High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri N Narasimhaiah vs State Of Karnataka on 18 February, 2010

Karnataka High Court
Sri N Narasimhaiah vs State Of Karnataka on 18 February, 2010
Author: S.Abdul Nazeer


§~Ji’:

ix *2′:-12 H363 com? 9? mwATaxA AT B.§.1!iG2%gi:»fiR::E . ‘”‘

§.).:%’F§2B :”:*£e§:ss TE-{E11 131*? gym’ <1')?E¥'EiB%%¥_3;'%.§é:':?'i2°§"£'{§'.';V.

E§§F{}RE§

THE HGl'§"§LE MR. Jusrxcng;.,g;3$:3§.{:HAzE$1§._~.,

wR:*:'~ PE;'F§'E."E{3§'€ ?JGs5_439Z»§3:f2i§_ 1;: _§L.Aé'fB:::g§§_

§§§§§T§VE§'i::-§€:

2..  §'§. E'€3ra$iz;:.f§:i'a1}ah H _ _ _ _ _
fsgezfi ahimi €32 ysgars  =i     = 

2% 3;;   _ %  

figmi :;”:V”‘:’§.’i*£’1i’E.’i”‘I”L ‘*’§L1__}7E’ff%3i}”i’$

E3{;::.i:. em: f:?{§_’,{1it¥» <3? E*§_a1;§9£§;«"§}~é,:
!X11.§§i.'1:~;';;L V " " V
~' 2 '_ E*§,;»3§§3:';a§§5%E;§}:2ai}«*a"" _____
' Béi:1gé§¥iir€"5»§§f3 {}'?§?

3, :_’«f;_;:;1 a;;g;.é’;;;»:7;:g%;’::~§s_i+&~;;;g: aaméa
‘;%Ega<~':«f§ a7i3:;:ré_':"§: 5322 years;

Ski; ifiizaiiafijaya
figgzgi’ :;§_J2:>§:f $2 fsaame

” _ ‘§j’;j£}{}3: am gamg £5? §€9;ra§-‘a::a’§pa
R53 %~:.:;,::;§;

?§<§j$:zna§§$2}§§:31ya
" ifiaiigaicsm 56$ 9?'?

Sri Satissh C-hazzdrazz
fiagezii éahémé :3} }7E.;’:é3§”S

fix Sri. Efiinesh Eézimar
Aged abautt 35 wars

Bafiz are 33313 if E<:E'i'IipéZ(f';§."i;EiI1(if§§i$1"-

R} an Piaf: ?~ics.E9'? V ._

§{an;a§§$h'ip:3};;a. » ' _ .-

Bangai-::=r€: {€366 G???

{B}? Ski .}a}”a}<:':3'm:ar S» Patif, _EiZ€:1*–._ €¢€;{L;:i'S:€V;E~
fer Efizti, S. Kaiyazz. Basavazajg. A€3ir;}' V'

E. swig'
E33: figs; .$€:E1C?;'f1:'I?§§;E;§', _ « .

Efiépaiiizxi :::,:_1£ ea? 3} :*§::.«’3:s.. I§c.%:’ei{>;3n3t:eI:?
¥’é4§{a;;§;a 5:§£7sE4::.{i.§.’;£’i~ ” _ “” _ V’
Ba1:g’£c}:€£= – 553 ‘ .§f?i3’}.,

~ V. «_ ‘3. ‘ifiaiigaierfi A1¥;}a”–:v§_:_i;5&t;§ms::1t :’%ui}E2i.}z’i’E}*

C4»? ~

E”€:zr}(. Wesi
.V V ii~%–:§:”§’ga?i$}:’:;% __~=- 563 82$
Egg ‘n*’-3:3 ” éZi’;=:»1m=.;1i$$io:2er

. A §fV§:Vs::§€i'”f;E7′:»€s:f:”§i§c:%§°3z
” §}€;}ai*::::.a::i; asf Lfrbaxzz §}Ef:’é2’€§0§}31IE3.E3.’i
§;?_.S§fi1-, B{§iZ{‘§fi’:1§
A : 3311;” Ambzstgfiegar ifwéizi
“‘_8&:}gaig}:’fi w 55%} 113233

