€3?fE§3’E§GfiS §}i”f3:Ei€i’j;’ 3i:E3mitf:€{i 31:1 vi§:v<: 0%" EEE: i3:*+{i€_i'::§_T'§:2..:§:s5_3%é:§:
E}? §_i':i$ Cl(}TL'i§."§ ii: §%f.§3,§§<;'é§E%E§i};' 2€}§ZE§ »:'i.atc:~i~{i {}1.{}8g2{}{}{é_,_ ' . * L. '

'§'hiS P::~m':r:;:m :;f*m1r;,i§:g an Egg' §3:*2::§§:§3?:z':.2fz1';: %§$5§3j:::gf§".§:iis (E2235, V'

€:§:.z::: {Z:{2u;;°i mafia ifaa fwing:~ _– ”

3. 1:: me East was Qccaséazis .:m.1_:24.a3%5A1.’g{>~:§9 mg: j:;;:f§;§:;?.1§I2{3<§=g:*[.:"%.

<::0'unse§ €91" {§:e,€gs:**:it:fr:¢11:i:?_ ¥¥S;–1f§v~':£«'iLh'8€%i}.";{_';-.__}'§§§'$'f€f*t?€I} is giw: mite
Eiiéfiffli cigaficfi 'SE18 ,§.'{.$~.:".'£%"1,V;€i"3'"-._'i'i;*3£E{_'Q%v3"fi'€?f§fé.;'C§; ':53 312%: §§S3°:fi{§_ étaéiajg.

23 "§'§’£Va}g €fi?:’:’:%; _V§hg7%1,;gi:_’%}’:§§ maifiér is mafia} mice; t§§ei”€ is 31%;;
§’i’:§}§’§’:3€Ei3:£§Zi{3§.’.§~ 252- E;%:?: A ‘:1;::rt:1?.§§.é:_<3T'§'m;;s?; %3':3':s';Ei;0:';€3: §§{":Ei'1flS 3:53 Eizfififéi §{;:$;"t

m'§.£~::"=€$? in i.§1§§":":13'i:.€§:r}–. }i.v_::n1<;ié§ the W113': §:s<2§.i'§3i0m is; afiisémigésisii fix'

" '*z::,€}::~}5:§'i§3fi?f3f}1:ié3¥:, " « ….. .. v

Sd/-Q"

Iudge