Thfi $§§iEi§§3; Lamii £m E:3E’5if§i§_}§m{iif§’E. ;»’§:;§;%m:”§1:jg
KEIIBBEE Eiyupa
Baxzgaiééréé «» ff3€3{3 €Zi’2{}

W

‘Thz: ?ri:1t:i;:ta£ 3€(,’I’E’i&I’}y”‘ K) {}GV$1’I3}CEl€Z1’¥_

Urban §}eveiapman.t Daparfzncxgtmh ‘ V
Gfivfifillfifilii Qf §{.ari;mia}-:3 ” ”

433* F3091′, Vikas Sauéha

Dr. BR. Amberdkar 35:26:35? , . ” a 1
§3:zga’E9′:2’€ W 5:66 :35: RE§$I¥7’C;%?-§{}_E3N’}Z’$§ ‘

{By Sri. Bk’. §:§h83;fl={31’1’i§£LiZ’a}”a;{léi Réizif-»,. ;’-‘x(}.3x. {<3-gt

Sm; M. KfiShE1V8.R€:{i-:'i}', fifigfi, fo;r~E"- "

These vm: ?et3’J’:ions gigs; a£:1g;g;§:’~ 225 & 227

9′? {E163 C1€}ZiS’€iTl1’§ii€)E} Vesf ‘{:1{iig:, ‘praf§{i:;_g ti: j:§i_E3 3sh the Grciars

zit. 1333.0 1 .28 10 Ea-:'”ii§;f§’.’2’3§:l},I3,€f}v{i1T(?”$3.’: a1’1.§i”‘{:_tf§:..u V V:

Thésg’ Writ_P:§iti0E;.$ €<:;:ifi31g :31; for Pr&§:'zm'rs.:zr_y .He*:{2:*in§g
this vfiéiy, Elm i"Eg:t1;"i._m:3;iv:b_fi1:: zfa-iicgwing;

GRQER

. , '§i'§1_éV;g;:t;?:%:ir;:;:3rs Cfiiiifiikfi that 'lhfiff are figs. owrzam and

§€'i§%iG:3 SC§"1£f':{§1}_§€ §3i.'€3'§'t"}"§i€$e "f'b&jg; haé

V VV _ a§§§§ic;%;§g:1$ ii; $x~'%$€i'§ 95 me igami éczgaisiiiafi 532m: :9

, §'éa"£:: s {§€3V<Ei"flmEE.i'€ $9 witfifiraw iiiaiir Eands fmm

" . a5<f:q§'z::§3i§i<:a2;. Since Sm wid agpiicatimis *e.%?Ei§'E E10?

u_;:i;:1"§3$§gi:::%§é§ §.i1&'§r fiicii '$55.? }'«E$.34§.§i*2G{}5 saaiczjng 2:.

" V fiérezsfzéim its t}::sz:< Siam {§¥3V€t§"Z1B3€IZ'§L. {:5 cgnsiziiér their

R

4

regzrfisazzxiziiioxxfi mad fiii’ {?€3;i’i&§E1 ether reiiefs. “§’h’i$ {7o11:§%;7..i;;t§:”

exéir ziaiziii E?.’?2:2C9{}’? £iismi3s&<i 111$ Writ psiiiiaxz _.__ A'

atimilezzga {(3 fix: a<:qui3ifi<;n. £3 C::}11£'€I't£}§3{i, H<:»w'a*:::§;f';~.Vi};43:V' 3?'

Tffspfifidfiifi wafi dfitctsd ix} haid an e:<1;qz1i:_}? ta:3 'f3f.f15.-Q4_(')'i_i_3i'"?3,S.V_h'f;s;;é' _

wheiiittr the '§:r:3*$$&:9$i0:<1 of the L:3=.::';<'};$ E3:%1'~=:.?e'Zr}&t3:;T¥2éi:€:i1 frail;

318 33:15: ~:;§v:1€rs:; an E8.}.€;}A20{)E§'. '§'i1.§%:§'{T;9u:*i" f:_:rfE1:§r éixetttsii

iéaai :.~3§t§r e::§1q':1ir§,-=", if it is §3§::2;'§;s;:i 'ttffzat 13:5: ;;;éj$s€ss§<33.i i§; iéikéfi,

fiifi r&;3:°s:=s€mtati0nS Caf file gr-::'z2§~?;1'g;3s;2ési*2t*é;1f03;'~.§2é::5g;;%iii§g:,7a£i=:2:: csf €216

fiszziiiis :15-::d -:u:u§V "'*€T;(:34»*};73$'A4*w';7§~$;*f't,':a?;?§,' I if aftfix" 'c:1:.§Tuir§:', Ehaa 5&3

zfisfgiaziisaifixit Egmiaig 1:§:a€'§::3:a$%3–$si011 has :30? ifitrcari iakrzzzz, {hex}.

_ fiifi r§:;;,§€.ész:§1£z:ti«:3%:$_ Ca? 23:3. prctiiriaxieim {Gr {1&§1<3i;%35iC&ti0:1 of tizfi

§;«:::1:;'-is §§:2e:}§;§§€§ _h%:…_:;:<:z:a$§§;:-zrésrii 911 iis merits 335% 51: aci “v§§£;x.;§E;=é*;£§ié:§::3§:;§.€é:§:é§i ‘aim 3::a:’£23:’ magi; has gaggfié iigs azszaiez ai

& “..;§;;$;:2¢x:2:’.é=’.f;:’ giaia§ £4-)’3€.§.<-:?{"{§ 1% .Ei:9Ze:§:i:':§, {hag '§»i;3$€s.:.~:ie::;. <3? Eha

yézag ?I:3::i2:='::a; iaiiatig fmm figs ififliiifi s§a.we:é::&rS§ fizsir

VM v..;f§§§:§:$€§;E3ti%;@g an 18;;§.2QQ:"5= "I'§1$:*t;i'<§1"t=;, the qzxasfian sf

«~ &<3§:si§.€i"§::g {Em p€€éii{;s::€.:"$' aj§3p§i:?a£.i0ms far dffI1.Qfi.fi€'.f&i§{§I1 0?

E
'*1;

Elm 3:332:38 {_’§,E}~I;f$ I192′ arise; “Figs p$f:£ii::}:1€r$ ham: ci:a§ié3;1gi§=:’i.T *

géééiiii Grim: in ihisiésé W”I”§_E p€f.ii:i<'211:-:..

L3. 817;. Jayak11mar S' Pafié, 15:;-iizned Sf; A€L':e3§3:;s;-;?.i',". V

appziazéng far fizz: petifiaizms {.'.1D£_'{.Vg'ff§:3j!,,.£TT1
re§}30§:,:icn€ was zmi §'usfii§='i'}§"3. ii} A151-a3i.:ui.£f{1g'VVi22;§.i i'1$£s"w£?;:3::i;:"§' has
mat direeffisi him to of iakizzg
pasgcstsfiiiyn af fl1€":§.§3iI'}€i$.:' V! Qrdar is
€';{)I}f£3'&E'f£ tit: Ehfi Céiniziffg ' arguaé 'fh,ai' '£328

pfigsasximg __z;_: f t;E':¢"§Jz§:::«_;_i$ §1S;E..fi£?i'1§£f?I3'§fa§{€I1 in f-5:'.i?3C{)I'Eia;§1,CE

igrzifiz ?h:::fé1"{i~.t*3.,_» :éf*:;é._ respcsixiiexzi smghi :0 have

Csmsideraé f§£L:1s:» aéigpiiifaiigéizfié $1" the 'pe"€i€;i:;f:21v.:1's fa:

d<n1:3f§f3§;:–:£i;3:: €21" "{.':;:~:»;= _V1éa':1d.s' mg éis merits as diI'§3(3§Z£'.-{ii E3}; this

'f'§:{éV."}j-329%?mspmizéeixi £133 fiifid fig Si"3,§:6mttm". 9}?'

txéggéciziéfiifi, ""L§2§3::}€é iimmssi ffif firm 2&3 :*@s§:3:::§iez2i' géazztfizzég

grrééazrsgsm" if; iififi if figs p&'§:"§£%E€§'S Ezafi aéhaiiitzzgfiii

£13: .;§a:?:§_§§isii:i0n ggrecaaéingg in respacvi af 31313 182165 1513;

;§;§'£:;:*£;i§i<:;I3 2331 'ERZP. §§€3a}.€§$%'§_{ Eflgé. Thfg Czjsuri. {_§§SKi';'§SS«€€§. the

is

K

said Vi}-'.§°i'§. p(–:'tii{m an €ia,12.}£3§6. Ths: State Sv0v::r111:3s::i_iV.}:_§;§éé A'

pass-.€:% 23:1 awmd fé§3Z}(i 3 zmtitras d:~1'E£:<;i 1G.,§.'i$3{}(}iii _T;%1a22:3.T'

bvegiz} issxufié ufS.};'2§°'L?.} (if 1:113 Land ;}i€§:;;{1i:n*§gu"§3:: ':r;;:

Ci}E}{',ET.{}E3(i §tE1."S{}I3,S. He has §}'r«:}1:::3€d Véfhé’-saié nfigicés a1<§;=–._1§;~,A "

with {ha S'§f;3§iZ€3_flE}}t Qf Qbjec'i:3'm1s; it-3 t:v:3:;2:rL'é£ja'11;:x{"§;:§::':{§L' '%i§$f'
the pfissfissian (33? the Eaxzzfiig havfi—*%1=$§€:'i1'§;aa}{€:: :':3i§'v-1§§.«§.2£3(§$
azzd baiided mzzir {(3 {E16 §-if: has 2113:}

wpraétzceii tiis maimzagg §i:a§x;-"':;- 133? E'iiZ*;#."f-V"–,{3{3rHVi;V§3£'*'§?.V"£'LL£.'§.I.. 2mtim31*2Tt}? in

iézis ffigaliéiiu Sézaifiz aazaiéi haw? 3316:.-iii}? bats}: vtraaifizé.
ss;'iii_; 'izha Sfjaztfi: €_§~f£i1:§_$131§I§,1;f;~:;gu€§’¥:i0:1 {Ff Cfianwtifyizig fixfijm

fmm act’; flifiéiiéii sikaes 1?”. £5 f”§1’§””i31€i’E’ arguaii aim; mm

3 ‘€1?§;u:’?»’:L§:i .._}**é::::¥’3«1§»’Vi’f”é*–,–“—-‘?.$_–“:.,«’f1’*G.§ has éiififlifid {E16 335 i%s;3<::1d&§1t

Véezri ;f§§}:{li"v£""§E1'i§%"i3fiz*§§§1i;'f {Em _'§'}GSS€3Si£.'}Z} 9%' fhfi lamis have hem:

isakéiiz 3::f'{§I}); iéjggei swzzers. '.§"E1e 33% §'fiS§}Q"£}£§i€3.'fi; Ems §}S.S§{is'.'§

{ht az'{§s:j1iV";?:§: ascmfiaxzcfi E§"§:fiZ1 fihfi aéirfigfigm sf ihig ff1s.:3::r':.

"?§'t,:;%$ fi;;Zi:;s :fl::§*'?s;"%3a;$ zzmi aiimsififi fiim 3% :*fi§pQ:1{1e':1E is :%.aE;&r::1i.m%

f§,§1é%v.é3é§'E3i"§:;'éf3? {sf iakéixg §}€}SS£3S$ii3I§ 2:25 firs §a:a::£$, '§"'§1a*::'E§::*:-$6,, 'aim

— _ §3e:2;ifii>:i€:”3 3:: gm: jusfifisci in <::3nf:521{iing fiméii fifié 13%:

1

mi

£’€Sp£}}.1{§§3E1′{ ought ‘Ea havé Efliifiidfififid E116 vafiziiigr {if taZg:i:’:g

§}{}SS€3$§Si0IIL H6 _”;_}z’a3g’S for dismi3sal of ‘the wrifg ‘;.’sef;%fi;i0z;:3..

4. A3 zwtiéreci aiismze, the §”I’t*d{‘–{T€SS£}1″ in “t.§:i»2: V’

p€’titifiE§_(~:1’$ haii Chaliézngeii {hrs §.)_f¥,’E3..’;fl;§;’¢iTXZ!.£!;i”_’,.1′ ” f’ii1′:a’1

I1€}’€§fiCafi€3;{iS 1’35;-2.3x::d by the 835% £iI}d:”‘7€’i1€; ‘S?§§it$V'{}f3″E?é3}}fiiéL€1£: .A

{§.a’i£*fi §.’?,};*’;38′? mid §{}.;’:S. 2995 réégigcfivéigr ‘£937 _aé5:;g;i§£i$it’L!3Ir%–‘;9f’

fizz: Ezangis iii {inflation in %*.?.P. :3 said

writ *p€”Ei’¥i<E:1i; "'?;E3é [}E%i:?LT§{3fi%i£TJ'?31!3I'§§§iWE345} C{}I}'iffXidE:'td fltiai he
was £9; '5t&:3:a1zi':_<3f th:*:« "ia§1i:1$ ';?;:; gguastign, 83 had mafia: 33::

appiicaiiaszi ffif .g1'a§:1*: ~95 '.<;§1:§::é}3;%.::93;r rights :3? {he said Eanzis;

~' '.€~Lf§}§d ijiiigsi ;%c'%<r:ji;;:a3'1::'jg*«3f§_g}2=€::; srzsf Q15 Eazads was gzagmad ii: his

'_{?a;s;s;§§'£;§;'._ 231"2,_i9?§, Tiia BSA i?~::~:=:1e::i prafiznéximy

§:(%t£*§£7a?§£av$i.'§:3'é2£'£l§§:. 9.?i EQ8? fa}: acquisifigg Bf aha gag} lamb

fésfifiwgéi £3333} naiifiifaiimz éaiafi 30.3 .1';}%£3: éftm"

.. _ 'ffi;§::'£ié€fifi§ file ziézai <:e§1?;€::§'.i{3::$ 52' the gariiga, this éigruri

_ i;§;ié;{:£s:£s'é& me 331?} Wig @3591; an 6.l12;Zi.§%96. fig £233? as it

'mg; '?i"§as: §§€'§5§:i::«§:ier3 made é§£?p§i{'.'3"§T.i{}IiS far

by ':§:2m3i:i_t'£A.7,

” (3) E3311: a writ 01′ witi’: ‘a.€iir€:§i::{igi§1″v
or Qréfir éizzecfigig {£15. I’€$§%;;¥;3.’VV};{‘1fi’€’iI1’i£-§_v is €’,’5(3iI}%j]$Ji{§?T§
the r&;}1″€se’ntafim13 ~. ” f.’i£f.i?Zi£3Z{1€I”S
wide A.:1z1ié§§’u:’€s–P’, G 55 L [b I

{I3} Cmissqzzgézxfiy, §v§;v*:*:ri§–.g;;” V’c€,:;€§<r:'a;i or

{rurder :31" 'Vti§_§I'fi§;fViiGI1.v émil. quasi: i:3:£4M :iInpugz2ed

{3if€w:i¥*'3'31"1'§LE1$;?{fff}¥;,:'v , I» ' . :}%fié§%_i13Gafl§{:t%l beafizag
§'€:3'§§._B;*3;,S§;;'%;:CZ3E§§.£;:§5R.; _i9i%§S?.~88 sziaied, 932F193?
zmzi z:<;€§f,E:*3§;:§:; §i;_«3.é$:' segrtiurz Si}; §:}i";ZiI'§Ii§§
gm.:g§§§"2'2§:':sz;3§:»<:§é:4 dam 24.:"*:x:99é Vida
_ Gf Eimds beimzgixzg ism fin':

. risspfict to Sg, §*~2′:3,§, 3%, E3 sf
A _
A 5.12;’ Q?i’fie’::’–1″ G1″ éfiaefiezzs as this H{é’£}5%=ifi
$3333: dmm 5:: ta gram in Ehfi
* .2;:£:*c2;§ :éxis€a$2c£$ Sf ‘thfi aéwvs Cagsiizz {E33 igziémsi {sf

” –};z:&35i;§::a gzrgd &:;3.1r£%}3’. ”

5; Thig €fi«:;2m”i a,€t:tr <';=£:11sis;§:?:"§'§1g 81$: xnaézsx' ':1: <.ié3§'::s.é};,

iiissiziisgeéi §'}Zi?";' W537'; §_}::'ii"ii«:m. in $613 far 92$ {E33

a(7qui$iEi:>m _”§)1’£}(.’f’3€”:€§i§}’?gE’–; ‘is: <?<::z'2r;':€:':1::2:.§. Th: <;:"z.i:::*' Qf

ilmifi is £33 :.'i':1dt:*:r:

“{3} ‘iéfirii §.?€?Eifi()§I} E 5:3 £213: as ciitifiaigiggz £§3*._I;}’:e;:~:’ ”
3(rqu.;isii:.im:1. sis C(}§?i(?’€:’.I’§1é’f(§, is :;i*:s:.:3is«;s€é:i_. ‘ M
{E} ‘§’§’;é: S€ft:’?.I’E’:ié13″}_;”, ¥}r’:;7¢:;i’ §3€?.Vif}Q§_}£}:¥§fI1€

§§;Zi€:;:s;32″‘:;m:3:1i, Séaic of §{arr1aia:z:a’;~ — £511.. L f€§”fE£}i*? . . _;j3f_,

tbs: :i:9;:sjgj .i$&:u€ .:1{3’iic<::< €213 €113
;}€i'i'$iéi:€2*$ V :a$"v.Vs§§g'§§_ VTA" fiat E35313 gaiam
§3'€2?€iG§};{ :1i%3§'i§'vs'3§£§i§§{}if§'§fg'x§%ii1{§ hs:}§::§ é:.m;:1i:*§; ii: fiziii
fiéiizéfiizéji' '§2£?,§§ S%f8Siij&1i {sf {hem Eamis havzzi §;'§E'??€3I§
§§é3;E€§':'£~' 'L§'§"e:31i;ii $1.6 {}"€fi;"'§1{f1"E§2 «:31: i8a,};:2{1*£'_'3$ :33
iii:-3 Earzggéliarzf §}::*.__fi§?;~..:%: §§_1′;’E’§ €.’I}€§E:§§’f§r'”, if i}.%;?’. §:<}§<;§.§»3s. 'iézat
§}{§S»S{F;$S'i(}£§ img. §'}€"-fi'"£1 iiaktézs, ihsz:m §}:s?:
%éE§;3::'%–§:31€.a2:;i{;:z2 es?' 'ééaié §;€ri:.é'§i{ms;"s €132"
"'v.V:i$f:§aii§i€a§i<'3:s 5:2? 332%: iazsii 1333411 my: Ex?
F <:*.{.m.$ie:£:*:::':={§, Ef afim' 2?::s;}§.:ir_§;_:. fizct. Eifiéffifiaf}? §':a:a§:;§;:§
iézai zéé £5; fmfizzi 'Eh.a.:. _"g{3'SS€;'*SS§{:=El 223:3 £:<.'¥€; §}§:.::i;':
Eéifiéffii, E3361: mi: :;app§iC;s.{§e:::':. {if 3316 §§§':§;iii(}'£1€i"E?2 fgzsy

5
\%

g.

E

1%

tifizmtificatien sshail ht: c0n$i<,i:r:r:?:s:i €31'; "
in acrrcrrsiaisca Wi:%: iaw. b _ 'V

{iii} if £3 mafia {'1€é';§j§ thai bjg iiajis «:3;;$';é1jj, ?£l¥,ji;is§: §;7'a«:s:«:if;f:.w 'V
is 11:}: issaxémg 3:13: –f€§gT§ the Si*t:-ate VV

f_§s::r*ss¢::If:3'§;z1§::sJ3: '$.13 d€::10i1?f};V€f%:é"-E:a;3€}sL" V

6. it 13 fividfirit $21:-}_ ~i:;§”;a”€”$1.j}fi1:z E393 ;:€:s’§3<:x11ci§:m.
was z":3£;'§::i";r€:§§ £0 fiiflciriazic £§g=jh§:i§:£:' .§§i§ §;§é:1$sC€*;é:{;;=i.s§1: ('sf Ehii Ezmiis

Ema Ewan. 'i&1i{E}:'§. {wear 30 $26 E%§):%.,

if gsssz;-=;&$S'i1;. GE”

£*m:$i{is5:fi§:g’–‘i§2€ ‘3:§g’33:§\:~;:-:’:’g.1;;[a§’i~ig§§1s :1? figgift ‘§}€.t§§;%.:;sn€;’:s Ltj $.=é~8{E}

{ff §h63_–~m1d ;%a:’i§iai5§§§§3:i’v.§%aii’£{ie:;u:«:S 351:3? a3:i§;;:% ass {£3.13 €;}r:}*s:%:1:z11s%:§%4

‘ V’ _’;§sa3___:51?3s3 :;e=::w:: * {Q £113 iatifis, $15 §:s<:s$$es$i<3§2 {sf axihiit-1:

Ea E? £3 {mi}? zzsheu fiifi Gfifififilfiifiiét. fimig E2331:

€::?:éi: ‘gifisgfisiééifi is §;<:s'i éaiaiafl, Shag; "ii ghzmié afsmzvfiyisg' fizz:

rafiffisafiiafiafis giszfim by ihé '§3:Ei§"€'3:{}§Ii€I"S fa}: ééilifififiiffififiiig

' '?'. E32 Qbasiiezxiéfi asf EEK: gait} eréfer, am 55% :%S'}f}€3fi{i§::3'€'

f:_3%3' <':=%;:si':si{i€3'§:{§ €335 mat.£:::.:' ii: €§€i';'§3.'{}, figfi 3":ig}";t3}7 :=;U;E}m:7:."£.aé %;sjg'

'' "'{:€?§%'3 iaarizzizaifi Céfliilfiifi far the iémi §'£$'§}4.f}.Z7i{§£i'§'§§g, {$133 ifllfmgzsi E1213

ix

£

H

mcsft. s§§r:;':<:t;:<i $133 Eih rfispeiégieni. K} €3.€f3?.€E':"fi;§3;"1€'i me: 'a§:e2§;e§§i§?.V_s§.°

ta kixag }3GS$€:'S$E:€}'§1. 'i'i1§;s. {Z2::;m': has <ii:*£tc§%f3éi' ' *1:§§z€f_ Eitmé

rziggrangiaizi to '.?§;r1:i Gut wé1€fi1.:ir iizé'. §:s:§s3€3:~;is;a::._ fig: lmzdé;

E1353 bczfisa '{£~1§{€7£}. :32" :1-oi" 'F'§;a SE31 ?:t3:§.;}ew:i61iii §:a$.1:£§éEd'i;%2at $155

peiaaagsiszz sf ihgz ianiisa has :.5{§:aad_§; §:":::e1i' §aE»:€:::'%3§:a E

amzi 31$ $3i–'§IIl*';f have Ezsfifi %1a:;:i£é€;i.._§)?x?r:I %i.::€'faE".:s::§A §i";3SE ::E1§€£':C'1ii§fif€?
§13g'i:1:*3€:"–iL Ziifigt B%;v.§_:?§i;;-:1, 335;" –.;::,L2a::;;23. The

E’€S§¥CiE{3(§%Z*iI1{ has girjfiuifgi E*;~’.§}.i1’E;Z’§._’s.v i{§.i:?’.§1€3i’.-S %’:h23:i’: iihi’.

‘g::a$$:3;3si’ii;~:$n., it 31$ vs;-“$23 fi$*iahZ:1$§1€::§
‘£13? {£16 =.;::§:”rmai=. fl’ii’§{§?§ ‘é.:£{§ai:1.g §:scss§%3s::::is3:; is zizzafiiiig fiifii

§7’2;::;a:f§:a§:ama “t}1§’ §r&$€;:ct@ 9%’ §?’a;:1¢::}:sa:3 znxfi Eakiizg

‘A «§3d:§$a§_§ig%§é. *,._e2″§:1g”§ giviiig éeiizsarg? £0 {Liars §}§::1efi{:i:.siri€s, E341

gavcarzsxgz as-as .22i?3{¥STR§éL

$3? fiifififi

$54: fig’ ‘

gjfiggggg .

AA gags .;%::é§§ sac i3;§§}, 3:: has man mg: gm:

“ii $3 Sfiflfi iiazafa fix ésgziém géifiiifi s::r’§’ fix:

a::.q:3.§$ii3?.:;¥:2 gmszzszsiiizzeigg $€§}¢;}§ ‘:’§
3;?§ E§;3′?§:« §§:§-*’ ixrhiaiz iiéaéafs ‘§_3:,2a2.{:g$§»:m {sf ihéi 133353
335113 %{:z:’é:;. izskfifid fig {i<m'§:"::, E3a*;*€§;h. has
€,'f§3§:§%';':§{'§iE::'§. 'Q23? §.".§"§£f" a§.,3";::€§:a;i:.§. $:£':i§§ §"§';"§;E%§.T§}.€3i3 ihstig'
E.»

.-

‘E2

§.}fiS§§€$$§()§§.A ii. £53 Isms: $953.1 ::3a2:~_t_>’f,.E.§?::§_ Eeggfi ”
‘éégz.-ii. if is Eééfii fuii: Em iaim §}§’1_§}E§’;§{7:%i}L..}={3{}S;§4¢§§E§:$’:i{}fi <:.::f' 'V
izim Eaizfi uizcifir :?{3z§;;3:.;§s§::§* V4:;§;:?*::§:;i§.ii3Zz3ié,,-v_. '"f.h§: V'
rsormaji mizrgie 91' iakfixg §::,–v:_V§_V;L4¥'$%:-.,*V._$$3*.e{'3::':;§' $2; :.§zfg§:i:1Tg _jiiaéi…
E'a:1zs:§:2:::;-3:233 its '$18. ;::':::sé§i1s"fi.=: {sf E7"é35;;=:,*.;':?1.:a"«:-3 s.§jr.3.§%
'iéikiiisg §V:<;S$€;~3:~§i{3,§i; *–:%i:aIi_ gi$.f£I3§;_ ,§i}§:3;:v::r3* Hééa V Vt§:1::*
'i:f:11s:fi:3§9ia?*{1 of iakizzg
‘§§0ss:§ssi0::_«.’ {E36 1 ?:§’1’§Z’€:’€’:€;, {£33
r£2§:5′:;£i;:s?% ve;’:{éa:_i:i’V.’i:a::?;2§.£m:3a1:1£: <:r::1'§.,-"

ii) ‘}

3* 3;: _:z’2s&j§fi§.%jVzs:?;&z3§:3»»«;;ezzs§s:& gcsam 13$, §?3″S€%fl§§£

{B§ RY Egfis; 33 ?’?:’13, éhfi :’%§:<E:*.< €.'.A:'2:'::"%. $132.5; %3:%§::§

Q23? é:;:i:£*:t «::ef fizz": zisééifiiiéiai medta GE' iziéééizg p<;'s$ss:2:s;%<:=:: {'35 £115?

' fi»:V:';:g'%.*$é:;"§:?:i».t fig 1'ae::(;:*{§.'§;ng cf 3 1fl{f'.1E{}§"E3;E'E{§%.i3$:'z <31"

'§;i:::2.<7}i:a1;E2:§:§::¢1'%3fg $333 ifisi} E2: $315 g§§":33€_%§:::t<§:~. {if '§~?§'i§i1€i%$fi-':*'§ $'§g:§:§{E

':3§-F ;":i:_%3;$m mzé '%i"1f.9;i:. '?§i':3§.§i{'3, :i=<3§3$'E.%%a;;§.€: '§a§§.§;.;:;g §}{}§%S€$$§€i§} <35

%.E:€; 33 2:? a2a»°€:'§.:§d §}iZ'E ;€:3:;3:T3 afaf EEK: as’-:i{T.'{§i§I’i€'{§ émzd,